HP: TSH — Chapter 271 - Persuasion
As true as that was, no subordinate would be naive enough to believe their superior capable of genuine empathy, especially not when that superior was Voldemort, teetering on the edge of madness.
Snape's gaze was deep and unreadable. He watched Praeris in silence. This student he had trained. This child he had watched grow up.
His entire life seemed to have been spent in regret, like a gambler crushed under compound debt who believed one more risk would win him money and happiness, would make up for the pain and the losses, yet who only sank himself deeper into a mire where every struggle pulled him further down, and took his loved ones with him in the end.
In the early days, this silence had often made Praeris feel as though needles were pricking her back. She moved carefully, acted carefully, terrified of provoking him.
As for now... time was a curious thing. That dreadful silence and its oppressive weight had long since lost the power to make her tense. Sir, that stopped working on me ages ago.
It was human instinct, deeply ingrained. When you know that everything a person does comes from love rather than hate, when you know they care about you sometimes more than they care about themselves, it becomes very difficult to fear them.
Just as no child truly fears a mother who loves them, those frightening gestures, you know she means well, even when you don't want to accept it.
Praeris understood this perfectly. She had genuinely experienced a few years of a happy family, however brief.
"I don't see it that way, Miss." Snape's tone was ice. "You have overstepped. This is entirely my affair, and absolutely not your responsibility. Your task is to follow my instructions —"
"And watch you take the full force of his wrath?" Praeris gave a cold laugh. "I'm sorry. I can't do that."
"Just as you refuse to let me put myself in danger, I cannot stand by and watch you suffer! Sir, don't try to tell me this is nothing serious. If it were truly nothing, Professor Sinistra would not have had to cover classes for an entire day!"
In the span of a few minutes, Praeris had interrupted Snape twice. The sheer audacity of it was enough to make every student in Hogwarts stare.
Snape's temper rose. His voice stayed cold. "Miss, I don't believe I ever taught you to behave this way, did I?"
"This is not one of your usual simple tasks, and the person you are dealing with is not some muddled fool like Carrow. The Dark Lord is far more skilled at Legilimency than you imagine. Far more unpredictable. Far more dangerous."
"I rather think Neville Longbottom must have scrambled your brains. To think that even someone like you has taken up Potter's brand of heroism, believing you can save people. That is profoundly foolish."
"Sir, you know I'm not that kind of person." Praeris recognized that Professor Snape was trying to provoke her and worked hard to stay calm. "You also know that I want to live more than anyone."
"You know how many plans and hopes I have for the future. I want to finish my studies. I want to continue my research. You've seen my long list of plans."
"Beyond that, there are things you don't know about. I want to go to China — Millicent Bulstrode has been there, and we girls want to travel. I want to go to America; Winnie said she wants to take me to visit Miss Smith. I want to go to Uganda — that's Professor Sinistra's homeland. The savannah stretches as far as the eye can see there, and the night sky is calm and brilliant."
"And connected to all those places are the people I love, and the people who love me. I want us all to share a happy future together."
Praeris paused. Her lips moved slightly. Her gaze trembled as she looked toward Snape.
"Sir, after the last time I saw certain people, they disappeared from my life forever, and I had no idea that meeting was the end. I don't want, I don't want —"
She didn't finish. She trusted Snape could understand what she had left unspoken. Florin's death had already brought her endless regret. She could not bear to imagine the day she might hear terrible news about Professor Snape.
When Sirius had been in danger, Praeris had offered Felix Felicis to help, but she had also criticized Harry for acting on impulse, believing his recklessness served no purpose and could even get people killed.
But now, standing in Harry's position, with Professor Snape standing in Sirius's place, he certainly wouldn't want to hear those words from her. She found herself forced into Harry's exact feeling, and understood his state of mind far better than she ever had before.
She knew, deeply, that Professor Snape's past successes in persuading Voldemort were no guarantee of success this time. And even if he succeeded, that did not mean he would escape unscathed.
When the hard approach failed, Snape tried soft.
