HP: TSH — Chapter 253 - Neville's Medal — Words Unspoken
Praeris's expression was unreadable, but she didn't expose what Draco was actually thinking.
"I've been rather busy lately and neglected you," she said, unhurried. "But that's wrapped up for now. Last time, you mentioned you've started practicing elemental transmutation?"
"That's right." Draco fell into step beside Praeris as they headed toward the common room. "Busy with what? Whatever kept you occupied must have been quite something."
"Potions research. For me, that's hardly insurmountable," Praeris said plainly. "So — how does the practice work? Have you actually started alchemy?"
"No." Hearing Praeris's easy answer, Draco didn't even notice his own quiet exhale of relief. He lifted his chin. "If you really want to see, I wouldn't mind spending a few minutes on a demonstration."
They entered the Slytherin common room. Draco pulled from his bag a small vial two fingers wide and a flat box. The vial held a colorless, transparent liquid. The box contained grayish-white lead pellets, each roughly the size of a blueberry.
Draco picked out a pellet with tweezers, let a single drop from the vial fall onto it, then raised his wand and incanted: "Converte!"
Under the magic, the grayish-white pellet turned silver-white in an instant.
"Transmuting lead into silver." Draco tilted his chin up, grinning with open satisfaction. "Out of the entire seventh year, I'm the only one who's managed it so far."
Praeris looked surprised. She genuinely was. She'd always known Draco had an interest in alchemy, known he had real talent for it, but she hadn't expected him to be this good.
She didn't hold back. "Draco, that's truly remarkable."
Draco's youth had begun with defeat. But how long can anyone endure darkness? Even a tree bends its branches toward the light.
The fields that had once interested him, that had once brought him joy, they had become the way he was piecing his confidence back together. Even if he'd voluntarily let go of some of those abilities, the ones that in his eyes had been stained with blood and terror.
Praeris wasn't simply flattering him. She genuinely thought it was impressive. With honest academic curiosity, she asked, "Doesn't this violate Gamp's Law of Elemental Transfiguration?"
"That's Transfiguration, and alchemy is a fundamentally different discipline," Draco said, with the particular confidence of someone who actually knew what they were talking about. "Take gold. What Transfiguration produces is something like gold. What alchemy produces is real gold. It's straightforward — Transfiguration is temporary and surface-level; alchemy is permanent and true."
Two distinct categories within the magical system, with different principles and different limits.
"So these lead pellets will be silver forever?" Praeris asked.
"Ahem." Draco cleared his throat. "This is our first foundational experiment in elemental transmutation. Do you follow?"
Praeris blinked. "I follow, so —"
"So the catalyst we're learning to brew is also temporary, far less potent than the Philosopher's Stone!" Draco said, words coming quickly. "Yes, this pellet is only temporarily transformed into silver — but it holds far longer than ordinary Transfiguration, and it persists independent of the caster's life or death. The silver I made in class will hold for a week. This piece here can probably last about three days..."
Praeris watched him scramble to recover his dignity and thought, with some private amusement, that he looked a bit like himself from a few years ago.
"You'll achieve something in this field." She rested her cheek against one hand and smiled at him, and she meant it. "I believe that."
Voldemort had written Draco off as cowardly and useless, never expecting him to accomplish anything. But Draco had not only learned Occlumency, he had actually repaired the Vanishing Cabinet and gotten Death Eaters into Hogwarts.
Draco was, in truth, a wizard of considerable potential. In Praeris's estimation, his talent for alchemy was no weaker than her own gift in Potions.
If not for Voldemort's return, he might have walked this path with far less difficulty. But by the same measure, his maturity would have come much later, and he'd probably still be that arrogant, insufferable Draco.
There was no clear right or wrong in any of that. But watching Draco grow, it wasn't only Lady Narcissa who would feel the ache of it.
Hearing Praeris's words, Draco pressed his lips together, then gave up trying to hide his pleasure. "Ah, I genuinely feel sorry for those fellows who can't manage even a bit of silver!"
"But my father always said there are too many unintelligent people in the world. We must tolerate the existence of idiots and let them do the things we'd rather not. Besides, without idiots around, how would our own exceptional nature stand out?"
