The Spectral Voyager Episode 2: The Premonitions Bureau
Are you ready to be premonition pilled? In the second episode of the Spectral Voyager, we take you on a journey through several devastating disasters - Aberfan, 9/11, the Titanic, plane crashes - and the people that seemed to dream of them before they happened. In fact, there were so many cases of these dreams and visions that a national bureau was created in the U.K. to catalog them, with a tragic ending. We also interview science writer, author, and precog expert Dr. Eric Wargo about the possible scientific explanations of the phenomena. So join Jake and Brad to find out if we can dream the future… or if it’s all just coincidence and hindsight bias.
Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
The Spectral Voyager theme composed by Nick Sena.
Additional music by Pontus Berghe and Jake Rockatansky.
Editing by Corey Klotz.
QAA’s website: http://qanonanonymous.com
Sources: Time Loops by Eric Wargo (@thenightshirt on twitter), The Premonitions Bureau by Sam Knight, Changed in a Flash by Jeffrey Kripal.
Comments (91)
This is just Joe Rogan-esque babble for lefties, right?
This episode was very evocative for me. I vividly remember the Aberfan disaster (I was 7 years old). We lived in north Wales (Aberfan is in south Wales). I remember watching the evening news, on a black and white TV all I could see was the white face of the reporter in the darkness behind him delivering the terrible news and my mum and dad hunched up next to me in an agony of sympathy, empathy and (probably thinking) thank heavens our three kids didn't go to school in Abervan.
This was fun. I don't believe any of it but this was fun.
The Elizabeth Krohn stuff seems too good to be true -- and emailing herself does NOT seem like a good way to prove time of premonition, vs. emailing other people or publicly posting. Is there contemporary documentation of her being struck by lightning? Usually people getting struck by lightning yields media reports.
Dang yeah premonition was always the one claimed field of parapsychology I could actually kinda entertain—The information *does* make it into your brain through wholly conventional means in the timeline of events, it's just the order of the information's mental accessibility that's anomalous.
Bem's study ("Feeling the Future") has been criticized on methodological grounds through and through. Here are just three examples: 1. Wagenmakers, E. J., Wetzels, R., Borsboom, D., & Van Der Maas, H. L. (2011). Why psychologists must change the way they analyze their data: the case of psi: comment on Bem (2011). Does psi exist? D. J. Bem (2011) conducted 9 studies with over 1,000 participants in an attempt to demonstrate that future events retroactively affect people's responses. Here we discuss several limitations of Bem's experiments on psi; in particular, we show that the data analysis was partly exploratory and that one-sided p values may overstate the statistical evidence against the null hypothesis. We reanalyze Bem's data with a default Bayesian t test and show that the evidence for psi is weak to nonexistent. We argue that in order to convince a skeptical audience of a controversial claim, one needs to conduct strictly confirmatory studies and analyze the results with statistical tests that are conservative rather than liberal. We conclude that Bem's p values do not indicate evidence in favor of precognition; instead, they indicate that experimental psychologists need to change the way they conduct their experiments and analyze their data.
2. https://slate.com/health-and-science/2017/06/daryl-bem-proved-esp-is-real-showed-science-is-broken.html Bem himself described that he changed methods during the study, looking for the one that yielded positive results: "Bem’s paper did acknowledge that he’d done pilot testing and even cites three sets of findings that he did not include in his final analysis. “As all research psychologists know, many procedures get tried and discarded,” he wrote. He did not, however, mention the other forks he traversed throughout the research process. Wu, for one, remembers Bem making lots of tweaks to his experiments. He would adjust the numbers of trials and the timing of the stimuli, she says."
You guys should make a road trip to Cincinnati for the Mutual UFO Network symposium this upcoming weekend! https://mufonsymposium.com/
This was so enjoyable! Exactly my shit. Gives me summer break Saturday late night tv vibes
I had a dream about 9/11/2001. Taking a late nap at my gfs. The dream made no sense when it was happening. People running and looking like they were covered in "flour" day turned to night people panicked etc... I woke up and told my then gf about how confusing and overwhelming the dream was. Went home, told my mom. The next morning I was at work and heard the news on the radio. Didn't put it together till I got home and I actually watched the footage. Nothing since then but I'm 100% sure it was a premonition.
