💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
Off The Record: Would You Go See A Dead Body? (1 of 2)
Off The Record: Would You Go See A Dead Body? (2 of 2)
July 28, 2025

Off The Record: Would You Go See A Dead Body?

Let us know if you'd like to see more of these type of videos. And don't forget to drop couples costume ideas below!

Comments (545)

S
Suttle T. Sounds · November 9, 2026

Listening to Creepcast D&D with Hunter being the arbiter of the scenario is definitely worth every penny of my patreon subscription

N
Noah Duff · October 24, 2026

MORE, more hour long chatting sessions

C
Carlo Anides · October 20, 2026

Crazy bringing up the gay zombie teacher from Weapons in the hypothetical 1985 fent-film

A
Ayden Kerner · September 18, 2026

Listening to this almost a year and a half later I would love more of this for easy content in between the bonus content so maybe less people complain about how much content they are getting from the patreon.

T
Tonka Nichols · September 10, 2026

HONK HONK

I
IhaveWings · November 15, 2026

🕊️🙏🏻beep beep

N
Nick Flesher · September 5, 2026

I love it when Hunter plays GM for his random roleplay scenarios with an unsuspecting Isaiah

G
GonathanDone · September 4, 2026

I know it's been over a year since this came out, but I'm just now listening to it and I love it 😂

J
Josh A · September 4, 2026

Yo when’s the next off the record

F
First name Last name · July 31, 2026

Please have the boys do a d n d campaign for the patreon

F
First name Last name · July 31, 2026

This alone made subscribing to the patreon worth it

U
Unsub45 · July 21, 2026

Human Centipede 😬

J
James Jacobjingleheimerschmit · July 18, 2026

Loved this, and I agree that this couldn't happen in a normal episode. My only regret is that because it's Patron only we won't get any animations of Isaiah's killing spree.

D
Das Techniker · July 17, 2026

why tf did patreon just notify me abt this post its over a year old

B
Benjamin Delgado-Knaack · July 14, 2026

Is this Patreon exclusive

J
Jtattedup93 · July 7, 2026

I was ready to say it with my whole chest, “Shoot the athletic kid, shoot the skinny kid, then get the officers gun and shoot the fat kid before he reaches me”. But I forgot the gun jammed 😂

C
Chris Vick · July 5, 2026

Haven't actually watched the video yet but I'm gonna do ahead and say *yeah make more videos like this one" I need as much content as you guys can put out lol

K
Kyle · June 27, 2026

We need another off the record!

J
Jude the hopeless · June 18, 2026

I made papa meat, Wendi, and Jacobi on my tomadachi island and it makes me laugh so fucking hard everytime.

C
CommanderWill2 · June 16, 2026

We have D&D at home:

B
Bill · June 2, 2026

This whole episode is a fever dream

J
Jessica Mogielka · May 24, 2026

Late here but my god Hunter you would be a fantastic guest on VIP

L
Lauren Coleman · May 12, 2026

New patron here! While I have to admit I have not read ALL of Stephen King’s books/stories, I have read several. In my personal opinion, Cujo is fantastic and underrated! I think the movie deterred people from actually reading the book.

I
IDontLikeKmart · April 29, 2026

50:29 Ever the psychotic child bludgeoner, Isaiah went on to pathetically crawl out of the woods. He later died in the hospital of a staph infection from his wounds. The investigation is still ongoing... WHEN THE NIGHT HAS COME AND THE LAND IS DARK

G
Grim Reader · April 28, 2026

I’m bursting out laughing over Hunter and Isaiah’s little necromancer stand by me roleplay lmfao

H
Hunters-Kitten · April 24, 2026

So the reason C.K Walker puts ac/dc in her stories so much is only because Stephen king does it in maximum overdrive

A
Antoinette_Chaton · April 13, 2026

Hunter is pissing me off in this hypothetical

T
Tristan Combs · April 10, 2026

Im so happy i spent 5 dollars on this

C
CaliCasper · April 10, 2026

I loved this!

A
Antoinette_Chaton · April 2, 2026

I love The Monster Squad more than The Goonies

S
Savannah Rayfield · April 1, 2026

I love how the name One eyed Willy went over hunters head

M
Mantis · March 30, 2026

I love tangents in the stories

A
Alyssa H · March 20, 2026

Oh I would loveeeee to make/see a horror mystery/cryptic monsters DND campaign for these two lmaoo

W
Wendi gooned · March 19, 2026

A comment from a more mod rn patron, costume idea, and two gay furry dogs or just normal dog costumes, but your guys names are Scratch and Sniff

T
TLPMD · March 10, 2026

Hearing Isaiah say "Fent overdose" is hilarious

j
john d · March 3, 2026

I love the off the records because I like radio shows while I work and it’s always really good time passing when you’re cracking up looking busy

K
KVValentine · February 26, 2026

Would love to see more off the record and role playing! This was so funny

T
TheITGuy · February 26, 2026

Would love to hear Isaiah trying to defend this in a courtroom that he shot 2 children because they were close to him with no weapons

E
Emily Seals · February 17, 2026

I've been putting off subscribing for so long, and boy have I been missing out. This is the content I paid for lol

C
Charisma · February 19, 2026

I really wish they'd do more

E
Elise · January 30, 2026

Give the opportunity to speak freely and they instantly start roleplaying 😂😂

S
Siroram · January 28, 2026

Love these fellas

T
Tsukiney · January 25, 2026

The Flesh gait thumbnail as costumes!!!

T
Tsukiney · January 22, 2026

50-60 def appropriate 👌if not more lol

B
Bull bob · January 21, 2026

Took me back to the Cream Crew days with this one. Loved the Dead Body segment.

G
Gus · January 9, 2026

Pet semetary is very good from Stephen King, I love the ending. The Stand is my favourite book of all time. Dolores Claiborne is a surprise favourite. The Long walk also very good and perfect creepcast vibes imo One of my favourite short stories is Survivor Type from the Skeleton Crew. Would LOVE to hear you guys read that one!!

D
DruepyDrue · April 7, 2026

The Jaunt would be a good one for them to read as well!

B
Bootle · December 31, 2025

I love Stand By Me DnD

Z
ZombiePossum · December 30, 2025

What kind of gun is Wendigoon holding, anyone know?

C
Codeine Cryp · January 1, 2026

browning hi power polished silver with wood grips

D
Damieon Best · December 30, 2025

I carried my dead grandma's body out of the house.

s
spicyboi · December 17, 2025

i really wanna see hunter dm and isaiah play a dnd campaign now, or maybe like call of cthulhu or something

S
Seth Goldsmith Jr · December 31, 2025

Creepypasta themed dnd campaign like the left right game or 13 rooms or something with constantly changing circumstances and wide array of possibilities

K
Kyle · December 16, 2025

I wish every Patreon exclusive was just an off the record. I love this recording

M
Maybe Baby · December 16, 2025

Marty is friends with doc because marty went back in time and gave doc the idea to build the time machine

p
phoenix penn · December 10, 2025

Out of context this is 2 Americans talking about killing children, and the pastor pulls out a gun

M
Mjaui · December 9, 2025

I definitely would love more of the D & D stuff and you guys analysing eachother through it it was a laugh ❤️

K
Krissy · December 5, 2025

This was awesome MORE

Z
Zdeněk Kabeláč · December 3, 2025

Isaiah trying to be normal in Hunter's head is hilarious 😆

T
Ty Baskett · November 24, 2025

Yes, yes I would love to see a dead body. It has to be Hunter's, though. He's been dead for several months now so I'm curious as to what he looks like.

