It Came From A Fan... [AD-FREE]
Keep posting your stories!
Comments (292)
First two authors seem so incredibly interesting. First one seems like a god tier writer in the making, and the second one feels like an experienced writer throwing something through on a burner to add to the story’s narrative
Fashionably late
Should dedicate one video a month to reading fan written stories from the reddit. Maybe two in one episode depending on how long they are. Y'all also need to finish Stolen Tongues, The Thing in The Basement, and From Hell I Write.
*CLEARS CARBURATOR* HONK HONK!!!
🕊️ 🙏🏻beep beep
I wrote “The Missing Person I’m Looking for No Longer Exists.” It was such a blast listening to this back when it first posted. Inspired me to continue posting stories. Thanks for reading it, and so glad you guys liked it.
HONK HONK, HONK? (Father* wants to know if you're writing anything recently)
They’re just ppl who could never successfully make their own creative channel and can only insult out of lonesome jealousy, Isaiah did make an interesting connection too lol
I hope you’re being sarcastic 😂
Suffering from insomnia but the spooky boys lull me to sleep with spooky silly stories
I wanna make one for you guys so bad.. ive had an idea cooking up since about august2025 (december as i type) and i wanna flesh it out completely and try to finish it before posting it on the subreddit!!
Me too, I've always loved stories. Told them through D&D as a medium. After I started listening to CreepCast, it inspired me to want to start writing. It's been slow going but the desire is strong.
That psychology joke was roughhh
No u
I want to say you guys have inspired me to get back into writing and though I just started writing it, I'd love to post it on the CreepCast sub when I finish. A little tidbit of information, is that the title of the first story I am currently working on will be "1000 Ways I Died"
Oh, that's a cool title 😎
vvvvçccçç v
You tell em
A short fun gag story that’s about creep cast (and makes Jeff the killer look like crime and punishment) is https://www.reddit.com/r/creepcast/s/yS3volsQlj
That nursing home story was really well done. Loss of Innonence was hilarious
When you look back and see the woman who hit you going 80 mph on her bike tumbling into the wormhole she created https://youtu.be/Mpcd45zvY-U?si=lc73-uv0f61rqrIV
I think hunter and baby pepper should read one piece could be a good bonding experience
Same, hope they do it, would be good for them.
I love Hunter crashouts sm lol
The audio was mad crunchy on this one. Was scared it was my tv speakers
Wild profile pic 😂🍑
Wild thumbnail 😂
Perfect Sunday: Take a shit Wake up Listen to creep cast Do chores Hit gym Listen to creep cast again Sleep
Hi.
Loved it
Hi.
Best podcast out there 😏
Hi.
It’s tangents like grandma being eaten by wolves that makes me KNOW, that’s exactly how PM got Beerpup to marry him.
Hi.
I haven’t gotten the chance to check out your vid Wendigoon, but I’m looking forward to it. Your videos have always come across to me like a friend telling me about something they really love. I appreciate all the work you do and the passions you share!! Thanks again for another great episode guys❤️
Can you guys backlog the rest of the creep cast episodes on here so I have one place to watch all the episodes? Thank you!
Fantastic idea
Hunter with baby pepper gives the same vibe as Isaiah with the bear
Hi.
(59:45) I dont know if someone's already pointed it out but that's why the windows in the house the book was found in were nailed shut
Hi.
Waka waka
Hi.
(48:39) They're the Unown from the Johto region and there's a Unown for each letter of the alphabet
Not Hunter almost summoning Slappy with his chant (39:02)
It would be so cool to have creep cast book club for longer novels (maybe even house of leaves!)
Hi.
can u guys go on tour again and come to the great city of brotherly love philadelphia
Hi.
They’re called UNKNOWN
Craaaazy bear trap in the first quarter from Hunter
Didin’t realize how much I needed hunters Irish accent
Still suggesting Everymanhybrid for patreon CreepTV. Its cringe as hell and I think Hunter would lose his MIND watching HABIT.
Benadryl and melatonin did me so right last night. I ran into hunter with his mom and disabled brother in Vegas. And we hung out abd took pictures. He just had implant dentures done and we even had a meal together and I kept saying "my brother is going to be so pissed (jealous) (context....I work in dental insurance.... there's where the implant dentures came from)
I also kept thinking if Kayla showed up i was going to die in excitement.
