💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 29, 2025

Interview With the Author: Dathan Auerbach

Today we talk with the author of Penpal, Dathan Auerbach, on the early days of NoSleep, the stages of ideation for Penpal and becoming a writer in real time.

Comments (432)

D
Devin Stoneberg · October 27, 2026

This is making me self conscious of how much I say “like”. Man that is annoying.

C
Capuwi · September 29, 2026

Imo Borrasca had the best jokes, but penpal I think will always be my favorite story

M
MAGGIE!!!!! · September 22, 2026

FLORIDA MENTION 🗣️🗣️🗣️

M
MAGGIE!!!!! · September 22, 2026

MAGGIE MENTION 🗣️🗣️🗣️

D
Dav Leo · September 8, 2026

What a fuckin baby. He was in the goop suit bro!

I
Ico · September 4, 2026

"LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE LIKE"

C
ColeyBoi · August 29, 2026

Since you guys had read Penpal, I believe you guys should read Bad Man

g
glubby · August 11, 2026

isaiah telling dathan about how hunter talks about the creek scene feels like a mom telling her nervous child's favorite actor about how much her kid loves them and talks about them at home

N
Nopey · August 3, 2026

I keep coming back to this ep cause it’s about a great questions and dathan is fkn awesome I hope we get more interviews they should cover bad man for their first book

C
CowSquid · July 15, 2026

This story holds a special spot in my mind because I actually have a personal story to meeting people through balloons. LONG STORY SHORT when I was in 3rd grade I found a balloon that had a note from another schools 3rd grade science class on it that was part of an experiment and our classes ended up meeting and having a pizza party.

O
Oliver.JM · June 17, 2026

They need to interview C.K. Walker

D
Daniel Barlow · June 11, 2026

I love how he started saying "like" in every sentence and then it started affecting you both xD creepy boys got like, cursed

C
Christian · April 12, 2026

Love this interview. My girlfriend bought me a year long subscription to the Patreon for Valentines Day, and I'm thrilled. Huge fan of the podcast and both channels. Love you guys

N
Nopey · August 3, 2026

Goated gift

R
Rem was completely right this episode, Shaun. · March 30, 2026

Awesome interview I loved it but around the 38 minute mark i couldn’t stop hearing every single “like” the author said it just highlighted itself every single time in my brain and i started laughing my ass off

P
PLAZZTICK · March 20, 2026

I love seeing Hunter and Isaiah talk about creating art/writing in general I would love to see (or I guess listen lol) to more of them talking about writing, drawing, and filming, how to get creative and their own processes with creating in general.

K
Kimbersmom · March 6, 2026

It's so cool to hear from an author! Penpal has definitely stuck with me as one of the greatest Creepcast reads for sure. Ya'll mention an old story called "Correspondence " by Bloodstains and it sounds pretty interesting, I would love to hear you guys bring that one to life :)

K
Konstantinos Tsagalidhs · January 21, 2026

The veronica voice offended me cuz i had superimpossed my actual crush to her character

K
Konstantinos Tsagalidhs · January 21, 2026

Child SA survivor here. I remember how much the story scarred me as a kid before my SA. After that period, i saw this story from a really different view

V
Vene · January 4, 2026

I’m not kidding when I say this interview genuinely got me out of my writers block

A
Amber Funk · January 2, 2026

I immediately bought Penpal and Badman as soon as I was done listening to Penpal on CreepCast! It's such a good book, and Badman was great. Super excited to read more of Dathan's work!

A
Archer21 · December 31, 2025

I really wish it would get turned into a show or something

E
Elle · December 24, 2025

Subscribed to the Patreon primarily because I want to watch this interview. Penpal is my favorite story on Creepcast of all time, it's genuinely insane that Footsteps is the first thing he ever wrote. Really great interview 🙏

J
Julian Miranda · December 28, 2025

same dude, just subbed and made a beeline for this one

H
Hank Greenburg · December 9, 2025

Wendigoon: "Penpal is one of the internet horror stories." Wow what a compliment lol Good interview and Dathan is great. Very glad he's still writing. You guys shoulda asked him about reading Badman for the show.

c
chase rivera · December 3, 2025

Bros dreamy

M
Monica R · November 27, 2025

So I'm a book girly and a reel just recommended penpal for a thriller that scared the shit out of them lol it was crazy to encounter it in the wild. I stay creeping til I cast 👻

a
autumn garrett · November 23, 2025

This story lives in my mind rent free, it has stuck with me in a way that few stories have. Id love to see you guys cover correspondence although it would be super long, it's worth it.

T
Tarek · November 17, 2025

We need a Jared Robert’s interview.. that guy has some insane stories then they should also cover but my word I’d love to see what that interview would look like

B
Bright Anderson · November 17, 2025

This is such a delight! Penpal was the story that affected me the most. He so eloquently captures the emotions and stitched-together dream logic of childhood to weave one of the most tragic stories I've ever heard. It only gets better/more painful on re-listens. I bought the paperback after the episode.

t
the_big_sandwich · November 16, 2025

joined for the author interviews, great stuff boys

T
The House · November 15, 2025

My favorite thing about experiencing Penpal is that its scarier the second and third time than the first time around

H
Horrorstory · November 13, 2025

Came from the Smiling Ones video when I heard you did this interview, immediately joined! SO EXCITED

J
Jesse B. · November 7, 2025

I recently moved into a house with a crawl space and still have nightmares to the first time I watched Penpal. man left a lasting impression

Q
Quinn · November 5, 2025

I used this interview as an excuse to relisten to Penpal

C
Collin Hall · November 4, 2025

You guys need to cover his Bad Man book too!

n
nyland nyland · December 30, 2025

That novel is so good. Idk why it's not more popular. It should be.

G
GoonMan · October 27, 2025

Hunter took a 30 before this one

B
Brian Menard · October 20, 2025

Discovery writing is the funnest way to do it. For me anyway, I get why he does it. Even I'm kept on my toes throughout lol. It can definitely be a problem though.

N
Naryan Schindler · October 19, 2025

Poison ruin shirt?

P
Phatfrankie · October 18, 2025

Penpal being my personal favorite this is such a great insight to dathans personality and writing techniques while also being just a fun time great interview overall bois

c
chipz · October 17, 2025

yall totally gotta read badman now

H
Hedgehog338 · October 16, 2025

I work at a library and bought Penpal for our collection but someone took it out and never returned it 😭

C
Casey Fairhurst · February 6, 2026

Kinda fitting tbh 😅

b
beak · October 16, 2025

what a genuinely awesome dude

g
gr1zlybear · October 16, 2025

good thing wendi clarified that he has more than 2 shelves in his house lmao

L
Liam Shafer · October 13, 2025

I'm so glad that y'all were able to have this interview with Dathan, he's one of my favorite writers since Penpal. Now that I have more disposable income I'm grabbing those books. Please interview more authors.

