THIS WEEK IN VIOLENCE: Look What They Made Us Do
2026, Week 17
For this week’s newsletter, we’ve got a piece from The New Republic about further developments in America’s flailing attempts to disentangle itself from a war of its own making – in narrative, if not in actuality.
At a time when antisemitism is on the rise, particularly among right-wing factions that form Donald Trump’s base, the State Department is now asserting that they did it all for Israel. This is not only a disingenuous lie, but also a cynical move which will endanger Jewish people.
State Department Openly Admits Israel Pushed Us Into Iran War
The New Republic – April 24, 2026
Reported by Ellie Quinlan Houghtaling
A government release written earlier this week by Reed D. Rubinstein, the department’s legal adviser, detailed how the U.S. “is engaged in this conflict at the request of and in the collective self-defense of its Israeli ally, as well as in the exercise of the United States’ own inherent right of self-defense.” The release cited multiple letters issued by the agency to the U.N. Security Council as evidence of the apparent connection.
But the candid admission directly contradicts the White House and Donald Trump, who has repeatedly insisted that Israel had nothing to do with his decision to spark another unpopular Middle East war. Just this week, Trump complained online about the circling narrative, claiming on Truth Social that “Israel never talked me into the war with Iran” but that “the results of Oct. 7th, added to my lifelong opinion that IRAN CAN NEVER HAVE A NUCLEAR WEAPON, did.”
U.S. involvement in the war was reportedly arranged following a February 11 meeting between Trump, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and several U.S. and Israeli officials in the White House Situation Room, The New York Times reported earlier this month.
It was reportedly Netanyahu’s direct influence—and the ensuing pressure campaign—that thrust America into the war. U.S. military commanders advised Trump that components of Netanyahu’s plan to attack Iran were “farcical,” but by that point, Trump had already been inspired to throw over Tehran’s theocratic regime.
It’s likely that Netanyahu continues to hold the reins. Last month, Trump told The Times of Israel that the decision to end the Iran war will be a “mutual” decision he makes with the Israeli leader—though Israel has not made peace negotiations easy, repeatedly defying fragile ceasefire arrangements by relentlessly bombing its regional neighbors.
One central challenge of maintaining an empire in a supposedly post-imperial world is finding ways to couch one’s perpetual military adventurism in exonerative terms.
Per the type of discourse which is common to evening news commentary and opinion pages, America cannot behave the way that it does on the global stage because its behaviour is representative of what it actually is.
Nor can its increasingly unstable belligerence be explained by its commitment to an ever-expanding arsenal of means of violence; means which it then dutifully uses for the purposes for which they were designed.
Explanations such as these are a little too A-to-B. And so, instead, American militarism must be rationalised and made sympathetic – particularly in those instances which ended in US defeat. The war in Vietnam was one begun ‘with the best of intentions’. The invasion and occupation of Afghanistan was ‘the right war’ (contra Iraq), but being fought ‘the wrong way’. Iraq, the wrong war, was a failure because Iraqis were not ready for democracy. You get the picture.
One trope which became increasingly common during the Global War on Terror was what Adam Johnson and Nima Shirazi once dubbed ‘the always stumbling US empire’, a rote media narrative in which America is constantly ‘sleepwalking’, ‘sliding’, ‘stumbling’, or ‘finding itself’ ‘drawn into’ yet another military conflict.
The sleepwalking trope has enjoyed heavy play with regards to Iran for a while. If you Google the phrase ‘sleepwalking into war with Iran’ you will find several articles from both this year and 2025 which argued that the US military was bumbling, unwittingly, into another military entanglement.
Unfortunately, as the US-Israeli conflict with Iran drags into its third month, that framing is becoming harder to maintain. It is difficult to blame a military operation of this scale on somnambulance when it’s codenamed Operation Epic Fury, and when the President and Secretary of War are making regular appearances on television to gloat about how much wanton killing and destruction are being committed on their orders – and how they can’t wait to do more.
And so, it seems, there is a new excuse being trotted out for America’s latest military blunder: Israel made us do it.
This is not a new assertion. Just a few days into the US and Israel’s assaults on Iran, US Secretary of State and National Security Adviser Marco Rubio claimed that the US had begun its war on Iran to pre-empt an anticipated Iranian attack on Israel which would have necessitated an American retaliation to defend its ally. Cart, horse, and so on.