Z
ZegramZombie · November 21, 2025

I love these a lot ❤️

N
Necrophallic · November 21, 2025

I love the DnD, I'm patreoning for more DnD. Dungeons & Creeps

S
ScotchCarb Heavy Industries · November 20, 2025

...how the fuck is Hunter not running a DnD campaign

V
VictoriaQ · November 28, 2025

he does on meaty magic i believe

k
kristina · November 19, 2025

Hunter and Wendy. Write a movie script. I know im not the only one saying this

J
Jade · November 18, 2025

im not very interested in D&D but i would love to watch a game be played with Hunter as DM. he is so creative with improv scenarios

K
Kade Norris · November 17, 2025

Hunter would be a great dm.

V
Voordalak · November 14, 2025

Any stories like Isaiah finding the body and choosing a story would be great to animate

L
Licksalad · November 11, 2025

I’m so glad they remade stand by me man

S
Siekra · November 10, 2025

Bros just playing D&D mid video, and it's actually peak

M
MeatyMadness1408 · November 9, 2025

I hope there's some more off the record cooking up for us soon! my husband and I listen to all of these and creep cast while we work and were on 3x each one now <3

N
Nai · November 3, 2025

When is Hunter coming to DM my next dnd session? 😂

G
Garret Huff · October 28, 2025

Definitely late to the party but Billy and Mandy would be a hilarious combo for outfits

C
Chin Diesel 98 · October 28, 2025

*BREAKING NEWS* Christian extremist Wendigoon executes an entire family for practicing their beliefs privately in the woods 😂

C
Christian Cruz · October 28, 2025

u guys would kill a Wario and Waluigi costume

O
Ozzi · October 27, 2025

i didn't realize there was a way to have just the banter without the story, but now that i've watched this, i'm really glad i joined the patreon bc the humor you two create when put together is perfect to entertain me at work :) it's literally like creepcast except the creep isn't the story, it's you two creeps! wonderful!

G
Grant Law · November 10, 2025

Same!!!!!

T
Tara Jones · October 25, 2025

I know it's probably too late , but you should put your live show online and let people who can't make it to Chicago watch all show and just discount it to 30.That goes to charity for the people who can't make it Y'all should dress as bonnie and clyde

O
Olivia Black · October 21, 2025

Pain and panic

E
Eren · October 20, 2025

Just subbed to the Patreon and didn’t expect it to include Isaiah pointing a gun at me. 11/10 would recommend

J
Johnny Samora · October 17, 2025

This was awesome 🤣🤣🤣

S
Simon Phylth · October 16, 2025

The fat purple monster woman from 1985s "House"

s
skinreaper · October 14, 2025

Go as Hunters grandpa and the dog

K
Kat Killjoy · October 11, 2025

The real gun sent me 🤣

K
Kat Killjoy · October 11, 2025

Freddy vs Jason costumes would be awesome

G
GoonerGoob · October 9, 2025

more role play please !!!

D
Danny · October 8, 2025

stupidly wasted bullets on the hypothesis here, now actually pulling a 360 no scope with the Deagle would be way cooler, all 3 kid heads aligned and doing a tripple shot would be SICK

☦
☦️Friendly Neighborhood Orthobro☦️ · October 8, 2025

You guys need to hit up Seth Skorkosky and have him run you some Call of Cthulhu

D
David Freaking King · October 8, 2025

This

K
Kyndaloo · October 7, 2025

I love that Isaiah just let hunter play out his fantasy for 45 minutes😭

D
Daddy Long Legs · October 4, 2025

Go as Jeffery Epstein and a little boy

S
Steve E · October 3, 2025

I'd pay good money to see you guys do a collab with NADDPOD

h
handstotheuniverse · October 2, 2025

COSTUME: GENDO (Hunter) AND SHINJI (Isaiah)

N
Numbers · October 1, 2025

Ik im late for this(new to the Patreon) but Kimber and Kyle

H
Homelessman.—. · September 30, 2025

I love This

I
I hate angel · September 28, 2025

I NEED y'all to do a D&D campaign

Z
Zorbrian · September 28, 2025

I need an animation of the RP so bad I might have to do it myself (never animated before)

R
Rian. exe · October 3, 2025

Agreed

L
Larkin Campbell · September 27, 2025

Sonic and Pikachu. An OG love story

A
Austin Mitchell · September 27, 2025

hunter as a flower in a flowerpot and isaiah in a bear costume for sure

M
Micahlonica · September 23, 2025

Egg and a frying pan definitely

G
GoonSoftware · September 23, 2025

That was so fucking funny

t
tiffany kimbrel · September 21, 2025

The people might now expect a little one-shot from you guys 😉📕

J
Jaylan Blankinship · September 19, 2025

i don’t know if this is the best or worst way i’ve spent 5 dollars

G
Gustavs Kreicbergs · September 19, 2025

It would be amazing to see you doing a show in Europe. A man can dream.

C
Cannibalcow · September 19, 2025

I know right lol

G
GoonMan · September 18, 2025

Please do another off the record D&D

S
Samantha Croft · September 17, 2025

You guys should totally do an rpg! And speaking of Weapons & whitest kids, they all got together (including Zach Cregger, the director or Weapons) and started a YouTube channel during quarantine and ended up doing a couple dnd style games. The 1st one is Buckerson & Meyers and has 13 episodes & is one of the best things on YouTube imo. They started a 2nd one called Road to Whoretown and only got 3 episodes in when Trevor Moore died (basically the head member of whitest kids if you haven't seen it) and they stopped there. But, anyone interested in listening to a sketch comedy group play dnd should check it out. It's ridiculous & hilarious

O
OXEY _ · September 16, 2025

Keep creep casting it

K
Kristie Abshire · September 14, 2025

Ya'll should do Curse of Strahd from DnD. It's vampires, zombies, werewolves all wrapped up. Plus there is a book to follow, it's a classic, and it's just pure horror. I think y'all would really love it. Plenty of resources at your disposal as well

M
Mae · September 13, 2025

I’m definitely gonna animate the whole “role-playing” bit yall did at some point- absolutely loved that 😭

C
CosmicSipps · September 13, 2025

There is more rustling coming from bushes. Wshhwshhwsshhsshhwsh. “I’m a robot” “I’m a robot”

P
PrehistoricOnion · September 12, 2025

One of you is a potted plant and the other is a house refusing to eat them

m
mark · September 12, 2025

A weird off shoot of Jekyll & Hyde and to twist it up more make hunter the doctor side

K
KEEFZILLA · September 12, 2025

They was hilarious I loved seeing Isaiah roleplaying I would've shot those dumbass kids too

D
Digital Krypyt Keeper · September 11, 2025

What started out as a somewhat classic 80s situation quickly turned into Isaiah becoming the stand by me child killer and I loved every second of it.

X
Xman the great 05 · September 10, 2025

Slimer and Melissa McCarthy

A
Alyssa · September 10, 2025

Listening to this made me realize that you guys should actually play DND together. Let someone else DM tho lmao

E
Easton and Alexis · September 10, 2025

I’d listen to Creep Dnd

P
Patrick Rowe · September 10, 2025

If you keep calling me an animal I will attack you with my teeth and nails thank you

r
rmarsh · September 10, 2025

Yes, faux DND concept is good. It's like those Incognito Mode videos, there's not enough of that shit that's not explicitly DND related. An untapped market you might say.

i
iobkuF · September 9, 2025

Creepcast DND is an amazing idea. Please give us more

A
Aekartzdefense · October 2, 2025

On god we need more of this

J
Jaybird · September 9, 2025

Weapons wasn’t as scary as I thought it was gonna be it feels very incomplete that being said TOGETHER was awesome

K
Kiernator 88 · September 9, 2025

Hunter should be kyle and windi should be kimber that would be peak

A
Aloha Cars · September 9, 2025

🔥💯👻🥩🐷

H
HairyCowListens · September 8, 2025

Y’all have to be Turnk Brownie and Jacoby

P
Pame Diaz · September 16, 2025

YES!!!

