Trickle Down Episode 1: Bad Seed (Part 1)
In the early 20th century a psychologist named Henry Herbert Goddard aimed to prove that “feeble-mindedness” was a hereditary trait. His work, fueled by the frenzy of eugenics research at the time, focused on the family line of an institutionalized girl named Emma Wolverton, but which he named “Deborah Kallikak” in his publications. Goddard’s 1912 study on the supposedly degenerate Kallikak family won him fame and acclaim. It was printed in textbooks and cited in a Supreme Court case that permitted the involuntary sterilization of people in institutions. But decades later the truth was eventually acknowledged by every honest academic: Goddard’s research, which was validated by heights of authority and power, was completely worthless from top to bottom.
This series is brought to you by the QAA podcast. Thanks for supporting us on patreon!
Written by Travis View. Theme by Nick Sena (https://nicksenamusic.com). Additional music by Pontus Berghe. Editing by Corey Klotz.
REFERENCES:
Carlson, Axel Elof ( 2001) The Unfit: A History of a Bad Idea
Smith, David J. and Wehmeyer, Michael L. (2012) Good Blood, Bad Blood. Science, Nature, and the Myth of the Kallikaks.
Smith, David J. and Wehmeyer, Michael L. (2012) Who Was Deborah Kallikak?
https://meridian.allenpress.com/idd/article/50/2/169/14846/Who-Was-Deborah-Kallikak
Smith, David J. (1985) Minds Made Feeble: The Myth and the Legacy of the Kallikaks
Zenderland, L. (1998). Measuring minds: Henry Herbert Goddard and the origins of American intelligence testing.
Comments (57)
holds up high
I was diagnosed with dyslexia and and ADD as a child and much of my life Was spent in special education. All these years later it Still affects my self worth. This was a very powerful story Travis thank you for telling it
This is very fascinating to learn about. As someone who is diagnosed with "high functioning" autism and is often considered charming by people I meet, I can only shudder at the line about how the "moron" or high-functioning "feeble-minded" is seen as more of a threat to these eugenicists due to our ability to... get laid I guess?
Is Henry Herbert Goddard related to Bill Goddard?
I've finally been able to listen to Trickle Down and I'm not disappointed. The compassion with which Travis covers Emma's life actually made me a bit emotional. More storytelling like this, please!
circled back and listened to this again - bad seed 1 & 2 are stellar. Travis' narration is becoming the voice of my thinking brain.
My cat’s name is Henry 😬
Boy, this is really making me rethink the use of terms like idiot and moron
Great research, great work. Very well done job
Vineland was a planned ideal community founded in 1861. It promoted progressive thinking and did not allow alcohol. Women (including 4 Black women) in Vineland staged a mock vote in 1868 (4 years before Susan B Anthony’s famous voting incident in 1872) This community also was one of the only places in the country that tolerated women wearing bloomers so it’s no wonder that a more humane way of taking care of people with developmental issues was founded here. Vineland would make space for these individuals verses other towns who would never let anyone build such a place in their community. However so many things that started as good social reform ideas —like trying to find a place for people who would otherwise be marginalized—get twisted into really bad things especially by people who want to better the human race. Here’s more info on the women of Vineland voting and a link at the bottom to all their names https://suffragettecity100.com/22
Curious now if that somehow relates to the title of Thomas Pynchon's book (which I read and didn't particularly deal with these topics)
I’ve listened to this twice now and am very impressed. Such good research. The only thing I would add is extending your timeline for looking at heredity as a leading cause for psychiatric/ developmental issues. Also check out these books on the subject if you have time. Mind Fixers by Anne Harrington Genetics in the Madhouse by Theodore Porter
Cliffhanger! Need more!
Great episode, absolutely looking forward to the next episode
Great episode Travis! Can’t wait for more! Thanks for all the research!
Seems like Emma was neurodivergent. I'd probably have ended up in a place like that if I was born during that time period, as I have ADHD (and I'm probably autistic too). 10/10 can't wait for part 2! 👉🏻😎👉🏻
I've listened to this twice already. Can't wait for more.
Amazing episode! Can’t wait for the next one boys.
Very interesting! I look forward to listening to the rest of this series!
so incredibly sad — fascinating to see pictures and images — that poster of her father!? thanks guys
Oh man, does this mean I have to stop calling people moron?
Great research and important topic. I just thought it missed the interaction between all 3 of you that makes your pod so good. Absolutely no offence to Travis but this was a bit too much like a lecture to keep me engaged.
So impactful, so grounded, so informative. I love the more jocular, but this hits different. Well done Travis.
It's absolutely wild the lengths people will go to avoid just providing basic support to help better people's environments. Apparently its much easier to imprison and sterilize poor people rather than idk gave them basic social services.
Emma's description (attractive, charismatic, gets mistaken for the teacher) is eerily similar to Charlize Theron's role on Arrested Development. Looking forward to the rest of this series.
She sounds like so many autistic women I have met
I'm interested in eugenics and so I've come across a lot of this information before but the way you've put it together is really compelling. #TeamEmma
We love to see a reformed internet atheist put that brain to good use!
And I hope the titles means that trickle down economics will be on the slab at some point
I’m hooked!
I loved this. I'm a big fan of history podcast and even if this series goes beyond the historical i find this all fascinating
I was a bit concerned at first due to the lack of humor, wondering when the jokes wud begin. However, the serious research that went into this untold story made it brilliant. Not surprisingly, the QAA team delivered more A+ content, albeit wth a diff feel. ps: Despite being one myself, it pleases me to know that my offspring won’t necessarily become idiots too.
Great stuff. I'm also REALLY liking the music.
Thank you for your time and effort - love this! Can’t wait for the rest.
Holy fuck Travis
Informative and infuriating.
Super good episode - no nonsense to spot!
So excited about this series
Fantastic episode!
I do research into how eugenic thought permeates American culture today. Glad it’s finally being discussed… but this is story is just the beginning.
A great video on the bullshit that is IQ is 'The Bell Curve' by shaun https://youtu.be/UBc7qBS1Ujo Also probably in the spirit of the series is 'How Race Was Invented' https://youtu.be/q7sxTnWeQ8s that shows how race was invented in law to allow for conquest, slavery and discrimination without giving people an out by converting their religion. It gives a really good broad historical overview.
Thank you, Tall Travis, and regular lads, for this new content spin! Can’t wait to measure my skull (jk it’s huge)
Is it wrong to call Goddard "feeble minded?"
Loved this. Great work Travis!
Excellent podcast and this thinking I feel is coming back in our society. They are the others.
Travis, excellent work! Were you inspired by Annie Kelly's Vaccine to do another excellent science based podcast?
Really good cant wait till the next episode
This was fascinating. But don't just use Jake and Julian as voices for historical douchebags I beg you. Some commentary please.
Boooo! Just kidding. Great work!
Excellent. Well done. I hope this leads to other limited series.
Great work Travis & team.
This is really good
This was a great episode! Thanks yall. Looking forward to the rest!
It's funny because it did nothing to improve society and what eventually did have the effect they were aiming for was banning leaded gasoline. I'm more than a little worried that the damage sars-covid-2 does to executive functions of the brain (infects nerves in upper sinus, loss of smell is literally brain damage to area neighboring executive function part of brain) is going to see us lose all the societal gains from banning leaded gasoline. It is really scary how many people report both their sense of smell permanently changed along with issues related to executive function like concentration and so-called brain fog.
Eugenics the OG Q
So excited for this, well done all involved and cannot wait for the rest of your solo stuff in this "White Album" phase of QAA
Let’s go!!!
