💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
October 16, 2026

HP: TSH — Chapter 304 - Saint or Sinner?

Dumbledore did not look away from Harry's scrutinizing gaze. That kind of gaze was nothing new to him. A very long time ago, he had come to know clearly that he was not a perfect man, and he had learned to face every flaw within his own heart without flinching.

But facing Harry, his voice dropped very low, filled with remorse. No kind person could make such a decision without feeling shame.

"Yes, Harry, I mapped out a path toward death for you. It was a cruel decision. But now... I will make the only amends I can offer — I will not let you walk that path alone."

Dumbledore's words had barely fallen when Voldemort's voice rang out like a thunderclap. He had projected it to its fullest, making certain every single person could hear him.

Harry and Dumbledore looked up at the same moment, turning toward the direction of the voice, even though neither of them could truly see Voldemort.

"Look at you, bleeding for him. But tell me — when you needed him most, where was the great Albus Dumbledore? He lured you into willingly throwing your own bodies before my armies, and then he hid himself away. Is that a leader, or is that a coward?"

Voldemort performed his feigned sympathy beautifully, his tone thick with affected bewilderment and condescending pity. The fighting had temporarily ceased. Everyone looked toward the Death Eater forces, murmuring to one another about what was happening.

"He is of course still alive!" Voldemort's voice cut sharp and clear. "Like a rat in a sewer, he crawled back out of the grave using the most despicable tricks! He preached to you about love and fearlessness in the face of death, yet he himself fled from it in the most shameful way possible! He orchestrated a year-long deception against every single one of his followers!"

"Why did he hide?" Voldemort asked, and answered his own question. "Not to protect you — to protect himself. He feared me. He feared losing his life and his precious reputation, and he was willing to sacrifice the very boy he raised up as the savior to do it — Harry Potter! Do you hear that, Potter? You are nothing but a shield."

The crowd had completely lost control. The murmuring swelled into an uproar. Even those who had chosen to stay and fight Voldemort of their own free will could not help but feel doubt begin to creep in.

If Dumbledore had truly never died, while they were bleeding, while their loved ones were falling, what had he been doing? Did their sacrifices now seem foolish and laughable?

"Albus Dumbledore!" Voldemort spread his arms wide and called out at the top of his voice. "Come out and face me now, or you are exactly what I have accused you of being — a fraud, a deceiver. A coward!"

In the Forbidden Forest, Snape stopped walking and looked toward the battlefield. He raised his left hand and held it out, stopping Praeris behind him.

"Wait and see."

When she had been burying her mother, Praeris had already anticipated this.

Voldemort was the kind of man who clung desperately to his own survival, someone who believed that as long as you kept yourself alive, the future would take care of itself. He had a deeply Slytherin instinct for self-preservation. But he was no fool. Dumbledore could only deceive him for so long.

It would not take long before Voldemort reasoned it out: since Dumbledore was alive yet had never appeared, it could only mean Dumbledore did not possess the power to truly threaten him at all.

Voldemort would use that to force Dumbledore out. He wanted to tear Dumbledore down from his pedestal. To prove that Dumbledore was not a god, but an ordinary man.

"Dumbledore cannot go out there — we need to go back and persuade him." Praeris said, her brow furrowed. "No one understands his condition better than I do. In his current state he has absolutely no ability to fight the Dark Lord. Going out there is walking to his death. And as long as he doesn't appear, who besides us and Harry and Hermione can even prove he's still alive?"

Aside from Voldemort, only their own people knew Dumbledore was alive. So why on earth should he go out to die?

After Dumbledore had faithfully kept his promise, Praeris had already begun to see him through new eyes. Not as a collaborator. As a true friend.

Snape was silent for a moment.

"Dumbledore will go."

"Why?" Praeris asked. "It's not a wise decision."

"Praeris, rationality is something only people like us talk about." Snape said, his voice low and steady. "Gryffindors are rather good at making unwise decisions."

"Harry, this is not a wise decision." Dumbledore placed both hands on Harry's shoulders, his gaze gentle and resolute. "But it is a decision that must be made."

"No!" Harry's eyes went wide. He reached out to grab hold and caught only empty air. Dumbledore's Apparition was so seamless, so perfect, that even the best Seeker in the world could not have caught him. "No, Dumbledore, no!"