J
Jakob Medlin · September 8, 2025

Papa can be the titanic and Isiah can be the captain

C
Comrade2022 · September 8, 2025

I've rewatched the rpg section so many times. Wish Darbo could clip it. And they could do something like this on the main channel

T
Tyler Johnson · September 8, 2025

Godzilla and mothra or Jeff the killer and slender man

T
Tyler Johnson · September 8, 2025

Godzilla and mothra

E
Ellie · September 8, 2025

Pls more like this

J
Jade Paulson · September 8, 2025

Flower pots 😭😂

D
Dominic Mc gowan · September 8, 2025

Tommy Taffy and the sister

D
Dice XC · September 7, 2025

Robin Williams and Koko the Gorilla

A
Abigail Duerksen · September 7, 2025

Sometimes when my girlfriend feels ugly I say to her "You're gonna live with me now. I'm gonna take care of you." Implying that she is Sloth from The Goonies. It does NOT make her feel better.

T
Trantoon · September 7, 2025

a full DND adventure with the meat crew and wendigoon would go so hard

L
LordOfTheCaves · September 7, 2025

I really hope they do more of these off the record

C
Clint Preslar · September 5, 2025

Goonies was responsible for me looking for treasure everywhere as a child.

L
Loathe · September 5, 2025

y'all have GOT to go as your favorite creepypasta monsters. it's what built creepcast to what it is now

N
Nick · September 5, 2025

One of you should dress up as the big mommy moth monster and the other should be the dad

R
Ryan Galton · September 4, 2025

The monkey was an amazing movie

L
LouieLouie43 · September 4, 2025

BEE COSTUMES PLEASE

C
Colt Liter · September 4, 2025

Jared Leto Joker and Margot Robbie Harley Quinn

S
Sabeth Starling · September 5, 2025

hunter has to be harley tho

S
Sophia Salinas · September 4, 2025

Uncle fester and debbie

v
vaya the pussy destoyer · September 4, 2025

A bloody pope and JD Vance

J
Jacob T · September 4, 2025

Mario and wario

R
Ryan Galton · September 4, 2025

Next year yall should try to be apart of hulaween music festival! I would have been there this year if i hadn’t bought tickets way earlier this year for hulaween

R
Rat Pobertson · September 3, 2025

Please God, put more of these roleplay scenarios into my veins. Or... a ttrpg show??

C
Charles Hayley · September 3, 2025

Go as Sloth and Chunk.

A
Abigail Duerksen · September 7, 2025

Someone's gonna do fan art of this. And I hope that if they do, they live a blessed life and you also do for bringing this into their mind 💕

P
POPS · September 2, 2025

Haha loved it. Definitely some more DD role playing omg hilarious

R
Rat Pobertson · September 2, 2025

I think John Ward and Gary from Faith would be a good couples costume for them.

R
Rat Pobertson · September 2, 2025

Stand By Me should have ended with Dum Dum Boys.

e
eagle7546 · September 2, 2025

Isiah asking constant context questions in an improv scenario was gold lmao

S
Serenity · September 2, 2025

Hunter should be fairy queen

L
Lady Quinn · September 1, 2025

I could listen to you guys do this all day lol

T
Trotter Clark · September 1, 2025

Was the name Tinky a reference to MDE presents: world peace

T
Trotter Clark · September 1, 2025

was isaiah aware that the roleplay scenario wasnt real his actions didnt actually have any weight in the real world

A
Austin Furukawa · September 1, 2025

COSTUME:::::: HUNTER-FAIRY QUEEN::::: ISAIAH- HUNTER

G
Grotesque Art Studio · September 1, 2025

I hope Isiah dresses as a Priest and Hunter dresses as an alter boy with defensive wounds

L
Lliam Alhazred · August 30, 2025

I think this is my favorite yet :D

C
Cova Brouwer Gentry · August 30, 2025

My husband and I are going to wear a PB&J couple’s costume to the Halloween live showwwww. 5th row from the front!

C
Cova Brouwer Gentry · August 30, 2025

My husband and I are going to wear a PB&J couple’s costume to the Halloween live showwwww

L
Latwaun Calles · August 30, 2025

This was awesome

J
Jonas Breuning · August 29, 2025

Ozzy and Sharon Osborne

k
kelby · August 29, 2025

I want one of these every day i’d watch this 100% of the time

k
kelby · August 29, 2025

Ghostbuster and Slimer

C
Chloe · August 29, 2025

Constume ideas Charlie and pim from smiling friends , meat as charlie and wendigoon as pim you both really give of there vibe

P
PinkiePantz · August 28, 2025

I’ve not even finished this yet but I’m thinking we need a full dnd roleplay episode, Wendigoon being the sole player

H
Hamptershmampter · August 28, 2025

At this point it's gotta be eat me like a bug and wendigoon as whatever the most popular variant was. We want potted house hunter for sure though

L
Lune · August 27, 2025

Hunter as his grandfather and wendigoon dressed as a hunting dog

R
Ryan Fifield · August 25, 2025

Hunter as Uncle Iroh and Isiah as prince Zuko

M
Milky BB · August 25, 2025

Harley Quinn and joker! :D

N
Nevaeh Allen · August 25, 2025

HUNTER AS THE EAT ME LIKE A BUG PLANT & WENDIGOON AS THE SHERIFF FROM BORRASCA

Z
Zachery skaggs · August 25, 2025

Hunter gender bend as chappell roan and isaah goes as a pink pony

A
Andrea De La Cerda · August 24, 2025

Lmao y’all should go as Harry potter and Dobby 💀💀

K
Kevin Perez · August 24, 2025

If the dnd is going to be a weekly thing …… money well spent. I couldn’t stop laughing lol

K
Kevin Perez · August 24, 2025

Scooby and Shaggy

r
roroi · August 24, 2025

yall should be fred durst and john davis

L
L3xG · August 28, 2025

YES

H
Hoosh_Goblin · August 23, 2025

If Hunter dresses up like Isaiah he could get lip fillers and a Hawaiian tee! To get the PapaMeat look add some temporary tattoos and a wig along with a heavy metal shirt!

J
Jennifer Boland · August 23, 2025

Costume idea: ATF agent and dog

H
Hude Collins · August 23, 2025

Costume idea: Meat-Jabba the hutt Goon- Han Solo

S
Stonedoughnut · August 25, 2025

One better, Goon- Jabba the Hutt Meart- Leia Skywalker

g
glue · August 23, 2025

Guests would be dope

S
Shelby Myers · August 22, 2025

I love how Isaiah took some time to think through all of his decisions in the roleplay but then immediately decides to shoot a child LOL

E
Ella Roo · August 22, 2025

I feel like I’m evesdropping on a therapy session.

Z
Zackery Kahle · August 21, 2025

Guys. I would pay double for the patreon if you did the dnd style role play thing even once a month. That was fantastic

C
Colt Liter · August 21, 2025

The roll playing bit was so funny. Reminded me of the good old cream crew days.

D
Dom · August 21, 2025

I might be late to the party but please do more of these!

h
handsfeetandnut · August 21, 2025

The guy and the plant from little shop of horrors 🙏🏻

L
Liah Long · August 21, 2025

Psh if I only wanna hear a story then I'll do that. I'm here for ya'll first story second.

g
grimmie · August 21, 2025

shaggy and scooby or daphne and velma no in between

P
Phatfrankie · August 21, 2025

Man non patreon members are missing out on Isaiahs stand by me adventure

m
marsbar · August 21, 2025

rainbow dash and pinkie pie!!