"So you believe you're helping me," he said. "That this is for my own good? Miss, your heart is not made of stone. Do you think I want to see you walk the same road I walked?"
Snape had once projected onto Praeris an image of himself who had chosen a different path, just as he had once searched for Lily's shadow in Harry.
Undeniable. He had done that foolish thing.
But gradually, he had come to realize how unfair it was. A person is only ever themselves. She could not be anyone else.
Whether searching for Lily's shadow in another, or projecting himself onto Praeris, both were a failure to respect the individual will of two young women.
And so Snape had stopped demanding things of Praeris. He stopped telling her how her research ought to be done. He told her only what was wrong, and let her create freely, let her do the things she chose to do.
But fate was merciless. Just as Snape had gradually learned to respect Praeris's independence, she was being driven, whether by forces imposed on her or chosen by herself, to stand at the same crossroads he once had.
"Miss, once you become a Death Eater, there is no road back." Snape's brow furrowed hard. "Let me paint you a picture of what lies ahead. You will watch innocent people die before you. It could be anyone in the Order of the Phoenix. It could be Brown. You will remember every one of them — every face at the point of death, every piercing scream. You have never been able to learn to forget!"
"What do you think the Dark Lord will let you research? He will want you to cross into forbidden territory. Research into the soul. Have I not made it clear enough what dark and terrible work that is?"
"Look at me, Miss! A living example of what you will gain. Eternal regret. You are so clever. Would you truly repeat my mistakes?"
Praeris stood alone in the middle of the office. She had grown older, but no fuller than she had been in her younger years, these years of hardship had worn down more than just Snape and Draco.
Yet even so, her gaze was steady. She was resolved, without a moment's hesitation, to walk this road. A moth flying into flame.
"Sir, I am not being reckless. I am fully clear-headed about what I must face." Her voice was measured, unhurried. "It is precisely because of what you have been through that I must do this."
"We have already walked a very long road. There is not much of it left. When the time comes — if we win, the Mark will mean nothing. If we lose, the Mark will mean nothing either."
Praeris had thought it through clearly.
If the Order of the Phoenix won, Voldemort would be dead, and the Dark Mark would vanish, just as the enchantments Dumbledore had set disappeared after his "death."
If the Order of the Phoenix lost, it would no longer matter whether she was a Death Eater or not. If the entire world had become hell, what essential difference did it make which torment she suffered?
"My Occlumency was taught to me by you, sir. You're more than welcome to enter my mind and test my level." Praeris spoke steadily, each word deliberate. "If I fall short, we can discuss other options then. Agreed?"
The moment she finished speaking, she felt Snape use Legilimency on her, the suddenness of it comparable to Moaning Myrtle bursting in to invite her for a water fight while she was in the bath.
Fortunately, Praeris's Occlumency, if not quite effortless, could at least be called masterful.
What Snape saw was this: after he had relayed Voldemort's instructions, Praeris's eyes had visibly brightened; she had asked questions with a certain nervousness and hesitation, while he had merely told her, dismissively, that she would find out when she got there.
Praeris asked calmly: "I wonder, sir, are you satisfied? There's no need to worry about my being caught off guard by an intrusion. I am perfectly capable of keeping my mind in this state at all times,"
As she finished, Snape's field of view was flooded with a torrent of jumbled content: page after page of books, piece after piece of knowledge. Potions. Charms. Transfiguration. History of Magic. Modern texts, recent history, ancient records, canonical volumes, newspapers, torn scraps of paper, roadside pamphlets. Everything imaginable, like the tornado corridor of the North American plains, one twister after another rolling through without end.
And her thoughts swept past just as rapidly, just as densely, impossible to keep up with. Heaven only knew how she could think so many things at the same time.
"Enough!" Snape was forced to break off the Legilimency. "Very well!"
He had no choice but to accept it. Praeris was prepared, and she had adequate expectations of what she would face.
"Sir, if we fail, you, Miss Winnie, and Lady Priya will all have to die." Praeris said quietly. "If I were the only one left alive, what difference would that be from dying myself?"
