Episode 191: Mass Shooters & the Chans
A cycle of violence fed by decades of online culture. But what connects the mass shooters who posted manifestos on 4chan and 8chan? How does a massacre become a meme, begetting more tragedy? Dale Beran guest writes.
Subscribe for $5 a month to get an extra episode of QAA every week + access to Trickle Down, the ongoing miniseries by Travis View: http://www.patreon.com/QAnonAnonymous
Follow Dale Beran: https://twitter.com/daleberan
Buy his book 'It Came From Something Awful': https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250189745
QAA Merch / Join the Discord Community / Find the Lost Episodes / Etc: https://qanonanonymous.com
Episode music by Nick Sena & Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Klotz.
Comments (30)
Just returned to this episode, and it is so very good. A+ for everyone.
This episode was a perfect articulation of something that has me deeply concerned about the turn our culture has taken over the past 15 years. For the most part, it is the central theme of QAA - the insidious nature of how internet conspiracies gain steam and eventually a facade of legitimacy through sheer volume. What follows is the slow-burn radicalization of a multitude of disempowered, anti-social, internet dwellers. First they are simply dabbling in seemingly harmless dark humor, but soon the “ironic” nature of the veneration for monsters like Elliot Rodger melts away. Then you are left with guys like War-Z referring to “St. Eliot”, extolling the ultimate value of “accelerationism”, and longing for societal collapse and the subsequent civil unrest to create an opportunity for him to find things like power and meaning that have seemed so elusive. I think it is time we recognize the danger of these sentiments, and show compassion for people like War-Z by helping them find meaning in a way that is peaceful and constructive. Anyway, fantastic episode - haunting, but extremely compelling and well-composed.
im permabanned poster:
Great episode, thanks for this one, it's nice to hear from people who were around on 4chan on boards like r9k that I was intensely familiar with but got ignored in favor of /b/ and /pol/ when it came to the atrocities despite how relevant and different the nihilistic miserable incel culture of r9k was compared to the out and out devoted fascism of other boards and how they intermingled
Such a good episode, so well explained. Had to take a second to get myself together after it finished. Thank you all of QAA for holding this kind of nebulous stuff up to the microscope, it's absolutely vital work and you nail it every time. I live in the UK and saw an elderly British man with a Let's Go Brandon t-shirt on in a sleepy Welsh town yesterday, just surreal how far this stuff spreads.
Depressing but a good episode. It's difficult to articulate sometimes what 4chan was like back in the day. To be honest, 4chan now is a pale shadow of what it once was, and I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't survive another decade.
Excellent episode. Despite the disgusting and disturbing shit that comes out of these sites, I still have a tiny amount of sympathy for these disaffected and depressed people. It's too bad that the chans are just echo chambers for their collective misery which only serves to further isolate and radicalize them.
The interview portions with the frequent 4chan flier signify one of the saddest thing about all these angry dudes. Guy thinks being homeless is the worst thing that ever happened to him and somehow existing in a war torn nation would be better. Clearly he's never actually listened to any of the stories from people living that life. Despite being terminally online he's spent most of his time in an echo chamber getting but pats from people who if they knew he was black would make sure he was first in the ovens in their new world order. If he wants a purpose so damn bad why not actually try to find it? Instead he's decided it's easier to help a bunch of fascist edgelords tear apart society because any other path would require more thinking and action and self reflection and that stuff is just to hard I guess. I spent most of my formative years on 4chan but I never saw the appeal of the boards like /r9k where people just wallow in self misery or /b where everything is a joke but the jokes all just happen to be punching down instead of up. I'm glad teenage me, as depressed and isolated as I was, was able to see through all of 4chans "irony" to the gross shit it spawned from.
This episode was incredibly done. I’ve never heard such a thorough and precise description of Chan brain rot.
Even though I was already familiar with Beran’s work (and others, like Coleman) on the ‘chans, this was a great episode because of the interviews and audio clips, which makes it essential listening for anyone who wants to understand the utter nihilism rotting at the core of contemporary capitalism. Beran and QAA are right that phenomena like 4chan and Q are not to be dismissed as “superstructure” or “ideology” in serious left circles. This internet bullshit is increasingly at the material centre of the global economy—it has become infrastructure, and that should worry us all.