Full disclosure: I love these episodes, don’t want them to change at all, and fucking love the vulnerability ya’ll hosts have to talk about these topics sort of thing in a forum— and with a fanbase!— that have such wide and strong views on… most things, lmao. And on that note, I’m sorry in advance for the whinging, lmao ((If I’m wrong/ misinterpreting any of this, please let me know? I’d rather be wrong once and learn my lesson here than keep being wrong ad infinitum , lmao.)) Assuming we buy into the block universe idea— where we have no control over the future because it’s already happened— why does precognition even matter? If people are just seeing the future, it will have already happened, and we’re just experiencing the echo. If time is fixed, you can’t change the outcome— because if you DID change the outcome, then you didn’t actually see the future, because that entire argument is predicated on the idea that you’re seeing things that already happened… right? It feels a lot like when people talk about “vibrational frequencies:” when you blast sound at water, the water vibrates and responds in weird ways, and since humans are mainly composed of water, we must also be effected by frequencies. That may be true, but like…. What’s is that *actually* telling me? Similarly, if we take at face value what Dr. Wargo is saying about how precognition is a more common phenomena than we’re collectively willing to admit, what information is he *actually* delivering? Granted, my understanding of his work is based on just this interview, but does he ever give his audience a way to test out their precognition, or a way to decipher between the “real” precog events, and the fake? What *is* his definition of “precognition?” If we’re getting this 4D imput all the time, how are we supposed to interpret these messages— and, assuming we just don’t have the ability to interpret them yet, is trying to interpret these things doing more harm than good, because we begin to make poor decisions based on data we don’t have the tools to interpret? I have a LOT of questions, and— sort of like my experience with religion— it’s hard to believe in anything that’s currently too “unknowable” to fully wrap my head around, but somehow “knowable” enough to have an agenda, if that makes sense? ….. lmao ok so this next bit is absolutely me being a pissy baby, but as an artist myself, I think it’s really patronizing for Dr. Wargo to make a grand ass claim like “some inspiration comes from the future.” My dude, inspiration comes from *work.* it takes a long time to practice your skills / research your art, parse that info/ those skills in a way you understand and can utilize, connect those acquired skills to the art that you’re trying to create (if you even KNOW what you’re trying to create), and then actually make the damn thing you’re trying to create. It seems like it takes away a LOT of my agency to give my inspiration to some future nerds. Anyways thanks for reading of you made it this far, I have a Lot Of Feelings, lmao
This series is The X Files with 2 Mulders and I am here for it.
my only real life premonition was a dream that my buddy in college had broken the bong we bought together, which i dreamed the night before he broke it in the exact way i dreamed, it was spooky and legit but also in retrospect a really lame thing to be psychic about
An excellent episode. I definitely relate to this.
I really can't tell if this is real or not but it's right up my alley. I loved those man myth and magic books and wanted it all to be real so bad when I was a kid - whoops commented too soon... premonitions are a touchy subject for me, I've had two unexplainable events happen to me moments before personal disaster that have NEVER occured again. It's so strange, I cannot account for them no matter how hard I try and Im not a believer of any sort. Weird.
Man, Myth and Magic is indeed real, written by Joseph Campbell. I may be telling you what you already know, sorry, but I grew up with that book on the coffee table and was completely fascinated, too 😁. He wrote many books of comparative mythology. His most famous the Hero with a Thousand Faces, which studies the archetypal Hero running through mythology across the globe. Much like it’s use in RPG/LARP today. MM &M was about the use of mythological symbols and how humans use them to make sense of self, conflict and the world, which is why it had so many cool pic’s 😎
Ok. Now you’re just fucking with us, Jake 🤣🤣🐇
Jesus Christ, some of you all are going buck wild that this will add to the misinfo field. First, this is on a podcasts whose whole bread and butter is fighting against kooky, misinfo. One can gather from context and being a listern to the pod that they’re having fun. Two, this is behind a paywall. If you’re paying for this, it means you’re already behind the mission of QAA podcast. This isn’t reaching an large outside non-paying audience. Three, they are not trying to reach an wider audience because again, this is for paying fans of the show. If it was released as a regular episode, then y’all would have a leg to stand on.
