Manclan Episode 7: Playboys Take the Godpill feat Hussein Kesvani
From Hugh Hefner to Roosh V and Hamza, we track the “playboy” archetype back to the post-WWII period and examine how it’s manifesting in current online manosphere influencers. How did pickup artists start promoting trad religion? Our guest is Hussein Kesvani, journalist and co-host of the Trashfuture and Ten Thousand Posts Podcasts.
This series was brought to you by the QAA podcast. Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Guest is Hussein Kesvani: https://twitter.com/HKesvani
Trashfuture Podcast: https://twitter.com/trashfuturepod / https://www.patreon.com/trashfuture
Ten Thousand Posts Podcast: https://twitter.com/10kpostspod / https://www.patreon.com/10kpostspodcast
Cover art by Jess Johnson (http://instagram.com/flesh_dozer)
Theme & music by Nick Sena (http://nicksenamusic.com). Editing by Corey Clotz.
Comments (55)
If you read Michael Kimmel’s Manhood in America he describes how the inner fantasy life of the American man has been like a respite from the constraints of industrialization and lack of upward mobility. However in the early 1900s, it wasn’t Playboy but cowboy paperbacks and wilderness novels that men read to fantasize and dream of being “real men.”
Arthur Dent got me bathrobe-pilled.
@1:10:00 ... "Alrighty, well, I made my millions, I'm out, peeaaccee!"
Joyce Carol Oates did not write handmaiden’s tale.
The Playboy bunny branding seemed to have a resurgence in the mid90's (in the UK at least)? I had no idea at the time what deeply misogynistic ideas/history it represented. Thought it was supposed to be tongue in cheek and trying to be 'cheeky' but just seemed cheesy and kinda degrading. Some deep seated shit right there.
I'm really curious what it is like now to be a teenager trying to make sense of the prevailing culture, and what it feels like to gendered folk compared to the mid 90's. That men were celebrated for doing whatever they want compared to everyone else, who could face ridicule instead, seemed inevitable and hegemonic to me in some way back then. Or that's how it felt. I guess it is hard to compare, but then I see the influence of Tate, seeing that news recently of that org in England who's had lots of calls from schools asking for their help related to kids starting to admire and talk about Tate in school. Or Jordan Peterson's shows selling out multiple nights a few years ago near my town, and all those people, largely men, pouring out of the venues after, emboldened.
On the topic of modern manosphere, I'm so glad that I am now older and in a better place mentally and emotionally to look into these guys and see them for the goofy chuds they are. Back when I was still dealing with the aftermath of a SA, reading something like a Return of Kings blog was my form of self harm. Thinking that every man was secretly like this and what happened to me was my fault. Now, I find them fascinating the same way flat earthers and Qanon is fascinating. In a sad, cautionary, roadside attraction way.
When you said: “I found a new book!” I was thinking: “Bang Believers”.
that accent saying “dicked down by chuds” was very funny to me for whatever reason
fuck being single i’m going cozy monk mode
Who is Larry king interviewing in the outro clip?
Dan Bilzerian I think.
In fairness, I'd also be pretty mad if I'd trekked out to one of the most beautiful places in the country and I can't enjoy it because I keep getting TO THE WINDOWS, TO THE WALLS, TIL THE SWEAT DRIPS FROM MY BALLS stuck in my head.
Never heard of the “whatever podcast” before, I’ve had it recommended to me 3x on YouTube since the ep came out 😟
Can’t tell you how long I’ve been waiting for this. Been following Roosh since his God-pill. Thanks for the amazing content.
Ok hang on folks--- this is def episode worthy https://www.ericconn.com/
One of the best Manclan episodes so far. Beginning with the history of Playboy and it’s cultural/political aesthetic, and then zeroing in on the stylistic and substantive similarities between the pre and post-conversion Man-o-types, was just brilliant. Thank you!!!!
This was a special one for me. I don't know why, but it was my manclan highlight, even better than the tate full dump.
poster boys for the zealotry of the converted
Fantastic points all around— especially about the Women’s Movement happening at the same time as the first issue and its thesis arguing for the single man and married man being “trapped” and supporting the Ol’ Ball and Chain. Fantastic analysis guys
Hussein asking “why didn’t you invent in Eastern Poland?”
I'm not a Catholic or a defender of that faith, but my brother is about to complete his Jesuit process it's taken him the better part of a decade of education and service. Comparing the spiritual training of these influencers to the Jesuit formation is pretty stark. https://bctorch.com/2015/04/28/catholicism-101-how-to-become-a-jesuit/
Maybe they are accurate about the formation of the Jesuits despite your brother’s dedication to that Catholic sect? About to listen to the episode now. Knowing that QAA generally treats all religious groups fairly, I doubt they said anything that was out of line.
Excellent discussion. I was particularly struck by the amount of "spiritual" guidance, and authority these undeservedly -self-righteous, judgemental, misogynist wackadoos are willing to exercise over others without a shred of training.
'sick of experts' etc
Bang Poland don’t bang Denmark.. I don’t know, but I just found that so funny when she said that. All of you in the group just keep coming up with great stories. I’ve been in a playboy hotel in Wisconsin. It’s really cool looking in the building they change the name after it was bought out. Keep it up. You guys do great work and I love all the information that I have listened to you over the last few years.
Gotta love Montreal. I vaguely remember Roosh V showing up and some chicks basically started insulting him and tossing shit at him until he cowered behind his bodyguards all the way to his hotel.
Oh god throwback to like 2016. Tate gonna have to debate Destiny about incest.
