THIS WEEK IN VIOLENCE: Little Marco's Big Speech
2026, Week 8
Headlines continued to flow out of the Munich Security Conference last weekend, following the publication of our newsletter about Nancy Pelosi’s remarks from the conference’s opening.
The appearance of Trump’s Secretary of State to provide the speech which had been given the previous year by J.D. Vance was always going to be one to watch. Due to increasing friction between the US and Europe over a number of matters—Greenland, defence spending, NATO, and Ukraine to name a few security-related issues—politicians, diplomats and press corps on the European continent have been looking for something on which to place a positive spin for a while.
With Rubio’s statesmanly speech, it appears they believed they’d found something. Compared to Vance’s disastrous appearance in 2025, it was an improvement. That isn’t really saying much. But to believe this was a deviation from the direction laid out by the Trump administration so far is to focus heavily on style and not enough on substance.
This week, we’re going to talk about the thinly-veiled white nationalist vision laid out by Marco Rubio in his Munich Security Conference speech. But first, we’re going to provide a little background on the man himself and what it means that a man like that would be giving such a speech—because this might be one of those cases where the medium is the message.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio at the Munich Security Conference
Saturday, February 14, 2026
And finally, we can no longer place the so-called global order above the vital interests of our people and our nations. We do not need to abandon the system of international cooperation we authored, and we don’t need to dismantle the global institutions of the old order that together we built. But these must be reformed. These must be rebuilt.
For example, the United Nations still has tremendous potential to be a tool for good in the world. But we cannot ignore that today, on the most pressing matters before us, it has no answers and has played virtually no role. It could not solve the war in Gaza. Instead, it was American leadership that freed captives from barbarians and brought about a fragile truce. It had not solved the war in Ukraine. It took American leadership and partnership with many of the countries here today just to bring the two sides to the table in search of a still-elusive peace.
It was powerless to constrain the nuclear program of radical Shia clerics in Tehran. That required 14 bombs dropped with precision from American B-2 bombers. And it was unable to address the threat to our security from a narcoterrorist dictator in Venezuela. Instead, it took American Special Forces to bring this fugitive to justice.
In a perfect world, all of these problems and more would be solved by diplomats and strongly worded resolutions. But we do not live in a perfect world, and we cannot continue to allow those who blatantly and openly threaten our citizens and endanger our global stability to shield themselves behind abstractions of international law which they themselves routinely violate.
This is the path that President Trump and the United States has embarked upon. It is the path we ask you here in Europe to join us on. It is a path we have walked together before and hope to walk together again. For five centuries, before the end of the Second World War, the West had been expanding – its missionaries, its pilgrims, its soldiers, its explorers pouring out from its shores to cross oceans, settle new continents, build vast empires extending out across the globe.
But in 1945, for the first time since the age of Columbus, it was contracting. Europe was in ruins. Half of it lived behind an Iron Curtain and the rest looked like it would soon follow. The great Western empires had entered into terminal decline, accelerated by godless communist revolutions and by anti-colonial uprisings that would transform the world and drape the red hammer and sickle across vast swaths of the map in the years to come.
Against that backdrop, then, as now, many came to believe that the West’s age of dominance had come to an end and that our future was destined to be a faint and feeble echo of our past. But together, our predecessors recognized that decline was a choice, and it was a choice they refused to make. This is what we did together once before, and this is what President Trump and the United States want to do again now, together with you.
And this is why we do not want our allies to be weak, because that makes us weaker. We want allies who can defend themselves so that no adversary will ever be tempted to test our collective strength. This is why we do not want our allies to be shackled by guilt and shame. We want allies who are proud of their culture and of their heritage, who understand that we are heirs to the same great and noble civilization, and who, together with us, are willing and able to defend it.
And this is why we do not want allies to rationalize the broken status quo rather than reckon with what is necessary to fix it, for we in America have no interest in being polite and orderly caretakers of the West’s managed decline. We do not seek to separate, but to revitalize an old friendship and renew the greatest civilization in human history. What we want is a reinvigorated alliance that recognizes that what has ailed our societies is not just a set of bad policies but a malaise of hopelessness and complacency. An alliance – the alliance that we want is one that is not paralyzed into inaction by fear – fear of climate change, fear of war, fear of technology. Instead, we want an alliance that boldly races into the future. And the only fear we have is the fear of the shame of not leaving our nations prouder, stronger, and wealthier for our children.
As we have discussed in a previous newsletter, of all the big names in the Republican party, Marco Rubio is a true ideological chameleon. In the early 2000s, while serving in the Florida House of Representatives, he hewed close to the political line of President George W. Bush, as well as his brother Jeb[!], who at the time was Governor of the Sunshine State.
