💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
The Gospel of Mark - Secret Mark (1 of 2)
March 21, 2021

The Gospel of Mark - Secret Mark

And they came into Bethany. And a certain woman whose brother had died was there. And, coming, she prostrated herself before Jesus and said to him, 'Son of David, have mercy on me.' But the disciples rebuked her. And Jesus, being angered, went off with her into the garden where the tomb was, and straightway a great cry was heard from the tomb. And going near, Jesus rolled away the stone from the door of the tomb. And straightaway, going in where the youth was, he stretched forth his hand and raised him, seizing his hand. But the youth, looking upon him, loved him and began to beseech him that he might be with him. And going out of the tomb, they came into the house of the youth, for he was rich. And after six days Jesus told him what to do, and in the evening the youth comes to him, wearing a linen cloth over his naked body. And he remained with him that night, for Jesus taught him the mystery of the Kingdom of God. And thence, arising, he returned to the other side of the Jordan.

Comments (12)

D
Duncan Lindsay · March 27, 2021

The thing that jumps out to me about the passage is how gnostic-adjacent it feels. This whole concept of 'Jesus took this person aside and told them a mystery we cannot repeat' feels like one that comes up a lot in gnostic texts - even in the ones where they are supposedly relaying those very secrets. With that in mind, and given the seeming prevalence of gnostic sects at the time, I could buy the idea that established Mark was a revision that attempted to strip out the things that could be the seeds of gnosticism (though if that was the case they still missed a fair few). With that said, I don't know how prevalent gnostic thought was among the other messianic cults of the time, and whether it would be inevitable that some kind of secret-knowledge-focussed branch would develop regardless.

J
José Morales · March 26, 2021

I am trying so hard to resist confirmation bias that Jesus is a femme queen. Thats internalized homophobia I will work on later. At this very moment, the questions I'd love to hear yalls thought on are: -why SIX days? That stuck out to me as a previously unimportant number for Jesus and doesn't come up until I think Acts when 666-Devil stuff starts happening? -who cried out? The youth, his mom, or JC? -What language was this written in, and does its use of "love" bring us closer to understand if this was romantic or sexual, and not the community love that Jesus has for all of God's created being? -w h yyyy do the disciples act so shitty randomly? the same people who can't perform miracles are telling this grieving woman to back off? This really rubbed me the wrong way. (Side note, are grieving people given a special status in these communities at this time? Some communities assume all responsibilities for the family who just lost some one; is that true for this time period and specifically for the Jews?) -Is there any other example now or coming up where Jesus dedicates basically a week to one person? Omg please tell me JC was queer

K
KN · March 27, 2021

I'll bet money the six days thing is a reference to the six days of creation.

A
Alex Koppel · March 25, 2021

Whatever its origin, Secret Mark has gotten me thinking about ways Jesus and the narrative in the Gospel of Mark have changed since the story started. We know Jesus is God's Son, but in the Gospel so far, Jesus _as a human_ has no special history. All he has is a hometown, a family, and an occupation. He could be anyone, and says anyone can do what he does. So when Secret Mark announces Jesus as the "son of David", anticipating Public Mark doing the same in 10:47-48, suddenly Jesus isn't one of us -- he's been Someone Special in human history all along. The Gospel of Mark so far only seems to see human bodies as sites for illness and for wonder-working (sick bodies lowered through roofs, hands stretched out to heal or to rub spit into eyes). In Secret Mark, though, the youth's (resurrected) body has a meaning of its own, naked under the linen cloth. This echoes the naked youth Jesse mentioned coming up in Overt Mark and also the Crucifixion itself, perhaps the ultimate in a body having meaning*. (* It doesn't seem right to group the Crucifixion with the disease stories, despite their common theme of suffering. Does that make sense, or will it feel different after we get to the cross?) Where Jesus in Secret Mark feels most different from Jesus in On-Menu Mark how he responds to other people. In the Gospel so far, Jesus only makes human connections when he initiates them. He invites his disciples and last week's rich man into his life; when the former host of Legion and his mother and family seek him out on their own initiative, he refuses them. I don't know this echoes stories yet to come in the Gospel or is a genuine difference, but here in Secret Mark it's striking that when the youth reaches out to Jesus, Jesus for once says yes (and how!). (Would be very curious how you and others think about Mark in relation to/after reading Secret Mark!)

