HP: TSH — Chapter 267 - Light in the Darkness
Neville was dragged out by Snape.
Snape hauled him along like a half-dead stray dog.
The Cruciatus Curse had ravaged Neville's body, but he still held onto some stubborn breath of defiance, glaring viciously at Snape as if ready to tear into his enemy at any moment. Not a single trace of yielding.
Neville understood exactly what he represented right now. He was Dumbledore's Army. He was Hogwarts's resistance. They had just "taken down" a "future Death Eater," disrupted Voldemort's plans, and their morale was at its peak.
If Neville couldn't endure, if he grew afraid, if he showed even a sliver of weakness, it would diminish the victory Praeris had willingly sacrificed herself to secure. He could only hold on. He had to hold on.
Snape bound Neville like a mummy and placed him beneath the statue in the entrance hall, so every passing student could "admire" his "heroic bearing."
"Behold this... valiant Gryffindor warrior." His voice was low and slow, carrying to every ear in the hall. "Professor Carrow told me you refused to use the Cruciatus Curse on your classmates in class. But today — you aimed your wand at your own classmate. She was focused on her potion. Completely defenseless. And you left her severely injured."
The gathered students broke into murmurs, buzzing like mosquitoes and flies. The noise made Neville's head swim. He had just been through the office. His stomach turned and he wanted to retch, so he pressed his lips tightly together and glared at Snape with everything he had.
Praeris. Their comrade.
Neville felt despicable.
It wasn't that he hadn't thought about it. Praeris's cooperation could reduce Dumbledore's Army's losses, but what about her? She was Dumbledore's Army too. She was his comrade.
Choose one person, or choose more people?
Abandon one person, or abandon more people?
Guilt had tormented him night after night, keeping him awake, turning the same question over and over in his head, searching for a way to satisfy both sides.
There wasn't one.
If such a method existed, would Praeris not have found it?
Neville was clumsy. He didn't have the quick, sharp minds of Hermione and Praeris. All he could do was rack his brains and go through every possibility one by one.
Praeris couldn't pretend she lacked the skill, because the person supervising her task was her own mentor, Snape, and Snape knew her abilities inside and out. She couldn't refuse the task either, or Voldemort and the Death Eaters would never let her go.
Her only choice was to carry on until she couldn't anymore, until the conditions to continue ceased to exist. Until, for example, she was severely injured.
Neville had known exactly what Praeris was about to face, and he had still chosen this path. Prepared to harm her with his own hands.
The rest of Dumbledore's Army had been waiting too, waiting for Neville to decide when to finally shatter Praeris's task completely. He had delayed it for a long time with one excuse after another. Now even Praeris herself had agreed. He had no reason left to hold back.
When Neville and Ginny Weasley opened the medicine box together, both of them saw the small silver-white piece inside at the same moment.
"I'll do it!" Ginny Weasley said without a second thought. "Getting the Quaffle through the scoring hoop is my specialty!"
Ginny Weasley was always like that, brave and fearless. Aside from a time when she'd once lacked confidence in her own feelings, she almost never hesitated. Her resolve and courage were a steady flame for everyone around her.
"No, Ginny." Neville had rarely been more decisive. "Let me."
That decisiveness was the result of countless sleepless hours. If someone had to carry the guilt of harming a comrade, Neville wanted that burden to stop with him alone.
It wasn't easy. He had spent a long time steeling himself for it. He had to convince himself, over and over, that this was also for Praeris's freedom, and only then could he summon the courage to throw that silver-white piece.
Back when he was a younger student, Neville had heard of Praeris. People said she was a formidable witch. To him she had always seemed cold, intimidating, and, inexplicably, a little like Snape.
After that thought had taken hold, Neville found himself even less able to look her in the eye. He was afraid of Snape to his core. A Slytherin who reminded him of Snape was not someone he could face easily.
In fourth year, Snape had punished him by ordering him to disembowel horned toads. Neville had a toad as a pet. He simply could not do it.
In the end, it was Praeris who supervised that punishment, and what she did changed everything.
