HP:BTHBP — Chapter 195 - 196: The It Accessory
Lucas shot Marcus a surprised glance. The two students with Marcus didn't question the remark at all.
They clearly had no idea Thestrals were pulling the carriages, and yet they had no curiosity whatsoever about what made them fly.
Lucas couldn't help pressing further. "Aren't you curious how the carriages actually get airborne?"
Marcus looked back with equal surprise. "What's there to ask? Magic, obviously!" Already having spotted a free carriage, Marcus had walked several steps toward it before turning back. "Do you want to ride with us?"
Lucas shook his head. A carriage only held three wizards.
With something close to reverence, Lucas watched the handful of firm believers in magic climb in and fly away.
If that was how it was, sorting the supplier's child into Slytherin made even more sense. At most it just meant one more person like that... right.
Lucas picked an empty carriage at random and stepped in. Hogwarts always kept enough carriages for the start-of-term run, and the Thestrals were specially trained not to depart until there were at least three passengers.
Carriages around him began lifting off one by one. Most young witches and wizards were traveling in groups, and when they peeked in and spotted Lucas already seated, they assumed it was taken and went looking elsewhere.
Lucas pulled out the book planned for the journey. The cover had barely opened when someone stuck their head through the door. "Excuse me — is it just you? Can we share?"
Lucas looked up. Catherine's wavy curls.
A nod, and Catherine quickly waved a classmate aboard.
Two older students and one younger one, an odd combination. The classmate Catherine had brought was from Ravenclaw, one of the summer camp members.
Lucas narrowed both eyes slightly. Many years as a professor had sharpened a particular instinct: whether certain people were involved with each other. These two were moving along quite quickly.
Neither of them recognized Lucas.
Once everyone had settled, each pulled out a book. The Ravenclaw student was clearly curious about Lucas's and couldn't help asking: "What year are you? Can you actually understand that at your level?"
Interrupted again. A growing suspicion took hold that the wrong book had been chosen today, how else could the sun be nearly setting and not a single page turned, the thing just sitting there like a fashion accessory?
"Second year. And yes, I can understand it." A sigh, followed by a decision to forgive two students whose brains had clearly been scrambled by romance. The more immediate reason was that the carriage had already lifted off, there was no changing now. "Do you really not recognize me? I'm Lucas Graham."
There was a small pang of missing Marcus. Marcus could be deeply earnest about magic sometimes, but at least Marcus would never make a fuss about Lucas's height.
Catherine lowered the book, studying Lucas carefully. "How is that possible!" A brief pause to collect thoughts. "I mean — you've grown so much! We only knew you were safe. What on earth happened? Are you all right?"
Lucas closed the book, shrank it, and slipped it back into a pocket.
Then came the edited version of events, delivered with patience to both Catherine and the Ravenclaw student.
Sharing summer experiences at the start of term was apparently a student tradition, and somewhere in the telling, Lucas registered with quiet resignation the fact of having become one of them. No different from anyone else.
By the time the castle filled the carriage window, Catherine embraced Lucas with an expression caught between awe and lingering dread. The Ravenclaw student behind made a pointed, deliberate cough.
Then, after being pinched on the arm, drew a small sharp breath.
Lucas pretended not to notice.
They landed smoothly. Lucas said goodbye to the two of them and turned toward the castle.
But Catherine caught up, pulling a parcel from a shoulder bag.
"In exchange for the dragon tooth." The tone was sincere. "I looked up the prices afterward. Everything I could pull together is in here — it's probably still not enough. I'll make up the difference next term."
Lucas looked at Catherine quietly.
Rather than taking it, Lucas said: "You saw it yourself. I only traded those things for a game of billiards. Honestly, they're worth nothing to me, just the price of one match."
The Ravenclaw student had been left some distance back and was crouching on the ground, unhappily drawing circles in the dirt with a stone. Not quite jealous enough to sulk over a second-year, but not moving any closer either.
Lucas pressed on gently: "And it didn't even cost me anything. If I had lost, I'm just a child, they couldn't have made me pay for it."
Catherine shook her head. "If all I remembered was that you won at billiards, I wouldn't be a proper Slytherin. What matters isn't the dragon tooth or the billiards, it's the value you and I showed each other."
