HP: TSH — Chapter 255 - The Badger's Battle
It happened during breakfast, with people coming and going at the entrance to the Great Hall. A few stopped to watch. Others murmured quietly among themselves.
"Ah." Praeris said with icy sarcasm. "If your parents had served even the slightest purpose in raising you, they would have told you that when you bump into someone, you apologize first. You don't go touching other people's things without permission."
In other words, Praeris was saying this large Gryffindor had no upbringing. To put it more harshly, she was mocking him for having no parents — which was why he had so little decency.
This may have been said in line with Pansy Parkinson's words, but for anyone who knew the inside story, it was hard to imagine Praeris talking back in this manner.
As a witch who could fairly be described as having no parents herself, it was difficult to tell whether she was cursing him out, still holding some expectation for the idea of "parents," or simply being self-deprecating.
Under normal circumstances, bumping into someone and picking up their things carries the intent of making amends. This Gryffindor clearly had no such intent. He neither apologized nor kept the barbs out of his words. No wonder Praeris was caustic.
Having failed to get what he wanted and been thoroughly dressed down, the large Gryffindor's face went ugly, as if he'd swallowed a basin of flobberworms whole, and he finally left with a belly full of anger.
Pansy Parkinson rolled her eyes hard and made an inverted V with her fingers to show exactly what she thought of him.
With Pansy Parkinson's help and that of other Slytherins passing by, the few things spilled from Praeris's bag were quickly gathered up. She slung the bag across her body instead of over one shoulder and cast a cold glance at the Gryffindor table.
"That's how it was." Praeris said, something almost like complaint in her voice. "Sir, they must have been after my experimental notes."
"Experimental notes?" Snape's expression was even more pointed than Praeris's. "Miss, you mean... notes?"
Knowing Praeris as he did, experimental notes were about as useful to Praeris as a bicycle was to a fish.
"Notes, yes." Praeris seemed to find nothing remotely absurd in her own words. "And that is merely one of the matters worth attention!"
Snape adjusted his posture, and something faint, barely detectable, entered his tone. "Do tell."
On the evening of the day she had been deliberately knocked into, Praeris returned to her laboratory after classes — the abandoned classroom underground.
The moment she reached the door, she sensed it. The protective magic she had set showed signs of having been triggered.
"Traces." Praeris said, trying to explain. "Do you understand, sir? Someone attempted to enter my laboratory."
Snape fell into thought. "Last night it was..."
"Professor Amycus Carrow was responsible for patrolling the underground structures." Praeris answered without hesitation. "But Professor Carrow appears to have noticed nothing. Which means whoever came must have been acting with premeditation."
Snape had not yet fully grasped what Praeris was after, and he suspected Praeris knew that perfectly well.
So, faced with this, what he needed to do was give the reaction he would normally give. If there were any additional needs, Praeris would find a way to signal them.
"Miss, your conjectures are quite interesting." Snape said with an air of indifference. "But this is neither the Daily Prophet nor Witch Weekly, and I have no need for a conspiracy-obsessed Skeeter. The first incident sounds entirely like a routine bump. As for the second..."
"Nothing actually happened, did it?" he said, his voice soft and measured. "I imagine you and Lovegood's daughter would find common ground. She's always going on in class, at every possible moment, about Nargles and things of that sort. No one has ever seen one."
"Sir, I am not joking." Praeris said with urgency.
"There, there. No need to say more." Snape dismissed her. "I will note your request and inform Professor Carrow to strengthen patrols and security."
Praeris left the headmaster's office looking heavy with worry, thus completing an unconventional form of notification to Professor Snape.
Snape's final words were not merely a brush-off. He said he would remind Amycus, and he did.
At the request of Snape, who was effectively his superior, Amycus had no choice but to make the trip to the abandoned classroom himself.
His weight leaned left. His right foot tapped the floor lightly and without stop. Lips pressed together, corners of his mouth turned down, his gaze swept the crude little laboratory in a purely perfunctory pass.