She was still just as intimidating. When she questioned him, her strict manner made his heart race and forced him to summon every ounce of focus he had. But she never criticized his mistakes. It seemed that in her eyes, a mistake was simply a mistake, as normal as eating or drinking.
Yes, a mistake was just a mistake. Nothing more. Acknowledge it, face it, and you would arrive at the correct answer. The only thing left was to remember it, learn it, and move on.
No humiliation. No punishment. Nothing that made Neville feel he couldn't hold his head up. Pointing out a mistake only meant one thing: here is what is correct.
This witch did not target Gryffindor. Before knowledge, everyone was equal. When she asked questions and someone got it wrong, even Malfoy would get a scolding.
So when Ginny Weasley told him that Praeris was Thalia, a trusted companion of Hermione's, and a member of Dumbledore's Army, Neville accepted it with almost no struggle at all.
"I imagine you think this is fair." Snape's icy, mocking voice pulled Neville back from his memories. "Brave, even. You call this justice, do you?"
"Look at this figure who fancies himself a hero. His parents — the Longbottoms — said to have been heroes among the Aurors, who sacrificed everything and became... empty shells. And yet the only legacy they left behind, their beloved son, turns his blade on a defenseless classmate and takes pride in it."
Snape's words made Neville tremble. He couldn't tell whether it was because his parents were being used as weapons against him, or because he had genuinely harmed his own comrade. Perhaps both.
"I wonder, for that couple — which is more humiliating? Their current condition, or watching their only child be so... pathetically incompetent, base, and shameless? It causes them such greater anguish, I'm sure. Perhaps Bellatrix Lestrange at least spared them from witnessing this... disappointment."
Snape's words set off another wave of murmuring. The Slytherins sneered at Neville's incompetence and baseness. Students from the other houses looked away, unable to watch.
Ginny Weasley stood among them, her eyes burning with resentment and sorrow. She wanted to charge forward and put her fist straight through Snape's face.
She couldn't.
The reason she was still standing in this crowd, rather than suffering alongside Neville, was because Neville had voluntarily stayed behind to cover their retreat. Her safety had been bought with his. She still carried half of his burden on her shoulders. She had no right to throw it all away.
For a Gryffindor, it would have been so simple. Shout something about friendship, and charge.
But more than half a year of resistance had taught her that courage alone was hollow. Real bravery was courage and wisdom together. Controlling your own impulse was itself an extraordinary kind of courage, it meant you had won the battle against your own instincts.
So Ginny Weasley stood in the crowd, clenched her fists, and forced herself to watch. She told herself: Ginny, look at this. Don't turn away. Remember this moment. You need to become stronger, strong enough that enemies cannot break your spells, strong enough to protect the people beside you.
"You — you mentioned my parents." Neville's voice trembled, but it climbed louder with every word. "Yes. They were tortured into madness. But they never yielded. They never sold anyone out. You stand here wearing Dumbledore's title, and yet — yet you do the same things as Lestrange. What difference is there between you and her?"
That counterattack landed hard.
You call me base, but what you do is baser than anything I've done. What right do you have to judge me?
"Yes. I'm incompetent." Neville's voice was slow and steady. "My Potions homework is a disaster. I forget things constantly. Plenty of people think I'm not even worth a Squib. But you can insult my ability all you like. You cannot insult my character. You cannot insult my family. I am not the kind of wizard who bullies others for no reason. And I would never torture anyone."
"Snape. And the Carrow siblings. You know exactly what you've been demanding Praeris Prince do. Blow up that classroom, and I won't feel a single shred of guilt!"
He would feel some guilt. Not for the classroom, though. For the price they had paid. For what had been done to their comrade.
"Is that so?" Snape sneered. "Then say it. Tell me clearly, what exactly have I been demanding my student do?"
Neville went silent. He knew Voldemort had assigned Praeris the task of researching a potion. He didn't know what potion. Praeris had never told them the full scope of her task.
"Nothing to say?" Snape's voice dripped with contempt. "Because of Mr. Longbottom's latest foolish attempt to display courage he simply does not possess, Gryffindor loses sixty points. Thank him for it. This is the gift Mr. Longbottom has brought you."
