RECOMMEND STORIES!
ALRIGHT YOU HEATHENS!
Tell us which stories we should read, if you see a comment that is a story you like upvote it and we will look at some of the most upvoted ones!
WE WANT THE GOOD SHIT! HAVE AT IT!
Comments (568)
Vita carnis creep tv
Oh my god please please please read tapers please please I am begging you guys please
Yall should do the backroads! I don’t remember the quality of the story but the writer just finished the entirety of the story I believe!
i just finished “Comfort Me with Apples” by Catherynne M. Valente. it’s a short story novella, only 83 pages. i think it would make a great episode! :]
Godzilla NES, Aboandoned by Disney
Not sure if this is still monitored but 'James, in the Golden Light of the Hereafter' is a pretty gnarly read that has never really left me. https://www.lightspeedmagazine.com/fiction/james-golden-sunlight-hereafter/
I don´t know why you nevert touched it but "all tomorrows" would be a great read.
So I'm new to the Patreon game and I just got into it because of you boys, and I don't even know if this is gonna get read because I don't know how anything works lol. I love your guys' content and you've gotten me through some rough-patches, which I am eternally grateful for. You two constantly surpass my expectations. I still thought it would be cool to throw in my two cents on stories to suggest, whether it's noticed or not lol. Three stories I can recommend are ones I haven't looked into in over a decade, but they each had a profound impact on me back in the day, and I had to use some random word-association-shenanigans to shake the cobwebs out of my brain just to remember the names of the writers and titles of the stories. Two of the three are 'Crying Numbers' and 'Plastic Glasses' by Ashley Franz Holzmann, they are not your common creepypasta with how they tackle some serious subject matter that resonate with a lot of people. The third is one that is just really cool called 'Invoking Ganesh' by Joshua Harding. Whatever you guys do next I'm here for it, thank you guys for all you do and God bless!
You guys should read this one, it can stand alone but it also has two continuations as of right now! https://www.reddit.com/r/TalesFromTheCreeps/s/fk5fdMOtyK
I have such fond memories of reading this one as it was being released. It came out closeish in time to Left Right game and has that "rules" format that was so popular then. I would love to see it, although part of me is scared Incase it ends up sucking https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/4rtg67/playing_the_game_of_seven_doors/
If you ever do multiple pieces of analog horror in one episode, I would recommend Kid with a Camera. It's only about 2 minutes long, but it stuck in my mind as one of the scarier videos on the internet.
The brighter futures suicide hotline is amazing but I think the subject matter isn't really yt friendly
17776: What football will look like in the future, for creepTV as it's a multi-media internet fiction
‘The previous tenant of my flat left a survival guide. I’m not sure I want to live here anymore.’ By newtotownJAM on nosleep. It’s a classic!
Colwin’s Corner
my eyes are black holes by logan ryan smith
HORROR FROM THE VAULT
I don't actually know if it's available online or if yiu could read it considering how litigatious GW is but a good story that takes place in the 40k universe that I dont think you need to know any of the lore to enjoy the story, is called "The rot took my name" You can find a reading of it on YouTube that has like 300 views
I don’t know if you guys will read it because it’s a book and not a creepypasta but someday could you do The Troop by Nick Cutter? It reminds me a lot of “The Ocean Is Much Deeper Than We Thought”.
I would do anything to hear u guys read “I'm a guard stationed at a 'secret' government prison.” It’s my next favorite story after left right game!
This story was just posted to the subreddit like two days ago and I’m obsessed. I just finished it. It’s called “Eat Your Heart Out” and it’s kind of a mystery, body horror about a cult that is trying to bring back a dead God by targeting women with insecurities? There’s more to it than that but Im trying not to spoil it. It’s so gross and freaky. Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/creepcast/s/Ro5Vw3aYHr
I highly recommend Between Two Fires by Christopher Buehlman. Religious horror set during the Black Plague feels perfect for Isaiah and Hunter to dive right into https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/between-two-fires-christopher-buehlman/1108799136
https://www.creepypasta.com/evaporation/ Highly recommend, it's very short and punchy so probably best for a grab bag
I'm late to the conversation but I was thinking about the movie Antlers and that it was based on a short by Nick Antocsa good for a grab bag. https://www.guernicamag.com/the-quiet-boy/
Finish the rest of Accounts from a lonely broadcast station!
"Flesh rains from the sky on Olympia springs" a great body horror story and quite gory (if you couldn't tell from the title)
I'd LOVE for you guys to read 'Salem's Lot by Stephen King. Because it'd be a longer one, I understand if you guys wanted to break it up into parts or something. Very good book, I really enjoyed reading it
Voluntary Committal by Joe Hill
There was this one creepypasta I listened to when I was younger about the Ronald McDonald house and I really liked it but I don't know if it was actually good
You should read the Skinwalker in a creepy grab bag it would be perfect! It is by max Minton
The Neverglade Mysteries are a fun read. Finding Vanessa is one I would recommend. It crosses into the Tales From the Gas Station. Runners by Unsettling Stories is a very weird collection of stories. Also of they were daring, they could revisit Jeff The Killer, but read the series written by BanningK instead.
Bedtime by Michael whitehouse is also a classic, and he has multiple other really good stories
The pill mills by Scott Wilson Very immersive and creepy in my opinion Plus it was awarded best no sleep series in 2016
Bonesaw Vic's Cryptozoological Gardens by T.W. Grim
My Tiny Town Got Put On Lockdown 💜
my property isn't normal!!!!
Sonic exe 2 would be hilarious because it's terrible
A short stay in Hell by Steven Peck
Oh please do the abandoned by Disney series 🙏
https://www.creepypasta.com/i-drive-for-cerber/
Would love to see another GrabBag Episode, “A Game Of Flashlight Tag” would be perfect short and sweet
As long as you stop reading the guy who wrote Tommy Taffy, and Feed the Pig stories then we’re good!!
I liked feed the pig but I agree Tommy taffy was not enjoyable at all.
By golly jeepers if they read the limetown script and Isaiah read Leah’s lines and hunter read the others they would love it and it would be so interesting
SCP 7819 is basically a survival guide with a few quotes from past survivors about an interdimensional motel that tries to blend into our reality but is full of traps and entities trying to kill you essentially. I love the eerie atmosphere so much especially as someone who grew up staying at a lot of shitty motels as a child. These places are essentially liminal spaces that never feel like home, or even safe or comfortable to sleep at, and they know that you only stay there when you're desperate so they don't try at all to make you feel better for staying there. SCP 7034 is a bit longer, and is made up of journal entries from someone who finds themselves trapped in an endless pocket dimension (along with maybe thousands of other people) consisting of an infinite traffic jam. While 7819 is a little lighthearted (while still being creepy) this one has a sadder, desperate tone. Won't spoil the ending but my god the protagonist keeps thinking he's getting somewhere in escaping only to have his hopes crushed again and again. The way he describes his physical pain, starvation, dehydration, and the idea he might not see his loved ones again is so visceral as his sanity descends throughout the story. I've always loved the SCP universe, and am a little sad that they haven't covered more, but I get it if Hunter just doesn't like the format and the whole [REDACTED] thing, which these above stories have very little to none of. They're just short, spooky, and well written. I've listened to readings of them a couple times but it would be awesome to see Hunter and Isaiah cover these. And best of all? No child abuse!