J
Jason Rose · October 11, 2025

W interview

A
Aaliyah Newton · October 10, 2025

Didn’t think I would enjoy this as much as I would. Definitely looking forward to the next one.

T
Trey Carter · October 10, 2025

Loved this interview. Penpal is probably my favorite story yall have covered so far. I'm looking to buy a physical copy as we speak. I really enjoyed the kinda look behind the curtain with the author. I love any tidbits on their creative processes and motivations so im looking forward to more interviews!

T
Ty Claro · October 11, 2025

You can find it on Amazon but only paperback

I
Indoctrinates · October 10, 2025

I am so glad he didn't stop with Footsteps. Penpal has been my #1 favorite horror story that I've heard from no sleep ever since. I recommend it to literally everyone I talk to, I own a copy for display and I intend on ordering another for subsequesial readings. I can not gush over it enough.

k
katie craine · October 10, 2025

He is quite possibly the most wholesome horror author I've ever seen 😆 love you all

J
Jake Briscoe · October 8, 2025

Just bought the physical copy, excited to re-read it! I had forgotten about scenes like the river scene until hunter brought them up. Time for a refresher on this badass story

E
Elley · October 8, 2025

Thanks so much for this interview it was incredible! I finally bought the book because of it!

E
Eastside X · October 7, 2025

Man this was so awesome!! Best $5 EVER

P
Phoenix Hofman · October 7, 2025

What a group of humble dudes. Loved this

M
Mars ✌️ · October 7, 2025

What a cool dude with an amazing natural talent. Wild that he just sat down to write it. Makes me super proud to be part of this community :)

E
Elliotte Beauchene · October 6, 2025

I loved hearing from the author. It was amazing getting his insight on the story and everything it entailed. Really kind of inspires me to try writing at some point. You guys are always doing awesome! Thank you!

S
Seth · October 6, 2025

Hell yeah, this was great

D
Dramamama-Lama · October 6, 2025

Dude, this was so good. I’m so happy this interview was able to happen. It was so much fun to listen to and I bet even more fun to be a part of

L
Logan · October 6, 2025

this is so cool! Wendigoon signed my copy, I want Hunter and Dathan too also, lol

W
Wesley Winn · October 6, 2025

Absolutely loved this! Just bought the book

S
Spare Rib · October 5, 2025

I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Hope you guys interview more great authors in the future!

J
Joshuah T. S. Walker · October 4, 2025

After revisiting Penpal, Hunter’s greatest bear trap is calling the hole by the shark pool float in “Boxes” a grave

A
AUBREY (Tenkkit) · October 4, 2025

Subscribed to CreepCast just for this; to this day Penpal is my favorite story yall have done

L
Leviathan · October 4, 2025

Super cool hearing from The Man himself PenPal remains my favourite story on the Channel

z
zena wood · October 3, 2025

im confused the merch password was posted hours ago why everyone vexxed?

z
zena wood · October 3, 2025

depression is hitting me like a hrick today but this interview is keeping me sane❤️ thank you for the community and good vibes. im so ever grateful for yall

H
Hunter Steward · October 9, 2025

Hope you're doing okay! I love this community too and I unknowingly am the most loyal Dathan Auerbach fan lol.

S
Sage_Witch7 · October 3, 2025

Why did no one tell me the writer of penpal was so FINE

K
Kirbythebeardeddragon · May 26, 2026

I’m late but came to the comments to say exactly this, I was not prepared

E
Edgar Sanchez · October 3, 2025

Crazy to think that penpal was so good that my senior year english teacher is making us read it

A
Ali Grace · October 3, 2025

I just ordered the bear trap shirt thru the recently ordered pop up🤣🥲

N
Nicole☆Faust · October 3, 2025

No hoodies? I'm freezin over here guys. D:

M
Murky · October 3, 2025

Honestly y'all I think it's a little distasteful that the reddit mods are removing any mention of the merch launch rn :// Obviously there's been a bit of a whoopsie with the password release but wiping any thread where ppl are trying to figure out what's happening feels pretty wack

M
Murky · October 3, 2025

This aside tho the whole merch drop looks killer!! Loving all the designs can't wait 🙌🙌

C
Carlyn Woods · October 3, 2025

somebody like this comment when they find the password 😭

N
Nathanion · October 3, 2025

Putting in every password I can think of so I can get in and buy the bear trap shirt individually 🤞

d
dixie johnson · October 3, 2025

I bought it through the recently bought

A
Abi ophelia · October 3, 2025

i also did this, got the bear trap shirt 🙏🏻

J
Jenna · October 3, 2025

Password for early access?

C
Cheyenne · October 3, 2025

If you click on the recently bought popups it shows you the merch!

A
Alichan · October 3, 2025

Yeah, but does it show everything that you can buy? It only shows me like 4 items, but in the large bundle there's a shirt not listed individually. rip.

J
Jenna · October 3, 2025

HELPPPPPPP

H
Haley · October 3, 2025

ITS SHOWING UP

G
Ghostly Wanderer · October 3, 2025

I’m so glad I’m not the only one frantically scrambling for the Merch password rn

A
Ali Grace · October 3, 2025

HOW ARE PEOPLE BUYING WHATS THE PASSWORD😩

S
Soggy Sock · October 3, 2025

Click the recently bought pop up in the corner and scroll down to see it

J
Jenna · October 3, 2025

PEOPLE ARE ALREADY BUYING WHAT

H
Haley · October 3, 2025

DID WE MISS SOMETHING??

C
Cygnetz · October 3, 2025

Surely patreon gets early access to merch

S
Soggy Sock · October 3, 2025

Sadly no

A
Ali Grace · October 3, 2025

WHATS THE PASSWORD😭😭😭😭😭

S
Soggy Sock · October 3, 2025

Click the recently bought pop up in the corner and scroll down to see it

A
Amber McCormick · October 3, 2025

This is crazzzzy

M
McQueen · October 3, 2025

Man I saw a glimpse of it but now the password is needed 🙁

A
Amber McCormick · October 3, 2025

At least you got that much 😂

K
Kylee · October 3, 2025

WHERES THE PASSWORD

J
Jenna · October 3, 2025

GIVE US THE PASSWORDDDDD

R
Rishabh Verma · October 3, 2025

MERCH PASSWORDDD

D
DillanDaMeatManJuggalo · October 3, 2025

I need that merch password pwease 🥺👉👈

D
DillanDaMeatManJuggalo · October 3, 2025

I ordered 1 of everything

H
Haley · October 3, 2025

EY MERCH WE READY

T
Tara · October 3, 2025

I was waiting for the merch and didnt see it was early access needed that finally push to get patreon anyway

k
kelby · October 3, 2025

we don’t got it over here either but hey girl welcome to the club

A
Ashton · October 3, 2025

Merch Password boys!