Praeris reconsidered what she had just been thinking. She probably hadn't slept enough. Because she had genuinely just thought Draco had matured, and had felt something like wistfulness over it.
She tried to hold it in. She couldn't quite manage it. "Keep that kind of talk for me."
She didn't need to guess the context in which Lucius had said those things. Crabbe and Goyle had almost certainly been involved. With talk like that circling the air, it was no wonder Crabbe had harbored resentment.
Back in the girls' dormitory, Pansy delivered another installment of complaints about Draco. Those two, honestly, why not just take each other to court already?
Praeris soothed Pansy with practiced ease, and finally stole herself a brief rest: half an afternoon and one evening.
After that, Professor Snape deployed some caliber of linguistic artistry, the exact nature of which remained unknown, and actually persuaded the Carrow siblings to cancel the Troll plan. But without the Troll, there were still the Cruciatus Curse. And other torments.
In Muggle Studies, Alecto spent the lesson openly insulting Muggle-born witches and wizards. She had dug up old Hogwarts enrollment rolls, working through them one by one, dragging out names and slinging the ugliest language she had at those former students.
All of them were Muggle-born. Some had died horribly at the hands of the Carrow siblings themselves.
Neville slammed his palms on the table and stood up. He demanded loudly to know how much blood, Muggle blood, Muggle-born blood, was on Alecto and Amycus's hands. This wasn't Hogwarts's old registry, he said. This was a record of Death Eater crimes.
Praeris lowered her head. Her eyes dropped to the desk.
Around her, she could hear the students: suppressed sobbing, the sharp catch of frightened breath. Through it, she picked out the sounds of Neville arguing with Alecto, then Neville's scream, then the dull, heavy thud of him hitting the floor. He went down hard. For a moment he seemed to bounce, like a fish thrown on a riverbank, too weak to do anything but thrash.
Closer: the delighted laughter of Crabbe, Goyle, and several other Slytherins.
Whatever else was true, Praeris and Neville had known each other for six years. They had worked together for over half of one.
Out of reason, she would not put herself at risk for him again. She would not stand up for him. The only choice she made was not to look, her small, private gesture of respect for Neville, this reckless and genuine brave soul.
In her judgment, what Neville had done was foolish. A pointless sacrifice.
But the things she and Ginny had once talked through let her understand why people made decisions like his:
Some things are not done because they are right. Some things are not done because they come with any benefit. Perhaps that was what Gryffindor courage actually looked like.
She thought, without quite knowing why, of something Mr. Snape had once said: "Every day, someone falls, and I just watch... just watch."
Praeris sat in the middle of the crowd, didn't even lift her eyes, and just listened... just listened.
She couldn't stop the thought that formed: she was only looking away, and already she felt sick with discomfort. Before all of this, she'd even been able to find small reasons to make allowances for the DA.
But Professor Snape? He didn't even have the excuse of lowering his head. He had to keep his eyes open and watch. Watch how those people died. He had to make decisions he didn't want to make, decisions that crushed and hurt the students. He, who was precisely the kind of professor who believed that children and students should not have to carry such burdens, that adults ought to be the ones to bear the weight of everything.
Praeris felt something sharp and sour twist in her chest, like a lemon being wrung dry. But she couldn't say anything. Couldn't ask.
She knew Professor Snape was not the kind of person who opened himself willingly. He always wanted to hold the initiative. A subject was only fit to be discussed when he himself decided it was time to discuss it. Everything else was an intrusion.
Alecto's Cruciatus Curse had been applied with precision. It left a long, savage scar across Neville's face, raw and hard to look at.
"Give me a little time," Praeris said quietly, from the other side of the mirror. "I think I can remove it."
Neville was still for a moment. When he finally spoke, he said, "Thank you, Praeris. But I don't need that."
Praeris's feelings were complicated. Ginny's eyes were full of fury and the particular heartache of watching a battle companion get hurt. But Neville said he didn't need it.