Yeah, agreed. I mean, I didn't personally like this one because I just didn't find it funny, but the notion that this will "lead more people down the rabbit hole" is just silly. Nobody who listens to enough QAA to be a patreon is going to get "pilled" just because the hosts didn't specifically say that they don't believe in magic future-powers.
I really enjoyed this episode, particularly the intro regarding the Time/Life "Mysteries of the Unknown" books. I was recently lucky enough to acquire about half the series in fantastic condition at a dirt mall for $1 apiece. Brad, I'm sure you have your own copies, but if you need an edition of "Psychic Powers," hit me up.
the voice track comes on RIGHT when the song starts to really cook!
For a show that often highlights the pitfalls of believing strange and supernatural claims without sufficient evidence, it's a little weird to have an episode that presents similarly bad ideas with too much credulity.
Thats literally the point of the series.
I’m someone who had to stop listening to all of their paranormal podcast over the course of Trump’s presidency as they all became increasingly right wing, I’m stoked to have a good old fashion fun podcast about the supernatural. I love that it’s mostly just an excuse to share cool anecdotes. I understand why some people would think that it should be more skeptical, but my view is that if you’re paying for the premium episodes of QAA you’re probably OK to listen to two guys talk about spooky stuff in a more relaxed environment.
I dream similarly to Jake’s wife, but I’ve never noticed anything quite like this precognitive stuff. I’m a total skeptic though so I probably wouldn’t make the connection to begin with. I just have very strange, detailed dreams that I remember for a long time and sometimes they pick back up again weeks or months later.
Same here. I think it's just a matter of interpretation, like religious people who see signs from God everywhere. I would never assume that something happening to me or the way my brain works is somehow different or special, but I think a lot of people want to feel there's something that sets them apart from ordinary people.
Love this series. I was a believer before I was a skeptic. I think my upbringing in the magic riddled world of Catholicism trained me to have faith as opposed to seeking out evidence. I was doomed in my youth to absorb conspiracies and any tale from beyond the veil like a sponge. I almost feel boring as the skeptic my younger self wouldn’t recognize. However, I’m very much a person who loves to dive into the world of the strange. This series is truly a gem for that. Although I understand the criticism of it being one sided, I never get the sense that you’re trying to pill anyone with these tales, more that you are describing the terrain without pulling us out of the story by delivering a downpour of evidence against the themes presented. This is not a space for debate, but rather for exploration. You two are great story tellers after all, and I find this subject matter to compliment your styles immensely. Honestly with the hard hitting subject matter covered in QAA and it’s sub pods like Man Clan and Trickle Down, I welcome a good escape into this old familiar lens of the unusual. Thanks a bunch for all the hard work you two put into this. 🖤
Firstly, I am both of your children bc I too was obsessed with those Time Life book ads (and In Search Of…before that) and Jake, I 100 % bought that same Offspring CD and too many others from C*lumbia House. Secondly, Jake’s wife’s dream freaked me out AND reminded me I too had a local to me (based in SF) nightmare the US was under foreign attack mere days before 9/11. Forgot about that! It was terrifying! I also have a HIDEOUS painting of the towers collapsing that i found in my neighborhood in the weeks after and was considering backdating it to august 2001…as an homage to the precogs. Finally, Jake and Brad have always been frank about their open 🧠 about these topics and I feel the tone of the miniseries has clearly been more whimsy-forward. That may not be for all QAA heads and that’s ok but I’m not concerned I’ll get more pilled🔮than I was going in ✌🏽
The detail about the fourpenny piece found clutched in the hand of one of the young victims of the Aberfan disaster strikes me as odd. As far as I can tell, at the time of the incident such a denomination of coins hadn’t circulated in the UK for over a century. There were lots of different denominations in 1966—I can remember at least eight—but no fourpenny bit. Is the amount given simply an error? Or is there more to the story?
He was probably clutching 4 1p coins.