Harry hit the ground and felt nothing. He had been furious at Dumbledore for being alive, but he had never once wanted Dumbledore to die.

He had believed in Dumbledore's power, especially after discovering that Dumbledore was still alive, but he had also taken to heart what Dumbledore had said. I will not let you walk that path alone.

The path Harry was about to walk was a path to death. So how was Dumbledore going to walk it with him? Walk with him into death? He ran out like a madman, stumbling and scrambling, completely forgetting that Hogwarts now permitted Apparition.

The Death Eaters and the resisting forces cried out in shock at the same moment. There in the open ground stood that familiar figure, silver-white robes traced with golden patterns, bright blue eyes, and that warm, kindly face.

Dumbledore spoke. His voice was not loud, but it was perfectly clear.

"What Tom has said... is largely true."

No one paid any attention to who "Tom" was. All eyes were on Dumbledore's words alone. His candor sent the entire crowd into an uproar, and in doing so, silenced every other voice at once.

"I did indeed survive, with the help of a brilliant friend, and I deceived nearly the entire world." Dumbledore admitted it openly, without a trace of shame. "I was indeed afraid of death, and I used what I considered justifiable reasons to choose for myself a path of clinging on to life."

The moment the words landed, a student in the crowd shouted out:

"Dumbledore! We believe you're not that kind of person! As long as you're alive, none of that matters!"

Hearing those words, Dumbledore broke into a smile, bright, a little boyish, and shook his head gently.

"Thank you, Mr. Lewis, but it does matter." Dumbledore said. "I hid not for the sake of my reputation, but for the sake of a responsibility, a responsibility I could not leave for a child to bear alone. I deceived not for myself, but so that more people would have a chance to live."

Voldemort let out a cold laugh. "Dumbledore, there is nothing shameful in the will to survive, but there is in lies. You can certainly say it was for justice, for more people. Who cannot speak fine words? When a person wants an excuse, a hundred come without effort."

"Then let it be called an excuse." Dumbledore replied lightly. "Today I stand here not as any kind of... great wizard that anyone might imagine. That was only a symbol, a symbol that has long since died. I stand here simply as an ordinary old man. One who has made many mistakes, but who is still willing to use his last remaining strength to correct them, and to protect something that matters."

"The dear friend who brought me back to life once shared with me a phrase from the Muggle world, I rather liked it." Dumbledore looked in the direction of the Forbidden Forest. There was nothing there but the dense, dark woodland. "She told me: every saint has a past, and every sinner has a future."*

"If my efforts can prove to the whole world that even a life full of flaws still holds within it something beautiful worth sacrificing for, that even a selfish and fragile person can still choose a path of redemption, and dedicate that path to more people... then, Tom, this is my final answer."

In the Forbidden Forest, Praeris lifted her chin and closed her eyes.

It had been in Southend-on-Sea. She had vaguely sensed that Professor Snape might have committed some error he himself could not forgive, and she had chosen neither to probe into it nor to dwell on it.

"You are not the least bit curious?" Dumbledore had asked with a smile.

"If I were curious, would you tell me?"

"I would not."

"Then no, I am not curious, unless Professor Snape himself is willing to speak of it."

"Even if it might be dark, contemptible, and revolting?"

"Your vocabulary is quite rich."

"Not curious." She had repeated it once more. "Every saint has a past, every sinner has a future. The moment Professor Snape made the choices he has made, he already began to atone for his errors."

Admitting you are a bad person is, in its own way, a relief. After that, nothing you do wrong will prick your conscience. That was how Praeris had been, a long time ago.

But the consequence was that she found it very hard to allow herself to become good again, even after arriving in a kind environment, even after receiving a decent education. The moment she began to do something slightly better, even something as small as forgiving someone else's mistake, it only made everything from before seem more wrong. All the cruelty. The way she had gone back and forth terrorizing, toying with, and hurting Fiona and others.

Until she found this phrase. And in it, a reason to forgive herself, even if it made her seem contradictory, sometimes good and sometimes not.

Was Dumbledore a saint?

Many people thought so.

Was Dumbledore a sinner?

Many people thought so too.