J
Juan Diaz · August 21, 2025

Hunter as eat me like a bug potted plant man with Isaiah being Ticcy Toby

A
Am · August 21, 2025

I think Hunter should be the "eat me like a bug" potted plant man and Isaiah should dress as Mr Bear

M
Mark Sanchez · August 20, 2025

You both should dress as Catdog, full orange make up and orange body suits with big red and purple noses and something connecting the both of you together.

F
Flumpy · August 20, 2025

WHY DID YOU DO CORNSWORTH LIKE THAT????

A
Alex Johnson · August 20, 2025

I just got the creep cast patreon, and now there's a goblin in my house. Is that supposed to happen? I called the tech support but he told me thats normal. I don't believe him.

A
Alex Johnson · August 20, 2025

The goblin has great taste in music though, and he gave me a contract I can't read. Idk know if I want to sign it.

O
Orion · August 20, 2025

I haven’t listened to the ep yet wtf are these comments hahaha

F
Froog · August 20, 2025

Hat man and Benadryl, Isaiah go in a full black skin tight suit with a cloth covering and a hat, give hunter a pink shirt with pink pants with the Benadryl logo on it

Z
Zach · August 20, 2025

Patreon exclusive full lvl 1-20 Creep Cast d&d campaign starts when?

D
Donovan Crain · August 20, 2025

Catdog- tie your ankles together

F
Fidget Attack · August 20, 2025

pinkie pie and rainbow dash

G
Ghosty · August 20, 2025

Dude Jeff the killer and Ticky Toby. So you have an outlet for your sexual tension

A
Aaron Jezierski · August 20, 2025

Mordecai and twilight sparkle pleaseee

C
Chris Sein · August 20, 2025

You guys should dress up as pinky and the brain

v
vore · August 19, 2025

Need more DnD style episodes tbh

S
Sarah Meyer · August 19, 2025

Charlie and pim as your costume pleaseeeee

A
Ash Conard · August 19, 2025

Seymour and the plant from little shop of horrors

D
Destiny Schmidt · August 19, 2025

This has to be animated PLEASE

L
Linus S. · August 19, 2025

Sonic and Mario

T
Trinity Matty · August 19, 2025

Zander and David Fking King

A
Alex Abbott · August 19, 2025

You guys should dress up as Charlie and Pim from Smiling Friends

Z
Zac Keenan · August 19, 2025

Dobby and the cum sock!!

E
Elron · August 19, 2025

absolutely need more of this. great episode

J
John Roache · August 18, 2025

Love the DND segment! Costume idea: Hunter as the Plant Man, and Isaiah as Ticci Toby

P
Peter P · August 18, 2025

Tommy Taffy and a toddler

R
Rebecca Fulin · August 18, 2025

Isaiah is hunters wheelchair bound grandpa and hunter is his dog

N
Noah · August 18, 2025

Hunter I think I’m in love w you

R
Ryan Leedy · August 18, 2025

Kyle and kimber

D
Dolly Partner · August 18, 2025

you should both dress as bumble bees

J
Juicebox1203 · August 18, 2025

one of you is mayo and the other is an aristocrat

L
Luca Carbone · August 18, 2025

Bear and Bear trap would be a pretty romantic duo

D
Danger_Dee · August 18, 2025

How could I possibly have thought twice about subscribing to this Patreon. Greatest 5 buck I ever spent.

T
Taylor Blumkin · August 18, 2025

I love the 'choose your own adventure'! Makes Isaiah nervous and let's Hunter do all his voices. What more could you ask for! I'd love to see them play DnD

K
Karli Allard · August 17, 2025

On SK, his books I think is really good is Dreamcatcher, Cell, and honestly I love the Carrie book more than the movie. The ending is so much more violent, and chaotic. It also has short snippets through it where it's written like an interview/court hearing.

V
Valhalla Outdoors · August 17, 2025

For costumes, Wendigoon as Tommy Taffy and Hunter as a battered child

S
Semir · August 17, 2025

this!!!

s
sosoleboxer · August 17, 2025

Holy yap

N
Nathanion · August 17, 2025

Kimber And Kyle costume. With the JBL Pill.

T
TheSalvationArmy · August 16, 2025

Do this again, please. You guys are funny I’ve come to hear.

S
Sarah W · August 16, 2025

"Am I going to get leeches on my balls?" "Probably"

z
zena wood · August 16, 2025

rob and bristol from left right game? isaiah as rob and hunter as bristol of course

z
zena wood · August 16, 2025

you gotta choose someone from a story yall have covered. maybe the penpal and the kid lol. or the sheriff from borrosca and tommy taffy. a crossover of two characters from separate stories that would get along could be fun. king creole and mr wellers. or maybe the couple from the baby kink one shit what was it called?

z
zena wood · August 16, 2025

my husbands taking roleplay too far

L
Lilly McNally · August 16, 2025

Hunter as King Creole and Isaiah as the little girl or Travis

B
Baobabz · August 15, 2025

Please more of these

X
X_PocketKnight · August 15, 2025

Hunter as Isaiah and Isaiah as Hunter

C
Cassie Berard · August 15, 2025

Cillian Murphy was in the movie !! He was the extremely skinny, frail looking zombie that the kid kills behind his mom!

N
Nokia · August 15, 2025

Batman (papa) and Robin (wendigoon) would be funny. Tights and all

B
Becky · August 15, 2025

Funeral Kyle and his Beats pill couple costume.

B
Ben Crawford · August 15, 2025

100% into this, please continue off the record discussions

C
Casserole · August 14, 2025

Your costumes should be you dressing/looking like your wives agshsgsh

S
Sharkitty Tiddycrumbs · August 14, 2025

$50 would work ok, $60 with goodies. Ya'll should come to San Francisco or San Jose California next. As for the costumes, y'all should be a 2 man horse costume. Hunter gets to be the back half, since Isaiah has the hose lips covered.

S
Shire Folk · August 14, 2025

This is the best thing you guys have done ever 🤘🏼

T
Taylor · August 14, 2025

I so agree with Isaiah! I loved the first half of the movie and then it was like what’s happening

C
CloBug · August 14, 2025

Is there going to be a recorded version for the people who can’t make it to the live event??

m
miku · August 14, 2025

Please have Isiah be Jeff the killer and hunter be slender man

T
TheQuietCat · August 13, 2025

Hunter: King Creole, Dobby, or Squish me like a bug guy Isiah: Shinji, Jeff Goldblum, or a Goth Mommy (Since he’s always talking about them)

J
Justus Rhines · August 13, 2025

I would like to see you as kyle and kimber

A
Austin Roberts · August 13, 2025

Would love to see more DND sessions like this and then they also get animated and it starts a whole creep cast universe

A
Alec Willis · August 13, 2025

Gotta have papa meat dress up as the plant man from Dionea house

J
Jacob Black · August 13, 2025

D&D shit was funny as hell

E
Eva Zimney · August 12, 2025

I love the 3 hour tangents

A
AtheistLady · August 12, 2025

I love when y’all just shoot the shit!

S
SquiggthePig · August 12, 2025

Ya'll should read the workshop by Christian Wallis. Just read it from the "With Teeth" book and it was a banger 🔥

t
tacobellknight · August 12, 2025

this was fire

S
Sydney Arnold · August 12, 2025

Dress up as some of the classic creepypastas! Like Jeff, Ben, Toby, etc. The makeup for some of them would be so fun!! And costumes wouldn’t be bulky/uncomfy to sit in for 3 hours.

B
Big Gooch · August 12, 2025

Need to see them in the classic couples costume of the plug and outlet

K
Kimberly Baker · August 12, 2025

I would pay good money to have Hunter DM a D&D game with Isaiah as a player fr

C
Casey · August 12, 2025

Isaiah was right - we want more D&D

E
Erin · August 12, 2025

Tommy Taffy and whatever that dad’s name was.