The stories that u/creepymonkeiboy has uploaded on Reddit
Heyyy just joined, the whistlers is a really good nosleep story. It follows a crew of researchers stranded on an island after their plane crashes, highly recommend
The rest of tales from the gas station
HOUSE OF LEAVES FOR THE LOVE OF SATAN
Guys please do Dear David!!!!
"My property isn't normal" by Murderbird17 is like tales from the gas station but with lots of skinwalkers 🙈
I will continue to beg for “turn it off” by pollum chill!!!
Maggie's Grave by David Sodergren, relatively short read, it's about a girl in a mountain town, and a vengeful witches curse. It's very good!
A bit of a longer one but “the haar” is really great. Horror tied alongside a beautiful and satisfying story.
Read Dogscape, really weird and grotesque story, but a great gut wrenching read. Especially considering it was written on 4chan as a collaborative effort by members on the site.
Uncle Gerry's Family Fun Zone is a pretty fun read.
"The man in my basement takes one step closer every week" By Polterkites is good, long, and cheesy. My personal favorite take on The Rules, with good body horror and a pretty fun plot.
It would be cool to see a folklore episode where y'all read urban legends, sort of like the rituals episode.
If you guys ever do another creep cast classics Godzilla NES would be wicked
We need more tales of the gas station that series and episode slapped
Tik tok ARG about the Panama meteorite
Please read "They Paid me $5000 to go through Hell" by Jacksim on NoSleep. Very good story!
The first full, multi-part creepypasta I ever read was "The Story of Her Holding An Orange". No idea if it was actually any good, but I saw that it was turned into a novel, so I'd love to revisit it. Especially on this show.
There is a creepypasta on reddit from 6 years ago that I think is pretty cool here's the link https://www.reddit.com/r/creepypasta/comments/cnm8m8/the_penis_monkey
I don’t know if you guys are still reading this comment section, but honestly, I think it would be cool if you read some of Stephen King’s published short stories
Hiiii not a story but since yall are playing games on the Patreon I thought it would be a good idea to play the video game adaptation of I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream.
Please please please track down "Petey" by T.E.D. Klein. THE best slow burn short story I have ever read
Definitely maybe later on (as we need some banger stories over gag ones rn) but I’d love to see more my little pony creepypastas!! Rainbow Factory and My Little Insomnia would complete a holy trinity imo….
PLS can we have more point line 👀
*point pine
Happy Appy will change your life trust
I NEED the rest of “the thing in the basement is getting better at mimicking people”
I definetly wanna say kaleidoscope by ray Bradbury , it's super short but fucking harrowing https://www.scaryforkids.com/kaleidoscope-by-ray-bradbury/
Yes!!!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_White_Ship_(story) It's aa real Hunter kinda story
As a little grab bag "The rules to summon the butter street hitchhiker" and "The strange rules for the night bus". Fun and interesting urban legend esque stories
"My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day" Yes it has one of 'those' titles but its actually really good. Reminiscent of penpal in quality and tone. The Dark Somnium does a great reading of it
there's a series of short stories by an author named max lobdell, currently on his website https://unsettlingstories.com/ and formerly under the username IIA on nosleep. he's incredible in the disgusting, gooey, full body tremors kind of way. sure to be a hunter favorite.
Little Black Bugs by Vincent V Cava
tbh i think anything by Vincent would be amazing i mean that one about the spring is peak
My property isn’t normal. It’s got the perfect amount of stupid + scary
The butherface tapes saga! It’s a nosleep by u/dash32. It’s three parts, real interesting. It’s an old story too so it does cut to the chase pretty quick
Personally I can think of a couple The Cellphone Game - A classic I remember being super good as a kid that might've aged poorly, no clue My Family Has Been Stalked For The Last 4 Years - I remember this one being very unnerving The Midnight Game (different to the ritual creepypasta) - This one I remember being very cosmic Horror Esque and being one that truly scared the shit out of me
more tales of the gas station!!!! It’s my favorite and there are a bunch more parts
Please at least look at The Black Farm, it’s a continuation of Feed The Pig, it is a book so it would be longer and it’s pretty extreme but at least check it out
Please I beg you, finish Tommy Taffy. Part 3 is pretty solid but imo Part 4 is fantastic, the best part and Tommy is at his scariest there. He's less a pervert and more a full on horror monster. It's great.
"My friend has been liing in an alternate reality fo the last seven years" by Mr Outlaw. Its as if IDMBFTRL had legitimate stakes, Tom Savini on bad trip levels of gore, Crononberg on a good trip level body horror. Its got plot twsists, madness and is the definition of "Balls To The Wall"
Someone has taken my face by WeirdBryceGuy is an excellent story
I beg you to read "Tales from the extension cord house" by A_Hawaiian_Shirt almost everything thing they write is awesome
I think it is called "The Masterson Chronicles." Mr.CreepyPasta did a read of it. Pretty much a wild west preacher turns monster hunter for God. It also has a corresponding story called "Hellbound" if I remember correctly.
UNOFFICIAL CREEP CAST PATREON CLUB DISCORD LINK HERE https://discord.gg/PFWApGZYvK
One story i thought would be funny to relisten to was "Ronald McDonald House" and yes its that Ronald McDonald
Bit of an oldie but I would absolutely love to see you two read the NES Godzilla Creepypasta!
HELL YEAH
“They paid me 5000 dollars to go through hell” is a story I think u guys would have fun with
We need some campfire stories something that gives Friday the 13th vibes. Campy goodness
It’s not a new story for them but id love it if they read stairs in the woods from start to finish so im throwing it out there
Tales from the Dogscape
Requesting Rap Rat once again
id recommend reading Scp-106, then follow it up with the tale "Treats". Get Hunter some of that old man action
clockwork your time is up
This isn't a traditional story but I'd love to see Wendigoon go over mystery flesh pit with Hunter
Infected town case Files or My Friend has been living in an alternate reality
I'd love to see you guys read SCP-2664 aka Redline, I think it's a fitting vibe for both of you to enjoy something out of
Would also love more scp stories
I know I’m a bit late to this but I’d love to hear the boys read “bonesaw vic zoo of cryptozoology “ It’s quite a large one and I’ve been itching for another long ass episode
I too remember this one. Maybe it would be good.
