Trickle Down Episode 2: Bad Seed (Part 2)
Henry Herbert Goddard’s work studying the supposedly degenerate “Kallikak” family made him world famous. In the words of a teacher at the Vineland Training Center, it also made Emma Wolverton, aka Deborah Kallikak, the “World’s Best Known Moron.” But the acclaim Goddard achieved for his work faded as psychologists discovered fatal flaws with his research. However, before Goddard’s work was dismissed as worthless by the scientific community is was cited as justification for eugenic programs both at home and in Nazi Germany.
This series is brought to you by the QAA podcast. Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Written by Travis View. Theme by Nick Sena (https://nicksenamusic.com). Additional music by Pontus Berghe and Nick Sena. Editing by Corey Klotz.
REFERENCES:
Carlson, Axel Elof ( 2001) The Unfit: A History of a Bad Idea
Cohen, Adam (2016) Imbeciles: The Supreme Court, American Eugenics, and the Sterilization of Carrie Buck
Smith, David J. and Wehmeyer, Michael L. (2012) Good Blood, Bad Blood. Science, Nature, and the Myth of the Kallikaks.
Smith, David J. and Wehmeyer, Michael L. (2012) Who Was Deborah Kallikak?
https://meridian.allenpress.com/idd/article/50/2/169/14846/Who-Was-Deborah-Kallikak
Smith, David J. (1985) Minds Made Feeble: The Myth and the Legacy of the Kallikaks
Zenderland, L. (1998). Measuring minds: Henry Herbert Goddard and the origins of American intelligence testing.
Zimmer, Carl (2018) She Has Her Mother's Laugh: The Powers, Perversions, and Potential of Heredity
Comments (43)
These came out while I was on a QAA hiatus. So glad one of them mentioned this series on a recent episode. Great work, Travis. This was thoroughly depressing and very informative.
I'm sad I took so long getting to this series. Go off Travis!
Of course there's plenty of eugenic sentiment still hauting us to this day, even people who don't want to believe they're subscribing to it. But I also think calling political opponents stupid is a way of wanting to believe their voters aren't bad, they just don't understand what they're voting for. They've been fooled. Or even harder, to deal with the thought that someone whom you consider BOTH your intellectual AND moral equal could come to the exact opposite conclusion and support the exact opposite thing you do.
Phenomenal. I teach about eugenics in my history classes and it always shocks people!
Really well done. Thank you for this. I would be very interested to see what today’s psychiatrists would think of Emma.
came back to listen to the last like 3 minutes of this episode... Shivers everytime
Brought ne to tears
I recall this family being mentioned in an episode of some podcast when they were discussing Free Britney and how she was forced to be on birth control. Not that things was better here in Sweden during that time and even longer if I remember correctly.
The language that was used at the time to talk about this shit is endlessly infuriating
We that got me crying. Could have been me or many of the people I've known and cared about were we unlucky to have been born earlier
This is all much more horrible than I ever could have wished to imagine. That being said, thank you for this episode. It is important to learn about things that are uncomfortable in order to understand how we got where we are today.
Found this two part story really interesting. Particularly b/c recently there was a general interest about when law is based on straight up wrong info, and when SCOTUS decisions include absolutely incorrect foundational arguments. I'm looking forward to more Trickle Down!
Over the last few years it felt like I was losing my mind. Early-onset dementia was considered. After almost 15 years building a career in environmental science and project management I found every step became exponentially more difficult. After 2 burnouts I was diagnosed with autism and advised that it would be better for my health to leave the career I worked so hard for. I've since retrained and now work in cybersecurity with an employer that actively sought autistic personnel, valuing a different thought-process. The point of saying this is had I been born decades earlier I may well have been labelled as feeble-minded. I feel so fortunate to firstly receive the correct diagnosis, and have been provided the support to change career in my 40s. Emma's life and the stigma associated with her family and genetics is a poignant example of how cruel and devastating misunderstood labelling can be. This podcast episode left me feeling both incredibly sad, but extremely fortunate. Thanks to everyone for putting it together, it's a must-hear episode that I'll listen to again and highly recommend.
https://www.penncapital-star.com/blog/pa-gop-governor-hopeful-mastriano-campaigned-at-event-promoting-qanon/
This was a great start and can't wait for the rest of the series On top of that the closer to this episode was superb!
Knew this podcast was destined to branch out eventually. Have been following for years now and is far and away my favorite series. Keep up the great work guys ✌🏼
Really like this series! And enjoyed the back and forth, similar to QAA, in this episode
I cried at what Travis said at the end. This series so far is absolutely fantastic, although it has blackpilled me even further into the abyss. Hook me up to the Viewist IV drip, baby!
