D&D Court: Dick Nixon and The Chowder Incident
Dungeon Court is back in session! Join Justices Murphy, Tanner and Axford, along with the restored Bailiff Jake, as they pass judgement on your trials at the table!
CREDITS:
Sound Mixing and Editing by Trevor Lyon
Dungeon Court Theme Song by Sam Weiller
Comments (121)
'He famously had plans' as a description of Nixon made me snort coffee out of my nose.
This hinge d&d case sounds like it either ends in an orgy or the cops being called lol
as far as i understand you can choose to fail any save that doesnt involve a risk to harm... this is buttoned up
Isn't the guy just holding him to the joke bet cause he's now dating the DM's ex. So like his Ex Girlfriend and probably Ex Friend are just being assholes to him.
I guess I just feel like people who've already kinda wronged this guy are dog piling on him.
"Loosely based on Richard Nixon" took me so off guard
Actually, I'm in a dnd game that partly consists of people I matched with on bumble lol
The beautiful absolution of dice sin at the end of the episode
My partner and I met on a dating app and before we started dating we both went on a date with a person we also met separately on a dating app by accident and we started a dnd game with them and a couple other friends and it’s great lol
Just say "Oh shit!" And walk away
Hey, I noticed the social link for the songwriter goes to a deleted account. Perhaps link to their website?
I also just read Mistborn!!!!
yall would HATE to hear how often I eat cold clam chowder straight from the can for lunch
That’s true, I do hate that
" but a dnd night where everyone wants to just be with you is, insane " correct. I would be more than offended if I was invited to a dnd night with the girl im "talking" to, too compete with others for you? Insane might be the best way to put it...
I think it’s genuinely insane to hold your friend to a financial bet clearly made as a joke and then keep count? Personally I might never talk to that guy again lol I also wonder if it’s the first time the “you should pay my fare” joke has been said
I don't think they're friends or at least not anymore.
No short rest bonus cases Murph? SAD!
The amount of money I would pay to the dnd dating show omg
Twenty Sided Love
Tommy Dickles made me cackle in front of my coworkers good job jork
As an experienced chowder-maker, the idea of eating leftover clam chowder cold is vile. It's like eating cold spaghetti, just because some people choose to do it doesn't make it not gross
Man... if I showed up to a Hinge date and saw 2 other dudes there who were also Hinge matches I was now competing against, I'd be out of there instantly. That's the behavior of a crazy person. And if I were invited knowing this was the premise, I would say, "Absolutely not. Peace out, good luck out there." I'm tired enough of playing mental games when looking for a partner. Who is out here making literal games out of it? Lol
Will we ever get a DND court with amir as a guest? 😊 Love y'all and your work
I think getting Karina Drawfee as a guest was as close as we'll get to that, lol.
In the case of “The free fare fandango”, I think the DM missed an opportunity here. He said rest of the campaign. Next session, BBEG shows up and one shots everyone. Slide the 8 quid across the table on the final killing blow, “So, campaign 2 will be set ….” Bet fulfilled.
"chowder mustache" just fucking sent me 😂😂😂
For Emily of all people to go "...Really?" Against the DM. Total burn. You immediately have to accept the ruling. Justice Axford is handing down a decisive ruling here.
I’m a vegetarian that hovers around my partner’s steak/bacon and takes giant whiffs because I love the smell; it could absolutely go the opposite way with cold, stinky fish. Also the feeling of Murph saying “I actually have some great news for you” about choosing to fail death saves was weirdly cathartic.
How fast The Bache-lore became Lore Island…
I actually did that "start a game with a bunch of people I matched with" one time. It was as awkward as you'd expect 😂
For the record, this was years ago and during a rough patch. I am, and have been, in a very healthy and fulfilling relationship for years.
Free Fair Fandango case That DM doesn't owe his player anything at this point. It's insane to keep the tab, you're dating this dude's ex anyway, and you sound real annoying
Queer person who has been on dating apps - I think making a dnd party out of hinge matches is standard protocol at this point, just figured I’d drop in to expose this apparently strange alternate reality 😂
Fully I was thinking “the comp het is really holding everyone back” when the idea of a D&D game with matches from an app was shot down with so much derision
The last game I ran ended with a party failure. They didn't get TPK'd, because instead of fighting, the party got to the door before the ritual they were supposed to stop, THEN decided to long rest. They returned in the morning to the bad guys waiting to thank them for waiting. Bad guys teleported out, campaign ended. My current campaign is with different characters dealing with the fallout, 2 yrs later.
I will eat pretty much everything cold or room temperature, but I also whole-heartedly acknowledge it is weird. I would also say that if COLD chowder smells so strongly, it has gone bad.
Ohhh, you're so right. It should smell much less. Eeek.
The chowder case should be sent to Food Court and those insane judges.
“AMERICA IS MAKING DEATH SAVES” is my vocal stim of the week
hey i was doing pull ups at the gym and i fell bc i laughed at “the boot is the taint”
The TPK-into-new-campaign case sounded to me like it was an issue b/c they were going to start a completely new campagin; possibly different setting/universe entirely. Was that just me?
the case directly said they were going into the same world. same setting, same goal, different characters.