You know, I really feel for these guys on some level because I am a perosn who was very promiscuous and it caused me a lot of grief but I felt like I had to be/wanted to be because it was satisfying. I've often found myself saying "it really just rots your soul trying to meet people to have sex with them" but I don't mean that in a find god way as much as I just think you're robbing yourself of genuine human connection and putting yourself in awkward unsatisfying relationships for meager rewards. Companionship is desirable, being desired is nice! but these a diminishing return to all this stuff and its a painful lesson to learn the hard way. I have to assume some of these guys had really heartbreaking breakups and caused themselves a lot of stress by not being who they really wanted to be, that or they got STDs and now they need to reconciliate their identity with one that is inseparable from a permanent life altering infectious disease. Its a cruel irony that they've overcorrected from ultra-promiscuity to celibacy, and managed to be sex obsessed in both.
Hell yeah
I love the theme song for Manclan so much but I can’t find it anywhere on Nick Sena’s page or Spotify or anything :( does anyone know if there’s a full version out there or something? It kicks ass
Yeah it bangs
In Byung Chul Hans “expulsion of the other,” describes the decimation of the negative and aggressive positivity, which creates an overwhelming sameness. Self help gurus preoccupied with finding purpose sit solitary, conversing with their re-projected image. This creates a narcissistic feedback loop. Social media(and capitalism more broadly) has found profit in nurturing isolation and atomization, reinforcing the narcissistic feedback loop. The women they ridicule, the only perceived negativity in their world, are expelled and never listened to or understood. They’re sole purpose is to be rejected. Women are only accepted as a tabula rasa, without negativity. Religious specificity does not matter because there is no renunciation of the self to any higher being.
I can't get over the fact that after these guys had all the sex and did all the drugs (while making a pretty good profit selling that lifestyle to other sad dudes) had their fill and got bored with it ,all of a sudden it's actually bad and what wrong with the world.
Well the PUA dark arts thing is a shtick that doesn’t age well.
One of my favorite episodes! Thank you!!
when i heard that one of these guys called themselves "the jordan peterson of rap" my knees actually buckled and i had to steady myself with my hand to remain standing
😆
Regarding how a lot of contemporary religious leaders are gig economy hustle/grindset types, I feel like a lot of this is related to the long-term influence of American evangelical Protestantism and historically related American religious movements (e.g., Mormonism), which in turn is deeply intertwined with late capitalism/neoliberalism hollowing out civil society and public spaces in general, as Hussein mentioned. The sick irony of these trad-masculinity influencers bemoaning the “decline of the family” is that it is precisely the ruthless amorality of capitalism—a system that is historically inseparable from patriarchal, heteronormative white supremacy—that is primarily responsible for ruining families, certainly in a material sense. Furthermore, the Social Darwinist, zero-sum, “scoring women (who are, per these influencers’ ideology, a bunch of manipulative, evil man-haters, because of feminism) is a brutal, eternal competition between alpha chads and beta cucks” toxic masculinity that these guys are steeped in and actively promote is on its face so poisonous and harmful to people of all genders and sexualities and does nothing but exacerbate the very issues these GigaChad-Trads are supposedly so concerned about. Absolutely disgusting, exploitative as hell, and—if you’re inclined to use this language—evil. Thanks for the great episode and the series, guys.
Good take 👍
In the midst of reading ‘Pornotopia’ by Beatriz Preciado. Lot of overlapping themes around Playboy here, but as always, Annie Kelly makes it better 😝
Sorry as an American listening to Hamza audio-only I'm just hearing a mid Cillian Murphy impression "Arthur, get ya fuckin head together, man. You're not back in school askin' Mrs. Blakely to go water closet Arthur, you're a fuckin' man. Now pick up that Qur'an and get in the car, we're going to mosque"
Wonderful episode! Kudos to this podcast for putting this series together
I think your analysis of the godpilling stuff is spot on. I did my independent study on deradicalization programs last semester and this reminded me of some of the studies I read from that. The religion arc for these guys is really in line with the significance quest theory of radicalization, the idea that people get radicalized because in our increasingly isolating society they’re looking for some kind of meaning to orient their life around. I think these guys have led especially meaningless lives because their hyper-individualistic lifestyles have led them to deny themselves of any meaningful romantic or platonic connections, and eventually the emptiness got to them. I read The Truth by Neil Strauss a while back where he talks about how the PUA worldview ruined his life and he had to go to treatment for sex addiction to learn how to have meaningful relationships again. Imagine living a life where you believe you’re the only real person who matters and everyone around you can be socially hacked with little PUA cheat codes—sociopathic, yes, but also painfully lonely and empty of meaning. But they’re too insecure to deconstruct their misogynistic beliefs so they instead turn to extremist religion, which still won’t fill the emptiness inside them but might work for a little longer because at least religion comes with attempts at community. It’s so pathetic, really. It would be sad if they hadn’t hurt enough people to earn this kind of punishing lifestyle and more.
After finishing the last few minutes of the episode I see how you very clearly addressed all the shit I said already. My bad I gotta learn to finish the content before commenting
I did an entire masters thesis on Playboy/feminism/pornography! Wild stuff.
I've been robe pilled for years, it's so cozy and comfy
So we've reached the point where a live YouTube show is called a "podcast"? I guess the word has fully lost all meaning and just seems to indicate 'media' now.
Are you referring to this audio recording of a discussion that is available to listen to as a digital broadcast or something they talked about in the show?
Haha perhaps after Bang Vatican they could Bang Salt Lake City and then fuck it take it back to the roots (pun so intended) Bang Nazareth Bethlehem AND Galilee
Oof, so...the religious bent to the right-wing stuff reminds me a lot of this book on the formation of the modern Romanian nationstate (Children of the Night by Paul Kenyon).
New converts are the WORST!!! Not that I'm thrilled about lifers, but right-wing noobs go straight for fanaticism. It gives them the power they crave.
Yay! I love trash future.
excited to hear from our Tower Hamlets no-go zone homie!
So excited for another episode of Manclan!