Be really cool if any of you guys would read my story in the r/CreepCast. (Nukwaiya, TN).
If they do another grab bag episode I’d love for them to read “ paid for in blood “ it is as the kids say “ very lovecraftian “
Loved this episode!
Can you guys read The Black Pill. I'm sorry i forgot who the Narrations are by.
Its gotta be the reddit mods, no matter how cool of a thing to be a fan of, reddit mods will abuse the tiny idea of power they have lmao. They're the worst, if you're a reddit mod, stop.
i hope this becomes a regular thing!! ive been inspired to write ever since i started listen to you guys and i could only hope of you both reviewing even with the witty remarks ahaha
The protagonist in the last story reminded me of how I would describe an out of body experience I had. It involved sleep paralysis and thinking I was walking around my living room but kept flashing back to my napping body. Had to force and will myself to move again/wake up. Makes me wonder if anything like that was incorporated in the story 🤔
This episode is peak Creep Cast! It’s the most creep this cast has ever been good short story with long tangents!
i think you guys would really enjoy crown the clown it’s a shorter sweet story
Great podcast, maybe the best all time But MAN do I hate when Wendi tries to deeply analyze hunters bits 😭 (I know it’s a bit in itself) but it kills the vibe hard
I thought it was funny. You're such an L
SHOUT OUT THE OFFICIAL PODCAST AND THE OFFICIAL BOYS LETS GOOOOO
It's so surprising seeing sm negativity through paid patreon. Thought only really solid fans would pay to watch like this. Did you pay to spread negativity? 🫷🤷♂️🤷♂️. Anyways. Great job boys love it like always #staycreeped
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with criticism
The stories were all amazing but Hunters Wolf story was by far the most compelling narrative of the entire show.
This was a fun episode.
Does anyone vid not work in closed the app and it won't let me skip ahead to where I was mobile data or wifi doesn't work
what is going on with wendi's microphone
He’s part mouse and thinks it’s food
When I write and post my own story, I hope you read it in an episode. I’m a very good person, so I feel I deserve it. I’ve donated liters of sperm, gallons of blood, and countless organs to various orphanages and soup kitchens in impoverished communities, just within the last month alone.
You donated liters of sperm to orphanages and soup kitchens? I hope the soup was good.
Hey! Does anyone know if there's a link to be able to listen on Spotify with the members only post? I don't remember seeing one of my email
What do you mean? Like to listen ad free on Spotify? Why not just listen here if you're already here?
That second story filled me with a deep sense of dread - bravo!
Is it just me or does Iceberg Boy hate us? Seems like he’s always got something negative to say about the audience. Maybe it’s some type of inside joke I’m not in on
Yeah he for sure hates the audience, I can't believe the audacity of that man
I apologize for writing a post that isn't about the story, but I was wondering (and hoping) if there was any talk abour either a patreon chatroom, or patreon dicord? I know I would very much like to chitchat with a lot of the people here.
Great idea
Training a pack of wolves to attack the nearest nursing home. Hunter made me a believer.
I recommend It Was a Different Time: https://web.archive.org/web/20180902232737/http://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/9c939p/it_was_a_different_time/ although I'm not sure if a video would be taken down... the original story was deleted because it was adapted by the nosleep podcast. Can a Patreon video get a copyright strike? It's really an awesome story. My boyfriend and I think it's the best one that NSP has adapted and I'd love to hear what you guys think!
They should read The sounding of the fifth trumpet.
These were great stories. I think this is a fun addition to creep cast
Please finish the thing in the basement
Please please please do a two sentence horror story collection
This is inspiring me to write the most compelling & long creepy pasta ever, and end it with a surprise scene of Hunter and Isaiah having butt sex that doesn’t make any sense for the story but just for the troll.
Anyone else hear some weird audio stuff in this episode or is it just my phone?
i thought it was my earbuds. kinda made it spookier tho
Peak
Can we get a audio only version to download
hello do we have a discord?
like a patreon exclusive?