Sixty points.
Harry had only earned sixty points for protecting the Philosopher's Stone. Neville alone had just lost the same.
"Snape!" Neville ground the words out through his teeth. "You know in your heart what you're making her do. You deserve what's coming to you, and she, she didn't deserve any less from us either!" He looked at the gathered students. "He wants you to hate me. He wants you to think I'm the source of the problem. But the real source of the problem is them."
Neville glared at Snape and the Carrow siblings, his voice rising. "Without them, how would Hogwarts have come to this? They are the source of fear. They are the source of trouble. Don't, don't hate me just because you're too afraid to hate them. We shouldn't be turning on each other."
The Carrow siblings had heard enough. This damned Longbottom was far too inflammatory. He needed to be shut up.
Amycus silenced him with a spell on the spot. Alecto launched into a one-sided tirade, trying to smother everything Neville had just said.
This was precisely the beginning of their failure.
They silenced him before Snape had "defeated" him. All that did was make it look like they had run out of arguments. Like Snape had no better rebuttal.
Snape understood this perfectly. He said nothing anyway, allowing the Carrow siblings to drag things down, as if he could have stopped those two from making fools of themselves regardless.
When it was all over, Ginny Weasley dragged her exhausted body to the Room of Requirement, forced herself upright, and led the remaining members of Dumbledore's Army through their training.
She had already suppressed one wave of outrage before this, holding everyone back from charging out to rescue Neville.
"Neville got caught to reduce our casualties!" she had said, fighting to keep her voice steady over the worry coiling through her. "If we walk straight into the trap now, we waste everything he gave up for us! Professor McGonagall is already fighting to minimize his punishment. What we need to do is train harder, get stronger, and come up with a solid plan before we go after Neville. Not charge out on an emotional rush and get ourselves killed."
She had told everyone not to act on emotion. She had been drowning in it the entire time. In the past, she had been the impulsive one, and Neville had been the voice saying don't. Now Neville was the one in chains, and somehow she had become the person saying the words he used to say.
She watched everyone channel their grief and anger into training, redoubling their efforts, and she kept telling herself to do the same. Pull yourself together, Ginny.
She made a round of the room, correcting a few members' mistakes, and then her eyes landed on the medicine box sitting in the corner.
She had no idea how Praeris was doing.
She had watched with her own eyes as Praeris was blasted across the room. She had no excuse to visit her. No reason anyone would believe. She drifted toward the wooden box almost without meaning to, ran her fingers along its surface, and froze the moment she opened it.
The box was full. Packed solid with potions.
Ginny Weasley looked up immediately toward Barron. The little nurse was already walking toward her.
"I brought it," Barron said, voice barely above a whisper. "But it also wasn't me who brought it. I was going to ask Madam Pomfrey about disposing of some potions, but she refused. Said it would be unsafe for me and would compromise the Hospital Wing."
Praeris's exact words had been: "Do you want the other students to hate you? Barron, if you drag the Hospital Wing into this for Dumbledore's Army, and give the Carrow siblings a reason to search it, occupy it, and strip everyone else of the last safe place they have to be treated and rest and breathe, they will hate you for it. That is human nature."
"So she prepared these in advance." Barron's voice was just barely audible. "The smallest bottle. It's the kind St. Mungo's uses for Cruciatus Curse injuries. She said it isn't ideal, but she didn't have time to improve it. We'll have to make do."
Ginny Weasley carefully lifted out the last small bottle and held it in her palm.
For a moment, she nearly cried.
This was for Neville.
It had to be for Neville.
Praeris had been forced to serve Voldemort. She had planned the scheme that allowed Dumbledore's Army to destroy her own task. She had taken serious injury for it. And even so, she had still thought of Neville.
She had known. She had known that Dumbledore's Army would almost certainly not wait for Neville's punishment to end before they acted, that they would find a way to get to him. So she had prepared this bottle in advance.
She had thought of it before any of them had.
➤ Next: Capable Right Hand