C
Casey · August 12, 2025

Screaming crying throwing up - I AM going to this Chicago show

C
Casey · August 17, 2025

i did it. i’m going

D
Dade Neeley · August 12, 2025

need it to be goon as shinji and meat as asuka

A
Altobelli Matias 237 · August 12, 2025

the ed, ed and eddy creepypasta

l
lali popz · August 12, 2025

Side note Hunter i bet you would be hilarious in GTA Roleplay

j
juggs29 · August 11, 2025

If wendi doesn't dress as shengi from neon genesis what are we doing here?

C
Connbarn · August 11, 2025

As long as you guys do a short dnd section like this in every off the record episode, yall can do it whenever you’d like

U
UnknownAutumn 39 · August 11, 2025

Would love to see them play bg3

C
Cosmic · August 11, 2025

Shaggy and Scooby. It's gotta be

S
Sophey Potter · August 11, 2025

Velma is Isiah and Daphne is hunter

S
Sophey Potter · August 11, 2025

I want full drag

S
Sean Hansen · August 11, 2025

Isaiah as a old man in a wheelchair with a faint resemblance to hunter and hunter as a dog

M
Melli · August 14, 2025

This is genius and why I am a part of this proud community.

A
AslanLionJesus · August 11, 2025

Hunter needs to be Kyle from Barrasca with a black and yellow shirt, idk about Isiah though

M
Melli · August 14, 2025

the mad funny wife in the box, duh

p
potato man64s · August 11, 2025

Jeff the killer and slender man yaoi situation just for the creppypasta

G
Gavin · August 11, 2025

Bevus and butthead costumes

A
Amy Brayan · August 11, 2025

For Halloween Isaiah should dress up as a Pimp and Hunter should dress up as Daddy’s little best seller.

G
GoblinDeez · August 11, 2025

Need more of these

S
Some Dead Guy · August 11, 2025

I and I imagine Isaiah too would have gone with a gun already and would have shot everyone there too

J
Jay Green · August 11, 2025

I think venus fly trap in a pot and a fly holding a bottle of whiskey is the perfect costume for y’all

M
Max Dalton · August 11, 2025

Came here to say this

I
Ivy_The_King · August 11, 2025

Id say Papa Meat actually becomes a flesh monster, and Weenidgoon becomes a windago, or like the messed-up mixed versions some art draws you as. Aka antlers coming out of Weenidgoon head and Papa meat face melting off!

T
TheGooseCaptain · August 10, 2025

I really enjoyed this kind of video. Ya'll keep stuff like this coming. Also that roleplay scenario was one of the funniest things I've seen in a while!

S
ScardieCrow · August 10, 2025

I'll literally give up my entire paycheck for yall to come to Utah

B
Brendon McConnell · August 10, 2025

Hyped for the Billy Mitchell vs Creep Cast lawsuit

H
Hellokeeri · August 10, 2025

On the topic of Stephen King. His short story book “If It Bleeds” is really really good. Stephen King I feel drags on in a lot of his books (It) but highly recommend!

W
W · August 10, 2025

I thought of an idea for the live show. "Fairy Queen" sing-along.

C
CatPawsN’Accordion · August 10, 2025

You guys should be characters form Lord of the Flies

W
WIkiDev · August 10, 2025

I read it as "would you go and see a dad body?" And i was like hell yeah

B
Bryan Gore · August 10, 2025

I actually liked the 90s tv Shining

J
Jared Laskowsky · August 10, 2025

Damn Borasca VI was fire thanks guys

j
juciycicken _47 · August 10, 2025

Id love to see more roleplay, but id also love to see hunter and Isaiah play magic together

D
Dougieman · August 10, 2025

Hunter - the fly Isaiah - Jeff goldblum

t
trippiwilli · August 10, 2025

For y'all's costume y'all should recreate the merch shirt where yalls faces are melted and stick the melted pieces together

J
JM · August 9, 2025

Love the roleplay

t
the kid · August 9, 2025

The Hat Man and a tablet of Benadryl

A
Alex Garza · August 9, 2025

I think Gomez and morticia Adam’s would be so killer for y’all

S
Stephen · August 9, 2025

Hunters gotta be a man in a flower pot Isaiah’s gotta be Mr Wellers

X
Xavier Blanford · August 9, 2025

I would HATE to have hunter as a dungeon master

P
PsychWorm · August 9, 2025

Pleaaaaase re-read stairs in the woods. It’s still my favorite nosleep post of all time. The first episode did not give it justice, the stories still creep me out every time I think about them

M
Mamabear 0824 · August 9, 2025

Hunter should dress as Jacoby and Isaiah should be Mr. Wellers

J
Joe Reel · August 9, 2025

Isaiah saying Stephen King isn't that great of a writer is one of the most insane takes from someone who likes horror.

S
Sharkitty Tiddycrumbs · August 14, 2025

Honestly, I agree. King drags on and on sometimes. The story concepts are good, just the droning for me.

Z
Z Z · August 9, 2025

Hunter should be the Fairy Queen

R
Roxxi Perez · August 9, 2025

Wish Hunter would switch Fairy queen to Dairy Queen and pitch it to them for a commercial. 🤣

P
PikaLENEKOO · August 9, 2025

PLEEAASSEEE READ STEPHEN KING SHORT STORIES PLEASE

M
Marty Brumblebee · August 9, 2025

One of them absolutely has to be man in flower pot.

M
McKenzie D. · August 9, 2025

Dear god yes

R
Roxxi Perez · August 9, 2025

Isaiah: bowser Hunter: princess peach

s
shannon :) · August 9, 2025

hear me out … other way around

J
Jt Azevedo · August 9, 2025

dress up as hunters dog and his grandpa

J
Jonathan Everhart · August 9, 2025

I'm married to an Italian American and I'm scared for my life

J
JoshSucksAtGames · August 9, 2025

Is the obvious choice for couple costume not just a Venus fly trap in a pot and a house?

S
Surta · August 9, 2025

couples costume? Kyle and kimber.

C
Caroline Strickland · August 8, 2025

Fantastic

C
Cherry · August 8, 2025

You should do slenderman and Jeff the killer costumes LOL

K
Kylan Chandler · August 8, 2025

These episodes are the BEST I’d listen to Mother Horse Eyes length episodes of you guys just talking shit. Also all the input you put into the stories, all your little tangents and the bits you guys do, that’s what makes the show great, that’s what makes me watch it every week

b
beau · August 8, 2025

can yall please dress as Benadryl and h man for halloween

N
Nic Truscello · August 8, 2025

I thought you meant the other h-man for a minute

L
Lojojojo · August 8, 2025

Honestly just make a second podcast for these roleplays

G
Gike Moldberg · August 8, 2025

I'm so glad someone has the same opinion on 28 years later as me. First half great, once the kid leaves, terrible.

R
RejectedNinja95 · August 8, 2025

Hunter: Jabba the Hutt Isaiah: Slave Leia

B
Brittany Zapata · August 8, 2025

my husband and I will be Dora and Boots (he's dora). Ya'll should match with us <3 ironically we were both Sonic last year.

