Which story should we read in-person?

You guys should read the rest of the Half Priced Voodoo store series. It's fabulous

Do any of them star David Fu(k!ng King?

Anything regarding voodoo makes me feel questionable after learning Voodoo dolls were literally just a form of medical records. I don't like the evil rhetoric around voodoo.

IF YOU DIDNT READ IT PLEASE READ MY DAD FINALLY TOLD ME WHAT HAPPENED THAT DAY ITS SO COOL

We need part three to the human game

Infected town case files & the previous tenet of my flat left me a survival guide

idk if anyone has ever said it before, but I would love if you guys read The Previous Tenet of my Flat Left Me A Survival Guide (i think thats the title)

Honestly you guys should just do a month finishing all the stories you never got to.

How much do I need to pay you guys to read A Mountain Walked? Seriously, I will sponsor the video myself

Jane the killer vs Jeff the killer

LOVE YOU GUYS 😃😃🖤💚🖤💚🖤

Voodoo is good and creepy for a few more chapters but it definitely gets more action territory rather than simply a creepy story

Voodo sequel please, imagine how many new members you’d get

Really want more voodoo

point pine i beg

They should do some stories from the backrooms

You should read the rest of the tales from a lonely broadcast station series

Please read “My life as a voodoo puppet” I’ve listened to I’ve worked at a half price voodoo shop like 8 times it’s my go to road trip episode I’ve showed it to like 6 people an they also loved it

Reading point pine while camping in a forest sounds incredible

Borrasca 1-4 around the camp fire

All of those should definitely be covered eventually, but I’d really like the voodoo puppet one as the first half priced voodoo shop is one of my favorite stories.

all of them

Voodoo

I loved the voodoo shop story its one of my favorite I really want to hear the rest by creepcast cuz they read the stories so much better then the rest cuz Hunter does great with the voices and Isaiah is good at reading the story to it just makes it so much better then like mr creepypasta or ones like tht

I remember the short stories from point pine being so good. Can anyone tell me what the name of the episode is??

Point Pine & My life as a voodoo puppet !!!

"My dad finally told me what happened that day" is a story with a nonsense ending that makes zero sense in regards to everything that came before it and I think that author in general is a hack and has multiple stories where the reveal scare is, spoiler alert, "This MAN is dressed like a WOMAN what a freak!"

17776

I HAVE NO MOUTH AND I MUST SCREAM

Can you read Isiahs credit card number together

All of them eventually please! :)

really hope for you guys to revisit the voodoo series, that episode was a blast.

one time I saw a red bird on the car

All

Ily daddy hunter

only like 42 mins in, but almost feels like a depiction of trying to ignore addiction and cravings. the intrusive thoughts of ingesting whatever it is, reminds me of trying to quit nicotine and how bad it just lingered in my mind

9/11 country is terribly accurate

LETS FUCKING GOOOOO POINT PINES COMING BACK

I just want yall to watch Mandela Catalogue man

VCR Willie

I just need another long long banger bro no diddy something like mother horse eyes

Wasn't sure where to post this but gave me "my wife is peeking at me" vibes and thought you guys woukd enjoy it 😉 https://www.facebook.com/share/r/19JfgTsCFb/

I'm not sure when the next grab bag will be but I'd like to suggest The Song and Dance Man.

Which ever is the longest

Two recommendations, I Just Bought My Childhood House, and Asylum by Matt Dymerski

We need a creep Tv for the Mandela Catalogue. Thank

you could just watch flubber

Is this coming out soon?

Just found this channel called The Glendale Archives could make for a sweet CreepTv!

Could you read more my little pony creepy pastas? Rainbow factory or rocket to insanity!!

The one most likely to produce diarrhea jokes from Hunter. "Your only job is to cook. Do you not realize I have had the diarrheas since Easters?"

I don’t know any of these. I’m trusting yall!! 🥛

Read my life as a voodoo puppet if you want to crash out. It becomes Redditor hero slop by the end. It’ll be funny though!

Bangers coming our way

hoping for at least one goofy ass story à la jane the killer

FYI I finished the Voodoo series, and while I think it is good and well written, it mainly becomes angsty misery porn and just gets sad and depressing. Point Pine is also fun. If I don't go and binge a reading of it, I would really love the boys to cover Air Traffic Controller~

Also I read one when I was a wee lad called harlequin number 7 which I thought was pretty cool. Idk if it still holds up

Ive never read point pine, but I've heard good things. I've never heard anyone talk about the sequel to voodoo shop.

