The Worst Word Of Dialogue Ever Written
Somehow Palpatine returned...
Comments (13)
Two thoughts: 1: your commentary about ignoring the prequels raised an interesting issue, which I hope other writers have addressed before, but I’m writing it down here anyway. IF when you saw the original Star Wars movie(s), you had not seen the prequels, your interpretation of Star Wars as an ongoing story would be radically different from someone who saw the prequels first. Those two experiences might be sufficiently different that they really should be treated as if they were from different movies. 2: The word "somehow," in this context becomes a thought-terminating cliché; something meant to stop inquiry dead. Example: I'm frustrated with a particular problem, and my friend says "It is what it is." That conversation is going to be massively awkward if I take it any further. Writing in a way that prevents or tries to sidestep curiosity is not good writing. [Here’s a better definition of the phrase for people who haven’t run into it before: a brief, commonly-used phrase designed to stop critical thinking, end debate, and bypass uncomfortable, complex, or taboo topics.]
Maybe goes to show that one doesn't need AI to produce slop...? I don't consider myself a "good writer" of any kind, and I felt a mix of amusement and desperation watching your video: how can people who are professionals come up with something like that? In the end, I guess that when extracting money out of a fan community becomes more important than telling a genuinely interesting story, the result can end up a severely degraded bit of kitsch rather than art...
Haha, yes "somehow" the word "somehow" was required
I remember sitting in the theatre and audibly laughing when I heard that line... or was it a moan? Somehow, I can't seem to remember.
I think my first instinct was that it was an intentional joke.
When the video started, I thought 'somehow' was placeholder text that they forgot to go back and explain, somehow. But after your implication that Palpatine's return was the studio's decision, and your reminder that JJ Abrams was the creative force behind the trilogy, it felt more like his way of saying "Is this what you want!?"
I'm laughing at this image in my head of Oscar Issacs going to JJ and being like, "Are you sure you want me to say this? This is a placeholder, right?" JJ looks around and sees hundreds of extras and crew members costing hundreds of thousands of dollars and says, "Uh, yep, that's the line... exactly like that." Oscar Issacs then calls his agent to say, "I'm leaving, I'm better than this".... but then his agent reminds him that he is getting a huge paycheck. He goes back to the set, thinks about the new pool he wants for his vacation house, and then somehow manages to speak. He then runs to his trailer, throws up breakfast, and sits there, shaking and sobbing.... and then, like Anakin after chopping off Mace Windu's hand, screams into the void "What have I done?!?"
Palpatine ended up being a meta-villain, playing the spoiler to the audience's understanding end enjoyment of this saga. I'd push back that the decision to kill Snoke was baffling. The major criticism of TFA was that it was too much of a retread of the original, and if Snoke had survived through TLJ… well, the good guys would've obviously taken him down as the Big Bad in the third film, just like Return of the Jedi. Rian Johnson put the writers of the third film in a creative corner, and they could've either innovated or fold to corporate pressure. One of those is easier than the other.
I agree the killing of Snoke could have worked, and might have been really interesting - IF they had done something with it. Even the idea of Kylo and Rey forming an alliance could have worked. Alas.
I could argue that "somehow" could work well in an investigation story. But I may be wrong somehow.
Yeah, the word somehow isn't in and of itself bad. I use it all the time!
Looking forward to the Salacious B Crumb deep dive.
Anything is on the table lol. Was thinking maybe it could be part of a series about the concept of "lore" itself. For example, Tosche Station is another reference in the films I've always wondered about. What's the backstory?!