The barbarian dating the DM’s EX probably shouldn’t be bringing up the bet anymore
so glad to see the return of bear hell
I’m just going to say it - Bache-Roll was better than BacheLore. Justice for Caldwell.
absolutely not.
I can’t tell if I’m just missing the consistency of weekly campaign episodes, disappointed by the recent shorter lengths, or if I’m burnt out on Dungeon Court. Maybe all 3? I don’t wanna be a negative Nixon, I just figured I’d voice a feeling.
Definitely negative Nixon.
Return of bear hell
For the two crews amusements. The kitchen is upstairs because the house we play at was built by the dms dad, who is an architect. It’s one of the most insanely designed places I’ve ever been too. Like it’s very cool but a crazy layout. There’s a bunch of bedroom and a very big games room down stairs which was big enough for us to host our 8/9 person dnd table.
Also thank for the warm response. Made my evening to hear my submission and me and partner got a good laugh out of it. 😊
Absolutely OH PLEASE to the chowder wimps. If anything it would smell less if it was cold. And that’s just science! It’s all in their heads because they’re grossed out by the concept of cold chowder. And that’s fair and worth a raz. I mean, I don’t know what kind of chowder this guy had but I have NO idea what kind of chowder Jake’s eating because I’ve never had or seen chowder that smells like a TUNA FISH SANDWICH.
There was an 8-Bit Book Club where they said they’d stop doing the show if they rolled a nat 1, and then proceeded to roll a nat 1, and then immediately reneged! I think they legitimately memory-holed it (and the rest of the fever dream that was 8BBC)
Watergaterade
Refreshing. It's the only manila envelope colored one.
Well you know what needs to happen now, right? They need to try cold fish chowder on Adventuring Party.
Yikes, I don’t think I would want to know the first OP. Sounds like they’re fishing for validation
Nice
The last submitter has the right to Bear arms
I played on a slo-pitch team that was exclusively made up of the team captain’s tinder matches. There were men and women (she is bi). It was actually a good time! I think a D&D game could work.
Definitely. It’s an efficient way to sync up common interests and compatible personalities 🤷🏻♂️
Might I suggest Gazpacho? Best story, we are in Spain and we all got Gazpacho. The goofball in our group literally told the waiter that his soup was cold. The rest of us are dying inside. 35 years later we still tell that story, “ remember when Ted told the waiter his soup was cold?”
Amazing. Not even time heals that wound 😂 I was like 25 the first time I ordered Eggs Benedict. When the waiter asked me how I wanted my eggs, I made panicked eye contact with some friends before saying “.. Benedicted?” One of those small, endless pools of humor for my friends haha.
So disappointing that it was a long lead up to a Nixon joke… I really thought they were going to play Dick Warlock actual Warlock, stuntman trapped in an rpg
Player was definitely not smart enough for that joke
If anyone wants a treat look up Murph's college humor cat dog sketch
Two words: polyhedron polycule
Shoutout to all the uk people who know what quid *really* means
To play Asmodeus’s advocate would it be equally bad to bring sushi down as a snack?
no because sushi is normally cold (therefore not abnormal for it to be so; the coldness was the no. 1 identifier of weirdness) and in my experience sushi doesn't really smell bad. cooked clams are gonna have a much more potent smell even when cold
Ayo wtf was murph talking about? Bro was finna tpk campaign one finale if he wasn't womped so hard. Players don't stand down usually, so you can't just give a win, that's not how wars nor history works
Yo speak in defense of 'not bring able to fail', I often draw comparisons to Marvel movies, or Disney movies. I don't go into those movies thinking 'wow, I wonder if those characters are going to make it out or die horribly!' - instead I'm asking 'wow, I wonder how these chsrscters are going to get out of this one?' For me personally, character death isn't a stake that makes the game fun, it's an unpleasant consequence that when not placed SQUARELY under mu own control, makes me nervous to have the character make interesting choices. I still want them to suffer snd struggle and goober up on things and fail, but for me charscrer death is the sort of keyfabe which everyone at the table respects. If you end up with a situation where that's no longer feasible, you pause and discuss what to do next, whether the player is happy for their character to die, whether you inflict some other consewu3nce, or whether you just do some rescanning of the situation. If someone then uses that to take advantage of the GM, that's an out-of-game discussion.
Hey sorry this isn't pertinent at all but I just got back from Big Daddy's (New Orleans bar) from which I had to walk away because a very tender and unknown young man was about to shoot up in front of me and I told him I loved him and couldn't watch that and now I feel so incredibly disoriented and sad and the only thing that's making me feel better is naddpod. Sorry to bring it down, I just don't know what else to do right now. All my love to the 2 Crew and everybody on here right now.
Why am I putting all stuff on the backseat of the car, not in the proper car storage location? BECAUSE I don’t want to get up in that car’s taint every time I want shopping 😂🤣
Please. Caldwell. My brain is gaslighting me and now I feel criminal asking for ‘a couple of quid to get a snack’ … I just want candy and not there are penises are everywhere.