The King in yellow

Yall NEED to read “my friend has been living in an alternate dimension” haven’t read it in a while so it might be bad but I feel like it has really cool moments

More like OrangeGinusCast

That’s the OrangeGinus effect

Mom calls… DECLINE! More amphetamines and CreepCast for this white boy!

That’s the Chinese yogurt effect

The people have spoken.

I read "my life as a voodoo puppet" not very good icl

Fug I don't remember these stories, however I love oberservation stories like the gas station and the other that I can't recall right now. So gonna go with Life as a Voodoo Puppet

Such a close tie between Voodoo Puppet and Point Pine. Ideally I want both

I'mma go with Point Pine, 'cause I feel like "I Work at a Half-Price Voodoo Store" had a satisfying ending already, so I'm not too hungry for a continuation.

I've been waiting for point pine since that parade story

point pine PLEASE

Point Pine in person but then please do the My Life as a Voodoo Puppet at some point!!!

I just like the sound of the air traffic one made me think of the twilight zone

I've been obsessed on hearing the rest of the point pine series since you first posted it! i'd love love love to hear more 💚

There are a few stories i'd love to recommend for future episodes. Bonesaw vics cryptozoological garden, my friend spent 14 years in an alternate dimension, how to survive in hell, and the museum of humanities last war series to name a few

Id love to hear them read knuckle supper by drew stepek. Imagine the reaction

Point Pine is goated

No we need the thing in the basement

Okay it may be in last rn but ‘I Was an Air Traffic Controller’ should definitely be read at some point. Inaaace is a nosleep legend and it’s one of the scariest stories to ever be on the sub. Recommending people check it out https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/2unmhs/i_was_an_air_traffic_controller_at_atlantic/

All of them

Been waiting for Point Pine since the parade story.

Noticing how Rainbow Factory isn’t on here

not listed: RAINBOW FACTORY

YES POINT PINE LETS GOOI

They should finish Tommy taffy and the thing in the basement their cowards until they do so. I’ll still watch but they’ll still be cowards until they read those stories.

Just do all 4 of them lowkey

Happy appy again

Anyone who doesn't know, "My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day" (Jesus, these no sleep titles suck) was written by Nazisharks, the guy who made the hidden webpage and sexy neighbor stories, he is a pretty controversial writer in these parts as far as the quality of his work is concerned, I love his work but if we have to pick only one of them for in-person, I think point pine would make the most people happy

Are you guys done with Creep TV? I'd still love it if you guys eventually did the analog horror "Arcadia".

There was this one story, called "why we don't return to the moon" or something like that, it was really cool when I first listened to it.

Some scp would be awesome as well

Fucking read My Property Isn't Normal already

Can you guys come to New York?

I keep hearing The Troop is awesome

for a creeptv episode you should watch some japanese mockumentaries, there’s one about the slit mouthed woman that’s quite good

Glossing right on over the rest of The Thing in the Basement I see

Just have Hunter do the truffle shuffle on camera for 3 minutes and call it a day

Not a story you should read but a patreon exclusive you could do; I´d really wish for another rp/DnD type of thing run by Hunter. I don´t care if you do an official play or have one in planning but just the basic rp you do is already fun enough. And in person it would be even funnier ^^

Happy appy

Heaven keeps a Prisoner

The mold saga including the Infected Town Case Files.

i’ve been day dreaming abt more from the voodoo story

Sending this again for a future episode. You guys mentioned being interested in more horror from different countries after the Japanese episode. ‘Welcome to the City Zoo’ is one of the most famous Chinese internet horror stories: https://www.reddit.com/r/Ruleshorror/s/oqRoGOT9hC. Would love for u guys to read it!

I don’t fucking know don’t ever ask me no bullshit like this again

Why no horrors from the vault :(

Oooh I love having a poll bcs I never have story suggestions but i like to be involved :3

I had to look up Point Pine to remind myself what that was and I am pretty psyched about it

SCP lips

SCP MEAT NEEDS TO MAKE A COMEBACK

POPPA MEAT I MISS YOUR SCP MEAT VIDEOS. CAN YOU AND ISIAH DO A SCP VIDEO MAYBE IN THE FUTURE???