I think it's important for you to get some skeptics involved in the show if you're going to go down this hole. You already have Travis who has an excellent background with skepticism and it often takes very little work to look into these supposed stories of precog and see there's plenty of much more likely explanations for some mildly 'spooky' predictions.
How about a format where you do your show then give the last 10 minutes for someone to review your evidence from a skeptical perspective? That seems like it would be just as entertaining without leaving the misleading impression that this woo exists when there is no evidence for any of it.
I was really disappointed by this episode, mostly really that last part with your interview with the anthropologist and what he had to say about physics. Just for starters, with quantum mechanics, we know that some processes at small scale have inherent randomness, so for example the location of a particular electron may not be deterministically predicted the way you could a marble rolling down a hill. But this doesn't mean that we cant precisely model the randomness, or that the possibilities are unconstrained. A coin flip is "random" but it will still only be heads or tails, its not gonna suddenly be burger or apple. And we know how much its going to be heads or tails in the long run, quite precisely. The math with quantum mechanics is definitely more complicated, but we do know it! The idea that there is a conspiracy to get physicists not to think about the philosophical implications of quantum mechanics is frankly kind of offensive, and also ridiculous to anyone who has spent serious time around physicists (frankly they could spend less time coming up with half-baked philosophies lol). It just smacks of someone who has no idea what they are talking about when it comes to physics, and frankly makes me question the quality of their anthropology. Its disappointing cause I thought that an anthropologist might have interesting things to say about how people collectively misremember things, especially all the premonitions we might have that dont come true. Or their psychological angle might be about how people in their dreams might be able to put together all the little clues we have that something is about to happen, like all the people in a town with a giant mountain of coal waste that they see everyday, and how they might have a bad feeling about it they cant quite articulate.
Thank you, from a physics teacher. All the guy did was spout a bunch of science terms with zero actual evidence. I love Jake but he’s probably not my top source for scientific information.
Love this series. Very fun and interesting. I’m loving it more than I thought I would even.
The album God Hates Us All by Slayer was released on September 11 2001, so I guess that is another artistic premonition (or unfortunate coincidence).
I dropped everything to listen to this. I love this series so, so much! Can’t wait to hear next one.
Scrolling up and seeing the hate. I must point out that I’m a fucking atheist who hates woo-woo shit but is CURIOUS about the world!
Would love to hear jake and brad talk about the show Dark!
I cannot second this hard enough
some of you guys need to loosen up a little god damn
Right?
Rice University! Go owls!
Cursor research shows that ganzfeld experiments have not been reliably replicated, much less "83 times" as is claimed in this episode. I don't mind the open-mindedness, and generally love the pod, but please can we not stray into giving listeners outright false information
I was curious about that claim and Daryl Bem the Princeton psychology prof. I found this: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4706048/
I love this series so much! You two are the sort of people that one is excited to come across because it’s like, oh yay a person who was clearly made from the same batch of space dust as me!
well said
This sounds like an episode an older QAA episode would have ridiculed and debunked. Look, to give honest feedback, I joined this podcast to better understand how people get pilled, and this series is just falling into the same bullshit that lead people into conspiracies.
Exactly, Julian would be like “these doofuses believe they have magic powers, that rocks”
sad! My favorite podcast hosts have terminal California brain. that's okay, I'll still keep consuming that content
Not since Ramtha's School of Enlightenment have I heard such quantum flapdoode..
I love this series so much. Thanks guys.
Really enjoying this series, Jake and Brad! I totally agree with the idea that our current understanding of the universe cannot be the whole picture — we have our limitations in human thought. It wasn’t until 200 years ago that we found out about germ theory — who’s to say what else we don’t know about. Thanks for taking us on this voyage! It’s nice to explore a space not based in hard evidence but rather shared human experience and curiosity to make sense of our world. Looking forward to the coming episodes
Dissapointingly one-sided. There is nothing 'open-minded' in presenting a completely pilled theory without counter arguments (and instead a derogatory old quote that implies anyone skeptical is so because they supposedly need to feel the security of a narrow and explainable universe). All of the 'evidence' here is hearsay, falible human memory, and interpretations of experiences after the fact. This version of 'open-mindedness' is exactly what leads people down the qanon rabbit-hole, I'm sorry.