"Honestly, don't laugh at me." Neville grinned, a little lopsided and foolish. "To me, it's a hero's medal. This scar tells everyone about my bravery. Don't I look a lot more formidable now?"
Ginny burst out laughing. Maybe it was because the sadness hadn't fully faded; her pretty face looked a little wrecked when she laughed. No one in the room cared.
Neville scratched his head, a bit sheepish. "I... when I was small, I was terrified of the Cruciatus Curse. I thought it must be worse than hell itself. But after living through it, I realized it's not unbearable."
"You might not know this," he said, quieter now. "My mum and dad were tortured into madness by the Cruciatus Curse. Now I can almost feel what they felt. Our whole family, standing together in that."
Neville's injury was plainly a bad thing. Yet somehow it lifted the DA's spirits all over again, and gave them more courage to carry.
"We learned this from Harry," Neville said, still smiling. "We thought there should be a banner. As long as the banner doesn't fall, hope doesn't die."
Praeris knew, clearly and without illusion, that she and the professor were not the same kind of people as them. And yet, quietly, they had ended up standing on the same side. She would never make the choices they made. But she found, unexpectedly, that she had started to respect those choices.
Perhaps there was no single correct decision in this world. All anyone could do was work, however imperfectly, to make their own decisions as close to right as possible.
Harry, Hermione, and Ron. Ginny, Neville, and Luna. Dumbledore, Professor Snape, and herself. All of them, doing exactly that.
Praeris also learned that she had not been attacked by the DA, and that this was, in no small part, because of Ginny and Neville. She had once beaten Neville up. The DA would have been within their rights to retaliate. But Ginny and Neville had told the others: "It's not worth it."
"I wanted revenge for Neville too. But our numbers are limited and our strength is limited. This Slytherin's aggression and vigilance are both too high; the odds of a successful ambush are too low, and the cost isn't worth it." Ginny's expression had been thoughtful. "If we ever do decide to go after her, we'll need a much more careful and thorough plan."
"This is nothing to me," Neville had said, picking up without pause. "Our more important targets are Snape, the Carrow siblings, and the Slytherins who keep informing on us. My personal score doesn't matter. Every decision we make has to be accountable to the whole DA."
"Neville practiced saying that for ages!" Ginny said, laughing at him. "He was terrified he'd botch it and give himself away."
Neville looked half annoyed and half embarrassed. "Ginny, so you're just naturally a brilliant liar, then?"
"Of course," Ginny said, with complete pride. "I spent all that time pretending I didn't fancy Harry, didn't I?"
At Harry's name, Ginny's mood dipped. Like a lion with its fur soaked in the rain, except a lioness's coat isn't long enough for the droop to really show.
"Thank you both. But it would have come to the same thing either way," Praeris said, shaking her head with a calm smile. "Let them come and run into a wall. Once they have, they'll know who not to provoke."
Ginny still didn't think the DA should be allowed to go after Praeris, regardless. "We're trusted comrades on the same front. Using your potions with one hand and attacking you with the other, I could never do something that dishonorable."
"Oh, right, Praeris, I should be clear about this." Ginny said it suddenly, as if it had just come back to her. "We haven't had anyone watching you. But some DA members have seen Amycus and Snape summon you to their office several times. And you mentioned something about homework... Can you tell us what that's about?"
Neville added, "Everyone suspects you and those two Death Eaters are planning something. The hope was that we could investigate and organize to disrupt it."
They were all in the same castle. There were students everywhere. It was like Draco's situation, no one knew exactly what he was doing, but they knew he was up to something.
Praeris toyed with her fingers, unhurried. "It's nothing. They wanted me to manufacture something, so I did."
"You did it!" Neville and Ginny stared at her. "But, but — but —"
"Could I have refused? I'd rather not die." Praeris said it plainly. "Professor Snape knows exactly what I'm capable of. Better than I do, probably."
"Relax. Potions having certain unavoidable flaws is perfectly normal, isn't it? Just like how your nose runs when you take cold medicine, or how eating Bertie Bott's Every Flavour Beans comes with the risk of getting earwax."
➤ Next: Extreme Push-and-Pull — The Conversation