Nor is the assertion entirely without merit. Reporting by Jonathan Swan and Maggie Haberman published in The New York Times earlier this month revealed that the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had played a pivotal role in pitching the joint military attacks on Iran to Trump a few weeks before they commenced – along with the Director of Mossad, Israeli intelligence, and senior Israeli military officials.
But there is a difference between the idea of a global military hegemon entering into a conflict with an ally on the basis of shared ideals and objectives, and that of the military hegemon being lured, tricked or dragged into the war. And it is noteworthy that it is members of the Trump administration who are now arguing the latter to obscure their own culpability for the military-economic quagmire they have so swiftly produced.
The nature of the US-Israeli relationship is often construed as the great power being bribed, controlled or manipulated by its Middle Eastern ally. At times, this is an understandable perspective, given how often Israel is permitted to behave with impunity in political and military matters.
It is also a framing which lends itself to, and so often veers toward antisemitism, conjuring images of Jewish puppetmasters manipulating American military might from behind the shadows.
More crucially, however, it is a framing which fundamentally misunderstands or misrepresents the actual power dynamics between the two countries. The United States of America is the largest economy in the world, with the largest armed forces, with the most expansive military footprint.
This is not the type of country which is vulnerable to being pushed around by a tiny nation with a GDP the fraction of its size. The United States has backed and legitimised Israel through even its most heinous actions because Israel is geostrategically useful to the United States. To the extent Israel has ever ‘convinced’ America to do something, it was convincing America to do that which it had already planned and wanted to do.
But as the conflict drags on, and the economic fallout of the Hormuz crisis continues to reverberate across the globe – including to the United States – it is significant that the ‘Israel made us do it’ excuse is now being adopted by even members of the Trump administration.
It is now increasingly clear that Trump’s decision to attack Iran was a folly, one which has shattered the MAGA coalition and may very well bring down his presidency. Unable to either win the war outright militarily, nor extricate itself and secure a peace with Iran that would not signal resounding, humiliating defeat, a narrative is now congealing to rationalise what is increasingly looking like another ‘forever war’. Either the war is being fought for Israel, or it was Israel calling the shots.
This continues to be a disingenuous line, and an increasingly dangerous one given rising discontent with the US-Israeli relationship among the American public and the explicitly antisemitic character that discontent has taken on the right-wing.
Shock jock streamers like Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson peddling deranged conspiracy theories and hate narratives about Jewish people and/or Israel is one thing. Higher-ups in the Republican political establishment becoming increasingly candid (or opportunistic) when acknowledging Israeli influence in US foreign policy might be another.
But if this conflict continues for months, as it appears likely to, inflicting greater economic pain and discomfort upon even Donald Trump’s own base, those two thrusts in Republican rhetoric will only entwine, and become difficult to disentangle.
It’s a state of affairs which sadly lays bare much of the hazards inherent to ironclad, bipartisan US support for Israel over previous decades. By treating the interests of the Israeli state and Jewish people in general as coterminous, American politicians have implied collective culpability among Jews for every action that state has pursued.
By speaking about Israel with a reverence and adulation that no other nation enjoys, framing both the state and its behaviours as exceptional in every sense, US politicians created the conditions in which regular Americans look at the US-Israeli relationship with increasing scepticism and distrust.
And by refusing to move with and speak for their own voters as they soured on Israeli in recent years, instead clinging to a crumbling Liberal Zionism while ostracising any one left-of-centre who questions or challenges that relationship, the Democratic Party has abandoned the space opened up by this scepticism, leaving it to be exploited by the most cynical actors. Even the very people who chose to prosecute this war of their own volition.
Those Republican politicians and operators who now describe this clusterfuck as a project of Israel’s creation, carried out on their behest, are transforming a failure of American foreign policy decades in the making into a fate painfully thrust upon them by Israel. By doing so, they are communicating a message which may sound inane at first glance, but which will resonate at another frequency for their own increasingly antisemitic base.
Pay attention, over the coming months, to see which and how many Republican politicians gradually shift to speaking about this conflict as Israel’s war, whether in noble or derisive terms.
They are lying. They are running cover for another American military blunder born from imperial overreach, arrogance and fecklessness, and they are trying to turn their settler-colony vassal state into the head honcho.
And it is not Israel that will pay the price for this cynical framing. At least, not in the immediate term. That cost will be exacted upon Jewish people, in the United States and elsewhere, who will be made responsible for a war America has desired for nearly half a century.
Comments (1)
Somewhere out there Clive Owen nods in reverence to the episode title