Yeah... I liked the concept of the series when they announced it, but actually listening to it it just seems like they're "Yes, and..."ing woo stuff and uncritically boosting fringe figures from academia.
Not enjoying the woowoo series. Feels like I’m actually listening to a Q-influencer podcast The exact opposite of why I subscribed in the first place.
Yeah I think these boys need to listen to some OhNo with Ross and Carrie on psychics or look into James Randi
I enjoyed the episode and I know that the series isn't about being rigorous but Wargo's citing of the Daryl Bem 'Feeling the Future' saga is so inaccurate and possibly dishonest that it motivated the little Travis in me to comment and point out. It's a really interesting case but not in the way Wargo describes it.
My brother went to art school in the mid nineties where he made a sculptural frieze out of glazed clay... the frame has a quote from Nostradamus about a great king from the East and the image is a face crowned by fire over the twin towers that are also in the fire. I know its a coincidence but it is quite an eerie artifact.
Eh love you guys but don't love the misinfo
+1 on this. It baffles me that they can be so skeptic and snarky on some episodes (see the alien episode a few months ago) and now they are talking precog. Wow.
So excited for spooky-ooky time with Brad and Jakey!!! yayyyy
Ok the discussion around physics around the 50 minute mark is pissing me off as someone who is a degree holding mathematician with a strong interest in physics. There's lots and lots of interesting philosophical discussions to be had around the quantum realm, but this whole framing smacks of a persecution complex. He literally says its a conflict between the "military industrial complex" and the rebel precog physicists. Furthermore, the idea of something traveling backwards in time is a part of the mainstream scientific discourse: it's called fucking antimatter. That's right: antimatter can be modeled as matter flowing backwards in time, so his whole argument that physicists are too closed minded does not hold water. Similar discussions around information traveling backwards in time can be found around the 'delay choice double slit quantum eraser experiment,' all though there are important nuances that pass over my head there so I'm no expert. ALSO he's just straight up fucking wrong about the math. It is super exponentially more difficult to model groups of atoms instead of individual atoms. We have cheat codes to simplify the math for both cases, such as density functional theory, but that makes the single atom and multiple atom cases both easier. While there are a lot of cases of physicists being closed minded to ideas, like the obsession with string theory to the detriment of other more fruitful endeavors, it is not the case that ideas like retro-causality (which is what it is called in the physics community - they have a word for it, which should be a good hint here as to what's going on) are ignored by some ignorant scientific consensus. 52:45 NO IT FUCKING ISN'T. SCIENTISTS HAVE KNOWN FOR DECADES THAT GENERAL RELATIVITY IS A FLAWED THEORY, AND HAVE BEAN WORKING AROUND THE CLOCK FOR NEARLY THE PAST CENTURY TO DEVELOP AN IMPROVED THEORY THAT IS COMPATIBLE WITH THE REALM OF QUANTUM MECHANICS. 53:14 ahh geez here we FUCKING GO with superdeterminism. That is NOT WHAT SUPERDETERMINISM SAYS. I don't have a good idea either, but at least I KNOW I DON'T HAVE A GOOD IDEA UNLIKE THIS ANTHROPOLOGIST LARPING AS A PHYSICIST. I'm not saying that precognition is impossible, but that he likes to sniff his own fart.
Nice to hear the rebuttal. Quantum physics is over my head, but the fact he said he's a psychologist was not lost on me.... Edit: Anthropologist writing about psychological science.
This series is so fantastic! I had those books as a child, I loved those! They were a treasure trove of cool illustrations and I'm sorry to say, in college I cut them all up and used them to make art.