J
Jillian · August 8, 2025

Undertaker: hunter Shawn Michaels: Isaiah

L
Laina J'onzz · August 8, 2025

Phineas and Ferb. 👀👀

M
Meghan Gove · August 7, 2025

new idea: creepcampaign. it’s a dnd style campaign with isaiah, hunter, allison and kayla

E
Ethan Bright-Evans · August 8, 2025

PERFECT

F
Finn Williams · August 7, 2025

Costume idea: Bdsm mistress and sub

M
Marzipan · August 8, 2025

And it be like a sub sandwich.

k
kevin joustra · August 7, 2025

w 1300th comment

P
Paladin Of The Old North · August 7, 2025

Zuko and uncle Iroh

C
Crabbus · August 7, 2025

Yeah 28 years later was dog shit. Especially the jimmy saville ninjas at the end

H
Hambone26217 · August 7, 2025

Jason Voorhees and Freddy Krueger

R
RexWitty · August 7, 2025

I loved sinners but I think why it was so good was how it used horror to describe cultural vampirism and metaphors for slavery, religious trauma etc. making it feel much more like a time piece of what life was like for black people in the thirties more then just a “vampire movie”

R
RikiSHE hawk fatua on that Chase Richardson · August 7, 2025

Hunter should do the eat me like a bug and Isiah should go as the homeless turtle guy

J
Jericho M · August 7, 2025

Dress up as Kyle and Kimber

T
Tom Ince · August 7, 2025

Can we get these on RSS/ audio?

J
John Maher · August 7, 2025

I think it could be fun to maybe look into some of the great horror rpgs that are super easy to learn and very fun to play, games like Dread which uses only a janga tower to play and 10 candles that uses candles to mark the passage of time as examples , both these games are built for horror and are very fun in dread when you knock the tower over your character dies and then it's rebuilt and the game continues with the other characters, you pull blocks to complete actions so for example you might want to open a closed door not knowing what's behind it and then you would pull a block hope that makes sense haha and 10 candles I haven't played yet but what I know is all the characters die at the end and the game starts with 10 candles and as things get harder candles get blown out as the story progresses it looks very fun and is on my list of games to try but thought no harm in suggesting it

P
Phoob · August 6, 2025

You guys HAVE to do creepypasta or like scary DND themed dnd or something. Sometime

A
A Concerned Citizen · August 6, 2025

My God I need more of these in my life

D
Debbie Chapman · August 6, 2025

Leopold and Lobb

b
ben · August 6, 2025

Funny story about leeches and balls… when I was a kid I went to Christian summer camp, I decided to go swimming in a shallow pond and I ended up getting a leech on the very tip of my weenie. Everyone joked that I was the only one who got a blowjob that trip

C
Centauri · August 7, 2025

thank you ben

F
Francho · August 6, 2025

I think it would be cute if they wore costumes based on creepypastas they've read. Examples: the pig from Feed the Pig, a conjoined twin from it bleeds it breeds, mother whore thighs, slenderman (kinda played out but funny), etc

A
Alexis Ball · August 6, 2025

Pim and Charlie from Smiling Friends!!

F
Francho · August 6, 2025

I think it would be cute if they wore costumes based on creepypastas they've read. Examples: the pig from Feed the Pig, a conjoined twin from it bleeds it breeds, mother whore thighs, slenderman (kinda played out but funny), etc

E
Enclave Edgar · August 6, 2025

Papa meat should start doing a DND thing with his crew and wendigoon. That would rock

E
EVAngelion · August 6, 2025

I cant go to the show because im European but i'm hype for the charity tshirt

N
Noah M · August 6, 2025

Tommy Taffy and Hulk Holgon

E
Eliott · August 6, 2025

If yall come to Boston again I will come to the show wearing an entirely exposed brain kill bill style makeup

C
Caleb · August 6, 2025

I love the dnd content

N
Nurse Nikki · August 6, 2025

Each other's wives

d
dbcakes · August 6, 2025

Couples costume: 5 year old boy, Mr. Widemouth. 😊

n
nmp · August 6, 2025

Christopher Robin and Winnie the Pooh

A
Aidan · August 6, 2025

Dress up as Pim and Charlie from smiling friends. you know who is who.

W
W · August 6, 2025

"you gotta be my daddy" ..... "I TURN THE GUN AROUND"

G
GMRedstar · August 6, 2025

Hey if you guys ever want to play D&D or Pathfinder Id be happy to run a few scenarios for you, necromancing children optional.

M
Muscle Mass Murder · August 6, 2025

I fucking adored that mini scenario

P
Porpoisepal329 · August 6, 2025

Old man and a dog is perfect

T
Tam Tran · August 6, 2025

so excited to see you guys in chicago and on my birthday!! please dress up as shinji and asuka from evangelion LOL

M
Meghan Gove · August 6, 2025

OMG YOURE COMING TO MY CITY YAY!!!!!! also, my vote is edward and bella.

D
Debbie Chapman · August 6, 2025

That’s really too scary

A
Axel Meza · August 6, 2025

Birthday suit!!!!

A
Addison Mason · August 6, 2025

An old man and a dog

R
Rachel · August 6, 2025

Cosmo and Wanda 👉👈

T
T Kemp · August 6, 2025

Costumes should be Peach and Daisy or Peach and Mario since Wendigoon already had the dress. Side note I'd love to see them play a ttrpg like kids on bikes, monster of the week, or even just FATE (not fatal) with Meat as the story teller

N
Nat :D · August 6, 2025

This might be an all time Creepcast episode

T
Tytufek · August 5, 2025

This was super fun! More DnD would be great, I also just like the format of Cast without the Creep, I think this is a great place for it... That's not to say I wouldn't also like more stories, just saying this was really fun.

S
Sean Woods · August 5, 2025

Man I hope you guys read the rest of the “Black Farm” series

D
Dead Red · August 5, 2025

Great... Now I need more horror DnD where kids die.

C
Cursed Cartridge · August 5, 2025

Jeff the killer and ticci tobi, professional make up, lightsaber battle/jason vs freddy scene Gold

A
Austin Duller · August 5, 2025

We need a couple costume where one is the sheriff and the other is the Shiny Gentleman

K
Kitty Sniffles Art · August 5, 2025

Whatever it is, I'll happily pay it

C
Caden Rivers · August 5, 2025

I think we need an "eat me like a bug" guy costume for sure

L
Luke Johnson · August 5, 2025

I live where they made stand by me funny thing is I didn’t see the movie until I was like 15

C
Chris Hetzel · August 5, 2025

Loved the d&d session. Hunter is a great dungeon master.

C
Cursed Cartridge · August 5, 2025

I will pay you a million billion dollars to keep doing these outrageous dnd sessions.

P
PikaLENEKOO · August 5, 2025

as someone who JUST finished reading the body for the first time a few weeks ago i didnt even know it had a movie this video was trippy

N
Nathan · August 5, 2025

Dress as the guys from broke back mountain

L
Lyndoh · August 5, 2025

Hunter should be a bear and Isiah should be a trap

F
Fith · August 5, 2025

Hey hunter i just finished wiping ‼️

S
Shannon Northrup · August 5, 2025

Couples costume: Godzilla and Mothra

P
Payton · August 5, 2025

“Am.. Am I gonna die?” “. . .” “Yes.”

A
Aiden Parry · August 5, 2025

Isiah is in a wheelchair and Hunter should be dressed up by a dog

M
Mathias Luczak · August 5, 2025

Hunter needs to be the pot from the plant house episode

Z
Zane Smith · August 5, 2025

Get the meaty magic gang and Wendi together for a DnD campaign

V
VintageHipster · August 5, 2025

Saying the 2nd half of 28 years later jumped the shark is one hell of a take, that's for sure. I loved it, my girlfriend was just okay on it. That's the most scathing I've heard anyone say about the movie.

M
Mysterious O · August 4, 2025

Isaiah didn't try to roll an Insight check, an Arcana check, cast Fireball, nothing.

A
Ashlynn Atkins · August 4, 2025

My first thought was Shaggy and Scooby but then I thought Hunter might not want to dress like a dog… might as well put Isaiah in a wheelchair at that point.