"I'm being forced to play the 24 hour game". Left/right game vibes but different
I would really like you to read Anasi’s goatman honestly my favourite creepy pasta it’s a lot less professionally written more like listening to your friend tell a story
I'm currently reading "The cold people and other fairy tales from nowhere" it's by the same author that wrote stolen tongues, I'm only a chapter in but I can already tell it's going to be heat I think it would be a good main channel vid too! Love yall
Since Hunter mentioned he wants a dinosaur horror, I liked "Weird Birds" . I think it had some good horror aspects and some good humor too, y'all might like it! There is a part 1 and 2 https://dinodadreviews.com/2023/10/08/weird-birds/
I recommended a story on the subreddit that got taken down for including a link to a different website (Wizards of the Coast), but I think I can recommend it here. “His Eyes, All of Them”. It’s a short horror story based in the Magic the Gathering setting Innistrad.
I made a full-length story on the subreddit titled Scream of the Wendigo. It'd be pretty nice if you guys read it (fans too).
Nothing new or revolutionary I know, but "I Have No Mouth But I Must Scream" would be great for the boys to chew on.
I submitted an original story to the subreddit called “I Shouldn’t Have Tricked My Dad Into Shooting the Family Dog” if y’all are planning to read fan stories again soon :)
"How to survive in Hell" by ratrotted A genuinely interesting story that I believe would make for an amazing episode https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/63ubzl/how_to_survive_in_hell/
I'm seconding Abandoned by Disney
the twitter arg birds
Any story by u/polterkites would work. We used to live here is just incredible. But I suggest starting with “the man in the basement takes one step closer every day”
Please read “The Horror from the Vault”, many POVs and an awesome body horror situation. Please OH PLEASEEE!!!
You should read part 2 of the voodoo store
Uh idk haha
Shameless self plug here. I submitted a story on both creepcast and creepcast submissions subreddits called blood on white. You should read that
TURN IT OFF!! Not a crash out story im so tired of them.
The Goat Room from elia witherow!
You guys have to read I Bought my Wife a Life Extension Plan by tjaylea on r/nosleep
You guys should read Asylum by Matt Dymerski! It's the follow up to Psychosis. It explores the issue the guy was having along with other victims to this weird situation. The original guy is in the asylum and it's like short stories of the other patients explaining why they're in there. It's not too long but I love the story and there's tons of characters for Hunter.
The Burned Photo - 17 part story, a long but good one. Captivating mystery https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/esp8xh/the_burned_photo_final/ It Takes - parts of dialogue is something to be desired, but good story otherwise. Creepy and sad/bittersweet. https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/It_Takes My Dad Finally Told Me What Happened That Day - honestly just bizarre (in a good way). https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/5dr9fh/my_dad_finally_told_me_what_happened_that_day/ I Think My Grandfather Might Be A Serial Killer - lol https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/8epbdy/i_think_my_grandfather_might_be_a_serial_killer/ Humper Monkey's Ghost Story - trust me on this one lol. military based story https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Humper-Monkey%27s_Ghost_Story
Burned photo is the one for this week, boys. Lock in.
r/nosleep u/Yobro1001 ‘I’m a Truck Driver on a Highway that Doesn’t Exist. There are Rules for Surviving the Road.’
The Girl the Universe Forgot still sticks with me years later. Not the scariest story, but certainly one of the more engaging and emotional. I would compare it to something like Maria On The Moon
The Holders series, hands down one of the coolest concepts. The website has been taken down but you can still find the object descriptions online.
Any object from 'The Holders' series. Started by User 'TheHolders' on a 4chan message board but like the SCP series has a potluck of people who've added to it. A lot of them can be found on The Holders creepypasta wikia http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Holders
r/nosleep u/PizzND 'Confessions of a deep sea diver'
r/nosleep u/DrunkenSwordsman 'I'm a cinema usher. We have some strange rules'
r/LetsNotMeet u/sweetmercy 'Dr. Ramsey'
r/nosleep u/glaotastala 'We get some weird calls in ambulance control.'
the harbinger experiment
Bros read these, trust: My Father Owned an Amusement Park- https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/5fGBto1160 Mayhem Mountain- https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/IJbYFW0E49 I made a Horror Game about Liminal Spaces- https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/HEIm6LRFIA I found a crypto that pays for pain- https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/POBdFodyVu
https://youtu.be/wnoGzlMz8cA?si=zZUtkI4wJyUxmVN4 1 hour 36 minute covers Appalachian folk horror that might be a solid source for a Wendigoon video
This story gets me every time I read it https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/an0s3x/time_travel_is_not_what_you_think_its_like/
I love "Spacegirl" on NoSleep, it's a very cute horror and the ending is fucking metal
“On a hill” written by Micheal Whitehouse a classic
Please do I sold my soul for a dishwasher. There is a ghost that died from an overdose on Viagra and is always hard. Hunter will love it!!
The Very Hungry Caterpillar
“My dad finally told me what happened that day” is a really good one similar to and by the same author as hidden webpage. If you like that genre like I do, I’d also recommend “Has anyone else noticed the moon is on fire?” For a grab bag, I’d recommend “a shattered life”.
The brittle man!
Finish The Thing in the Basement is Mimicking People!!!
bold.
Finishing old stories please
Bad Man by Dathan Auerbach. Its the same guy who wrote Penpals and the story looks really intruiging.
Harbinger is amazing
Best r/nosleep stories that I first read Confessions of a Deep Sea Diver" by PizzND | https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/3lll1h/confessions_of_a_deep_sea_diver/
The Arkansas Sleep Experiment was one that was really cool
The
yall should read happy appy, its so fucking bad i love it
I havent seen this in the comments yet, but can yall consider reading “the girl in the picture”? More tales from the gas station would be cool too!!!
My friend has been living in an alternate reality!
This is kind of different but yall should explore Ethel Cain’s Preacher’s daughter lore. Or at least Isaiah needs to
The continuation of the voodoo king (can’t remember the name off hand) would go pretty hard
Rap Rat Jvk1166z.esp, MARIO,
More Elias Witherow.
Call of Cthulhu by HP lovecraft
Whitefall by C.K. Walker!
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3MfWOh2L6IM&pp=ygUiQ3JlZXB5cGFzdGEgZmFtaWx5IGhpc3RvcnkgcHJvamVjdA%3D%3D
Ooh, “The Family Experiment” is a good one!
Rainbow Factory. Do it, cowards. Cupcakes is NOT enough. 🤣
creepy internet stories come from somewhere by matt dymerski, the writer of psychosis!
That one’s really good
Something Sweet to Bite, it's a pretty decently written MLP grimdark 'creepypasta' Much better than cupcakes
Billy Smiley's Cul-de-sac
“100 Match” 100% Match" by Patrick C. Harrison III is a dark, humorous, and twisted story about a man named Bart, who is looking for his perfect match. Bart is a fry cook who is described as bald, overweight, and dislikes cats and children. The story delves into his depraved and often violent search for love, with a healthy dose of black humor
I feel like this is way too graphic for them to read but I love it lmao
Please read My property isn't normal its great
I second this it's so fun
Please read Rap Rat
“The Song and Dance Man” Creepypasta. Its a good length story and have positive reviews! I heard it a long time ago. But still think about it!