B
Brooklynn Robinson · October 3, 2025

Merch passwordddddd

A
Amber McCormick · October 3, 2025

Merch password????

S
Soggy Sock · October 3, 2025

What’s up with needing a password for merch??

M
MightyMouse · October 3, 2025

HUNTER ISAIAH HELPPPP

B
Bobsters · October 3, 2025

Is there a passsword for us to have for early acess to the new creep cast merch?

K
Kayla Adkins · October 3, 2025

Came here for this as well

D
Digital Bacon · October 3, 2025

Does anyone know how to get the early access for the new merch drop?

M
MightyMouse · October 3, 2025

Right we never got passwords

D
DiggingTrapHoles · October 3, 2025

Cool guy cool stories

A
Aly_Mariposa · October 3, 2025

Had to re listen to Penpal again after this interview! Such an amazing read, one of most memorable stories ever created. Thank you, Dathan for sharing your amazing talent with us through this story and we cannot wait until your next release!

H
Haley · October 3, 2025

This story is phenomenal. I could listen to it/read it a million times over & it never gets old. It’s so great getting to hear his writing experience from him.

M
Max Towner · October 3, 2025

Penpal is one of the best horror stories I’ve ever read it’s so encouraging and fun the hear the author talk about his work! Would love to see more of these interviews of the patreon!

P
Pertinax · October 3, 2025

Absolute banger video, I hope to hear more from him and his future projects. I’d also love for more authors to come on here and share their stories as well. Cheers!

A
Ali Grace · October 3, 2025

Can you let us get the merch now since we’re more special than everyone else who didn’t subscribe on here 😛😛

H
Harper Pearce · October 2, 2025

The fact that he wrote penpal in a week blows my mind, it is still the scariest thing, in my opinion, that y’all have read on the podcast.

T
Ticky Tonka · October 2, 2025

I want another Wendigoon stream so bad. I miss his Gmod livestreams. Or when he’d play COD Zombies.

A
Angel's_Purge · October 2, 2025

Ive actually watched mother horse eyes in on sitting 😅

J
Jonah robbins · October 2, 2025

This was so awesome, penpal is one of my favorite books and favorite stories in general, hearing his thought process and how much he pulled from his child is so cool and thank you so much for writing penpal! I can't wait to see the next author interview.

S
Savannah Rayfield · October 2, 2025

Does anyone know if Isaiah or Hunter have PO Boxes for fan mail? I customized something for each of them and I’d like to send it

J
Jason · October 2, 2025

This was fantastic, I loved not on lit hearing from Dathan himself but also getting to hear the various questions from Hunter and Isaiah, love this. Money well spent 🖤

s
squish · October 2, 2025

I'd put this onto youdtube

D
DifficultCombat · October 2, 2025

patreon discord server link here https://discord.gg/PFWApGZYvK

S
SilentDani · October 2, 2025

Notice how they did talk much about badman? Cause its trash

J
John Le Van · October 2, 2025

Hating for hates sake in the big 25

K
Kellye Yates · October 2, 2025

chapter one of penpal was one of the first nosleep stories i read. by then, the book was already out and i immediately bought it and finished it within a night. i still think it would make an amazing mini-series.

b
baphel · October 2, 2025

Ive seen alot of people interview hunter, but my first time seeing him conduct an interview and its amazing how well he leads and takes charge with the questions very well done, very excited for more

b
baphel · October 2, 2025

This is gold

K
Kyle · October 2, 2025

Day 18 of asking wendigoon to draw me with a cookie. Will for sure be rewatching pen pal. Hello. Dear diary. Day one. Hello me? My therapist wants me to keep a journal to keep track of my day. Basically a diary, but he insisted it was a “personal journal to show my journey.” So here it is. I guess. I never really write about myself, but today was pretty normal. Had to go back to school today. The teachers were extra carful with me, like I was gonna fall apart at any moment. Some people even asked if I was okay. Of course I’m not, but I pretended I was, not to make things awkward. My parents haven’t been much better either, but at least they’re trying. Mom has been acting like everything is normal, but I can tell shes is always watching me. While my dad keeps giving me surprise gifts. Cosmo still treats me the same which is nice. However, things have gotten weird , since I got back. I woke up a couple weeks ago, after feeling the my bed vibrate. My room is right above the front door of the house. So when any one enters, it causes my whole room to shake a little. Peaking out my window I saw my dad leaving. It was around 5am. He was carrying a small plain package with him. This usually isn’t that weird. He sometimes goes to work early, but he’s been doing this consistently for the past 2 weeks. Every single morning, and always the same package. I’ve started to realize he’s been wearing the same clothes too, every single day. A couple days after I first saw him leave, he started to come home later. Now it’s to the point where I barely see him. Leaving before I’m awake, and coming home after I’m already asleep. But he still gives me presents. Every morning, outside my door there’s a little present. This morning it was a flower Lego set. I hope I can talk to him soon. Besides for that everthing has been good.

M
Mamabear 0824 · October 2, 2025

I am SO mad at Isaiah How did you neglect to mention that Poe is Mark Z. Danielewskis sister and her album “Haunted” that I grew up listening to coincides with “House of Leaves”?!!?! I’m reading this book bc of how much you reference it. I’m reading it today and I get to the part where he takes a ride with Kyrie on mulholland drive and as I’m reading this part I’m having flashbacks to my youth. After two seconds of research I found out about Poe and this album I haven’t heard in like 20 years. Mind BLOWN 🤯

D
Duke Marine · October 1, 2025

Love this! Going to rewatch the Pen Pal ep now!

D
Disco Panda · October 1, 2025

This is inspiring me to write the stories I've wanted to!! Cause who can tell me what the fazmos want??

U
UnculturedPigeon · October 1, 2025

Badman has to be read, it’s so good

S
SilentDani · October 2, 2025

It sucks

B
Beef · October 1, 2025

Beef

C
Cae_C · October 1, 2025

This was AMAZING! More interviews please, really really enjoyed seeing this kind of content from you guys!! Love it!

D
Dimitris Kyprianou · October 1, 2025

Dathan just sitting there for the glaze train

D
DVS1 · October 1, 2025

I was excited for this interview but never expected to hear about Dathan's creative process. It takes me about 6 to 8 weeks to write single part stories for r/nosleep. The fact he wrote Pen Pal in about the same amount of time, with only 1 week to write each part is incredible.

r
roroi · October 1, 2025

god i fucking love this dudes work. have physical copies of penpal and bad man. made me start reading again. super awesome to hear from him like this!