A couple of "precog" experiences I've had, though not exactly the same as the ones discussed in the ep. 1. I moved to New York in 2008 and had never been there before. One day, I decided I wanted to get a look at Ground Zero (which was, at that time, still a giant crater). I was wandering around in lower Manhattan and got completely lost. I had no idea where I was, but suddenly I felt this intense weight pushing down upon me and when I turned a corner, I was face to face with Ground Zero. I'm certain I had no idea I was that close at the time. 2..At the time I moved to new York, I was coming back to the US from Japan and hadn't yet secured a job. I had a job interview lined up with the studio of a contemporary artist, but since it was a recruiter, they refused to tell me who the artist was.. When I got off my flight, I was at the baggage claim and happened to catch sight of a very famous Japanese contemporary artist who was (to his embarrassment) being fretted upon by the airport staff. He was at the same luggage terminal as me and had been on the same flight. The next day, I found out it was the same artist who owned the studio where I was having my job interview. I got the job and worked there for the next 8 years....
So if the future is fixed, does it alter the present to ensure that things align in that direction? Like how time expands or contracts to ensure that light and visual phenomena are always reaching everyone simultaneously?
Awesome! Thank you guys for this! Can’t wait for the next ep
Thanks, Jake and Brad! I appreciate your open-minded nature. There is a lot that science cannot explain in its current state. Embrace the mystery is my motto.
I'm highly skeptical of any premonition being documented with an email. You can retro date an email by changing the date and time on your computer before sending it, a little trick I learned from a coworker when I had a job where paper trails had to document filing deadlines. Same thing goes for digital files. You can retro date when a file was saved or updated by changing your computer's date and time and the time stamp on the file will show that date
Agreed. I also wonder if the stories that were recorded in advance by "the bureau" were really as accurate as is claimed or if they were "sexed up" after the fact. I'd wanna see the raw data on that
TBH Am a weak fool for ominous synth soundtracks, so every episode of this is now connected to bassy speaker always from now on - your eclectic soothing voices are sounding real good too! (Am miserably awful to please so hopefully that compliment means something, also am trying to be less miserably awful but don't let that water down the compliment!)
Jacks wife! I Like!
Another fantastic episode! Just a small amount of feedback maybe instead of saying favorite picture, say poignant or another strong descriptor.
Yeah, that word choice did jump out to me too. Favorite implies that you take some kind of pleasure in viewing it (not saying that's the case for Brad. Just agreeing with you that a different descriptor would be better)
As an artist who just finished a piece that was a product of inspiration, I find "the best ideas always feel like they come from nowhere" unconvincing. Even on projects where I feel very inspired, I'm also very aware that I can never "capture" my imagination in my work. Ideas are slippery, they change when you observe them. If I try to follow my imagination to the letter, I generally realize it's actually too vague to be useful. However, when you look back on a finished piece in hindsight, it's very easy to forget all of that. It only gets easier to forget as you tell people about your work, too - what was a messy and contradictory process can wind up retold as an act of God.
I have had dreams that string along multiple nights. There’s an entire world; I call it “Fake California”. I’ve even saved up money for a sports car too. I could only afford to rent it though because I have really low self esteem. I really hate it. I usually wind up having the dream loops where these dreams end with me waking up but still dreaming. Over and over. It feels like dying. I think it has to do with my sleep paralysis. Idk. Not fun. I hate dreaming.
“I could only afford to rent it” Jeez, even Fake California is a neoliberal hell
This reminds me of that show Early Edition. My mom and I watched that religiously
I used to watch that with my roommate in the late 90s. We thought Kyle Chandler was cute. 😂
This must be done. There is no turning back.
My grandmother used to tell me to watch out for podcasts that made my brain rot. Yet here I am.
With a brain happily rotted.
My grandmother used to claim she had premonitions, but I never really believed her until I had one myself. I was in my late 20s, and it was related to a very personally traumatic experience I’d had not long before. And a month or so later, it came true. It’s never happened again. Also, Brad, I used to BEG for those same Time Life books. I never got them, but like you, those commercials kicked off a lifelong interest. I’m loving this series!
Bring Annie Kelly back!
Annie Kelly hasn't been seen in public for 17 years #WhereIsAnnieKelly
Having a premonition that I’m gonna have a fun next hour hee hee!!
I’m going to need to start taking off work just to keep up with the QAA feed.
Don’t go don’t go!!
Fantastic! I loved that book so much. Look forward to hearing this.
Child of the 1980s here. I had the whole series!