Hunter's bit about unleashing the wolves unleashed an extra wolf into my dream last night. It was in my house. Best purchase I've ever made, no other patreon subscription I'm aware of comes with feral pup induced nightmares. 10/10
Hunter. This is why i'm here. It's you. Lmao obsessed with your humor. Paying here, paying at the papa meat patreon, and a papa meat channel member. Please never stop with your bits lmaooo
The Pokémon is called Unown! Hunter was close lmao
My fav bonus story: I left the door open and wolves ate my grandma in the nursing home
Discussion at 1:11:00 reminds me of pyramid head in silent hill basically becoming just a big scary man for the franchise, appearing in homecoming and the movies when it’s James personal monster that’s a reflection of his guilt
Hi guys please play in sound mind, it's kinda scary but more trippy. love the content!
I would love to hear the part two for the last story
You guys should play still wakes the deep
My God, the last time I laughed this hard Hunter was talking about Mr. Widemouth.
the peanut butter baby reference killed me
The wolves and the nursing home was so unbelievably funny
When you're crying laughing listening to 2 guys discuss wolves in a nursing home
I’m 40mins in & my bear trap is that the demon this guy is talking to is Tom Riddle ⚡️
One year my brother and his friend almost got shot by our grandpa. He's got dementia and thought they were trespassing. And my mom and grandma were out of the house. All the guns got removed after that.
Wendigoon's Blood Meridian video is one of my favorites to rewatch.
In Praise of Shadows had a stroke the second you commented that
Hi.
Grab 😉 bag
Creepin the fuck outta myself might lose my innocence type shit
We’re halfway through the year of our Lord 2025 and Isaiah would still be better off with a blue yeti mic 😂
OZEMPIC KILLED THIS MAN 🤯🗣️
MILLIE IS SHORT FOR CAMILLE WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DONT UNDERSTAND
Truly the best in the business! Thank you guys for the content
I came here to recommend Fleghgait and if you don't read it, I swear I will turn into a giant baby and throw my diapers at someone's grandpa!
i second this they would LOVE fleshgait i just know it
Would be AWESOME to listen to this on my iPod, but I guess I'M PAYING FOR NOTHING as I am still GETTING THE FREE VERSION THRU ITUNES!! So let me guess, in the future this will be a "perk" at a higher membership level. Am I right???
Sooooo… you’re NOT happy with the patreon then?
My two favorite huzz
Fix your mic pls
I think Wendigoon was using a microwave as a microphone
Tour de France aaahhhaaha
Wild bear trap in this one
Was the audio a bit crusty for anyone else sometimes?
yeah, i experienced that too. wasn’t too bad, i thought it was my airpods lol
exactly what i need to drown out my mom snoring while we’re trapped in a tiny cruise room together!!!
exactly what i need to drown out my mom snoring while we’re trapped in a tiny cruise room together!!!
I’m Sorry for driving scooters at 80 miles an hour cuh 😭
Anyone able to use the pause timer? I can’t find it
Day3 this is a certified loss of innocence classic The ded girl in my yard was the best friend I ever had Chanting in the woods The whistlers.
I’ve got a lot of story concepts floating around in my head. Maybe this’ll be the motivation I need to finally inflict them on the world in written form.
After mulling it over, one story in particular comes to mind as my perfect brainchild to bequeath unto these men. It has brutal imagery, body horror, countless religious references, and just enough lovecraftian influence for Hunter to no doubt pick up on. I think I may need to brush up on the ol Bible before I commit to writing it though :)
Im about to creep my cast all over work tonight
my autistic ass sitting here listening to yall trying to name pokemon was like a boomer yelling at the tv watching a football game
Boomer? Teenagers still do this shit
AIsaiah
Them not knowing the unknown are called unknowns lol
This is for whomever on the team is running the patreon. Any chance we'll get the patreon feed integration for Spotify soon?
RSS pls
44:50 book demon boi shoulda said “drawing nearer” lmao
2:24:26
This patron is worth it for the ad free content alone. So happy you guys made this
I’m 15 minutes in and the bear trap is crazy
Pretty sure windy said "one finger in them" and not figure.
If your gonna play «no im not human» i really recommend «Home Safety Hotline" it’s right up your guys valley. And has some really fun elements
Trueee that’s text heavy too so wouldn’t feel like too much of a shift
You guys should read some 2 sentence horror
The audio was a bit scuffed this episode other wise this made me creep my cast at work
Dude. The Pepper guest appearance was SICK.