C
Carlos B · October 1, 2025

Currently rewatching Penpal and this is by far one of my favorite episodes ordering the book now

C
Chelsey · October 1, 2025

Omg such a good interview. Author seems so sweet! I HAVE to buy a copy and read it for Fall. 100% rewatching the episode too lol

R
Rhiannon · October 1, 2025

Knocked it out of the park with this interview guys! Everything went so smoothly and the chemistry of you guys and Dathan was so wholesome and fun. Definitely worth the wait.

J
JimPlatinum · October 1, 2025

PenPal is one of my favorite stories. So glad to get to see this interview.

z
zena wood · October 1, 2025

this is so great guys, such a fun piece of content. Dathan seems awesome, so cool to hear about his writing process

F
Flipper · October 1, 2025

left right game author interview would be awesome

C
CherryPieBomb · October 1, 2025

This was Patreon worthy! Love it! Want more of it! 🎈💵

K
Karma Super · October 1, 2025

Yall should interview the author for Tales from the gas station, I read the whole series, I need to know what this man was on 😂

J
Jakob Spieth · October 1, 2025

When they announced this interview I binged all of "Bad Man" on audible, highly recommend anyone who enjoyed Penpal to give it a read/listen

C
Chandler Carroll · October 1, 2025

Hey really loved this! PLEASE WATCH/LOOK-INTO Allan tutorials on YouTube PLEAAAAASE

A
Alexis Hincks · October 1, 2025

Omnomnomnom ate this up

I
Ian Fields · September 30, 2025

This is amazing content!

T
Tech9902 · September 30, 2025

Amazing interview! I’d love to hear more with other authors

B
BearBeat22 · September 30, 2025

This was dope, please do more of these

C
Catsby Nimble · September 30, 2025

I read penpal like a year prior to the boys reading it and you guys managed to put how I felt reading it into words perfectly. Hands down the best story you’ve read on the channel and now you have an interview with THE AUTHOR holy wow i am fangirling

M
Marshall Klein · September 30, 2025

Dathan, if you’re reading this, I still have one of your signed copies of PenPal from the Kickstarter you did, even though I lent it to multiple people for them to read over the years. Footsteps through Friends is still my favorite series of NoSleep posts I ever read during my freshman year of college. To hear that it was your first time really trying to write a story is crazy impressive! Good times, and really awesome to see my worlds collide this way. Thanks to Hunter and Isaiah for making this happen!

C
Catsby Nimble · September 30, 2025

AHHHH my fav author omgggg

K
Keenan · September 30, 2025

This interview really does earnestly feel like 3 fans of each other all just so excited to spend time together and talk about the things they’re passionate about. I love this

R
Rodney Wilder · September 30, 2025

Well that was awesome. Thank you for doing this, guys!

I
Ian Bayne · September 30, 2025

Me likey! Yummers for my tummers!

F
Fishbone.Hotline · September 30, 2025

Penpal is still my favorite story you guys have read to this day and i think im gonna listen again after i finish watching this… its just so good man whew

N
Nani ✨ · September 30, 2025

Penpal still emotionally impacts me to this day. it was so immersive and visceral and the conclusion was incredibly devastating in the best way for a horror tale. it’s rare to find stories that hit sooo hard !! 11/10

h
huh. · September 30, 2025

You guys show alot of love for stories in ways most people don't, appreciation is a lost art in many ways.

S
Shy Nep · September 30, 2025

This was so wonderful to listen to and I am so glad this show exists. I seriously love you guys so much. Listening since the original Ted the caver and I have loved every minute of it. Well at least most of the time. Creepcast fucking rules.

B
Bee · September 30, 2025

isaiah said that as i just got done being buried alive with a pedophile. thanks for nothing. unsubscribed

L
Linc Stephens · September 30, 2025

This was EXCELLENT. Dathan is super super cool. He would make an excellent guest reader on a normal creepcast episode.

c
chase rivera · September 30, 2025

I really like this idea bru

A
Ashley Hablitz · September 30, 2025

this was so much fun :) i loved penpal and bad man (i audibly went "NOOO" towards the end). seeing y'all nerd out over the creative process gave me sooo much inspiration. such a joy to see y'all excited. also to know dathan has watched even mother horse eyes give me so much joy!!

J
Jacob DeSchepper · September 30, 2025

Loved the video would love to see more like this

C
Cameron Baker · September 30, 2025

I loaned Penpal to a friend as well

C
Crabbus · September 30, 2025

Very funny that wendis take away on reading comprehension from bloodridge was that the protag was a girl, and not that he thought a dead body was alive and how it tainted the entire read

J
JustFullofBeans · September 30, 2025

Penpal made me sob. I mean face in my hands ugly crying. Anything that can make me feel that much emotion is instantly a favorite. Beautifully written. I think about it often.

O
Overgrown_Vineyards · September 30, 2025

Please read “the white people in other weird stories” by Arthur Machen

T
Tay · September 30, 2025

Awesome video!!!! This was great!!! Hope you guys are able to coordinate more interviews with more authors!!!

T
Tristian · September 30, 2025

Would love to see more of these!

e
edwin martinez · September 30, 2025

“Limitation breeds creativity” is a crazy quote

C
Chiggadut · September 30, 2025

Love this idea of bringing in authors. Even if they just read their own story, I’d be stoked 👏👏

T
TheSalvationArmy · September 30, 2025

I think “think” is his most favorable word

A
Andres Torres · September 30, 2025

this was amazing, love this author excited for the new book!

I
IanForth · September 30, 2025

This was great, Dathan seems like such a genuinely awesome guy. I'd love to see more author interviews!

H
Hail Cesar · September 30, 2025

Loved this would support this man in any endeavors and I will be purchasing bad man

M
Marcus Doyle · September 30, 2025

Love it

C
Corey Leab · September 30, 2025

There's an author named Sam Rebelein who made a book of short stories called "The poorly made" and I think you guys should check it out. Very fun

f
funnygunboyy · September 30, 2025

This was a fantastic interview that I love tuning into, I will definitely have to pick up Bad Man and this new book he is working on!

J
Jordan Harris · September 30, 2025

This kicks ass. Been waiting for his new book for so long. Hopefully the book is sooner rather than later!

N
Noah · September 30, 2025

Would be a cool promo for Dathan when the third book is close to release if y'all released a short bonus episode reading the first chapter or two.

O
One of these days I will have the constitution to do it. · September 30, 2025

Three cool guys being cool. Really coo! Can't wait for upcoming stuff from Dathan.

Y
Yote Jotunn · September 30, 2025

Im buying the pen pal book because of this interview! Protect this man at all costs!

f
funnygunboyy · September 30, 2025

Yeah I definitely want to pick up Bad Man as well, I heard a bit about it before and now I am definitely sold on it

M
Mik · September 30, 2025

10/10

C
ClockTowelGB · September 30, 2025

Seems like a cool dude

O
OSOxRG711 · September 30, 2025

Amazing!

