HP: TSH — Chapter 306 - Racing Toward Death, Part 2
Death is terrifying. And yet it is also beautiful.
A person who dies with no choice in the matter is destined to die full of regret. A person who chooses to walk toward death is, without question, full of courage.
On this day, Harry witnessed two people make that choice: Lady Sylvia, who walked toward death to protect those she loved, and Dumbledore, who walked toward it to protect even more.
Harry turned and looked back toward the distant castle. The people he had fought so hard to have were in there, his godfather Sirius Black, his love Ginny Weasley, his friends, and many others he had only ever met in passing.
He knew the ghosts surrounding him were not real. Most likely they were only his imagination. But they were also real in another sense, real in that they had existed, and in doing so had made sure he was never alone on this journey.
Harry seemed to reach some kind of resolve. He walked deeper into the Forbidden Forest.
Stepping out from the centaurs' hollow, Praeris clenched her fist beneath her sleeve. She said calmly, "Sir. Go to Hogwarts."
"The Dark Lord wants to kill you. Even if he knows you are not the master of the Elder Wand, he will torture you regardless. You did not truly kill Dumbledore — in his eyes, that makes you either a traitor or an incompetent. He cannot tolerate either."
"Right now Hogwarts is full of wounded. Madam Pomfrey needs you. The fact that Dumbledore survived after the Astronomy Tower is the best proof of your innocence. Tell Neville the potions were ones you instructed me to provide, and no one will question you further."
The logic was clean. The reasoning was sound. It all made perfect sense.
Snape was not easy to fool.
"Is that so?" He studied Praeris carefully. "Why should I need to prove myself? Miss Praeris — are you not proof enough? Or rather." He paused. "What exactly are you planning to do?"
Praeris had been seen through. She held Snape's gaze steadily, her tone so calm it bordered on indifferent. "I am going back to the Dark Lord's side, sir."
"You forbid me from going to my death, and yet here you are seeking your own." Snape's voice cut with contempt. "Praeris, your mother — this is an utterly foolish decision!"
He barely managed to swallow the rest of it: Your mother didn't plan on seeing you this soon.
"I must go. This is what I promised Dumbledore. He kept his promise, how could I break mine?" Praeris said softly. "Severus." She paused. "May I call you Severus? I've seen how others address their family. Wait for me to come back at Hogwarts, will you? My cover hasn't been blown. I still have value to the Dark Lord. He won't kill me."
"You may," Snape said.
Then: "No."
The first was his answer to the name. The second was his refusal to let her go alone.
"Very well, Severus." Praeris said. "This is a notification, not a negotiation. You know me. Whenever I have decided to do something, you have never once succeeded in stopping me."
Snape's hand moved. He raised his wand, then lowered it. When he spoke, there was something in his voice Praeris had never heard from him before, a faint, barely contained plea. "Praeris. Do not underestimate the Dark Lord's cruelty. We cannot be certain he hasn't read the truth from Potter's mind. Come with me. Don't make me,"
"Are you going to use magic on me?" Praeris asked. Not a challenge. More like stating a fact. "Bind me like I'm an enemy?"
She knew her professor too well. Severus would never do that. Even if she had truly pushed him to his limit, the worst she would get was a few sharp words.
But saying it aloud would make him hesitate.
In the single instant Snape froze, three vines shot out from behind him. He spun instinctively to defend himself, and a flash of red light slipped past him from behind.
The Expelliarmus knocked his wand from his hand. The vines followed immediately, coiling fast and tight. Praeris stepped forward and caught Snape's wand as it arced through the air, the whole sequence one unbroken motion.
That was right. Snape would not bind Praeris. But Praeris would absolutely bind Snape.
"This is what you taught me," Praeris said. "Soft-heartedness is the most unacceptable weakness."
She stepped forward and gripped Snape's arm. She Side-Along Apparated, and they vanished.
This had been Snape's last chance to stop her. He could have struggled, disrupted the Apparition midway, but that risked Splinching her.
Just as Praeris had said. Soft-heartedness is the most unacceptable weakness. From the moment he had resolved to protect this child, Snape had only ever had one outcome in front of her.
Utter defeat.