Day..... I lost count but I want them to react to clockwork but thats just me lol

I wish I could see the guys in person but I'm in the UK 😪

Please God don't read my dad finally told me what happened that day, it's not great

Pucking around or nothing

I want all of these I hope they all come into rotation

Finish the thing in the basement!!

I love woods,winter, and underwater themed horror

no banana 😔

All. Thank you very much

All of these. We really want all of these.

The second part of “I once worked at a voodoo shop”???? YES PLEASE OMGGGG

One day they'll read Godzilla Nes. One day

Point Pine Series for sure because it’s the longest out of all the options, but you guys should definitely read My Life As A Voodoo Puppet at some point! It would be nice to see how Travis is holding up 🤣

Is the “My Dad” one a continuation of anything they’ve covered already?

Please vote for My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day

"My Brother died when I was a child. He kept talking. I think people should know what he said".

this is day 247 of asking PapaMeat to support his child he had with me, he has not paid his child support in a year… Just because he’s some “big internet personality” he thinks he’s above child support!! Your child misses you Hunter!

Best Friend Ruined My Life Part 2 🤣

Can we find less goofy sounding music?

Happy appy

as someone who works in aviation the air traffic controller one is intriguing

Yo! my first time making the Poll!, I'm down for anything as long as it doesn't turn into another incident with David 'fucking' King

Can we get a sexy one where you guys make out at the end

Can we get some good ones again

The longest one

Air traffic controller story definitely involves suicide

Forget all that. Do NES Godzilla

So many good options so little choices

“My Dad” is such a great one! Please!

I Bought My ChildHood Home or Rap Rat

I’ve heard my dad is long and a really good story

Point pine, seems like the longest, I'm unsure how plausible it is but for extra content a horror movie night someday would be cool.

I always love stories that involve voodoo it’s always so interesting to read

Point pine or voodoo puppet. I know they'll absolutely hate the second half of vodoo. Orrr.... Hear me out. You guys ready all of them!!! In one sitting.

If the Voodoo Puppet is a follow up from the Half Priced Shop, I’m down.

I started my voodoo puppet and it's great! Would love to hear all of them

MY DAD PLZZZZ ITS SO WORTH IT

All?

Please do point pine and voodoo puppet! Both bangers

Which one has the most dialogue i want to hear hunter fumble and struggle the whole time like a good boy

Creep TV: Mandela Catelog

Whats the point pine series?

MY PROPERTY ISNT NORMAL

“mom.. somethings wrong with Isaiah‘s lips” heard that’s a pretty good one

I want whichever is longest to fill my big belly

Who is the point pine series by I know that I liked the story that’s attached to it I think but I can’t remember the story or the writer

Whichever one is longest

Whatever is ready I will be sat, ready to listen! 🎉

I'd love for you to read the sexy neighbor one Hunter did as a bonus

Has to be point pine stories the short ones they already read were elite

I really want point pine and voodoo puppet ya gotta do both its like lays potato chips can just eat one. Cmon guys fill our bellys with good creeping

read 50 shades of grey but isaiah is christian grey and hunter is anastasia

MY DAD PLEASESEE

I was hoping that twin paradox would show up because I've been asking for it for ages but yet it never gets put out.

Point pine would be fun, but I think my dad one is interesting

PUPPET MASTERS REGIME

If theres room for more suggestions Christian Wallace has one about 20 minutes long called "Im a social worker for psychic children", its UNBELIEVABLY good and has so many scary concepts in 20 minutes, it's a must read for a grab bag at some point

Which one is the longest?

Happy appy AGAIN AGAIN!

I’m stoked that my dad finally told me what happened is on their radar

Half an hour ago I just listened to the episode of them reading “Everyone Month A Parade Would Pass By My Home Town” and thought “They should read the rest of the Point Pine series” and then they post this

Didn't even have to read any of the other titles, easiest vote of my life.

Please let voodoo win

Grimm's Fairy Tales

They need to finish the Tommy taffy series

Don’t know any of these but point pine sounds good in name alone

You guys will read borrasca 5 but will not finish the thing in the basement? Whack

We the people, the casting creepers, the children of the creep. We must band together and vote for the most quality (or hilarious), but longest episode.