But Dumbledore had made up his mind entirely. He no longer wanted to be a sinner. He wanted to atone, so he stepped forward, and cast aside whatever future he might still have had.

Without a word of warning, the battle began.

The opponent Voldemort faced was not Harry Potter. In this moment, he had none of that obsession, none of that need to repay with the Killing Curse, to reclaim the ground he had lost seventeen or eighteen years ago.

He twirled his wand and fired off several powerful bolts of dark lightning in quick succession. The soul-condensing potion had made him powerful again.

Dumbledore swept the water of the Black Lake into a surging band, using its yielding force to meet the hard edge of Voldemort's black lightning. The lightning was caught and wrapped by the water, turning it into a crackling electrified whip that lashed back hard toward Voldemort and shook the very ground.

"Dumbledore is still every bit as powerful." Fred and George high-fived and let out a loud whistle.

In the earlier fighting, a massive explosion had ripped through a corridor, and the three brothers had been certain they were finished. Then, to their astonishment, a Slytherin had used a protective spell no one had ever heard of to block the entire attack right in the middle of the corridor.

"How did you do that!" Percy was completely astounded.

Meryl grabbed one of them in each hand. "Stop talking! Get up! Evan is only good at this one thing!"

That Slytherin was Evan Travers, the boyfriend of Meryl, a Muggle-born witch under the protection of the Order of the Phoenix. Evan said he had found the powerful protective spell in a battered old book from his family's collection and had practiced it for nearly an entire year.

A full year. One single spell.

"I told you I would protect you." Evan said proudly to Meryl.

Fred burst out laughing. "Being saved by a Slytherin feels really strange."

"Then you can go die." Meryl said flatly.

"Then it wouldn't feel strange anymore." George said.

Percy worked hard and squeezed out a joke. "Thank us, then, we proved Travers's reliability."

"So lame." Meryl pulled the corner of her mouth.

Evan ran alongside them, grinning to himself.

Back on the battlefield, the electrified water whip surged toward Voldemort like a living dragon. The impact shook the ground itself. Voldemort spent considerable effort before he could finally destroy it, scattering it into a torrential downpour.

"Roughly a stalemate." Snape raised his wand and conjured a magical umbrella, sheltering himself and Praeris from the rain.

Praeris's Insight Charm was easy to learn and easy to use. Snape joined her in watching the battle from a distance.

Praeris shook her head slowly. "No. Dumbledore didn't break through the Dark Lord's attack, he neutralized it. He's not generating force of his own. He's guiding the force already present in the environment."

"Dumbledore borrowed Voldemort's black lightning, transformed the water of the Black Lake into an electrified water dragon, turned the enemy's own weapon against him, and layered his own magic on top of it to achieve an effect far beyond the strength it cost him." She paused. "He's conserving his strength."

The words had barely left her mouth when Voldemort rose into the air. He swung his wand and summoned an enormous serpentine column of Fiendfyre, trying to crush Dumbledore from both above and below simultaneously.

The Fiendfyre advanced with devastating force, roaring and crackling, evaporating every raindrop in its path, warping the sky itself in ways the naked eye could see.

Praeris felt a jolt of alarm. How could this be countered? Fiendfyre cannot be extinguished, the only options are Finite Incantatem or its specific counter-curse.

But against this kind of assault, Dumbledore's Finite Incantatem alone could not completely destroy it. And a counter-curse, a counter-curse could certainly work, but Dumbledore would be burned alive before he ever had the chance to cast it.

Unless there was some way to hold the Fiendfyre back first.

Sure enough, Dumbledore and Praeris had arrived at the same thought. But his combat experience ran so deep that he had already thought several steps further than a merely clever Praeris.

Just moments before, the enormous water dragon had been shattered by Voldemort and had come crashing down as a torrential rain, and that rain had soaked the earth beneath Dumbledore's feet.

Dumbledore swung his wand. Without any great effort, he transformed the wet ground into a vast magical bog. It held the Fiendfyre in check just long enough for him to cast the counter-curse and break it apart.

Voldemort unleashed more and more powerful, more and more terrifying magic. Again and again. And each of those spells, upon reaching Dumbledore, was met and dissolved with effortless ease.

The whole scene felt like a quiet mockery of everything Voldemort had ever pursued.


➤ Next: Racing Toward Death