Love hearing the discussion about storytelling! I think Hunter’s take on it was killer and a great philosophy towards creating and engaging with things you love! Oh also, super cool to get into the showcase at the end! I made the collage for Stolen Tongues and I’m excited to make more creepcast inspired art :]
The Swing! Read the swing! It's so campy and creepy
I WILL GOON MY MEAT UNTIL Y'ALL READ "My property is not normal" YOU HAVE BEEN WAAAAARRRRRRNED
I’m currently up gooning my meat Who else?
Might post a story about the stage/scary moments I’ve experienced in my town
Does it involve a creature
Those saying "Isaiah AI voice" obviously don't know that he died after episode 3. #NotMyCreepCast
OFFICIAL PODCAST MENTIONED. who else was exposed to wendigoon for the first time through his guest episodes on the O.P?
How do we upload our stories???
On the creepcast subreddit
She creep my cast till I wendigoon on her meat canyon
My creature in her bear trap
Can’t wait for all the inside jokes that the redditors were talking about
The stories were alright I think the second and third were better then the first one but they were all ok
In the off chance you read this wendigoon, your video on blood meridian convinced me to go off and read the story before watching the video and it truly changed how I read stories to this day, your video was perfect for what it set out to do
Wendi we love you bro but PLEASE FIX YOUR AUDIO OH MY GOD WERE BEGGING ON OUR HANDS AND KNEES
I commented the last one, not realizing you've already posted another. You should read "The Whistlers".
What if when he went to look at his window there was just a bloody ass print on his window taint and all
can't believe he didn't call out the bear trap moment
Hi Creepcast, Please play the game No I’m Not A Human!
“Don’t write porn on the subreddit please and idk try to be scary” - you have too much faith in us, good sir
They went all fight club on us with the random flashes of images lol
Their editor has been doing it for a minute now
Isaiah is so nice when he isn’t talking to us
who up redding their thread- wait wrong show
this episode was okay but they should really replace those freaks with the esteemed Dr Kayla Garrett
Thank u guys for the ad free upload not tht the ads both me they're usually pretty funny so they just add to the show
lube on one hand, cheese puffs on the on the other, headphones on. this bouta creep the cast out of my neighbours, 4 sure
Thank you kings
idk i f anyone has said anything about this yet but theres some pretty bad audio issues in this video
The editors had a pop up apology in the beginning about the sound. Something about Isaiah chewing on his cable
the subreddit is giving me eyeball aids, came here to calm my nerves
I’m creeping my cast so good rn
Hi, I’m the author of “I have discovered a book that does not end” thank you guys so much for reading my story on the pod. Never in a million years did I think I’d be featured on here. I love being a part of this Patreon and cannot wait to see what you two have in store for us going forward!!!
That was some good shit fam
no smut? aw man...
love creeping my cast at work 😌
honestly love that you guys are reading fan made stories 😼
hunter’s grandmother in the nursing home being devoured by wolves is a new all timer creepcast bit
After I ran over and killed a women who was using a rocket propelled bike I turned into a baby aswell
She creep my cast till I beartrap
Was the audio fucked up for Isaiah for yall too? Edit: my dumbass didn’t see the disclaimer by the editors in the beginning. Yall doing the lords work
yeah dude has to sort out his mic issues
hunters hatred of old people is so real
I mean he did watch one murder his dog not even 6 feet away from him
I’m actually here just for the smut…. Should I leave?
Would be nice if there was somewhere else to post besides reddit for those of us who have been perma banned by the losers with a god complex over at reddit
Mille was probably a nickname which the demon had yet to erase, camile being the 'true name' was the first to go
You’re the first person I’ve seen to get this part correct:) love hearing people’s theories
I would have spent tens of dollars for extra content
Yeah, they definitely undercut themselves. I’d happily pay another 5 if they gave me a bear trap sticker
What is with the random ai Isaiah voice
mic issues for sure.
Damnit, now I actually need to buckle down and finish writing my story idea. Son of a bitch
You should! Maybe they’ll read it in here. Just a tip, if you’re story includes a living mattress character, I heard that sells well
WHAT WAS THE INTRO AHAHAH
Just joined! So happy to be supporting you guys and I’m inspired to create ❤️
What if the first story was a reverse David King where he wants to lower the maximum required effort
David King or David Fuc|{ing King?