M
Mark Sonnet · September 30, 2025

15:40 - Dathan used ASBESTOS as a fucking PADDLE BOAT

f
funnygunboyy · September 30, 2025

Dathan does not worry himself with lung diseases or cancer

c
cj 4101 · September 30, 2025

Incredible stuff.

M
Mark Sonnet · September 30, 2025

Wish we Patrons had an opportunity to ask him some of our own questions via comments

s
sophia Kk · September 30, 2025

this was fucking awesome

F
Frieza · September 30, 2025

Marvelous show, Monkeys! Oh I do so hope you continue to do this dance for our amusement.

P
Prag · September 30, 2025

Read this and just thought "wow this guy is doing the most" then I saw the name. Keep doing this bit. Never stop.

b
black dawn · September 30, 2025

The fact that some of this were lived experiences make it so much creepier

B
BrainAmoeba 918 · September 30, 2025

This was awesome, more of this

A
Andrew Guerra · September 30, 2025

What a treat, thanks for putting this together, and hoping for more in the future 🤞

T
Trotter Clark · September 30, 2025

he broke character no sleep mods please kill them all

H
Holly Pop · September 30, 2025

amazing to discover he decided as he was writing. That just shows his incredible talent

J
JerryDelTaco · September 30, 2025

Definitely a highlight of the patreon episodes so far, id love to see more author interviews! Every episode of creepcast i watch the more writing motivation i get, and this was no exception

N
Nick · September 30, 2025

This was awesome! Great to see what he thinks about his own story. I look forward to more of these.

J
John Eisele · September 30, 2025

As an aspiring horror writer, I really cannot thank you guys enough for this episode.

P
Paige · September 30, 2025

May you guys please interview the author of Borasca friends 🫶

b
bat · September 30, 2025

i think it's so interesting he got so into the role play aspect of no sleep! such a awesome interview can't wait to see more of this content

K
Keagan Fowler · September 30, 2025

This was fantastic. Absolutely love the goofs and gafs of the boys but seeing the more serious discussions and diving into the innards of a fantastic work like pen pals was the best. Please interview more authors! ps. start a book recommendation list from hunter and isaiah because i’ve never been a reader but want to get into horror books. starting house of leaves now god help me.

t
tacobellknight · September 30, 2025

Incredible interview, cant wait to listen to more

A
Alex Cooney · September 30, 2025

That was awesome!

T
The Shareholders · September 30, 2025

I started listening to Bad Man today and it reminds me of one of Wendi’s videos where he says something along the lines of “the only reason the gov gets away with anything is because the only people that challenge them are crazy” except in this case it’s a supermarket lol. Good & quality read so far, would love to see you guys cover it

M
Meganladon · September 30, 2025

Fantastic!

J
Johnny Hammerstyx · September 29, 2025

Next week: ARI ASTER???!!

J
Johnny Hammerstyx · August 30, 2026

BTW I bought and read BADMAN and it was absolute dogshit

T
TrogdorTheMan · September 29, 2025

Such a good palate cleanser after yesterday’s ep! Cool interview guys!

I
Inbathroomatwork · September 29, 2025

Imagine the first thing you write being 'Footsteps'. That's an insanely good start. One of the high notes of the story and functions so well by itself.

V
Vic · September 29, 2025

Loved this interview!! Thank you so much guys!!

K
Kingofgam305 · September 29, 2025

Love the interview videos immediately so fun to get to hear a persons process on how they write and what inspires them a great first pick for a guest to was so much fun. I hope they interview Oda next

B
Breybrey · September 29, 2025

That was a great watch. Dathan seems like a good guy. PenPal is still my fav episode of Creepcast.

j
john shibaジョン志波 · September 29, 2025

Y not read bad man on creepcast

A
AP · September 29, 2025

This was sick, would definitely love to see more content like this

D
Dylan Mares · September 29, 2025

This is so rad. Penpal was and still is my favorite story. Still wanna read the book eventually. Definitely would love more of these

T
Taryn Brazeau · September 29, 2025

This was an incredible interview! I hope this can be done more often, I love hearing from the authors!

d
diego · September 29, 2025

This was so entertaining this is the kinda Patreon content I think fits.ck walker next?

M
Martian Mishaps · September 29, 2025

This was such a cool interaction, the guy is genuinely interesting to listen to and getting to hear his perspective on writing and the creative process was really insightful and fun. David Lynch famously said that his creative process was like fishing for ideas, waiting patiently and you never know when something will pop into your head and you immediately need to act on it. Excellent interview, I think you all asked some great questions.

M
Makdaddyb_ · September 29, 2025

SO MUCH CREEPCAST CONTENT!!! GONNA CHUUUUUMMMMMMMMMMMMM

N
Nopey · September 29, 2025

I’m glad we finally got a interview

N
Nopey · September 30, 2025

Also great post glad it felt genuine and not to official.

H
HALFMANxHALFGOD · September 29, 2025

This was so awesome. What a spectacular person and conversation, had me hanging on every word. Really looking forward to my next Penpal listen!

L
LB Blubber · September 30, 2025

Same!! The fact that this is his first writing is INSANE

K
Korey Sarven · September 29, 2025

Fantastic stuff! Really enjoyed author interview. Penpal is easily my favorite story to date on the pod

D
Dennis DO · September 29, 2025

I think I have listened to the PenPal episode, no joke, 30 times, I’m so exited to listen to this.

B
BogDance06 · September 29, 2025

it would be really cool if you guys could get jack anderson of left right game too! this was really cool to watch

G
Grits Kun · September 29, 2025

Penpal was goated

S
Shelby Myers · September 29, 2025

Loved this, hope you guys can do more 👌🏻

A
Ally Edgell · September 29, 2025

This is awesome!

J
Jacob B. · September 29, 2025

Good call posting this with the most recent episode cause woof. That one was a doozy.

D
Dakota · September 29, 2025

What Harry did should never be forgotten. What Harry did should never be forgiven.

R
Roachsteppaz · September 29, 2025

Great keep it up

M
Mia · September 29, 2025

Ok fine I’ll rewatch the Penpal episode for the 100th time 🙄🙄

S
Shelby Myers · September 29, 2025

Bout to buy the book 💀😂

M
Marisela Dean · September 29, 2025

I love this. This story struck me emotionally so much so that I bought the book but I haven’t read it for myself yet because I know what comes at the end and I’m not ready to go through that again. When you can evoke such a strong emotional reaction like that out of the reader you definitely have a great and memorable story on your hands.

E
Eggy63 · September 29, 2025

Someone needs to draw Dathan as Goku going, "I'm following in his footsteps"

E
Ethan Wallace · September 29, 2025

More interviews please!!!