In the 2012 presidential elections, the GOP selected former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney to go up against the incumbent President Barack Obama. Romney’s fight for the White House ended in defeat following a campaign laden with gaffes, controversies and missteps which had seen Romney, and by extension the party he represented, labelled as elitist, racist, xenophobic, and out of touch (unbelievable, right?)
For a brief period after this defeat, Republicans committed to a period of soul-searching. It was feared that without significant efforts to make inroads with America’s diversifying electorate—including black and hispanic voters, and even immigrants—that the Grand Old Party was headed toward permanent collapse.
In Rubio, the GOP had found the perfect vessel through which they could communicate the conservative vision to that shifting electorate, without whom (it was believed) the Republican Party was doomed. A bilingual, Hispanic son of immigrants—Cuban exiles, no less—who could confidently articulate conservative values such as pursuit of the American Dream; defence of Christian morality; and unwavering bootstraps (or, ‘no handouts’) ideology.
The conflicts and tensions in these values had been made unavoidably clear by Romney, the multi-millionaire, Mormon co-founder of private equity firm Bain Capital who once campaigned on the notion that there was roughly 50% of the nation who it was his job quote ‘not to worry about’.
But from the lips of Rubio, the 41-year-old second-generation son of immigrants from a country associated with communist tyranny, who grew up in comparative poverty, and who had risen from an immigrant community in the battleground state of Florida to Congress’s Upper House? Those conflicting tunes became so harmonious they made the fucking walls shake. Oh, and on top of all that, did we mention that he’s white?
And so, in early 2013, folllowing President Obama’s State of the Union address of that year, to provide the customary minority party’s response, the GOP selected the freshman Florida Senator Marco Rubio, who had been sworn into the Senate only two years earlier.
In the final event, he ended up being upstaged by a bottle of water, but internal to the GOP, it was a minor blip. Over the next few years, it became clear that Marco Rubio was being groomed for a presidential run where he would retake the White House for the GOP as, in essence, the Republican Obama: Young, diverse, eloquent, and photogenic—but, above all, conservative.
In 2015, an article was published entitled ‘The Myth of Jeb’s Protegé’, a soft rebuke to claims that Rubio had long been groomed as an inheritor of the Bush dynasty mantle and standard-bearer for a new generation of neoconservatism. It appeared in POLITICO, which meant, as with all articles that appear in that publication, one must ask who placed it there, and for what reasons.
With both Rubio and Jeb Bush ultimately pursuing the GOP nomination in the primaries of that year, it is equally possible that either campaign had the article placed in order to distinguish one from the other. The equitable flourish on which it ends—Jeb having mentored the younger Rubio without molding him into a carbon copy, Rubio having dutifully studied this master of Florida politics without failing to craft his own vision—elevates the status of both without either losing honour. (Ain’t that funny thing?)
But the piece cannot as easily conceal some of the objective facts it shares, such as that when Rubio was elevated to Speaker of the Florida House in November 2006, he hired a staggering eighteen of Jeb Bush’s top advisors to assist Rubio in his new role.
And so, when Rubio and Jeb both threw their hats into the ring for the Republican Party nominations in 2015 for the election the following year, their politics were more attuned than any of sparks generated by a fierce primary campaign would suggest. What these two men represented, in effect, were the same bog standard continuity neoconservatism in ‘older white guy’ and ‘younger exotic white guy’ packages; the Duff and Duff Lite options of Republican candidates. (Ted Cruz, the Texas son of the Zodiac Killer who ascended to the Senate on the Tea Party wave of the early 2010s, would complete the picture with Duff Dry.)
In the end, all that elaborate daubing of different shades of lipsticks on nearly identical pigs was to be for nought. On June 16, 2015, a real estate magnate and reality TV star from Queens, New York, would ride down the golden elevator of his eponymous Manhattan skyscraper and reduce their years of planning to ashes.
In just a few short months, Donald J. Trump would completely rewrite the playbook for what constituted ‘acceptable’ politicking within the Republican movement. Well, later, he would rewrite it. First he would set it on fire, then piss on it, then douse the piss-soaked ashes in gasoline, then set them on fire again, then piss on that, and… well… the process is actually ongoing. If you look outside toward Washington D.C. you might see the flume of smoke and steam wafting through the air.
Not that the Republican stalwarts didn’t go out without a fight, of course. Some of you may remember the last gasps of Rubio’s campaign during a primary debate, when he tried to best Trump by adopting his tactics, lobbing barbs about the man having small hands to make crude insinuations about the size of his genitals. Though some in the media initially praised Marco for taking a swing at Trump, it did nothing to dent the big man’s popularity. In fact, it may have even hastened the demise of Rubio’s run, as brief elation turned to criticism for the right’s prospective Obama having sunk to the Hamburglar’s level.