A crack split the air inside the Room of Requirement, and every wand in the room snapped toward the sound.
"Lower them, all of you!" Neville shouted. He looked at Praeris and hesitated. "You're back. Are you hurt?"
Praeris shook her head. Then she turned to Neville with full gravity. "Neville. You wouldn't believe that Professor Snape had no idea what I was doing, and you'd be right not to. Everything I did for you, all of it, was done at his direction. He has also been covering for me this whole time. He is a member of the Order of the Phoenix. He always has been."
The good reputation she had built helping the DA meant nothing to Praeris. Clearing Snape's name meant everything. If her luck ran out and she never came back, her Uncle Severus still needed to be able to hold his head high.
Neville stared at her. "...What?"
The rest of the room was equally lost. From Neville's reaction alone, it was clear Praeris was one of their own. But they had only known that Snape hadn't truly killed Dumbledore, none of them had imagined he had been working for their side in secret all along.
Several Slytherins shot to their feet in stunned delight, Evan, Meryl, Millicent, and Astoria.
Praeris made her decision the moment she saw them. "Leah, Milly, perfect timing. I have something I need to finish. Professor Snape is yours."
She looked back at Snape. Still bound fast by vines, his eyes holding a tangle of shock and fury and something that looked too much like despair. She left him with a single sentence.
"I'm sorry. But I have reasons I cannot put aside."
Praeris Disapparated.
The room erupted. Everyone turned on Neville at once, demanding to know what had just happened. One mouth against a dozen wasn't a fair fight, and he was quickly swamped, only the Slytherins still remembered the professor bound on the floor.
The four students rushed over and stood around their former Head of House, completely at a loss.
Snape, holding his fury in a tight grip, said through his teeth: "Un. Tie. Me."
Millicent nudged Astoria. "Leah, didn't you say Praeris taught you something?"
"She taught me one thing!" Astoria said. "One! Millicent, you can't actually expect me to undo Praeris's magic!"
Meryl sprang to her feet and bolted for the door. Evan lunged after her. "Mer! Where are you,"
"Miss Brown!" Meryl's voice was already fading down the corridor. "She knows counter-jinxes!"
Snape had lost all faith in the intellectual capacity of his own students. He enunciated each syllable with a precision that could have cut glass. "Fi. Ni. Te. In. Can. Ta. Tem."
What in Merlin's name was Flitwick teaching these children?
Harmful spells require counter-curses to undo the damage they leave behind, that was basic. A non-harmful jinx like this only needed Finite Incantatem. This was first-year material.
Astoria hastily drew her wand and pointed it at the vines. The vines went limp. They slid to the floor in a heap, and Snape pulled free, standing up in one sharp motion. He raised his wand.
He did not take another step.
The three Slytherin students looked at him. Then at each other.
Finally, it was Millicent who spoke, the oldest of them, and the one who had been closest to Praeris. "Headmaster Snape, are you,"
Snape let out a slow breath. His wand hand dropped. "No. Where is Madam Pomfrey?"
"Shall I take you?" Millicent said.
Perhaps this, too, had been part of Praeris's plan. Going after her now would do him no good. He had no idea where Voldemort was. He had no idea which direction Praeris had gone. All he could do was wait, and, as she had said, help Madam Pomfrey with her work.
He had to keep moving. He was afraid that if he stopped, the child's parting apology would start to echo in his head, spoken in the same voice as her mother's. He was afraid that if he stopped, he would find himself helplessly imagining what terrible end might be waiting for her.
Praeris had admitted she was a liar. She had lied to Snape. And that was never only about a promise to Dumbledore.
Yes, this step had been part of the plan she and Dumbledore had made together. But she and Dumbledore had long since settled their debts, if anything, Dumbledore still owed her. She had no real obligation to follow through. It wasn't as though Dumbledore could climb out of his grave and call her to account.
And yet she had chosen to go.
She had never forgotten the sight of Voldemort's wand leveled at Severus. She had never forgotten Sylvia crumpling, powerless. She had never forgotten the better part of a year spent biding her time, enduring in silence, waiting.
The plan had to be executed. Voldemort had to die.
"Master!" Praeris pushed through the undergrowth, her voice bright with relief. "I've finally found you, Bella, what exactly is the meaning of this?"