C
Chris Pitts · September 29, 2025

This is peak content!! PEEEEEAAAAAAK!

v
vinny · September 29, 2025

great interview guys!! so cool hearing from dathan, as someone who’s a chronic planner and trying to “discovery write” more there was a lot of interesting points made. especially agree with the power of online writing communities in letting people of all skill levels share their stuff! in the future if yall do another author interview it’d be cool if you asked on patreon or youtube community posts or something if the viewers have any questions we’d like answered!

M
MeGan MangOLD · September 29, 2025

I love when I get to the end and he says normal people wouldnt have watched the 11 hour Mother Horse Eyes. I did in one sitting. My husband calls me a mutant every day. Red head blue eyes and negative mutant blood! I guess they are right

M
MoonCakez · September 29, 2025

I watched all of it, but I did it at work. I can't sit still and watch that long of a episode.

G
Gabriel · September 29, 2025

True story, Hunter was not this happy even when he got married

M
MoonCakez · September 29, 2025

Very true, he talked about about his wedding not in the best light lol. Especially that horse Alison rode on.

m
meatgooner69 · September 29, 2025

bros first story became a beloved horror masterpiece, Dathan ur the goat this was one of the earliest stories they covered and its still my favorite covered on the show thank you for writing !!!!!!

c
craptopia · September 29, 2025

I really hope they read bad man some time

C
Chancellor Robinson · September 29, 2025

I finished it a couple weeks back, another banger from Dathan

M
Matthew Robison · September 29, 2025

Awesome interview, PayPal is definitely my favorite of the stories they’ve covered.

J
Josh Halter · September 29, 2025

Definitely would love more author interviews!

Q
Quentin W. · September 29, 2025

I loved these two before they started the podcast, but the Penpal episode solidified my love for horror writing and what Isaiah and Hunter bring to the community. This one story has inspired me to write my own so thank you to all three of you❤️

C
Cory Henderson · September 29, 2025

1. Absolutely love content like this. 2. RSS feed, please.

M
MeGan MangOLD · September 29, 2025

This was very interesting. I enjoyed it.

Z
Zergling50 · September 29, 2025

So nice to hear from the dude about everything. Always fun getting a peak inside their head.

B
Baal · September 29, 2025

I still will say penpal was one of the best early nosleeps, it just got that relationship between the boys that makes it above other stories, and for me one of the strongest versions of the brocode. It's also one of the few stories of that early youtube/podcast era that really stuck with me for the longest.

B
Brian C · September 29, 2025

THIS WAS SO AWESOME. I really love hearing from an author and I really hope they do this with more stories. I’d be curious to see if they could talk to an author whose story they kinda goofed on and the author received it well.

C
Can'tSellTickeyWickeys/SoWeSuckSaudieDickies JK ❤️ · September 29, 2025

Now that's interesting 😜 especially the last episode,I'd like to know what was going on in the authors head to end it off with a goblin....

s
sam · September 29, 2025

It’s really nice hearing these kinds of things from authors that are loved so much by the community, and seeing the struggle/journey of what it took to write these kinds of things. Especially since we don’t see this part of the process, it gives hope for aspiring writers like myself to go out and put my works out there. The writing journey feels a little less lonely in that sense. Thanks for the amazing interview guys! Lots of love

e
evil white guy · September 29, 2025

Oh this kicks ass. Super interesting and honestly really motivational/helpful for folks trying to get into the art of horror

Z
Zippofiber · September 29, 2025

This was such a great interview and im excited for more interviews down the line!!

c
crystalizedcanines · September 29, 2025

Such an amazing story from an amazing author and this was an awesome video! Super cool to see and hear from everyone :)

N
Nölan · September 29, 2025

Y’all should read badman

L
Lillex · September 29, 2025

More of this PLEASE

S
Sean Allen · September 29, 2025

I think one of my favorite stories is penpal. The way you guys covered the story but also the story itself. I fell in love with the way it was told and you had to put it together in a really creative way. I cant wait to read coma v2 max when it comes out!

L
Lennan Lacasse · September 29, 2025

You guys should try and get on the person who made left right game! That’s my fav story you’ve covered and I must’ve listened too those episodes 3 or 4 times

J
Jax Ott · September 29, 2025

I think that, since this is so good and Penpal is such an important story, this interview should be uploaded to the CreepCast yt channel for everyone to enjoy!

C
Can'tSellTickeyWickeys/SoWeSuckSaudieDickies JK ❤️ · September 29, 2025

I really wish Patreon would do a casting thing so I can watch this from my phone to tv

A
AyoJezuz · September 29, 2025

This interview was as entertaining as the actual episode. REWATCH TIME!

c
chase rivera · September 29, 2025

YES

B
Bailey Smith · September 29, 2025

i’m pretending like this is the episode for this week.

M
Mr. E · September 29, 2025

I would love to see you guys read the author's favorite part of their stories with them the next time you get someone on, like whatever part of the story that had impacted the author the most when they were writing it or whatever part they enjoyed getting people's reaction from, like if you guys put aside a little more time just to do that I think you could get even better reception off of this outside of how fun this episode already was

k
kiera · September 29, 2025

this was so so so awesome. i hope you guys can get jack anderson (left right game) on here as well!

L
LouieLouie43 · September 29, 2025

Penpal was the first “creepypasta” I personally read, I loved the story so much that it was the first creepcast episode I watched too. Thank you Dathan for taking the chance to write this story and changing my life

G
Gavin · September 29, 2025

I’d like to hear an interview from the author of hidden webpage

D
Deviant · September 29, 2025

Like

G
Gun Magician · September 29, 2025

Im working on a story heavily inspired my the pen pal aesthetic and themes. Dathan is such an inspiration for upcoming writers

C
Can'tSellTickeyWickeys/SoWeSuckSaudieDickies JK ❤️ · September 29, 2025

Hope to get a link in the comments and get my hands on it eventually,best of luck buddy. Stay Spooky 👻

C
Cple Williams · September 29, 2025

Do more of these absolutely

G
Graymatter28 · September 29, 2025

Definitely a brilliant idea for interviews with the authors. I think it would be fun if they could do an interview with Tony lunedi (spire in the woods).

C
Chloe Mahala · September 29, 2025

This was so cool to watch. Penpal was one of the stories that, I would say, got me really into creeppastas/scary stories. I loved hearing about Dathan's experience with nosleep and the way he works and writes. I definitely love watching you guys talk to the authors :)

V
Vee · September 29, 2025

Loved the interview and it is really interesting hearing the process behind everything. Hopefully there are more author interviews in the future

B
Bbmn221 · September 29, 2025

So happy how this turned out. PLEASE GOD MORE haha

s
starmamma🤍 · September 29, 2025

They should create patreon only chats for the audience. That way the ones on reddit dont get angry when people talk sbout patreon eps

P
Papa Pish · September 29, 2025

Penpal is now so big that my therapist in the Philippines recommended the book to me without any knowledge that it was a creepypasta

J
Josh Halter · September 29, 2025

I never even bought a book before penpal, besides the school book fair years ago

F
Fernanda · September 29, 2025

I love this! I gotta check out bad guy!