And yet, Marco Rubio’s political career survived his humiliation at the hands of Trump. How did he do this? By doing what he had done his entire life: Hewing closely to whomsoever appeared to be occupying the centre of political gravity within the GOP at that time, and orbiting them with just enough spin to appear to be following one’s own path.
Off the campaign trail and back in the Senate, Little Marco endured Trump’s first term by mostly keeping his head down. Maintaining the GOP’s rote oppositional stance against the Democrats was easy. As a studious creature of the blob, it may have been slightly harder for him to consistently praise Trump’s foreign policy decisions.
Then again, foreign policy is historically an area where Presidents have enjoyed more latitude to freestyle, and by extension one where politicians with presidential aspirations like to demonstrate their geopolitical chops.
For much of the first Trump term, one of the central challenges confronting the conservative movement was trying to construct a more robust intellectual scaffolding behind Big Wet Don’s behaviour. Rationalising the actions of an increasingly unitary executive in the foreign policy space was ultimately a low-risk, high-reward way for Rubio to perform his apparatchik functions while currying favour with party higher-ups for a future second run. (2028 is coming, remember.)
In 2021, following Joe Biden’s election victory and the events of January 6th, Marco again stuck his finger in the air, and swiftly condemned Trump’s incitement of political violence. In February, one month later, he voted to acquit Trump on impeachment charges related to those events. Whichever way the winds of power blew, Little Marco followed.
By the time Trump 2.0 rolled around in January of 2025, Rubio’s occasional shifts, barbs and betrayals had been forgotten. More importantly (particularly for the President), his submission to the Trump Train and obsequiousness to the MAGA Movement proved he had ben sufficiently cowed. White Obama would be allowed back into the inner circle.
Rubio’s appearance in the second Trump administration was well-received by the Washington press. With plenty loons and quacks to worry about such as Pete Hegseth, Pam Bondi, Tulsi Gabbard, RFK Jr., Dr. Oz and Elon Musk, Rubio’s selection for Secretary of State was interpreted as the judicious placement of a voice of reason in the top diplomatic role.
This, of course, relied on ignoring that power-chasing logic which had directed Rubio’s behaviour throughout his prior two-decades and change in politics. But this is something political reporters in both the States and Britain have in common. Like the dead people in The Sixth Sense, they had a tendency to only see what they want to see.
This is perhaps one of the reasons why Marco Rubio’s address to the Munich Security Council last weekend was one people would be paying attention to: Because it offered both political reporters and commentators, but also diplomats and security planners in Europe, a chance to see what they wanted to see. To pretend that, because played on a different instrument, they were hearing a different tune.
It is worth remembering that at last year’s MSC, the world’s largest conference on international security concerns, the US speaker’s slot was occupied by J.D. Vance. In that speech, the freshly-seated Vice President delivered an abrasive lecture against the Europeans in the audience, hectoring them for their abandonment of ‘Western values’ and embrace of wokeness, political correctness and other far-right bugbears.
Furthermore, Vance signalled that the collaborative security arrangements which had secured the transatlantic region since the end of World War II were not long for this world. As with any engagement headed up by Vance, a man who wears his daddy issues like a pat on the head from Trump, and reveals his insecurity in every desperate attempt to ride in his President’s slipstream, the speech did not go down well. Ten days after his speech, the incoming German chancellor Friedrich Merz declared an end to US-European relations as previously understood, and even went as far as questioning the future of NATO in its current form.
Since then, Europe has, indeed, taken some steps toward bolstering its own defences and reducing its reliance on the US for security. It remains unlikely that this will advance to a full decoupling, at least in the near future.
In spite of continued signals that neither Trump nor the broader American right-wing much care for European security concerns, as well as Mark Carney’s much-lauded speech at Davos in which he declared the end of the rules-based international order, Europeans remain ambivalent in their actions.
One gets the sense that the nations of Europe and the UK are bolstering their individual defence spending more to try and keep the Americans onside and in the club than in preparation for a later, definitive break. In the worlds of geopolitics and international relations, ideas live peculiar, durable lifespans. On occasion, they die even more peculiar, sudden deaths. Evidently, few of the Europeans currently hear a rattle.
It is in this context, then, that Rubio’s 2026 MSC speech was, apparently, quite warmly received, interpreted as an olive branch – with weighty conditions. Contrasted to Vance’s bellicose jeremiad of the previous year, there seems to be a popular desire to believe that the messenger is the message; that the appearance of a familiar, institutional player like Rubio is a positive sign that all is not lost.
At a handful of points during Rubio’s delivery, he was even awarded with an approving applause break: When he said the destiny of the US was intertwined with Europe; the America is a child of Europe; and that, though America is charting a new path, it wishes to do so with Europe.
