Premium Episode 217: Esoteric Agenda and the Rise Of Online Video Conspiracism
In the ‘00s there were three big Conspiracy theory movies on the internet: the 9/11 conspiracy theory film Loose Change, the multi-conspiracy film Zeitgeist, and the illuminati and conspirituality film Esoteric Agenda. Esoteric Agenda is perhaps less famous than the other two, but it was just as impactful for the first generation of internet users who watched videos online.
On this episode, we talk about the movie and its creator Ben Stewart. Stewart was the singer/songwriter for an up-and-coming but unsigned band called Hierosonic. While Stewart initially made conspiracy videos to discuss topics in his songs, he soon discovered his YouTube clips were making a bigger impact than his music did. That set him on a path towards becoming a professional conspiracist that stretches to today. He now makes series for the conspirituality streaming network Gaia TV and right wing YouTuber Tim Pool. To help us learn more about Ben Stewart’s career arc Travis spoke to one time Hierosonic roadie Steven Wynne.
Travis, Liv, and Jake ponder the chicken-and-the-egg problem of the conspiracy theory media industry. What really drives the popularity of online conspiracy theories? Is it suppliers like Ben Stewart? Or does the demand for exciting misinformation create influencers like Ben Stewart?
Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
QAA's Website: https://qanonanonymous.com
Music by Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Klotz.
Comments (68)
Conspiracies have been a part of musical lyrics in metal music for a very long time. There is/was a swedish doom metal band called Count Ravem which has a clear right wing, christian conspiracy bent, with songs about wacko, anti abortion, moloch, evil shadow goverment with some hippie anti war, coming nuclear apocalypse stuff mixed in. German long standing power metal band Running wild, mostly known for their Pirate lyrics on the 1994 album Black hand inn have a song about the planet Nabiru. Iced Earth founder and leading force if I recall corectly is/was a member of the oathkeepers and stormed capitol on January 6, had another project sons of liberty with a song titled Jekyll Island (good music in its genre, sadly lyrics are what you would expect, with a more libertarian conspiracy bent). As metal music is often into sci-fi or fantasy it can be just cool stuff to sing about (lizard people, ancient aliens, x-files stuff), or other times its clearly part of musicians belief structure
The streaming tech was introduced in 2004 as an update to Flash allowing embedded MP4 video, first used to debut the Spider-Man 2 trailer online.
Sorta hate that I really must say that the music doesn’t suck at all.
As a massive Dresden Dolls fan who has to deal with Amanda perhaps not being an awesome person, as well as a 2012 survivor who was disappointed to neither ascend nor undergo torture, I deeply relate to this episode. Solidarity, comrades.🙈🙉🙊
One reason why I joined the Patreon is that I have a friend I haven’t given up on in the hopes that he can get out/see the light. I don’t easily find the information about the support group DOUBT, discussing our unusual beliefs together. And when I try to look at the integrity url it asks me if I want to download anything, which sets off my spidey sense. So, yeah, did y’all look I to it?
Lmao I watched the esoteric agenda when I was 18 and was convinced I could change the world by spamming it all over MySpace. Totally missed the antisemitism in it tho, i focused on the spiritualism thing. Cringing even harder now
Stewart’s band and character progression is giving me Tim Heidecker/Dekkar vibes Let’s hope he doesn’t get horribly burned in a vaping accident. That said I know a guy who makes similar sounding music who suffered a stroke then fell headlong into conspiracy culture. Luckily has kept it mostly separate from his music and doesn’t go on fascist podcasts, but if you want to learn which blockbusters are Templar propaganda he’s more than happy to entertain you.
Which blockbuster are Templar propaganda?
Folks the songs are actually good. There was a glimpse of an alternate timeline where this guy meets Trent Reznor, they go through the whole Year Zero thing, but Trent pulls him back from the edge (they’re both from the same PA context) and he never makes that terrible vid.
Amazing episode, wonderful journalism! Thank you all so much. Travis makes an interesting point about supply versus demand, and I think about this a lot. How do we foster communities and a society that does not desire this fantasy world over reality? Without being too much into pop psychology, I have met a lot of conspiracists in my life who are very emotionally immature. Idk if they were coddled too much? They just never got the hang of dealing with reality. The hum-drumness of it. Our humanity, our mortality. But within those harsh realities is a lot of potential and hope and beauty! And they miss out on that too. There’s no real potential with these people because they’re lost in fantasy world. But it’s not just sensationalism in the way of good happy fantasies, it’s also these negative fantasies… You know the Cabal, the devil, it’s like all the good and bad things in the world are greatly exaggerated in their minds. And at the end of the day, the thing they really shirk is responsibility. Their responsibility to differentiate good information… The responsibility to help vulnerable populations, which is the answer to most of the worlds problems… I know it’s complicated and can’t be boiled down to one thing but it’s definitely interesting to try to point out all the ways we (as a society) go wrong and how we end up with so many people who would prefer fantasy over reality.