I hope they all get read at some point! but the in-person part makes it so much harder to decide

BLOWFLY GIRL

Point peens or my story daddies

One that changed my life as a kid was, "Knocking." Would love if the boys read that one day

Hey guys, I think you would really like the Novel Tender Is The Flesh by Augustina Bazterrica. It's not very long and since yall have been doing longer vids, maybe it may fit in. It's a crazy read and I think you'd like it. I read it when looking for more authors of color. I will keep commenting this everywhere until you acknowledge it!

Jane vs Jeff

This one for sure Post 15 of asking that I would really love to see yalls spin on reading "I'm a Guard Stationed at a secret government prison" https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/cr0lna/im_a_guard_stationed_at_a_secret_government/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Hunter has to show Isaiah the story about the sexy neighbour. that was hilarious

finish tommy taffy

can you guys plss read the novella in the miso soup i loved it & think its a cool monster/psychological horror!! i think more non-u.s horror would be fun too!

Manifesting the creature to read point pine 🌲

I wanna know which one is the longest before I vote, I love a long episode and what it does to mummy and daddy’s sanity

Fifty shades please

No Christian Wallace story. WHY MUST YOU DO THIS TO ME!!! But fr tho I’d love for you guys to read the point pine series, that authors grab bag episode was really fun

Choose my life as a voodoo puppet

The one that rivals Mother Horse Eyes in length

Where in the world is Jane vs Jeff I know you remember. It's going to happen one day.

When are you finally going to read Moby Dick from front to back in one episode? Your fans are getting hungry, Mr. Creepy.

It's a hard choice for me between point pine and voodoo, but I really liked where Voodoo store ended and don't really need to see more. Pine it is

I want voodoo puppets please

I saw so many people saying "My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened" today for their recc on the previous post, it's time to put your money where your mouth is, guys..

Finish thing in the basement

I'd give you my left nut to keep reading the Voodoo series. It's in my top 3 all timers for Creepin my Cast.

Point pine 💯🔥🔥🔥

The rest of accounts from a lonely broadcast station

If I can make a recommendation, I would really like for you guys to read “The Neverglade mysteries” at some point as well

How in the world is the voodoo story getting more votes than the Jared Robert’s one 😭

Im still begging yall to read the troupe 😭 its not a long book at all and the boys would LOOOVE ITT

Please lord five me more of the Point Pine series!!!

Never have we heard a story about air traffic controllers

Voodoo doll had some good laughs, if the follow up is similar I think we'll get some good mileage out of it

Personally, I’m a really big fan of the grab bags. Christian Wallace is also a super good choice.

My dad finally told me why happened that day has big penpal vibes. If you liked penpal you’ll prolly like it

VOODOO PUPPET PLEASE

Whichever is the longest

whichever one is gonna take them so long to read they end up recording at 2am completely delirious

Man blast from the past with my life as a voodoo puppet

Is My Life as a Voodoo Puppet the sequel to the voodoo shop story?

The Longest one ♥️

I remember listening to point pine but not what happens but I really enjoy the half priced voodoo shop series

Would love to hear the voodoo shop series continued on.

Read the rest of "I dared my best friend to ruin my life"

Don’t vote if you don’t know the story guys!! Or do fuck it

The day of all the blood

Clearly the one with series is gonna win we want our 7 hour episodes to last our work day

Thing in The Basement pt2

Baller

Happy appy 2…

POINT PEEN

The story of how much you two love each other

Longest one

This story is very good https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/CiWYYTVaYE

Which one is the longest?

Goy

The Rats in the Walls by HPL, Tower of the Elephant by Robert E. Howard

What happened with the livestream?!?

Hehe PP

Where is Isaiah’s Van Gogh Dr Who fanfiction???

My life as a voodoo puppet PLS MY FELLOW CREEPS

Secret Jane vs Jeff option

my honest answer is: the longest one

Point pine ez

Yessspoint pine I’m so glad they added my suggestion

hell yea second!!

I don’t see gameboy SP blue edition here?

My life as a voodoo puppet seems like a sequel to “working at a voodoo shop” episode they did

Is my life as a voodoo puppet a sequel to the voodoo shop story?

TOMMY TAFFY 3 AND 4

First homos