One has to wonder, however, if those clapping had been listening to any of the other words in Rubio’s speech. For all of Little Marco’s statesmanlike delivery, the speech in toto was as caustic and vituperative as Vance’s, only now buttressed by a hodge-podge ideology of white nationalism and 4chan-derived civilisational panics.
In his speech, Rubio bemoaned the harms of deindustrialisation and globalisation as though these were fates imposed upon the US and Europe, rather than having been entirely self-inflicted. The entire twenty-minute delivery is peppered with references to western civilisation, Christian values, Christopher Columbus, the virtues of colonialism, the mortal threat of mass migration and sundry asides about security, futures, existence, peoples and children. The aggregate message was a scattered, truncated fourteen words so brazen that it would be not surprising to learn Stephen Miller had had a hand in the speechwriting process.
And most centrally, Rubio pulled off the classic rhetorical trick which has characterised most of the right-wing rhetoric we have been subjected to since the years of Reagan and Thatcher: Pointing to the dysfunction of an institution caused by your faction’s own deliberate, systematic destructive actions, and then using that dysfunction to argue for the ‘reform’ (read: wholesale dismantling) of that institution’s remaining vestiges.
In this case, the institutions caught in the reticle were the United Nations and the entirety of International Law. Per Rubio’s framing, every instance of the United States’ flouting of international law, human rights, and the so-called rules-based international order—a term which had been popularised by his own country’s foreign policy set, and which he now dismissed as ‘overused’—was now evidence of the inefficacy of the UN.
Not only that, the unhinged unilateralism of US military actions in recent years, most of which have succeeded only in producing further destabilisation and unrest in the world, were evidence of the all-encompassing just cause of continued unilateralism.
This is the grotesque incoherence of MAGA foreign policy: That we keep breaking the rules proves you have failed to keep us in line. That we steadfastly refuse to accord with any and all rules proves that our own line is just. What is good for the goose is good for the gander—but while we’re on that subject, fuck the gander.
If individual words about the US and Europe were enough to elicit applause from those assembled in Munich, it is worth considering which other individual words do not appear to have provoked much discussion, let alone condemnation.
References to hostages being liberated from ‘barbarians’ in Gaza (a remark made obliquely enough that it could be interpreted as being solely about Hamas, but whose character is entirely altered by speech’s larger civilisational thrust). The neutralisation of a nuclear programme, not of a sovereign nation-state, but of a small group of ‘radical Shia clerics’. The successful apprehension of a ‘narcoterrorist’ leader in Venezuela, making use of a term whose meaning or substance has still yet to be elucidated by anyone who does not reflexively accept the tautological thinking it rests upon. And negotiations surrounding Russia’s War on Ukraine involving two sides ‘in search of a still-elusive peace’.
While it is not surprising that the first three remarks would not be poorly-received by a gathering of western diplomats and military planners, that the last remark was allowed to slide by Europeans more directly confronting the fallout of Russia’s military aggression on Ukraine reveals the shallowness of this all.
Whether Mark Carney declaring a break from the US at Davos, Friedrich Merz declaring a similar end to the rules-based international order, or any other leader gesturing toward some new, independent European order, it doesn’t quite seem like any of their hearts are in it yet. For now, they still want to believe.
And on the subject of belief, perhaps it is worth ending on the irony of Marco Rubio, a hispanic son of Cuban immigrants, being the chosen vessel to deliver this speech to the Europeans about the indelible father-son bond between Europe and America; the importance of Europe as the font of culture, science and Christianity; the progenitor of the great western civilisation of which the US (and he) are the inheritors.
What a sad, cheap, pathetic irony that it would be a man like that heading to Munich to utter a twenty-minute version of the fourteen words. Marco Rubio and his acolytes would like to believe this well-choreographed statesman, decades in the making, is really so different from the MAGA imbeciles whom he has elected to serve as a mouthpiece, of his own free will.
In reality, he’s no different from Enrique Tarrio, former leader of the White Nationalist street-fighting gang the Proud Boys, or the notorious groyper and neo-nazi Nick Fuentes; just another confused Latin-American nazi working doubly-hard to prove his bona fides to the fascist bullies, convinced that, in the end, his enthusiasm will make up for his demographic shortcomings.
But then again, as we’ve covered in this newsletter, that’s our Marco. Just an empty shell of a man, playing a role for whichever man is next up on the totem pole, in the hopes that one day, he’ll reach the peak. It’s worked for him so far. It remains to be seen whether he’ll make it all the way up—or if, when he finally gets there, there’ll be much of a world left to rule over.
And on a final, troubling note, that a pliant, institutional player like this is now comfortably articulating scarcely-veiled white nationalist ideology within the comfortable idiom of transatlantic security concerns is not a sign that the politics of Trump will one day end. Rather, it is being accepted, even embraced, and incorporated into the normal thinking and operations of not just the United States, but the entire western bloc. And that is something to be concerned about.