Several Death Eaters had their wands trained directly on her.
Voldemort tilted his head and produced an expression of exaggerated surprise. "Well, well. Praeris. What a pleasant surprise. I had rather thought you would never appear before me again."
Whether that "never" meant wouldn't dare or wouldn't be able to, he left unsaid. He was waiting for her to explain herself.
"I thought the same, Master." Praeris said, and her unease was not entirely performed. "But as it turns out, a wizard like Dumbledore — one who fancies himself righteous — cannot bring himself to kill a student."
"Oh?" Voldemort's voice was soft. "So you were held captive?"
Praeris nodded, then shook her head. "I'm not certain... they knocked me out. When I came to, I was bound. The Shrieking Shack was empty, no one left but me."
Bellatrix's voice pitched high and sharp. "Liar! Then how did you escape!"
"I thought I was completely trapped!" Praeris shot a glare at Bellatrix, then turned back to Voldemort with careful deference. "But as I lay there... the magic holding me simply dissolved on its own."
"That's impossible —" Bellatrix started.
"Now, now." Voldemort raised his right hand, and wands lowered around the clearing. "Bella. It is perfectly possible."
"Of course it is!" Mrs. Bulstrode agreed at once. "Master's power is supreme, Dumbledore is dead, naturally that old man's spells would collapse without him!"
Mrs. Bulstrode was not speaking up for Praeris. She was simply seizing the opportunity to praise Voldemort.
"And Severus?" Voldemort asked.
Praeris shook her head. "I don't know, Master."
"He ran!" Bellatrix had no hesitation in thinking the worst of Snape. "He failed to kill Dumbledore and knew he'd be punished for it, so he ran!"
Praeris passed the test. She was permitted to rejoin the circle of Death Eaters.
She took stock of her surroundings. Two giants, both bloodied. A werewolf gnawing anxiously at his own fingers. A scattering of wizards, some hooded, some not. Like the others, she kept her head down and waited. Voldemort seemed certain that Harry would come.
Truthfully, one of the reasons Praeris was here was to ensure Harry did not fail to appear. Dumbledore was convinced Harry would walk calmly to his death, but Praeris had never trusted human nature. She trusted airtight plans.
If Harry lost his nerve at the last moment, Praeris would find a reason to track him down with magic, just as she had tracked Dumbledore, and make sure Voldemort got his kill. The tracking spell she had originally devised to find Dumbledore had, in fact, been designed first to find Harry.
"This is too cruel of you," Dumbledore had said, sighing. "I believe..."
"You believe!" Praeris had given a cold laugh. "You believed in James Potter and Sirius Black, and Harry ended up with no home and no family. Dumbledore, belief is the cheapest sentiment in the world. Hardly anyone truly cares about it."
Dumbledore had let out a breath. "That was an accident. No one could have anticipated..."
"If you failed to anticipate the first time, you'll fail to anticipate a second." Praeris's voice had been merciless. "Can we really afford more things no one anticipated?"
"Of course, you are free to believe," she had continued, her tone easing slightly. "And free to be caught off-guard. But I will account for all of it. Whether you anticipate it or not, everything will proceed according to plan. Every event that is supposed to happen will happen."
Let Gryffindor go ahead and be brave. Slytherin would be right behind, coiled like a snake, ready to deal with whatever prey escaped from the lion's mouth.
Praeris had never killed anyone. She had never even indirectly caused anyone's death. But she had drawn up this plan to send Harry to his heroic end in something close to cold blood.
Dumbledore had looked at her for a long moment.
"Don't look at me like that," Praeris had said with a short laugh. "Is this not exactly what you have been hoping for? You've simply wrapped it in a gentler guise."
But then she noticed something that sat uneasily with her. His gaze was not contempt. It was something quieter, a look of gentle, knowing recognition, the kind that comes from shared experience. He seemed to see, in Praeris, some version of himself at a certain moment in time.
She had looked away.
When she spoke again, her voice was softer. "If I could choose otherwise, I would. But if this moment must come, I will carry it out. Without flinching. Without a moment's hesitation."
➤ Next: Slytherin's Resolve — Heartbreak