V
Valhalla Outdoors · August 4, 2025

Do a whole episode of Hunter as the story master,

M
Moist Chungus · August 4, 2025

Tarzan & Jane

m
m05ch · August 4, 2025

That was awesome.

R
Ryan Sullivan · August 4, 2025

When and where can we buy event tickets? And is it confirmed Halloween night in Chicago?

M
Marshall Klein · August 4, 2025

Why did cornsworth come back lol

C
Creep · August 4, 2025

kyle and kimber

M
Molly Hamm · August 4, 2025

Lovecraft and Cthulhu

H
Hallie · August 4, 2025

Husband and wife who have taken roleplaying too far 👁️👁️

J
Josh · August 4, 2025

I’m short on money and I had to cancel my membership. But then I watched this and realized I can afford it

P
Pontifex · August 4, 2025

PLEASE dress as Rob and Alice from The Left Right Game.

M
MrZelda1313 · August 4, 2025

this was fucking amazing, worth every patreon peny

f
flaminghobo310 · August 4, 2025

This is fantastic make more of these off the records for patreon. This format works so well.

S
Skylar Ehrlich · August 4, 2025

WENDIGOON doesn’t like kids with hobbies- confirmed

J
Jason Henning · August 4, 2025

WHY IS WENDIGOON AIMING A GUN AT ME

B
Belle · August 4, 2025

I could watch y’all play a Call of Cthulhu or Kids on Bikes

Z
Zach Fruin · August 4, 2025

Not gonna lie im making a Call of Cthulhu campaign based on the Left Right Game. They'd love it. And yes I've changed most of the story as it didn't fit the gameplay

O
Orion Not Ryan · August 4, 2025

Applejack and rarity

D
Devi · August 4, 2025

A bear and a bear trap 😂

S
Slumpy · August 4, 2025

This is hilarious, yall should definitely do more of the RP stuff

B
Brennan Cruz · August 4, 2025

Buzz n woody

c
colton Lem · August 4, 2025

When weapons come out yalll should do a full length movie reaction of it on here

S
Satchamo_Jones · August 4, 2025

The DnD improv was hilarious.

J
James Cameron Wain · August 4, 2025

The Severed Halves of CatDog would be a sweet costume

d
dan · August 4, 2025

please more of this

B
BDG · August 4, 2025

Everyone going to the charity show needs to be dressed up as either Hunter or Isaiah. That way it will look like a cult meeting

S
Sergio jr Reynoso · August 4, 2025

y’all should do a D&D campaign!

N
NaurTheOrc · August 4, 2025

Batman and Cat Woman

A
Aly Molina · August 4, 2025

Hunter should be Boo from monsters inc and wendigoon be sully

J
Jason Henning · August 4, 2025

i love seeing the yaps

J
Justin Bolles · August 4, 2025

Venus Fly Traps

S
Sergio Arellano · August 4, 2025

I love the DND type role play stuff! It would be too much to actually play the game, but that’s be a dope once in a while thing if y’all did!

N
Noremac Northman · August 4, 2025

Rob and Apollo 100 percent!!!

M
Myexwife · August 4, 2025

John Wayne Gacy and Ted Bundy for the costumes

A
A. Hixon Photography · August 4, 2025

the two worse creppypasta, Jeff the Killer and Squidawrd Suicide

j
jon · August 4, 2025

Nice

S
Sleepy Head · August 4, 2025

Yall need to paint yourself green and dress up like Venus fly traps

T
Taylor · August 4, 2025

Chucky and Tiffany!!

J
July808 · August 3, 2025

All I know is that Hunter needs to dress up as the moth bed creature from "we weren't allowed to talk to women"

o
owen · August 3, 2025

mr bear and tommy taffy would be fun

T
ThatCuriousCat333 · August 3, 2025

For Halloween: Either Mr. Wellers and the man who follows OR dressed like Venus Fly Traps (complete with doing the set in a giant pot)

D
DLB · August 3, 2025

I'm not against a couple costume, but I think individual costumes would free you up to go all out. Hunter already has those beefy legs of his, I'd like to see him go all out on something that looks like his drawings.

D
Dadwelltk · August 3, 2025

Orgasmo and Choda Boy!

S
Sepi · August 3, 2025

I love seeing everyone comment d&d and yes I think we need an episode of that

R
RAFIKI · August 3, 2025

jekyll and hyde

W
Witt Edwards · August 3, 2025

I’m late to the game, but one of the fondest memories with my dad (not a close relationship) wanted to watch a movie with me and he picked Maximum Overdrive. Thanks Hunter for being nostalgic memories of nostalgia

M
Mitchell Carter · August 3, 2025

Honestly a DnD with you two and the rest of the crew and the wife would be amazing! Even if it were just a one shot in case you don’t want it to take too long

K
Knowgi · August 3, 2025

One of you be Hunter’s Grandpa, the other one be the dog 💀

I
Isaac Burns · August 3, 2025

Obviously for Halloween both of you need to be in big flower pots and get eaten like a bug on stage.

R
Rooney · August 3, 2025

A regular horror themed roleplaying segment would be so fucking good!

s
shi10 · August 3, 2025

Pim & Charlie

n
no no no no · August 4, 2025

Lol was typing that when I saw ur comment

S
Slathosaur Porb · August 3, 2025

This was fantastic, the roleplay is amazing

A
Alga Wyspe · August 3, 2025

Kyle and Kimber!

T
The Spire Battlemaps · August 3, 2025

Need a creepcast dnd campaign now

C
Chef · August 3, 2025

Jabba the hutt and Princess Leia

S
Sean Ryan · August 3, 2025

Couples costume: Kyle & Kimber

E
Evan Brandon · August 3, 2025

Hunter’s grandpa and the dog

E
Edith Puthie · August 4, 2025

Yes.

C
CharybdisSlashCrow · August 3, 2025

jeff and jane the killer

h
henry rodriguez · August 3, 2025

Victor and the corpse bride

T
Ticky Tonka · August 3, 2025

Hey it’s my birthday and I am so so so excited for the new episode today!!!!

Z
Zyntheis · August 3, 2025

Hunter as a fairy queen and Wendy as a 6ft tall goth queen named Jacobi

J
Joe · August 3, 2025

Jeff the killer and ticci toby pls Tyty

g
gangrene98_ · August 3, 2025

Shiji and Misato

t
the kid · August 9, 2025

they should dress up as tgom yorke and jonny greenwood 🙂‍↕️

g
gangrene98_ · August 3, 2025

Go as Josh and the Stalker from Penpal

b
bigboigangleader · August 3, 2025

Mr.Wellers and Shinji would be an ultimate combo

D
Dilf_hunter64 · August 3, 2025

Bella and Edward

Z
Zander Shinn · August 3, 2025

Frankenstein and the monster

L
Liz G · August 3, 2025

This would actually be cool

M
Mackensie Wagner · August 3, 2025

Will you guys try Malort in Chicago

T
TheSoupMan · August 3, 2025

They need to go as Kyle and Kimber for the tour

M
MeGan MangOLD · August 3, 2025

Could you please make an eat me like a bug short in v neck? I already commented on the non story that was very nice

C
Chris Rivera · August 3, 2025

Hunter is a comedic genius

s
starson · August 3, 2025

Shinji and Misato

C
Cynthia · August 2, 2025

Maximum Overdrive is my faaaavorite 80's movie

F
Fat_guy_comics · August 2, 2025

Papa- grandpa with gun Wendi-Hunters dead dog.

C
Colt Busick · August 2, 2025

This is the best one

H
HankTheTank · August 2, 2025

#1 couples costume is Jacobi and Scary Teri

P
Pertinax · August 2, 2025

I don’t have a specific suggestion, but any CreepCast story related couple’s costume would certainly give me a good chortle.