Could we finish the saga of If you are armed at the Glenmont Metro, please shoot me.
“I’m a 911 Operator” “Autopilot” 👍🏼 for the grab bag
Bonesaw Vic's Cryptozoological Gardens
Welcome to Funland and Return to Funland!!!
Dr. Black!!!! It's a cool little short story!!
NES godzilla series its awful
Imagine they read blowfly girl 😭🤣
Just kidding but it would be really cool to put Hunter through greylock!! For stories anything by Darkly_Gathers on Reddit!
One of Isaiah's stories from high school haha
The girl in 402 is great and such a thrilling one
The girl in 402
You should watch server blight, its another game creepypasta but its super cool
Rocking horse creek
Clive Barker Books of Blood, ik its a long shot but it'd be cool
The dread series by TheJesseClark on reddit
Invasion of the road weenies!
If you liked the world building elements of the painting story, "My friend has been living in an alternate reality" is a banger
The Troop by Nick Cutter would be a great option
For fucks sake READ THE NEXT PART OF TOMMY TAFFY
I loved the nursing home at the edge of the world! Would really like a continuation on that. I’d also love to hear y’all’s take on the western crossroads stories
What ever happend to the idea of inviting guests onto the podcast?
The unofficial sequal too Ted The Caver. There was aman who stole the original story and wrote it in his own words and retooled it a bit to make it fit with his sequal. Then acted like Ted stole the story and it became so bad Ted had to prove it was his story.
I’d like to see Marble Hornets continued. Good goofs and good horror
Your secret admirer
Tales from Uncle Henry's Farm
Ooh, I love that one!
I hope you guys can get around to reading https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/The_Girl_in_402 or The Girl in 402 if you guys would rather look it up. I just read it and thought it was incredible
Ad nauseam trilogy, same guy who did fleshgait and it breathes
Infected town case files
Neverglade Mysteries
Would love to see you finish marble hornets :)
"Happy Appy." It would be incredible to hear you two recount that epic tale :)
beacon house! https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/uMN4umLual
Abandoned by Disney would be a good story
This is a great idea.
if you guys EVER do another creepy grab bag PLEASEEE please do doors!!! https://www.creepypasta.com/doors it was one of my favorites growing up and it's short and sweet.
Dogscape
Yes that story is insane
Abandoned by Disney, or It Comes at Bedtime
"The Quiet Sky" by Ryan Brennaman
https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/ejuqwb/i_watch_people_in_cages_part_1/
my property isn’t normal seems right up the creepcast alley
I've recently started writing horror, and I think that it’d be awesome if you guys checked out some of the short stories I have so far on my Substack! I probably wouldn't have entered into the foray if it wasn't for this pod. https://projectanemoia.substack.com
From no sleep, ‘my wife and I bought a ranch in the mountains last year’ And ‘ Ithink I’m dating a goose’ (this is a short one though)
"I think I'm dating a goose" has to be the wildest title.
“I’m a cinema usher we have some strange rules” it’s on Reddit and I was honestly scared reading it along in my room at night.
The evil beneath by fishman tales https://www.reddit.com/r/FishermanTales/s/i3ryu9QQbT
I just want them two to come up with a creep cast story staring the creep cast boys where they are put in horrific situations where lols insue hell I'll even take a comic or an audiobook even just a creep cast ep
How to Survive Camping by u/fainting--goat. This is the author that I started with on r/nosleep and kept my notifications on for the new post every week. It's now a book! https://www.reddit.com/u/fainting--goat/s/lksAaNc3G6
Dead Mall is quite interesting and unique. My girlfriend likes it a lot
who was phone
'In the Walls' genuinely scared me despite being a horror fanatic. It still gives me shivers when I think about it, and am a bit scared of being near walls.
Midnight Papers
Not sure if this has been asked, but please consider reading "On A Hill". I think it will be something you both enjoy
Read “my dad finally told me what happened that day” it’s not super long and immensely creepy. Has a penpal vibe.
It’s one of my favorites. Same author as hidden webpage
Accounts from a lonely broadcast station My friend has been living in an alternate reality for 7 years. Tales from my uncle Henry's farm.
My friend living in an alternate reality is amazing!
Finish the thing in the basement is getting better at imitating people
I really enjoyed the ritual stories episode you did and would love to see some more
The abstergo man was one I liked when I was little
There’s a short fan made story called the house of the lambs! Just got posted a bit ago and I liked it
day one of asking for the pine point series
RE-READ STAIRS IN THE WOODS -ad nauseum ad mortem ad infinitum and other works by that author -“I live in an abandoned high rise…” -more point pine stories :D
I think they said they'd revisit that one for a 2 year anniversary
Please read this I’m begging you: https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/dj5fgp/i_just_graduated_from_medical_school_and_my_new/ Cool medical horror!
Lord of the rings the two towers has scary orks, you guys shpuld read it!
Both scp-3001 red reality and scp-001 when day breaks ready like creepypasta stories and I think would be really good
really need to hear the rest of the thing in the basement pleaseeeeeee
For the love of unholy read more tales from the gas station, the book literally mentions you in the later parts
So idk if counts as a story or would be like creep TV but I really want to see the guys talk about the poughkeepsie tapes I know wendi talks about them alot
My property isnt normal Accounts from a Lonely Broadcast Station.
Accounts from A lonely broadcast My property isn't normal Tales from Uncle Henry's farm The quarantine- by the same guy that wrote it breathes it bleeds it breeds
"An inbreed family lives up the road" https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/oe8nzx/an_inbred_family_lives_up_the_road/ One of the first nosleep stories that grabbed my attention highly recommended.
Dogscape It's a post-apocalyptic story after earth has been completely engulfed by dog flesh. The flesh is sentient. The story is presented through log entries. https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Dogscape
I remember “my property isn’t normal” being a funny and fairly interesting one
I work as part of an expedition team in Greenland. We think we've found Noah's Ark by Christian Wallis on r/nosleep
Muladona by Eric Steiner Carlson
spooky folk book that takes place in spanish flu texas, with a spooky horse demon woman. there's an equally spooky concept album based on the tales from the book by the same name by a band called Rorcal
Happy Appy, Abandoned by Disney
My friend has been living in an alternate reality is really good from what I remember.
It's so good just did relisten to it
Happy appy
Omg please read happy happy
Your Secret Admirer or Abandoned by Disney. They would have to be in a grab bag or something of the sort, as they are only 20 mins-1hish respectively but they are classics!!