"Sir, winter has already passed. Spring is on its way." She smiled. "You've been in here and may not have noticed, the water in the Black Lake has risen, hasn't it?"
A flash in Snape's mind: his office of many years. The windows submerged by the Black Lake, overgrown with waterweeds. And on the desk, bright yellow daffodils.
It seemed he had never truly managed to refuse any choice Praeris made, just as he had never been able to change Lily's mind.
Praeris left with the report.
Since the fate of continuing the experiments could not be changed, there was no need to write anything that would displease Voldemort.
She would of course write that, despite her recent serious illness and her mind still not being entirely right, she remained willing to serve the Dark Lord, through fire and flood, without hesitation.
She had never expected it would come to this. Back in the day, Praeris had heard quite a few stories about Miss Stella's humiliating boot-licking of Umbridge right after graduation. Now, before Praeris herself had even graduated, she was going to reenact that tragedy.
Without any warning, in one fluid motion, Praeris drew her wand and, BANG, sent a Gryffindor flying like a Bludger. He skidded along the floor a good distance after landing before finally stopping.
Every passing witch and wizard cried out in shock, hands flying to their mouths, eyes wide.
Damn it, Praeris cursed inwardly. How on earth are Neville Longbottom and Ginny managing their people? To let a fourth-year have the nerve to come and provoke her!
Right now, in broad daylight and in full view of everyone, how could Praeris, a Slytherin through and through, possibly let this go easily?
She walked over at a leisurely pace and came to a stop at his feet. She tilted her chin up and looked down at the name on his chest. "Louis. A good name."
"How curious." She gave Louis a light kick and pointed to the name on her own robes. "What does this say? Tell me. You can read, can't you?"
Her tone was genuinely puzzled. "I truly don't understand who gave you the courage to think you could challenge me, even by ambushing me."
Louis was sucking in air in short, shallow gasps, one hand pressed to his chest as though he'd been struck hard. He pushed against the floor and edged backward, slowly propping his upper body up. "Nobody gave me the courage. I wanted this myself! Damn Slytherin! The Carrow twins' lapdog! A vile Death Eater-in-training!"
In the past, words like that would not have sparked even a flicker of anger in Praeris. But that last sentence caught her unexpectedly and stung.
"Ha, vile Slytherin?" Praeris laughed with contempt. A flick of her wand and he was bound. "And I suppose that makes you a noble Gryffindor, does it? Noble by way of ambush, hmm?"
"My, my, brave Gryffindor charging at me, the cowardly Slytherin, like a knight on a quest. You've quite terrified me, fresh out of the hospital wing as I am! It seems I have no choice but to hand you over to... hmm, Professor Amycus Carrow. Nearby!"
At her words, fear crossed Louis's face.
And so Praeris dragged Louis along, just as Professor Snape had dragged Neville Longbottom a few days before. The difference being that she used magic, which saved the effort.
They were on the fourth floor. Amycus Carrow's office was on the third.
The reason Praeris had not chosen to go up to the fifth floor and hand him over to Professor Snape was, firstly, that going downstairs was less effort than going up, and it was on the way back to the Slytherin common room.
Secondly, before reaching Amycus's office, she would pass through the Charms classroom, located on the fourth floor, near the corridor leading down to the third.
"Ah! Pra, Prince, what is the meaning of this!" Professor Flitwick cried out when he saw Praeris dragging someone along. "Is this Gryffindor's Louis Bedford!"
Praeris gave Louis a cold glance. "That's right, Professor Flitwick. Mr. Bedford openly attacked me in the corridor. I subdued him."
Louis glared at Praeris with open hostility, then turned to Professor Flitwick with a pleading look.
Professor Flitwick coughed awkwardly. "Mr. Bedford, this will not do! Here is what I'll do, I'm sending you to Hagrid. He needs help patrolling the Forbidden Forest."
➤ Next: Second Visit to Malfoy Manor