This AI is getting really good a replicating hunter fly low 💔
WE’RE LOSING THE SAUCE, THEY DONT CALL OUT BEAR TRAPS AS MUCH ANYMORE
Hunner! Wendy! can you guys do a link to an unlisted youtube video as an option for these videos? the patreon integrated player is annoying. Thanks boys!
Also noice No I am Not Human, can't wait for that game.
I am one of those that wish I could add this to my watchlist on Youtube
Literally creeping my shit. Also could you guys add these AD-free casts on spotify for supporters? A thing you can do and makes them less annoying to listen through. Thanks.
I’m not sure if spotify can do unlisted episodes for patreon, but YouTube can. Also, spotify always tacks on their own ads to podcasts anyways 👹
I would like a compilation of all of Isaiah’s jeff goldbloom impressions in exchange for my patronage (please I beg)
I SECOND THIS, GIVE US THE GOLDBLUM CUT
Maybe the real loss of innocence is the cyclists we killed along the way
isAIah!!!!! 😂
Isaiah fix your gosh darn Audio!!! I hear you, AI Isaiah!
Oh yeah this is peak content
Time for PEAK
rss feed when?
Not sure what's going on with the audio. It sounds like Wendi is switching back and forth between two mics. Hard to focus on the story.
Suicune better jump out of that book and start hopping around
Aw hell yeah
Day 2 of asking for "The Supermarket Monster".
Let’s go
Omg!! we are getting FED
Day 2 of asking for them to continue "the thing in the basement is getting better at mimicking people"
Ahh feels good to be amongst the upper echelon of this Fandom and not the peasants.
Real 🤣
Obsessed w this lil community we got goin here
Patreon gang 🥵 we creepin our cast extra harder today!
just crashed into a cyclist oddly enough she was also going 80mphs
i am seated
Seeing them follow through on reading fan-stories has me grateful we can support this show more with the patreon ❤️
I greatly miss Wendi-Blum, please bring it back or give us the Goldblum cut of the episode from over a year ago.
Thank you for paying attention to the fan-made content! 💚🖤
We eating good today
Oh yeah baby
Y’all know what time it is !!
Will any of the stories given to you guys on tour be read? I remember you guys said you had a stack of stories all given to you guys by fans.
Can you guys create an RSS feed for the ad-free podcast? 🙏🏼
Let’s goooooo
Cranking my hog to this, appreciate you fellas🫶
So happy you guys uploaded this at the same time as the YouTube video was posted, gave me a better option. Moving forward, I hope this episode doesn't feature in your court case.
thank God I don't have to watch 2 minutes and 16 seconds of ad's
Love the thumbnail haha
I’m an old dad who gets his Sunday bonding time in with my 21 year old son enjoying this nonsense.
Guys please read Abandond by Disney and its sequals !
this would be soooo funny omg
Does anyone know where we post stories for the creep cast people? Is there a Reddit or something?
Yes! It's just r/creepcast
I was just starting to get withdrawls at work but now my creep cast fix is here!
Finally we get an unedited picture of hunter
papa meat and hunter dropping w faps
Might be the best thumbnail yet, really captured the mania that I think is underneath the surface of Isaiah.
Peak
Oh no, don’t give him a gun and hide your dogs…
Do stairs in the woods again 👍🙏
I believe they said they were going to recover it for the anniversary
YIPEEEE YIPEEEEEEEEEE YIPEEEEEEE
It's one o'clock y'all!
Release the Jeff Goldblum cut content for the paying fans
I just creeped my cast over that thumbnail
TIME TO CREEP MY CAST
Getting me thru the work day!!
Omg he’s in a wheelchair NOOOO HUNTER PUT THE RIFLE DOWN
Just in time for work
Love it
Hunter ending up in a nursing home just makes sense
Made Hunter look like jack black in this thumbnail😭
Beautiful
I think this is the beginning of the thumbnail wars.
Nice
Thank you
This thumbnail is insane
Papa Meat back in the thumb nail 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
I’m creeping hard on my cast
my ingrown toenails are slowly getting better, your treatment worked wonders hunter
GOOD MORNING
Peak 2
Creeping myself rn
Thank you for another horrifying thumbnail
Peak