I really want y’all to read I Investigate Disturbing Cases: These Are My Stories - The Tall Woman
Definitely gotta read Happy Appy
I know the tales from the gas station timeline is kinda crazy but I would love to see you guys so bedside manor. Imo it stands on its own
Recommend “skullbelly” by Ronald Malfi
I'm not sure if it is possible based on the writer, but I would like to hear you guys cover the "Abandoned By Disney" trilogy
Parts 3, 4, and 5 of the showers
Please read the book version of “stolen tongues” or “the church beneath the roots”
I’d recommend “The Whistlers” by Amity Argot pls
It Comes at Bedtime. Known as Bedtime on nosleep by u/Mike_Rants
I think you guys should read the My Little Pony creepypastas: Cupcakes and Rainbow Factory.
If you guys want to try a published work again, I think Annihilation by Jeff VanderMeer would be a good episode. The audible version is 6 hours long so I feel like it would be a good longer episode
The previous tenant of my new flat left a survival guide. I’m not sure I want to live here anymore. One of the top stories on nosleep and its got multiple parts too! https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/ci94do/the_previous_tenant_of_my_new_flat_left_a/
There Is No Anti-Memetics Division by qntm is an amazing story. It's a SCP story but it reads like something that'd be right at home among some other creepcast stories like mother horse eyes and is formatted as an actual story not a typical scp entry. https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/antimemetics-division-hub
Been thinking this since the scp 3000 episode: if yall liked the idea of mnetics you’d love this story
(My Tiny Town Just Got Put On Lockdown) would be a fun one
The r/nosleep story, Autopilot
It isn't a no sleep story, but: "I Work In A Prison For Monsters, I Interviewed The Worst One." Would be fun to hear all the voices hunter could do and the story is a nice mini thriller and slight horror. https://www.reddit.com/r/HeadOfSpectre/comments/mrirfj/i_work_in_a_prison_for_monsters_i_interviewed_the/?rdt=53727
My Mom's Dementia is Terrifying. She Keeps Talking About All the Bodies in the Basement
Bedtime by Michael Whitehouse was one that fascinated me when I was young. https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/uBqpWEcRqE
I'd really love to see Abandoned by Disney in one of the next creepy grab bags. I haven't read it in years but it's a classic in my mind
I just re-listened to MrCreepyPasta’s video of him telling the story, and I’m convinced Hunter and Isaiah would have fun with it—especially with some of the voice acting Hunter could do for the characters.
When you guys start to play games still wakes the deep needs to the first one it's so good and the perfect game for y'all
You should read Cursed Bunny by Bora Chung. It’s a book filled with short stories that are not necessarily super scary in the traditional sense, but are definitely uncanny and can make you uncomfortable at times. It is described by the translator as an “adult version of Scary Stories to Tell In the Dark” and I would say the description kinda fits. It was also shortlisted for the 2022 International Booker Prize, if you want credentials. Relatively short and sweet read!
you have to do Whitefall 1) because it’s so good but also 2) Hunter voicing all the characters would be fantastic
Please watch vintage 8’s the children under the house
It's a full book, but playground by aron Beauregard. It's like saw meets operation paperclip, it's a splatter punk book and is one of my favorite horror books ever
The previous tenant series.
I’d love for you to read The Forest Of A Thousand Legs 🕷️🕸️
PLEASE READ MLP CREEPYPASTAS THEY ARE SUCH A LOST ICON. rainbow factory and cupcakes are both works of art
Perhaps an odd choice but The Time Ships by Stephen Baxter, it being a sequel to The Time Machine by HG Wells it obviously references the original at times but it doesn't take away from the overall narrative. Real existential at times and had certainly vivid imagery. Would understand if it's not suitable for the channel considering published books didn't go down too well but I do believe it's worth a read!
One day you will have to read the entire Jeff the killer universe, it is unavoidable
I would love to hear you and hunter read this story by HeadOfSpectre. I think you guys would enjoy it one way or another. Love your work as usual! https://www.reddit.com/r/HeadOfSpectre/comments/mrirfj/i_work_in_a_prison_for_monsters_i_interviewed_the/?rdt=53727
Hi boys! I remember hunter saying he wanted to do more SCP. There is an SCP for hunter specifically- SCP 597 it's a short read and also really stupid. Thank you for doing these I get so much done while listening!
i'm dying for a continuation of Marble Hornets creep tv
please we need more creep tv like i’m begging for it
I NEED THE REDO OF STAIRS IN THE WOODS PLEASE
My friend has been living in an alternate reality or any Mr_Outlaw stories. Really cool sci fi fantasy with horror and comedy mixed throughout
Godzilla NES and I'll bust
A bit late, but I'm throwing in Accounts from a lonely broadcast station as well, this series slaps so far
I would give my left nut to hear you guys read w Campbell's who goes there or frozen hell
The Girl in 402
https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/YOgfVjf6X0 weird shit ive seen as a marine is a banger
Dead mall on creepypasta!!!
Danny's Story by MJ Pack is like a really well written story you guys would like. Scary monster too. Also I'm a bit late but it was my 23 birthday when you posted lol
Listened to Laughing Jack’s origin story a couple months ago and I remember thinking it held up very well, I mean obviously it’s a little stupid but it was my personal favorite as a preteen LMAO https://creepypastafiles.fandom.com/wiki/The_Origin_of_Laughing_Jack
Love you
Honestly you guys need to finish off any stories you haven’t finished, if it’s too long just put it on patreon we will not complain Like feed the pig, there’s 2-3 other stories from that universe that are fuckin wicked, read em all get them views up, they are wild, and you thought crawling in that pigs mouth was bad
Interrogated by a death guard warlord -warhammer 40k
I know I’m late and this is a shot in the dark but…. There’s a warhammer 40k short story from a novel called “interrogated by a death guard warlord” that would go pretty hard in a short story episode There’s a really cool vid on yt narrating the story, I’d love to hear hunters voice acting on it
Ok maybe an alt suggestion but please do a grab bag with “The Supermarket Monster” by Phoebe C in it
The Mold Series on r/NoSleep!
Please let me know if link works!!!! Just a shot in the dark, Ive been working on a collection of short stories for a bit now and have really wanted the guys to take a look, they dont have to read it on the podcast but itd be really cool to have them at least look at it. And any feedback from others would be wonderful too, im genuinely trying to get this collection going and want to see what others think! I appreciate any feedback. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PqqHGY6GoB_UXUYe9Ft9eayja-ZHyMP6JNMY2Xk5EVQ/edit?usp=drivesdk
Cool concept and setup! If I had one constructive criticism to give it would be to be careful about repeating words in quick succession. You have Cool visuals, but when a reader reads the same word one after another enough it can take them out of it, speaking from my own experience having done that. Keep it up!
the epstein files
Nahh we need a meat canyon vid for that… or is that too dark?
I would love to see y’all read the second part of The Showers
Gotta do NES godzilla
I agree with the person who said Angel Engine
Angel engine for creep tv!
The employees at the zoo are not human https://www.reddit.com/r/scarystories/s/RjbkMTJ7H3
There Is No Antimemetics Division https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/antimemetics-division-hub
Waka waka
CK Walker’s Whitehall and C.M Scandreth’s A Seaside British Pub. Both are great - I go back and read them frequently.