Love this host combo
I think the reason conspiracy theories took off in metal music is that you can quickly discern the lyrics in songs by a band like Hierosonic. The general vibe of a band like this just doesn’t seem like the right vessel for the topics, it’s approachable, friendly, inviting. Too upbeat for such nefarious plots. Metal bands get away with it because you can never understand the lyrics and then distract you with a kickin’ guitar solo.
Do you all remember the band Muse? They were from the same time period, and had some songs that were conspiracy related.
Man, I loved that band when they were just fuzzy space rock with a falsetto voiced singer. I checked out on them with their album The Resistance, which is very 1984 and probably also influenced by conspiracy theories. Didn’t think the album was very good and their image/music just seem like lame rock now. That said, their frontman, Matt Bellamy, has stated despite his interest in conspiracy theories, they are just distractions and took issue with Glenn Beck using their music, who published an open letter basically saying no and confirming that Beck continues to be a major asshole.
I love that you guys gave Ben Stewart a conspiracy version of Behind the Music. Great episode.
What about Seth? And Channeling? I was reminded by the Esoteric Agenda stuff about the books on Seth and Mu, the lost Atlantis?
I attended a campus screening of Loose Change with the filmmakers and some guy who claimed to be a professor. They brought people to sit in the audience who heckled. The professor yelled at them to get out and said they were from the government who followed them around to harass them where ever they went. When questioning the logic of the film, he would interrupt and badger the speaker and vaguely threatened them. This dude was very creepy and convinced us that they were full of shit.
Interesting. I wonder if he actually is a professor. I remember reading about the Seth/ "channeling" Egyption Queens thing from the late 70s early 80s...she was a writer who claimed to be an ousted professor ... it's the same story from them all, "mainstream" society wont accept them. (Because it's not true basically lol)
There needs to be some kind of governmental program for failed performance artists to build nationalised music festivals or something if they are serious about tackling online radicalisation.
There is a strong argument for this failed artist support based on events after Weimar Germany
Dunno if they ultimately get to this point (37 minutes in), but it’s amazing how this doc feels AI char of generated. Between scraping the Internet indiscriminately and accidentally citing a satire site and the confusing contradictory see/say video in Groupthink section, it really feels like a dumb guy with a lot of time employing a search engine is the same as a dumb computer doing it.
these are cool, always an interesting listen, I also really love the dives into the alien stuff like the plejarin's episode(spelled wrong i think)or the one about planet serpico i think the name was? if theres more stuff like that please please put together some episodes on them, they offer much needed laughter in some rough times for me. thank you for all the hosts efforts, it is greatly appreciated.
It breaks my heart the band failed. I really like those songs, especially the one with the fantastic guest singer. Will be looking them up. Conversation starter at the very least. They could have gone further but I don't think there was much avenue for independent artists like there is today, and it's bad today too.
Agreed! Amanda Palmer and the Dresden Dolls are awesome. They actually just finished a reunion tour.
Great episode as usual fellas; the music is honestly surprisingly good, not even just by Qanon standards
Big behind the music vibes
dude sounds like McLovin
The failed artist——> conspiracy theorist pipeline is fascinating to me. Thanks for a great episode.
That meme with the two paths to two different castles and it’s “failed performing artist —> regular Tim Pool guest” on the one side and “failed performing artist —> Daily Wire personality” on the other side. Both sides are the dark castle with lightning.
Oh man, wish I was half famous enough to be able to pivot into more lucrative conspiracy grifts instead.
i gotta admit, the discussion of supply and demand near the end is a little bit of a black pill.
Grimace 😂
FYI, if you watch the entire SNL animated segment referenced in the show you'll see that it has a number of footnotes and is more of an attack on GE and media corporations than anything else. To be fair, there is one humorous footnote that is directed at conspiracy theorists themselves, but that's not the thrust of what they're skewering. Watch it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nh6Hf5_ZYPI. Consider that Stephen Colbert and Steve Carrell were involved the group that produced these shorts when inferring their intent. This intent is what motivated GE to remove it from future airings of this episode.
Came here to say the same - it wasn’t making fun of conspiracy theorists, and it wasn’t making crazy claims either. TV Funhouse was a Robert Smigel project and he has a long track record of subversive content
The George Bush lineage thing is just the DaVinci Code
Amanda Palmer is also Neil Gaiman's wife which is just some interesting trivia
Used to be… they separated in 2022…:)
went down a google image rabbithole searching pics of the band. just funny on every level.