"I don't see anything wrong." Amycus said with impatience. "Miss Prince, if your experiments aren't progressing and you're under strain, just say so. You're young. Don't end up like Alastor Moody, paranoid every waking hour, convinced someone is out to get you."
Praeris's demands and Snape's warning had together forced the Carrow siblings to send the trolls away. The trolls they had been using on the students.
According to Snape, it wasn't simply a matter of experimental precision. More importantly, one of the Dark Lord's purposes in keeping Hogwarts running was stability.
Trolls were too conspicuous. They lacked the intelligence to measure how far was too far, in the way Death Eaters could.
The students still at Hogwarts were all half-bloods or pure-bloods. However much they were tormented in private, it hardly counted as a serious matter. But if someone actually died, the repercussions would be unpleasant. Certain reporters, operating from outside the country, were already saying reckless things with no apparent fear of consequences.
The Carrow siblings had no choice but to abandon the trolls and settle for redoubling their cruelty afterward, to compensate for the frustration.
What infuriated Amycus even more was this: he had spent real time learning about Praeris's improved Elixir to Induce Euphoria, preparing to put on a fine show of diligence before the Dark Lord. Then Snape had pulled the Dark Lord's attention away in just a few sentences, rattling off things Amycus couldn't begin to follow.
Praeris's improvement process had been logically clean, her reasoning complete, and the results had met first-stage expectations. Minimized side effects. Precision of effect. Achieved.
Compared to other wizards who could spend months on something without a single visible result, this level of efficiency left no room for complaint.
But what did any of that have to do with Amycus?
He had painstakingly provided Praeris with everything she needed, and Snape had walked in and taken all the credit. How could he not be furious?
Faced with Amycus's resentment, Snape simply did not see it.
Voldemort wanted his subordinates to work without hindering each other, but he also didn't want them too friendly. If the Carrow siblings and Snape stopped having friction between them, that would be when Voldemort grew uneasy.
So Amycus, who had once been more or less supportive of Praeris, now spoke with open ill temper and couldn't be bothered to look closely at anything she said.
"I don't agree." Praeris delivered her warning with full seriousness. "Even if those rebellious students don't know I serve the Dark Lord, they would still take pleasure in destroying my research."
"I have my experimental notes and reports here, my regular instruments, rare herbs and magical creature materials, phased experimental results. Among them, some potions were accidents. I may not be able to determine in time exactly why they turned out the way they did."
Anyone who has done experimental work knows this: sometimes even following the exact same steps will not produce the same result.
This is how incomprehensible traditions form in potion-making. How strange rituals accumulate over generations.
Until someone finally discovers that you don't actually need to wear plain robes and cut mistletoe like a druid for the brew to succeed. You just need to wait the same length of time before adding the mistletoe. As for why any wizard started imitating druids in the first place, don't ask.
In short: yes, the potion failed because the cauldron temperature wasn't high enough.
Just like that kind of laughable reason, sometimes a desired effect appears during a brew but simply cannot be replicated in the short term. Finding the cause takes time. If the original batch is contaminated or destroyed before the cause is identified, it is a devastating blow.
Praeris wore an expression of barely contained patience, working through all of this with Amycus step by step, emphasizing why protecting the laboratory mattered.
Amycus didn't understand any of it. He only grasped that Praeris was telling him to protect this run-down classroom.
"Alright, alright!" he said, irritable. "Alecto and I will pay attention. Just make sure you store those notes and things yourself!"
"I hope so." Praeris said coolly.
"Miss Prince, rather than fretting over things that haven't even happened, you'd be better off focusing on your actual task!" Amycus, thick-headed as ever, had the nerve to lecture her. "The Dark Lord thinks highly of your previous results and your next phase. But don't you go treating that as the finish line."
He let out two rough, wheezing laughs. "It won't be so funny when you trip and fall!"