How to Survive Camping by Bonnie Quinn
A short story, I personally think. Alabaster Angel. I found it very enjoyable, hope yall do too
“I am stationed at a secret government prison”
I love that story so much I always go back to dark somniums vid of it
Wounds By Nathan Ballingrud. It’s 6 short stories. It’s an anthological piece that takes place in hell, essentially. Super uncanny and unsettling. Idk if you guys could read it on YouTube due to copyright issues but I still think you would enjoy it
I absolutely love North American Lake Monsters
READ SLENDERMAN
Infected Town!
Completely forgot about that series, that’s a good one
Continue the Tales from Gas Station. The chaos just gets crazier and more entertaining. You haven’t even met the Wendigo yet.
Bro yes nobody would be mad continuing that series it wasn’t serious like borrasca anyway
Accounts from a Lonely Broadcast Station.
“I’m A Guard Stationed At A Secret Government Prison” I think the two of you would have some of the best fun and dialogue with this story the writing is up to par and I could imagine hunter coming up with some great additions to the visuals the OP lays out
I agree great story
I know this is probably gonna be buried but I remember a smaller creator back a year or two ago did a reading of this story it was called the books of sands but the author changed it recently apparently to a smoke story. But there is something about the writing in this story that just makes it feel so nostalgic and has like the creepy feeling of the darkness of day to day life from childhood to your early 20s. I’ve been wanting to suggest this to you guys forever and I’m finally getting around to it. Even if it doesn’t get read on the show I suggest giving it a read the community Members here I feel you guys would enjoy it. https://substack.com/@asmokestory?
I’ve seen a few people suggest “Does anyone know a good plumber?” And if they do that, it’s 100% Hunter coded. I would feel like I was missing out if Isaiah read it
Hunter would interject his own thoughts enough anyway you wouldn’t miss anything
There’s a r/NoSleep I remember from years ago that I really liked, I want to say it was called something like The Red Ball Game. From what I recall it’d be up your alley
The Thing In the Basement, but read the rest of it.
It would be genuinely fun to hear you and hunter read this story: https://www.reddit.com/r/HeadOfSpectre/comments/mrirfj/i_work_in_a_prison_for_monsters_i_interviewed_the/?rdt=53727 I think the both of you would make the story light hearted and entertaining. Big fan of both you guys! God bless!
You should read “The Serene Knowledge” it’s not so much of a story as it is a grab-bag of weird ideas. It disappeared from the Internet a while back, but I happen to have a link to the archived page here: https://web.archive.org/web/20120810181936/http://thekingofwolves.webs.com/index.htm#111596429
More Point Pine!!!!
Do a tier list of all the stories you’ve done Patreon exclusive
abandonded by disney
Finish the thing in the basement!
I'd like to see Wanderer of the Dogscape
The Magnus Archives. It's a podcast story but the transcripts are completely available and able to be read in story format. Would be amazing.
Book-talk smut, maybe a classic like pucking around
Get out bro we don’t need those kinds of ppl here 😂😭
I think it would be cool to read viewer stories on the patreon but it would also be a bummer if the author isn't a patron and therefore isn't able to watch their story’s episode
Im a big fan from Winnipeg ! Please come see us here !!
I'm a guard stationed at a secret government prison Really good character styles
This comment might get buried since I'm late but I rediscovered an old one I had so much trouble finding, but a good one I remember was "I just bought my childhood house"
Hidden Picture by Jason Rekulak is a great thriller novel
"My Name is Lily Madwhip" by William Dalphin. It is the first part in a series, but it would be amazing if y'all covered it. It is also published on Amazon so it would give the author new fans too.
I love the story called "the girl the universe forgot" its not all that scary but its such a good story imo I'd be interested to see the boys take a look
I think I heard dark somnium read that, pretty damn good
This morning the doors to our apartment complex were welded shut. I'm starting to think that it was a good idea.
I haven’t seen anyone mention them, but any of the stories by TJay Lea in the sturgeon universe would be so good read by you. They’ve got a ton of stories in the world that are really weird and well written
The Salt Grows Heavy by Cassandra Khaw
read the fanfics written about you guys on ao3. specifically the explicit ones.
Mystery flesh pit national park
Didn’t wendigoon already cover that one on his channel?
The Patient (not the tool song)
Abandoned by Disney
Ooooh! That's a good one. That one scared me as a kid so bad.
The lost city of korona
My property isn’t normal by Murderbird17 please fun story and a likable protagonist
The Metro 2033 books would be crazy
I think Wendigoon would have such a fun time if y'all did A Short Stay in Hell by Steven L. Peck!
Please please please do a few parts from tales from a lonely broadcast station…it’s one of my favorites that I go back to often
Shattered life
FAIRY KING
I would love to see them read The Mist by Stephen King
“The previous tenant of my new flat left a survival guide. I’m not sure I want to live here anymore” Series posted on r/nosleep. I haven’t read it all the way through but really liked the first few posts and would love to hear it read here!
Part two of Tales from the Gas Station or I Worked at a Half-Priced Voodoo Shop
Blossom by Owen Morgan Nice short body horror tale
House of Leaves since Isaiah won’t stop talking about it I think a full book especially that one would be great
This comment reminds me of a part from House of Leaves!
Yo how about that one, many hands by Clokw8rk
I found the bunker of a prepper family who went missing three years ago. And one of my favourite things, Weird Birds.
this
The abandoned by Disney series is one of the older creepypastas I have been waiting for you guys to cover for a while now
Wait there's more than the one story?
finish the nursing home one!
Please.
There’s a writer named Mike Lombardo who is an indie filmmaker and he has a book of short stories called “Please Don’t Tap on the Glass” with lots of great stories that I think would be worth checking out! He’s currently working a feature length film based off his story “Dead Format”. Met him at a horror con, super nice guy
I Dared My Best Friend To End My Life 🤣
y'all should read the bible. terrifying stuff.
You absolutely got to check out SCP-7004. It falls more tale than strictly SCP, but it is a fantastic ride. Left Right Games vibes, got the road-trip-esk with characters you can sink your teeth into. It's good world-building and would make an excellent video.
Happy Appy.
Violent Faculties by Charlene Elsby!
When will the cut Jeff Goldbloom content be uploaded to the patreon?
My brother died when I was a kid, people should know what he said after or something to that affect. It’s a no sleep story. Only thing that’s truly scared me in the past 3 years.