I'm mentally ill and have ADHD and the conclusion really spoke to me <3 thank you for this incredible series
Great work as always but I was floored that you mentioned that forced sterilization of disabled people has ended in America. https://nwlc.org/resource/forced-sterilization-of-disabled-people-in-the-united-states/ "More than 30 states explicitly allow the forced sterilization of disabled people, and more than a dozen states allow it on disabled children" In a lot of states the process is trivial and the only block is a single judge deciding that sterilization is the best course of action to "protect" a child. Not hard to imagine ideologically motivated judges handing these out to "pathologically promiscuous" minors and shit. Remember the "cash for kids" scandal where a single judge sent dozens if not hundreds of kids to "behaviour therapy" camps for shit like talking back to their teacher because he was getting kickback from these institutions? Not hard to imagine something similar with these sets of laws.
One thing Travis didn’t get into was how many of the leading lights of American black politics at the time totally signed off on eugenics.
This was fascinating. Thanks
Forced Sterilization continues today. Here’s a 2020 aclu report about forced sterilization in ICE facilities. https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/immigration-detention-and-coerced-sterilization-history-tragically-repeats-itself And the Indian Health Service was sterilizing women without their consent at least through the 1970s https://www.google.com/amp/s/time.com/5737080/native-american-sterilization-history/%3Famp%3Dtrue
So important and wow, Travis, goosebumps for the closer!!
Came here to say exactly this.
Nope, it’s fraud, just like Dr. Frederick Wertham towards comic books: fraud
man i think we all know what its like to have to be evaluated by someone whos completely incorrect about many things. on 9/11 my 5th grade teacher speculated that maybe it had been the russians, japanese, or french who were the perpetrators, and even my 9yo self was like "nah thats not even close mrs. sweeney."
damn Travis
Ha I just finished the episode and said the same exact thing
Forced sterilizations continued in California long past the timeframe of the podcast, until at least 2010. I would doubt that they've been entirely stopped in the US prison system. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2013/07/09/200444613/californias-prison-sterilizations-reportedly-echoes-eugenics-era
I remember reading a news report last year on a doctor that was dismissed from the US border because he was prescribing hysterectomies to immigrant women without them even knowing what was happening to them, or why. Many women had their uteruses removed for no reason. :-(
Travis please do a segment on MTG testimony for qaa. I am really enjoying this new series man keep it up
Much better episode over the first one. The conversation between you three made much better listening.
When we were married in New Jersey in 1981, the paperwork we signed included swearing that one was not an idiot, imbecile or moron. Or insane. A lot of states had those laws. My home state, Vermont, has a shameful eugenics history. https://www.uvm.edu/~eugenics/
This series is tremendous. Great job.
There's also some statistical reasons to doubt "too good to be true" work like Godard's that are still underrecognized today. These same reasons are why we can be almost mathematically certain that Mendel's bean research was either described incorrectly, fabricated, or both-his numbers are too good given the inevitable measurement error of his methods. Mendel was just fortunate in that he was right about his fabricated conclusions.
These are great!
Bravo again, boys. As a history professor, I am constantly confronted by blank, doubting stares when I explain to students that eugenics is at the very base of liberal ideology despite living liberals denying this completely. So, thanks.
Just like the one before, this is an amazing episode! Julian Feels mentions the contradiction between Darwins conception of fitness and the morally laden idea of fitness that Godard pushes. Attempts to bridge this gap have e.g. been made in biologist E. Ray Lankasters "Degeneration", in which he seamlessly moves from the biological explanation of degeneration in nature to differences between human races at the end of his book. This teleological twist already started during Darwins lifetime and was strongly supported by Herbert Spencer and Francis Galton.
I feel very proud to be a supporter of this project in a small way. Thanks for such a generous addition to the Patreon. And congratulations on such a great evolution of the podcast
I was very much looking forward to this second episode. I am so fascinated by americas history with eugenics which goes mostly unacknowledged. I was also very moved by the life story of emma and found myself with tears in my eyes at the end. Thank you for the lesson and well done
This series such an amazing exposé. I listened to episode one and was floored. I’m a law professor in an undergrad program and Buck v Bell is, as much as I try to move students toward a structural analysis, is viewed as an unfortunate misstep. This material provides the stuff people can actually digest as structural that even the best scholarship on the topic can’t get across to a very important audience. Disability is a very misunderstood and exploited area in our culture. I love you guys! This should be nominated for a Pulitzer.
This is seriously one of my most eagerly awaited podcasts currently. Everything from the research, the production and presentation is top tier. Please condiser this one to someday get a full free release so it can get as wide an audience as it deserves. Fantastic effort, thank you so much for producing this.
