The Devil's Party - Secret Mark
This week, examining the long-awaited SECRET MARK - its provenance, its context, its thematic ties and textual applications to reading the literatures of the Marcan and Johannine communities, and its long history of acrimonious and homophobic reception.
full text of Clement's letter, and its included passages from Secret Mark, can be read here: http://gnosis.org/library/secm.htm
Comments (8)
Basically, the thought that occurs to me is there is a young man in the Garden of Gesthsemene who is wearing a white garment and when the Romans show up, drops his robe (because it's white and would show up at night) and runs away stark naked. And in Luke, there is a young man in a white garment who is at the tomb when the Marys show up. And "a linen cloth over his naked body" really kind of sounds like "describe a himation (or indeed, a toga) badly" Especially since this young man is described as rich, in a context where money and status was frequently connected to Hellanization/Romanization. And clothing is a really good way to identify people in a literary text. So although there is a legit argument for sexytimes, I don't think that it's explicit in the text we have. What is explicit, is that these two people, the young man and Jesus love each other, which might be the really important thing.
As much as it pains my queer heart to say this, I do think that Clement of Alexandria has a point when he says that there is a heterosexual explanation for this.
The Roman-ness of it is interesting because I feel it could support any of the theories of the origin of Secret Mark in a way, being older than Mark, being created by Clement of Alexandria, or being written in the 1950s
I’m finally getting caught up, and the thing that struck me about Secret Mark is how Greek it is. It has the whole thing of a teacher being almost expected to have sex with his pupil as part of pedagogy, I think in both religious settings as well as just learning some basic numbers. This to me felt like a very Hellenistic moment, and I was wondering if you’ve ever gotten this vibe from the passage.
hey marc - yes! i think it also has a specifically Roman initiated-into-rites quality...
The Gospel's had some great moments, but Secret Mark really stands apart. (Literally and in almost every other way, except for how it sounds so much like Mark.) The more you've talked about the Gospel of John in the podcast, the more I've been looking forward to reading it alongside the podcast, so reading John next sounds great. That also seems like it would make Luke and Matthew feel fresh afterward, rather than retreads of something we just read. (Growing up outside Christian tradition, I'd actually always thought of John, being the last and as being filled with the kind of fabula you described for the apocrypha in the episode.)
HOLY HECKIN WOW, this week's episode was life changing and wonderful!
this was wonderful Anthony, thank you so much for this opportunity to read the gospels as a(n) "internet" community. It reminds me so much of "the Gospel in Solentiname" and I hope you eventually edit our discourse into a written volume.