NES Godzilla would be cool, it could be more like a creep tv episode with the animations on show
Wake Up and Open Your Eyes by Clay McLeod Chapman
Haven't seen 'The HAAR' recommended yet. It's a short novel by David Sodergren. Coastal Scottish town / body horror
"I haven't slept since 2023" from r/nosleep. One of my all-time favorites -- like the lovechild of "Ensorcelled in the Earth" and "If you're armed and at the Glenmont Metro, please shoot me"
More glenmont station esq. Stories sounds fire af
Schmerz Macht Dich Frei It’s a monster story of sorts with some nazi tendencies and modern adjustments. (Also it’s the OC that I’m the most satisfied with so far) https://www.reddit.com/r/creepcast/s/Dn0XJvZMZD
The tulpa. I dont remember much about it. I do remember thinking about it a long while after reading it tho
recommended it before and KNOW it's a book, therefore a longer read, but i'd love for you guys to read devolution by max brooks. i think it'd be a fun experience for both of you!!! :)
Awesome book I don’t think gets enough attention
Humper-Monkey's Ghost Story
Read Hunter’s search history.
i haven't read it in a long time so it might be ass, but i remember enjoying Wolf Lake National Park a few years back.
We need “My dad finally told me what happened that day”, genuinely one of the most terrifying slow burn horror stories ever.
That's such a good story
Ok i don't know what the legality is about reading actual Book books but: The Haunting of Hill House and/or We Have Always Lived In The Castle. Shirley Jackson is such an incredible writer, I read both in quick succession and loved them
Weird Birds! The puppets are amazing.
Seen this recommended a ton on the subreddit
For one of the grab bag episodes “Meek”would be amazing
i like this silly one called i hired a hitman to kill me, or i hired a hitman to hunt me down. the title describes the story, its stupid but hopefully fun stupid
Tommy taffy part 3 and 4
WE PUT A SOUL IN A COMPUTER PLSS Written bij u/athousandrows https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/a0c0yYLkAW
THE TOMORROWS PLEASE!!!!!!
Redo Stairs in the Woods
+1 here
i need mystery flesh pit national park !! i know isaiah has a main channel video on it but i think hunter would like it
Sunfall by S.H. cooper, i don't know this story had me in a chokehold for like 6 months
I had a friend who lived in the air vents r/nosleep mjpack https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/5f8wjj/i_had_a_friend_who_lived_in_the_air_vents/
The Black Farm, Elias Witherow
While I agree, that's probably too spicy for youtube.
I'd love for you guys to read "I was a part of Queen's Guard in England" on /r/nosleep. It's one of the first creepypastas I read and I remember being terrified, would love to see if it holds up :) It's on the shorter side I think
Christian Wallis stories
“My dad finally told me what happened that day.” written by the guy who wrote the hidden webpage.
Seconding this, they would love it. Closer to Penpal than The Hidden Webpage vibe-wise too.
I’d LOVE to see a Creep TV on the Weird Birds twitter ARG, and I’d love to hear your reading of There Is No Antimemetics division.
My name is lily madwhip
more tales from the gas station! i really really loved that episode! or maybe if the author of penpal has more stories those could be cool!
They were listening to us
My friend has been living in an alternate reality plsss
Great story
Their
did i imagine you guys posting “the church in the woods” or was it deleted
It was on Spotify then got taken down, then I think went back up but its on the YouTube rn
Waiting not so patiently to creep my cast today :( is there no upload?
it was on spotify but it got taken down
More tales from the gas station!
All Tomorrows
I really could of used a Creep cast today, really bummed about it
Is it confirmed there won’t be an ep today?:(
My dad finally told me what happened that day
Yes yes yes
Whitefall
Genuinely a great one, a creepcast submissions classic too.
do like at least 30 min of the 2 sentence horror stories!
you guys should upload all the episodes here ad free I am tryna listen to MHE RN, and I am abt to paint my walls red from all these better help ads ironically enough. Also, if you guys are thinking about reading more published works do i have no mouth and i must scream. Isaiah covered it on his channel a while ago and it was sick but i would love to hear their back and forth on a story that has some of the best examples of singularity in sci-fi horror as well as one of the most beautifully written antagonists EVER. Shit just holds up especially with a lot of the themes that are still resonant td.
The ocean is much deeper than we thought Short ones that are pretty good for a grab bag but maybe nsfw would be tampon recall, and body pillow
Omg yes bodypillow!!
PLEASE do vita carnis for creep tv there’s some new episodes that add absolutely insane lore to the story
Fifty Shades of Grey
I would love to see more of the "I work at a half priced voodoo shop" story for a normal creepcast episode. Vita Carnis or Obelisk would be good for creep TV. Mystery Flesh Pit would also be cool for a patreon episode
How to Survive Hell by ratrotted
Would be cool if you guys could check out the magnus archives, maybe on creep TV or something.
Weird birds arg
The rest of the thing in the basement
Just a whole meat canyon torture episode 😭
You have to finish the Tommy Taffy stories
The Day I Hired A Hitman !!
Tales from uncle Henry's farm is one of the best stories ever. Please read it. 🙏
Great story
ELIAS WITHEROW ANYTHING
pleeassseeeeeee
“The Art of Jacob Emory” and “The Strangest Security Tape I’ve Ever Seen” I remember being pretty good, but on the shorter side. I’d love another Classic Creepypasta Roundup episode because we were centimeters from Rap Rat 🤣
These are great suggestions.
MLP Creepypastas 😂
Honestly would be so funny. Love the great stories but every once in a while I like some good old brain dot
Happy Appy, case file by fear_of, NES godzilla, the puppet masters regime, the cell phone game, a favor for a favor
Do more from the point pine series
Crime and Punishment
Keep going with the same author from last week and read ad nauseam ad mortem ad infinitum
Y'all should do some more creep tv reactions.
A very short story but I always found it interesting. “A parallel life/ awoken by a lamp”
I've been asking for a year now for The Pastel Man to get a chance in the spotlight. It was one of my favorites in my teens and it still holds up pretty well as an adult.
What if you guys had an episode where you have viewers come on and share personal scary stories that have happened to them
Pucking around
FINISH TOMMY TAFFY!
I want to request and beg NO MORE Tales From The Gas Station it's cringe and boring, anyone who disagrees stay mad you don't pay my sub fight me irl
Is there anymore from the story or the creator of the voodoo store one?
Yes. They mentioned he has like a whole series that comes after, they should read more for sure.
My friend has been living in an alternate reality!
That one is sooo fucking cool
Whenever you do a creepy grab bag, you should start with "Next Time You'll Know Better" by Reddit user IPostAt Midnight. That user posted several good short stories some years ago, and suddenly stopped. This one, in my opinion, has the best plot twist amongst their stories.
Read a fanfic of you. Terrifying i must say
hypnagogic archives!!!
We’re not supposed to watch the local broadcast channel from nosleep
The Chernobyl disaster was a cover up for something terrifying
Prequel to stolen tounges!
The church beneath the roots
Thing in the basement part 2 PLEASE
more tales from the gastation
Vox and King Beau, Its been years since I heard it, but I feel it's a classic Story.
A Scarecrow For God - It’s a short one I remember fondly from being a middle schooler so take that with a grain of salt. It might be more appropriate for a grab bag tho since it’s only like a 20 minute read.