B
Bob Bae · March 26, 2021

On-Menu Mark. Bless you, Alex.

A
Alex Koppel · March 24, 2021

Wow! Secret Mark feels like a Rorschach test that brings together elements from all over the Gospel into a single passage: six days from the Transfiguration, the rock rolled from the tomb from the Resurrection, love at first sight with someone with money from last week's passage, angry Jesus, that naked youth Jesse mentioned, probably more. It seems like we can make out three different shapes in that passage: 1. a very skilled forgery, a pastiche of details copied from around the Gospel to look real 2. an episode from a stable, coherent document that got purged in producing the "Public" Mark we know and love 3. a survivor from an earlier stage of the authorial process that produced the canonical Mark Personally (and with no evidence) I like #3: that Secret Mark is a genuine ancient document, an example of the early Christian community trying out different combinations of the sayings and stories of Jesus in search of ones to keep. There must have been hundreds of these in the early days, a whole multiverse of Jesus stories people created and told and stopped telling. The formation of the canon gospels would have been a great cataclysm in which almost all of those stories perished, except those saved and knitted together into the official Gospel and maybe also this one bit of Secret Mark that survived on the lifeboat of Clement's letter. Or maybe it's fake. Who knows? 🤷‍♂️

S
Stephen Butts Liore · March 24, 2021

Oh I LOVE spooky gay Jesus. Am I correct in assuming that the youth passing over the Jordan is him dying again? Or would it be him fully returning to life after being with Jesus and being taught by him? Either way it reminds me of myths from other cultures that have rivers as spiritual crossings between the lands of the living and the dead. Additionally, how easy was it supposed to be to move the stones away from the tombs? Because I always imagine huge stones used for sealing them and if Jesus could move one by himself he might be incredibly ripped. Another moment of demigod Jesus forgetting that humans can't usually do things like that.

A
Alex Koppel · March 24, 2021

This is funny -- I read "he returned to the other side of the Jordan." to refer to Jesus (since Jesus always on the move) but thought it would be cool if it were an poetic way to talk about the youth! One thing Secret Mark gets right, whatever Secret Mark may be, is Mark's stylistic abruptness and ambiguity.

J
Jesse Webster · March 23, 2021

I keep reading various scholars saying that this can't possibly be gay, no one would assume that back then, when the entire context of the Mar Saba letter is Theodore asking Clement, "I heard this letter is extremely gay" and Clement going "ugh, no it's not gay at all, it's just that Lazarus [he was Lazarus, right?] loved him Very Much and Jesus spent the night with him doing revelations...is all." One wonders how Theodore took that response.

A
Alain · March 23, 2021

Yeah, I'm struggling to find a heterosexual explanation for this bit myself. If I close one eye and squint I can *maybe* tie it into last week's bit about forfeiture of worldly possessions in life, since the youth is professed to be rich and is also in a sort of post life state and yet is not quite dead. But who knows? I certainly get some big queer vibes.

W
Wilhelm Engelbrecht · March 22, 2021

No comments, just really glad that I was able to catch up with the podcast for this doozy!

S
Sara M. Harvey · March 21, 2021

You are correct, you could not adequately prepare us for Secret Mark! What's the provenance of this thing?? I'm dying of curiousity! As a kid (4th grade, I think), our teacher once promised to read us an apocryphal gospel and I was SO READY for something like this and instead I got a story about Jesus and his mother going to Turkey to buy coffee. I was so disappointed and disruptive that I was sent to the principal's office for the first time in my life! FINALLY, VINDICATION!