Unfortunately, when the President makes a character like Dick, it's not illegal
I do wonder if this person with the fish chowder thought that it would be less offensive to smell cold then it would be hot? But I think that’s a conversation that one could have directly 😂
I have absolutely considered getting various Lex matches together for a DND one shot as a way of assessing how they handle failure, cooperation and conflict before deciding on whether or not I want to go on a date with them 😂😂😂 I even have a straight friend I asked to be the GM enabler!! to be fair, I would also be happy with them dating each other?
From Boston area: don’t eat chowder cold, that’s gross AF. It congeals, and anything fishy already is rank as left overs.
The justices are technically wrong about the confession- there's no rule saying you can choose to fail any save you like, and there are certain effects like Zone of Truth that specify you can choose to fail, implying you can't on most. Also, you can't really choose to catch a disease the way you could choose to not dodge. That said I still agree that the player is fine
Murphs take on player death being on the table is a bit weird since he was totally unwilling to let Zirk die at the end of C2 Idk if he’s lying to us or himself but that man does not like player death in his campaigns
Home campaigns are different than actual play shows. But also I feel him. I'll always say oh I'll totally kill my players, but balk when it comes up
I read the dating app one in the original comment I’m SO GLAD it made it in
Be so careful with sorrel soup
caldwell I feel like if you're gagging because of your leftover salmon its cause you're making bad salmon lol
the dnd date one is crazy for a lot of reasons but also because if you're gay then you dont have a 6th sense for people who like dnd, gay people just like dnd. I too have matched with many people who like dnd (and even a couple who like naddpod) but nothing like this has ever once crossed my mind
Literally playing games with people's emotions
Dick Warlock is a real dude
@ 27 min 3 rounds of combat while stunned that's like literally 30 min of just sitting there. Ive had so many 3hr sessions where the one and only combat was one round. I would be so pissed. That dm was out to get that barbarian. Fuck that guy.
Getting dungeon court and a tortle tank in the same week is a huge blessing! happy 4th everyone!!! bless you all
I feel like the the player is way more in the wrong on the D100 bet. Yeah it sucks that the DM made no concession at all but imagine showing up to a weekly game and demanding $5 (and counting) every week from the person doing hours of free labour every week so you can have fun...
Not to mention the DM is in control of when the end of the campaign is. They could have made good on that first day by offering up $5 then saying a Tarrasque rolled in and ate the whole party. Genuinely pretty wild to expect someone to make good on a bet like that. Just make a joke about being blessed by the gods or something and move on.
DnD Bachelorette?? Get Sam Reich on the phone right now - the NADPOD guys have got a pitch for dropout!
“Fuck, I forget this bit” Murph being so jaded and fed up with comedy is very endearing and funny to me
You can't willingly fail a saving throw unless a spell specifies you can like calm emotions does. From the rulebook: "Saving Throw: A saving throw--also called a save--represents an attempt to resist a spell, a trap, a poison, a disease, or a similar threat. You don’t normally decide to make a saving throw; you are forced to make one because your character or monster is at risk of harm."
Willingly fail is different from willingly make though - they're not saying you can choose to fail and just have the effect not work
3 0s in a row on a D100?! First you go through a break up, and then you lose a bet when the odds were 1 in a million in your favor. It's hard not to think the universe might be against you in a situation like that.
The absolute horror of becoming Caldwell-pilled and thinking “Grinchard Nixon” two seconds before he says it
lmao save some enlightenment for the rest of us 🙏😪
gatorade shower with clam chowder if you do a boston live show 🙏🏽
Y'all know about Hackers but haven't done a podcast for it??? Best movie ever. The fashion. The cringe. It's the epitome of the 90s
Please, no more DVDs, I don’t know how much more I can take…
How about a VHS? It’s like a D6 with very skewed results
The Nixon one sort of made me think of the cockburn song “call me rose” where Nixon is reincarnated as a single mom. Idk why that came to my mind but it would be a sort of fun character to play.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Kzx_zSG3WVU&pp=0gcJCfwAo7VqN5tD
“They’re not matching with each other they’re matching with the submitter” smh so heteronormative, Murph. This could be a polycule of lesbians or an orgy of gays think of the possibilities, the drama, the stank 😩
ally hosts the queer bacheLORE if it is a polycule of lesbians 🤞🏽🤞🏽🤞🏽
"I am not a rogue" Dick Nixon impression made me choke
Dang I saw my name and was like what did I do, well time to listen to the court.
Don't think it's meta to not trust a guy that can't tell you anything about who he is or where he came from...
It's been good to be completely caught up this last year.
oh i’m going to start a series of campaigns based on global scandals- first one, watergate, you have to either break in and get the files for nixon for a stealth mission or ig do a highly social campaign trying to figure out the entire watergate scandal. tortles im looking for 1 egg (and a contract with headgum 😚)
ok fine i’ll just PA for the BacheLORE
The only officials I trust
Im earliest ive ever been and it hits amazingly
Man I've listened to each Dungeon Court a minimum 10 times and that's not an exaggeration lol
I’d like an appeal dammit
I don't I've ever clicked something so fast
I've never been so early! Love this!
Tiny W