The Harbinger Experiment!
I WANT GAMEPLAY!!!!
Dogscape !!! Haven’t read it since I was a preteen, only foggy memories of it— but I remember liking it enough that I’d go back and reread it every time I felt like there was nothing better out there. I’d love to kind of get my Isaiah on with remembering things as y’all go through it & I read/listen along!
DOGSCAPE is peak, speak your shit
Creep gaming 👀 fears to fathom?
less of a story more of something you might be able to cover, the Magnus archives
"I've been squatting in a condemned high rise"
"Dog World." I'm sorry.
Also known as "Dogscape"
If you guys go back to creep TV i would love for you guys to react to Arcadia. Super underrated analog horror series by chilling abyss on youtube.
Play the game peak, cowards
A shattered life, the thing on the porch and the fall are good ones. Atleast from what I can remember.
The Kimberly Story (alternatively known as They Live In The Walls)
The Origin of Laughing Jack Or a CreepyTV episode on Polished Mercury (Wakin Bonk)
The Jaunt!
Read Black Bugs by Vincent V Cava and a Favor for a favor by the same writer
honestly anything by vincent v cava
maybe a creeptv episode on local 58 in the future? its a classic
Weird birds twitter ARG. Probably the best of the twitter ARGs imo.
channel zero
My grandma worked at nasa for 40 years!
part two of Thing in the Basement! I beg you!
Raised by a serial killer (series of Books but all only about 100 pages I read all 10 books in less then 3 days!
Or, I Have No Mouth & I Must Scream
Since Hunter always says lovecraftian, you should do a lovecraft episode! The White Ship is a really good one, Call of Cthulhu is a classic, honestly you could do it like a creepy grab bag!
Either Marble Hornets p.3 OR finally making Hunter watch the Mandela Catalogue MAYBE with a guest cameo of Alex for some behind the scenes stuff or just to enjoy Hunter's reactions
I would love for you all to re-do Stairs in the Woods!!
Horse eyes chronological
Please upload the other creepcast episodes on here
For a creep Tv please watch Channel Zero it is so bad other than maybe season 1
“I saw some strange stuff in a tunnel in Vietnam” by catface0 It’s a short story but super fun
lotta heavy tales recommended here. lemme lighten it up... i recommend "The Girl Next Door" by Jack Ketchum :D
Whitefall Why It Pays To Be Nice To The Children Oddkids Is Ed Real, or Am I Crazy? Or finally, Does anyone know a good plumber? I fucked up one of those stupid ritual things that everyone is doing and now my shower is leaking and also there’s some faceless guy in my kitchen.
Splitting this up for safety’s sake Whitefall
My favorite story is tales from uncle Henry's farm please read it
Darkness Ad Infinitum: Villipede Horror Anthology 1 https://books.google.com/books/about/Darkness_Ad_Infinitum.html?id=rmmvoAEACAAJ&source=kp_book_description
MARBLE HORNETS PART 3
ALSO ALL TOMORROWS MY FAVORITE BOOK OF ALL TIME I KNOW YALL WOULD LOVEEEEEEE IT
shimmer https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/NmyvQl5RcU
my wife and i bought a ranch https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/s/UnXIB0woVo
i’ve been waiting for this one (i’ll seperate them in the replies w links) Grandpa Mapped Out His Entire Basement Correspondence (you’d have to get someone to make a list of all the stories in order with relevant comments, it’s very mother horse eyes in that way) (also there’s a ton of parts to it but iirc they’re all pretty short) Infected Town My Wife and I bought a ranch Alternate Reality Shimmer by Elias Witherow (one of my favorites by him but somehow one of his least popular works) Deep Web by Mr Outlaw Harvard Wormhole by nslewis
infected town https://www.reddit.com/r/NosleepIndex/s/IIe9UIhgvO
Please do "I bought a strange guitar; I think the world is ending" and "The thing in my Yard has been telling me the most horrifying stories" . Love the show thank you for the content❤️❤️❤️❤️
There’s one that’s just been finished on the subreddit called “Under the Stars where the Ocean Glows” by u/the_pentagon_fool. I love it so much and think it would be a very good fit for the channel. Very mystery heavy with realistic and fantastical horrors, and the writing is top notch!
You guys should read 'We Used To Live Here' by Marcus Kliewer. It's a published novel and I bought it from b&n and didn't realize that it was adapted from a /nosleep story until I read the dedication page. It's a shorter read and a very interesting psychological thriller. I enjoyed it and would love to hear your guys' opinions on it!
Godzilla NES
Read "Dig In Wendigoons Butt Twin Two Sentance Horror"
Advice from a veteran monster hunter. Mr.creeps covered it a while back it's 45 min
The Butter Street Hitchhiker Is pretty cool
I feel like if they do another grab bag they should read smile dog
Vita Carnis for Creep TV I LOVED the Greylock Episode it’s my favourite one
A grab-bag of some stories by Chuck Wallis, the guy who wrote "my wife has taken our roleplay too far" could be cool and if you do it definitely read "A carnivorous chapel".
"My patient spent 8 million years trapped at the glenmont metro" was really fun not gonna lie. If you guys liked the glenmont metro story i highly recommend this one.
"Accounts from a Lonely Broadcast Station" by Kel Byron
Snow on Mt Silver!!!
This isn't a story recommendation and I don't know if this is the best place to put it but I have an awesome idea for a new CREEP CAST T-shirt.
Infected Town by r/vaniercupid. Great mystery leading up to the real meat of the story. Pretty long, but I’m sure no one would complain. Gets a little cheesy at the end but not enough to ruin it. Mostly in text message and Reddit comment format from what I remember.
that's the "correspondence" one right?
Cupcakes, or any old my little pony creepypastas
i just finished mother horse eyes as i listen to it at work and guys i have to say, if yall liked that, i think you’d love the youtube series Oakburn Opus for creep tv. it is by far one of my favorite horror series on youtube, above greylock even. the cinematography of it along with the satanic themes reminded me a lot of mother horse eyes herself. please please please give it a shot i beg id absolutely die🙏🏼🫶🏼
Mandela catalogue for creep tv please °3°
God damn does anyone remember the title of the creepypasta where the narrator was part of a new coding software and it ended up being sentient and taking over but he realized it when it was too late and it was already sent out into society, controlling everything? That one.
The Icelandic Starerer
Have Zach on to a creature of some sort
yall can’t read this bc copyright but comfort me with apples is a novella in isaiah’s wheelhouse
CreepTV man in the suit and shelter 54, both very satisfying godzilla analog horror. The creator of man in the suit got a lot of shit for it and ended up cancelling the series but it was soooo good, he deserved better responses
“ I’m playing a game called SMILE, but no body taught me the rules” Great story, medium length, with the weirdest names possible for the most serious characters
My neighbor handcrafts organic wind chimes
Do the Oldest View as Creep TV!