R
Royce Anthony on Spotify · September 29, 2025

yall are COOKING

B
Becky · September 29, 2025

Loved this interview! Really great content today.

B
Boonie Bound · September 29, 2025

My payment has finally become worth it lol

C
CryingFroggy22 · September 29, 2025

The fact that this was his first proper story is insane! Loved this interview style kind of video btw

D
DreamEater · September 29, 2025

God, that must be so gratifying and validating to have a community so enthralled with your work; that they immediately support every single piece as it comes out, and literally push you to continue submitting. That’s such a rare situation, and the result is such an amazing piece of literature. Community driven art at it’s finest.

K
Kay Young · September 29, 2025

This really makes me want to write again after being in a slump for so long, Creepcast interviews are S tier!

C
Crash Kamio · September 29, 2025

This was incredible. Not only was it an amazing interview with so much insightful questions and such. It was just so fun. It was just such a great time listening to you guys talk writing but also just goof off. The creepcast format + author interviews is perfect. Amazing stuff! Also was great hearing him need out about the pod a bit. Hes so talented too. Footsteps being essentially the first thing he wrote is just wild. He has such an engaging style. I finished Bad Man earlier this year (great book) and I was maybe halfway through it and something hooked me so hard that I binged the rest of the book in ine sitting. My brain is cooked and it can be hard for me to read for long periods of time, but he knocked that down and I had to read it through the night to the morning. Can't wait for his next one! And looking forward to more author interviews too!

C
Colton Serven · September 29, 2025

They need to read badman

P
Poli · September 29, 2025

This was awesome! Currently reading his book, Bad Man, so it was cool to see some of the author’s perspectives and how he started writing. Can’t wait for more interviews!

L
LouieLouie43 · September 29, 2025

I also recently picked up Bad Man!

s
starmamma🤍 · September 29, 2025

why he kinda

H
Hania · September 29, 2025

I was gonna say 😋

J
Jake · September 29, 2025

This is good content. It would be fun for you guys to interview some of the fans that send in stories too, give advice and stuff in real time

K
Kermie · September 29, 2025

Why did I assume Dathan was younger? Anyone else? Lol

E
EpicE · September 29, 2025

He said somewhere that he wrote Penpal in his late 20s, and that would be almost 15 years ago now

B
Brennan Cruz · September 29, 2025

grab me goofys boots while your at it.

J
Josiah Virgil · September 29, 2025

YES!

M
MrPolarbear · September 29, 2025

Wow. Hunters a damn good interviewer

M
MeGan MangOLD · September 29, 2025

Hunters great with his interviews!

S
Sydney Arnold · September 29, 2025

Loved this! So excited for Dathan’s next book! 💕

O
Ocean M · September 29, 2025

Omg the first interview being the author of my FAVORITE story. Honestly Dathan's writing is absolutely beautiful and so inspiring. I'm so excited he took an interview for us creeps. Thank you, king 🙂‍↕️🖤

B
Bryttanie Eastman · September 29, 2025

I'm so excited for Comav2mac

N
Nick · September 29, 2025

This is great patreon content. I’d love to see you guys do video interviews with other authors!

A
A21 · September 29, 2025

Man Dathan was such a chill dude

M
Michael Durand · September 29, 2025

Great interview!

0
0veR · September 29, 2025

Like, like, like.

C
ConsequenceLevel7877 · September 29, 2025

Sick

L
Luckyking234 · September 29, 2025

Ok hear me out a big fucking fuck off tv for video call guests alla space ghost so that they're in the room with yall just a thought l9ve this

B
Brandon Diaz · September 29, 2025

I have listen for a 4th time now. Makes me cry everytime.

J
Jackson Wolfe-Lehman · September 29, 2025

Didn't know how I'd feel about this but this was amazing cant wait for more

D
Damien · September 29, 2025

This was awesome. You guys gotta get C.K. Walker on here at some point too, no pressure lol

M
MeGan MangOLD · September 29, 2025

I agree. As long as they do not talk about their reactions to 5 and Alpha!

K
Kaden I Watson · September 29, 2025

Yessss!!! Please do More author Interviews, This is Fantastic!!!

l
lasanga · September 29, 2025

This interview really highlights one of the things I love about the show, which is how much they’re all interested in what they do. Everyone here seems so excited to talk about the story and the love for stories is a huge draw here (besides gooners Jeff Goldblum impression)

R
RedBeard · September 29, 2025

Definitely like this format as well. Cool to throw in, is like to hear more

s
spookyeds · September 29, 2025

Please do a compilation on junji ito shorts

T
TRIGGER2oo1 · September 29, 2025

This is a great segment for Patreon! Please have C.K. Walker on at some point!

B
Badoopadoo! · September 29, 2025

I LOVE this type of content! Listening to passionate people talk about what they’re passionate about will never get old 💚🖤

K
Kat · September 29, 2025

This interview was so fun to listen to. Please do more of these!! Dathan was an awesome first guest

B
Ben Alexander · September 29, 2025

Hell yeah we need more author interviews

G
Graceee · September 29, 2025

just in time for lunch thank u guys

K
Kyle Hockenberry · September 29, 2025

35 mins in and this is absolutely delightful

0
0veR · September 29, 2025

Love how much content we’ve been getting, I feel so spoiled

S
Shann · September 29, 2025

This is most excellent! One of my favorite stories they have covered. I'm going to tuck in with my crochet, and some pears to nibble on whilst I listen

B
Bob · September 29, 2025

Same

k
kurt russell · September 29, 2025

Love this awesome job team!

F
Foster Perry · September 29, 2025

I hope if they do get an interview with C.K. Walker they really hold her feet to the fire in regard to Deepwoods part 3 and Borraska part 5.

J
Jake Hoffman · September 29, 2025

This is awesome. I cant wait for you guys to do more of these interviews.

B
Bwoods · September 29, 2025

Dammit, now I have to watch the Penpal episode again, for the 3rd time.

M
MeGan MangOLD · September 29, 2025

I have watched it so many times. Then I watch Darbo. I have no life!

N
Nick R · September 29, 2025

An interview with Tony lunedi for spire in the woods would be super cool!

P
PollutedPersephone · September 29, 2025

Yessss!