C
Christopher Chamberlain · August 2, 2025

The voodoo shop owner and clerk

S
StGenevieve · August 2, 2025

Drunk psychotic man and his talking plant wife

S
Silje · August 2, 2025

Wtf

H
Haloreach Around · August 2, 2025

ornstein and smough would be wonderful

C
Chowie · August 2, 2025

Surely Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy costumes 🤣 for the nostalgia 🥹

A
Aidan Patko · August 2, 2025

I’d sell my left nut for CreepDND

K
Kyle A. Berg · August 2, 2025

For Halloween costumes, how about Isaiah as Jeff the Killer and Hunter as Ticci Toby?

J
Jenny Bonno · August 2, 2025

Please come to florida for a tour I know it is hot, but we have spooky lighthouses here :D

M
MobuMikey · August 2, 2025

Imma need hunter as tiki tobis potted plant father and Isiah as Tobi for holloween also just gotta say this podcast really makes my 11pm electric scooter ride from work on a pitch black trail doable

T
Ticky Tonka · August 3, 2025

That ride and this podcast would fix me.

L
Looking back on Earth. · August 2, 2025

Me and sasha are listening sasha is a cat

h
huh. · August 2, 2025

A full short DND session just you two would be absolutely fucking hilarious

P
P2K-itty · August 2, 2025

God can't get over how much I enjoyed the dnd part

f
fakenickib · August 2, 2025

I never knew i needed a DnD channel/podcast hosted by Papa himself.

f
fakenickib · August 2, 2025

Hunter just wanted to kill the fat ginger

H
Howard · August 2, 2025

Wendi needs to be a Venus Flytrap, and Hunter needs to be a bug. And Wendi needs to eat him live on stage

S
Samuel Brandon · August 2, 2025

Please more faux dnd. It was amazing ^^

S
Sun · August 2, 2025

Marble hornets pt3?

R
Runt Rich · August 2, 2025

you guys should do a CreepTV episode of Accounts from a Lonely Broadcast Station, I absolutely LOVE the Audible version, the narrator adds a lot

A
Alvaro V. Gonzalez · August 2, 2025

Tommy taffy and king creole

M
McKenzie D. · August 1, 2025

Hearing hunter confidently say protland hurt me inside a little bit,, it was filmed in Astoria

M
McKenzie D. · August 1, 2025

BUT ALSO KEEP CONFIDENTLY ANSWERING HUNTER!!!!

M
McKenzie D. · August 1, 2025

My favorite part of the story readings are when you guys riff off and joke tbh

G
Grandpa with a Shotgun · August 1, 2025

Isaiah would be the needlessly violent d&d player lol. And Hunter would be a hilarious dungeon master

M
MightyMouse · August 1, 2025

BOOOOOOM

R
RagingNight724 · August 1, 2025

I freakin loved this!

M
Ms.Boner · August 1, 2025

you guys gotta do mario and princess peach but hunter is peach

M
Mayor of SpicyTown · August 1, 2025

Go as how you saw the characters Kimber and Kyle

M
Minerva Noctua · August 1, 2025

This was a very nostalgic episode for me: Stand By Me is my dad’s favourite episode & The Goonies is up there with his favourite too so I’ve seen both films dozens of times. I knew EXACTLY what the ending monologue was for Stand By Me before Wendi read it out (:

D
DapperWendigo · August 1, 2025

You two should totally go as Leatherface and Chop Top

k
kaitlynn cole · August 1, 2025

If yall don’t do eustace and Muriel bagge from courage the cowardly dog I’ll kick the wall with a toothpick under my toenail (this is a threat)

M
Minerva Noctua · August 1, 2025

Is there a possibility you could upload these another version of these stories that is audio only so I download them? Patreon won’t seem to let me download these video episodes. I work at a Port & the Data is spotty at best and I like to listen to your episodes during night shifts (which at pretty quiet). Would greatly appreciate it!

D
Dylan East · August 1, 2025

I do love the usual format of the podcast with you guys telling online stories but I think once a month you guys should have an episode like this. Where you two just blab off about random things😂😂😂

S
Sebastian Cabrera · August 1, 2025

Naruto and Sasuke

G
Greg · August 1, 2025

Off the record is an amazing name!

O
OopsoTheWoopso · August 1, 2025

An aging lesbian couple on the brink of divorce. Hunter and Isaiah would need to shave.

C
CH · August 1, 2025

Costumes should be Tommy taffy and sheriff walker

C
Chris · August 1, 2025

50-60 sounds super reasonable guys, esp for charity

D
Deernuts_270 · August 1, 2025

mother mary and joseph Costumes

N
Nat :D · August 1, 2025

I am happy to pay $4.99 a month for this content!

N
Nate Lamborn · August 1, 2025

Two Jeff the killers

B
Boobiebuddha · August 1, 2025

Gypsy Rose and deedee costumes please, hunter would make a mean deedee

n
nobodyanyways · August 1, 2025

These videos are fun

P
Puck · August 1, 2025

Sonic and Amy (Hunter is Amy)

G
George wash · August 1, 2025

This isn’t matching at all but I think it would be hilarious if Isiah was balloon boy and hunter was barf from space balls…

R
Rokket · August 1, 2025

Dressing in drag would be ridiculously fun 😭

a
ag2699 · August 1, 2025

I love this format lol

S
S · August 1, 2025

frankenstein's monster and his monster wife (hunter obv)

S
S · August 1, 2025

a show near me :0

c
cade hammons · August 1, 2025

I would honestly watch Hunter and Isaiah talk about horror movies/movies in general for like 10 hours

S
Sash · August 1, 2025

Dress up as king kreol and the main character of half priced voodo shop PLEASEEEEE

S
Sash · August 1, 2025

Hunter could dress in the full king kreol outfit with the fake stitched mouth, and Isiah could adopt the roses cheek doll look the main character gets at the end of the story

T
The Zombinator slayer · August 1, 2025

Hansel and Gretel (Hunter is Hansel)

L
LipsMcGee · August 1, 2025

I feel like for Halloween you have to dress as the dog and Hunter’s grandpa

d
diana villalobos · August 1, 2025

Genuinely loved this so much!! Like idk what I expect but you guys always provide so thank you 🥹💕💕

J
JALMRob · August 1, 2025

Tell me its ok Isaiah didn't like 28 years later ...we can have different opinions lol... me and my brother loved it

J
JALMRob · August 1, 2025

This patreon just paid for itself... Isaiah walking off camera bec hunter wint let him kill children. And one of these men is going to be a father soon....

K
Kathi · August 1, 2025

Who is gonna be a father????

K
Kyle Brown · August 1, 2025

Loved the story prompt format! Don't need it all the time but every once in a while would be great :)

M
Meghan Mathus-Goolsby · August 1, 2025

How about pay per view tix on youtube for those who can't be in Chicago??

P
Patrick Jenkins · August 1, 2025

Could you upload all the episodes on here?

A
Ave · August 1, 2025

Immediate thoughts on costumes: Hunter - The Mayqueen Isaiah - her ex in the Bear suite

A
Ave · August 1, 2025

CHICAGO?!?! LETS GOOO!!! The crazy thing is that I was planning on being in Chicago for a Halloween party that weekend anyways 😏

G
Garrett Turpin · August 1, 2025

Denver would be awesome

D
Damian Van Vuuren · August 1, 2025

Think we need a proper D&D episode now lol

S
Space Sparker · August 1, 2025

DnD episode would seriously be so awesome, and perhaps a cool segway to introduce guests onto the show!!

C
Courtney Sanderson · August 1, 2025

Hoping you guys do a live show in TN sometime. 🤞 Don't forget to get a Chicago dog !