Tough listen, but accurate. Something Awful forum goons represent. It's a problematic thing to be, but by god the forums are better than ever
Well that was depressing.
Love you guys so much- started listening at the beginning of Covid. I am really enjoying trickle down too. This episode was amazing- I will be picking up Dale’s book for sure. Such a succinct explanation of motivations behind recent events. I am going to share with my non-online friends so we all can have a better understanding of what’s been happening around us. OK HAVE FUN AND BE SAFE OUT THERE EVERYBODY.
This was a very good episode. Glad it's a free one as I can share it with friends.
It still blows my mind that some DJT zealots were once fervent Bernie supporters.
A lot of these people are inherently shallow and are probably more attracted to the loudest cult of personality around politicians more than their actual policies. I'm a staunch Bernie supporter myself but even I'll admit "Bernie Bros" at their height were fairly insufferable. Couple that with a growing disillusionment in society and you have an easy flip.
As someone who was on 4chan a lot during the late 2000s and early 2010s I always found the ominous tone modern people use with 4chan as kind of hilarious. I was mostly on /a though and I'm still friends with a lot of people who I met there today (though we eventually migrated to twitter). I even originally met my now wife there (I'm a lesbian, and most of the people from /a I'm still friends with are women or afab). I'm always kind of critical people who say how traumatized they were because of /b or /r9k, because going to those boards was a conscious choice. I flipped over to /b once, saw a human turd, and said well this place is not for me and never went back. This isn't to dismiss the fascist hellscape some boards became, especially for those susceptible to it, but it was entirely possible to hang out on 4chan (and to an extent still is, though I don't really visit the site often now and havn't for a few years) and never see the dregs. Just like you can live contently in a city your whole life but also be aware there are neighborhoods you just don't go to. It's still our inside joke anytime someone blames 4chan for violence that "/ck would never".
Sorry but I disagree. It USED to be easy to avoid the worst parts of 4chan but at this point /pol has bled over into Everything. Even seemingly innocent boards have an undercurrent of it running through at all time. /X used to be about paranormal junk, goofy innawoods stories, sad boy tulpa shit. Now it's Jewish conspiracy theories and qanon lite shit. /Toy is a board I still frequent regularly and you can't mention starwars, Disney or basically any franchise that's ever had a minority in it or the thread will spiral into openly racist baiting and hatred. God help you if you take a picture of an action figure in your hand and your skin isn't lily white. /co is basically /pol 2.0 lol
Sweet Jesus, what an episode. Thank you for sharing.
This was such a powerful episode. Thank you.
Damn. This was really good but also horrifying. Glad I never found 4chan when I was a depressed and angry teen in 2006...
Man, I'm glad I was a teen in a relatively Internet-free era. Great episode! Important episode!
Masculinity is such a drug. If it doesn't go as promised, it's a high place to fall from. If you've got no decent power analysis, it must be the fault of those below you.
This was a rough episode… I don’t expect content warnings for the podcasts I listen to about online radicalization but damn, that was a LOT of animal cruelty :( I usually can find some way to empathize with wayward, disenfranchised people who turn to the far right or conspiracy theories for some kind of validation but not this time.
Yeah thanks for pointing out the animal cruelty. I'd tried to forget that instantly. Worth mentioning violence towards animals has often been a precursor to violence against humans. In a world where we torture and slaughter 2trilllon+ animals worldwide every year, as though that's normal, we have some questions to ask ourselves (not the slaughterhouse workers themselves btw, who tend to be traumatised by the work nobody else is (yet!) poor enough to have to do), if we want to minimise violence in our societies.
Dale has a beautiful style to his writing, and the episode was really well produced, I especially enjoyed the music selections. But jesus shit-eating christ was that bleak.
Great ep. Very interesting person Dale interviewed, sounds like a very smart guy. Thank you for this!
This was a heartbreaking episode. A hard listen, but I’m thankful for it. Thanks all 💜
The "Twenty Days of Turin" is an incredible novel. Absolutely check it out.
Fuck it. I’m officially black-pilled.