P
PokéHorror777 · September 29, 2025

Here’s the real episode, yesterday never happened

s
spookyeds · September 29, 2025

For real

G
Gabriel H. · September 29, 2025

Love it. I’ve been so excited for you guys to pick Dathans brain

D
Dietrich · September 29, 2025

Penpal is still my favorite story they've read, and the novel version is fantastic. I also got Bad Man, its really good but not as good as Penpal imo

A
Andrew Watson · September 29, 2025

This is fucking fantastis

Z
Zach McIntire · September 29, 2025

I hate pinpal not because it's bad it's a masterpiece but because its ending was so sad and haunting

Z
Zak M · September 29, 2025

Honestly the "scariest" story they've read. Truly haunting lol

J
James · September 29, 2025

An interview with the author of Left Right Game would be amazing

A
Austin · September 29, 2025

They really need to read his other book

A
Alex · September 29, 2025

Love penpal so much! Got my own copy of it and made my girlfriend listen to it too! So excited for this

W
Writer_Guy · September 29, 2025

Love this type of content

j
jazmin · September 29, 2025

Penpal is my favorite creep cast episode

E
E Thomas · September 29, 2025

Y’all are cranking these out this month, THANK YOU!!!

L
Lojojojo · September 29, 2025

Penpal was my favorite of the stories you all covered

n
nobodyanyways · September 29, 2025

Lawd have mercy

H
HUGGYBEAR · September 29, 2025

Piggy want roasty

E
Elaina Gurung · September 29, 2025

y’all should interview the author from the last story and just do a wellness check

M
Michael Koehler · September 29, 2025

Been waiting on this! Can’t wait to listen!!

L
LB Blubber · September 29, 2025

READ MORE OF HIS WORK PLEASEEEEE

T
Thora · September 29, 2025

Thanks so much! This interview is so fun!! I totally would love to see more of these!!

D
DilEmmaLou · September 29, 2025

this is fucking amazing i’m stoked

R
RedBeansAndRicin · September 29, 2025

maybe the real pens are the pals we made along the way

H
H3XX3DBUG · September 29, 2025

I HAVE NO MOUTH AND I MUST SCREAM

M
Mitchell Carter · September 29, 2025

Wendi covered this in a video of his already years ago

J
John Schow · September 29, 2025

Oh let’s gooooo

J
Jerard · September 29, 2025

I genuinely listen to pen pal at least once a week 😭😭

I
Ignacio Villanueva · September 29, 2025

Cakes and pies baby.

M
Monky · September 29, 2025

WOOOOOO!!!!!

M
Monky · September 29, 2025

YESSSS LETS GOO I WAS WAITING FOR THIS

E
Em💕🕸️ · September 29, 2025

PLEASE read bad man on the show it’s so good!!

T
TopazBeast · September 29, 2025

Would be cool if you guys read his other published book on the show

M
McShiddon · September 29, 2025

listening to this at work. So excited to hear from the author of one of my favorite stories from creepcast so far. Creepin my cast fo sho.

P
PollutedPersephone · September 29, 2025

This is so freaking awesome dudes

C
Can'tSellTickeyWickeys/SoWeSuckSaudieDickies JK ❤️ · September 29, 2025

Ayyyeeee 💪

D
DeathOfMyEgo · September 29, 2025

Spooky Season kicking off right

K
Kaleb Mccubbin · September 29, 2025

As patrons, how early will we have access to the new merch? I love you guys

c
clahkie · September 29, 2025

WE MAKING IT OUT OF THE CAST WITH THIS OKE

f
frommaplestreet · September 29, 2025

penpal was an absolute experience, his writing is so gripping and the characters are so relatble and believable, you feel the sheer trauma with the main character the whole way

t
trin · September 29, 2025

palate cleanser from that boo boo ah main episode

A
Anthony Alvarez · September 29, 2025

Creepin my cast rn

C
Chloe · September 29, 2025

So excited for this penpal is up with the best stories you have read such an interesting, terrifying and amazingling written

A
Alex McKell · September 29, 2025

Who up pennin' they pals?

Z
Zachary Budriss · September 29, 2025

Who else’s favorite story is Penpal?

R
Rodrigo · September 29, 2025

It’s crazy to think it’s still the best story they’ve read still, definitely still top 5

N
Nathan Martin · September 29, 2025

Finally I’ve wanted this interview for so long

J
Jaren Tilford · September 29, 2025

How the hell am I supposed to get my masters if yall keep dropping bangers like this

J
Jonathan c · September 29, 2025

Who up dathaning they auerbach

A
Austin · September 29, 2025

Top tier comment

A
Austin Rankin · September 29, 2025

So excited for this!

I
ImJustEman · September 29, 2025

Yay! Penpal is still my favorite story/video that you two have done, so this is such a treat!

W
Waffle Wendie · September 29, 2025

Who up creepin' they cast?

p
pinheadlarry · September 29, 2025

Penpal to this day is still my favorite story they read

E
ElijahW. · September 29, 2025

Let's gooooo

M
Max Chambers · September 29, 2025

I JUST finished registering to penpal today that’s crazy

P
PollutedPersephone · September 29, 2025

Hi fellow Creeps!

S
Shann · September 29, 2025

Hi! fellow one of 5 girl-creeps(or was it 7?)

m
moonlit.86 · September 29, 2025

Creeping our cast at work again

c
catgirlnya · September 29, 2025

YAYYY

T
Tripod · September 29, 2025

Yessssss

D
Dot · September 29, 2025

YES YES YES YES YES

B
Benso · September 29, 2025

Penis toes

Z
Zach Huneycutt · September 29, 2025

The fucking poison ruin shirt goes SO hard I am already In His corner

Z
Zach Huneycutt · September 29, 2025

Anyone reading this needs to listen to Poison Ruin now.

d
dawn jones · September 29, 2025

Yayy

L
Lynnsey · September 29, 2025

Oh here we go!

a
aj g · September 29, 2025

yoooooo my creepy casters

a
aj g · September 29, 2025

i had bought this book before the podcast was started, and listening to the boys read it made me pick it up again :) 👍

B
Breaded sticks · September 29, 2025

Bread

C
Colt Aronhalt · September 29, 2025

Bout time white bois

I
Impeloqn17 · September 29, 2025

IVE BEEN WAITINGGG

s
slater · September 29, 2025

YAYYYY THIS IS AWESOME

M
Mason Emerson · September 29, 2025

Heck yeah

b
bass_jockey · September 29, 2025

Big if true

I
Izzy · September 29, 2025

Nice I just finished the main episode :)

P
POOPGOBLIN · September 29, 2025

I'm ready for this episode to blow my Auerbach out with knowledge.

V
Voiyaa · September 29, 2025

What a time to creep my cast!

A
Assata Pellegrino · September 29, 2025

Yessssss

C
Cream · September 29, 2025

Cream

C
Cherrycxsmos · September 29, 2025

Perfect thing to listen to while I make chicken tendies So excited!!! 🤍

C
Crash Fistfight · September 29, 2025

Sweet

C
Christian Downey · September 29, 2025

H U G E

S
Shane Campbell · September 29, 2025

LETS GOOOO