Praeris's expression tightened. She cast a deliberate glance at the experimental records on the table, then pulled her gaze away, and said with visible stiffness: "Of course. I will not disappoint the Dark Lord's expectations."
Amycus left with suspicion written across his face and ran into his sister Alecto on the second floor. He gave a mocking laugh. "That student of Snape's probably thinks her place with us is already secured."
"Prince?" Alecto was playing with her fingernails. "She behaves well enough in my class," she said, her tone indifferent. "What's she done?"
She listened to Amycus's account, then scoffed. "That little bitch must have hit a wall with her experiments and can't swallow it. Ah, aren't people like her all the same?"
Neither of them took it seriously. The siblings didn't know enough about potion experimentation to believe anything was truly unrepeatable. As long as the notes and any materials that could leak secrets were kept safe, the rest was nothing to worry about.
Praeris had thought the Carrow siblings might at least hold some degree of wariness. She hadn't expected they genuinely couldn't be bothered.
"Things have become dull." Praeris thought. "This won't do. I need to add some spice."
She couldn't give the Carrow siblings any room to defend themselves. If they turned around and insisted she hadn't explained clearly enough, shifting the blame onto her, the whole thing would fall short of what she needed.
At just past four in the morning, close to five, Ernie rose from the soft sofa in the Hufflepuff common room, felt for his Invisibility Cloak, and pulled it over himself.
Across from him, Hannah was doing the same. Her hands were trembling slightly from nerves.
Ernie tried to keep his voice low. "Maybe I should just go alone."
"No! Ernie, I'm not afraid!" Hannah said, her fists tight at her sides. "I'm just excited!"
For her mother. For herself. Hannah had waited far too long for a chance to hurt the Death Eaters. As long as she could make them miserable, she was willing to do anything.
Ernie had to pour cold water on that. "Save the excitement for when we actually succeed."
He pulled the fake Galleon from his pocket and watched it without blinking until the numbers changed.
"Go!" He said it fast. "Neville and the others are moving!"
Badgers live underground. Their senses are sharp, and they move at night. This pair of Hufflepuff prefects slipped out of the common room just like their house animal — fast, low, and sure — moving nimbly through the dim firelight.
Neville had told them: based on what other DA members had scoped out, Praeris Prince had moved her rare herbs and experimental materials to Snape's storage room.
According to their intelligence, Snape had left the castle at dusk, presumably for a meeting with Voldemort. This was their window to destroy those ingredients.
The snow and ice were melting. The high-water period was almost here. But Snape's office sat roughly halfway between the entrance hall and the underground passage, and before the water fully rose, a quarter of the office window still cleared the surface. Hannah was small enough to fit through.
The two of them made their way to the first floor, entered a classroom facing the lake, and opened the window.
Hannah was much lighter than Ernie, so he gripped her left wrist with both hands and lowered her out over the water.
"Stupefy!"
Her spell struck the upper part of Snape's window. CRACK, breaking glass. She pushed off and vaulted through the gap.
The moment the glass shattered, the clock started.
No matter how long Neville and the others could stall, it wouldn't be long enough. Forcing a standoff with Alecto would only mean more people getting hurt. Ernie and Hannah had to move.
Everyone knows badgers can run when they need to. Ernie, left behind in the first-floor classroom, turned on his heel and bolted for the stairs like a gust of wind. As he ran, he could clearly hear the noise breaking out above him.
Hannah landed clean. She hit the floor steady and saw it immediately: a box of herbs sitting alone on a separate desk.
Ginny had said Prince used these herbs regularly, so they wouldn't be buried somewhere hard to reach.
But no matter how Hannah had imagined this going, she hadn't imagined this. This was the complete opposite of hidden. So much for rare and precious herbs.
There was no time to think. Her heart was slamming so hard it felt like it wanted to climb out of her throat. She stumbled over the words:
"In — Incendio!"
➤ Next: Ignition and Extinguishing