This is really hitting home. I live/grew up near Harrisburg PA in the early 00s and used to go to Lancaster to see bands at the Chameleon club. I remember seeing Hierosonic open for one of my favorite local bands. I really don't remember any other random opener but I do remember these guys simply because of the singer. Dude was barefoot, hippie dippie kinda guy going on and on about whatever between songs. I just remember laughing with my buddy about how weird this guy was, and turns out he truly is an odd character.
Great episode all around — and I appreciated the analysis of Chansley here, since it wasn’t in that episode.
finally we know how to feel about Q anon shaman
Did you guys see that he made a documentary with our favorite fake shaman and bullshit salesman Aubrey Marcus.
Oh hell yeah.
Jesus, the soudntrack on that doc. They're using a naked white noise sample. At least put an EQ on it ffs, some movement with an LFO or envelope. It's horrible. Bin it.
This band would have definitely been something I listened to at like age 13, but then again I was also a conspiracist back then so...
Hits hard. Another good one.
So it may just be me who never noticed before, but we're clearly starting to see a through-line where all of these supposedly anti-authority conspiracy theories are not only serving the interests of entrenched power but can actually be said to represent the paranoia of entrenched power. The revolution against revolt is now.
Gotta be a dissenting voice here. Those song clips you played were god awful.
Loved this ep. What a fascinating case study.
Do conspiracy theorists not understand that jews had a calendar with different names for the days and created before the ones used in english speaking countries? Shabbat doesn't come from the same root word as saturn.
To answer your question: no, they do not understand this.
This was another good episode. I might be a minority here though, but that band sucks ass IMO :D
Good grief, homeboy str8 sucks......turn your damn samples down,and get closer to the mic! Better yet, keep making those "radical" movies. And Jake is wrong, the whole band is trash too. Come on guys really??????
Looking forward
Ah it’s really too bad the music career wasn’t more lucrative than the peddling of misinformation career. I’d be totally into their music and the auto-q was really good. Gonna be stuck in my head for days 😅
HARRISBURG PA MENTION!!!!! WOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
We got this guy, we got the internet brain poisoned lady who tried to steal nancy pelosi's laptop, hope some more cool characters come up
Illuminati 2: Electric Boogaloo
Excellent episode! To the “supply v. demand” issue, I think there are two factors at play when it comes to a figure like Ben. The first is that free lance conspiracism is less “corporatized”- video sharing platforms provide frustrated creative folks an opportunity to produce and distribute what they create with very low cost. This contrasts sharply with recorded music- where recording and studio infrastructure is priced up by recording and distribution companies. Similarly, music venues have largely been consolidated and bought up by large live music companies, ensuring that most profits flow away from bands. In terms of purely pragmatic opportunity cost- it’s easier to be a conspiracist (and just having a certain level of aptitude for promotion and starting platform can really set you apart, in a way bands rarely can.) The second, regarding the latent audience for conspiracy content, relates quite well to the “structural antisemitism” episode yall had a couple of weeks ago. Alienation is a proliferating reality under capitalism, and the relationships that undergird and perpetuate this alienation are obscured from most folks who experience it. Conspiracy content provides a “poetic” explanation that rhymes with older extent myths and value systems- morphing according to the audience or conspirators preferences and needs. Given the crisis of history and humanities education in the US, it’s not hard to see how an absence of information (combined with miseducation and American self mythologizing) create fertile ground for this kind of content. It provides some answers as to the “how’ and “why” of American anomie few others can, in an attractive, succinct and resonant package. Given these two factors, the career of a man like this makes a lot more sense. He is one of thousands of alienated, not quite successful, creative folks whose journeys can so easily represent the frustrations of wider, misinformed, audiences. It’s like we’re living in Walter Benjamin’s or Theodor Adorno’s (or, maybe in this case more aptly given his hatred of pop music, Horkheimer’s) nightmare.
I was hoping to tie Neil Gaiman to this guy, but it seems like he collabed with Amanda Palmer a year or two before she met and married the maestro of modern esoterica
Still, it was kinda wild to have Amanda Palmer pop up there.
Antisemitic conspiracies still shock me for some reason. Even though I grew up in a small town in a deep red flyover state, the main employer was nearby Tinker Air Force Base. The Defense sector always gets funded, so the community was largely shielded from market forces and things like NAFTA and had no need of an economic boogeyman, so I'd never heard of Jewish conspiracies until I was an adult. Just goes to show, there is a real correlation with economic anxiety and these conspiracy theories. It's unfortunate that so many bad actors over the centuries have kept it going.
The Real Player Episode
THE HOLY TRINITY
Please, please look into patchman and “the spirit science”
Please do an episode on Spirit Science! That guy is so bonkers and responsible for pilling a lot of my friends. Plus he preaches the electric universe theory 🤦🏼♀️
Very exciting, great topic!
🔥