Lucas had proved the ability to navigate a foreign place with ease, landing on both feet wherever the situation led. And it was with Lucas's help that Catherine had begun to distinguish herself among students of the same age.
The moment had gone rather serious, until Lucas suddenly laughed. "I'm genuinely sorry. This feels a bit like we're playing house. Are we being too serious? I apologize, I'm not very good at conversations like this..."
A hand reached up to touch the hair that had grown out, and Lucas offered an apologetic smile.
Slytherin had people like Marcus. People like Catherine. Think further and there was Lord Voldemort, Severus Snape, Horace Slughorn.
Lump them all together as Slytherin?
That umbrella was genuinely vast. Who got to decide what a proper Slytherin even was?
Lucas had no intention of pulling current students into stories from outside school. As for things within school, it hadn't reached the point of pledging loyalty, picking sides, or forging alliances. Any of those would be premature.
Catherine didn't relax. There was a faintly lost look, like someone who had been playing the adult and found nothing there when the act dropped.
Lucas did genuinely think more of Catherine for following through.
With both hands, Lucas accepted the parcel. "Thank you for the exchange. You don't need to bring me anything next term, this is more than enough." The tone was easy and light, as though the easy dominance at the pub had been nothing but a dream from yesterday.
Catherine watched Lucas walk into the last sunlight before sunset, the young wizard heading toward the castle at an unhurried pace. An unlucky boyfriend sidled up and wrapped an arm around the shoulders. "Let's go in too, the Sorting's about to start."
.
"Benjamin Hank." Professor McGonagall read the name from the long roll.
The Sorting Hat settled onto the young wizard's head and reached its decision quickly,
"Slytherin!"
The four House tables erupted. One indignant young wizard stood up and leveled a full accusation of fraud and injustice.
"Liar! You tricked me out of my sweets too!"
The protests came from all sides. Quite a few students on the train had handed over their own sweets, paying upfront for the promise of thrilling adventure stories from a future classmate.
Some of those listeners had ended up in Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff, of course, that was understandable enough.
But this young wizard, the one who had been telling stories about Slytherin's wickedness, had gone and ended up in Slytherin. It had to have been premeditated. A calculated scheme to con everyone out of their sweets from the very start.
Professor McGonagall's gaze swept the hall with quiet, unambiguous authority, pressing the young witches and wizards back into order.
First-years who hadn't sat through a single lesson had no fear of professors whatsoever, and the students still waiting to be Sorted had even less. Students from other years stared at the scene in open amazement. Some leaned over to ask what was going on; others were already inventing their own versions on the spot.
In the middle of the chaos, Lucas drew a paper tissue from a pocket. In that same pocket sat an empty glass vial, the liquid inside had just finished evaporating completely.
➤ Next: Coming to the Door
Chapter 196 - Coming to the Door
After a brief commotion, Professor McGonagall swiftly brought the situation under control.
Lucas frowned toward the staff table. His classmates were murmuring about the same thing, why was Professor Walter still here?
The Sorting was over.
The headmaster walked to the podium and addressed the hall: "Welcome back, everyone. There have been some changes to the teaching staff this term. Our Defence Against the Dark Arts professor has at last found a calling in life — a letter of resignation arrived, along with the news of a decision to go to Africa to save wild animals. Let us wish all the best. The professor taking over that course is someone you are all quite familiar with — Professor Walter."
The members of the Walter Research Society applauded with gusto. Another term had been handed to them, more time to study this vampire professor and determine who the favourite student was.
"Brilliant! We actually get to take the class this year!" Marcus nudged Lucas and grinned. "If you put in a bit of effort and bring out the same enthusiasm you have for Professor Snape, I'd wager you'd stand out."
Sitting across from Lucas was Catherine, who glanced at Marcus and saw an opening. Having already resolved to grow closer to Lucas, Catherine joined in: "This professor doesn't quite have the same honours and distinctions as our Head of House."
Marcus was left a little flustered by the senior student who had jumped in uninvited. A glance toward Lucas was a silent plea for an introduction, but Lucas's gaze was still fixed on the staff table.
Lucas was thinking: what kind of deal had Walter and Professor Dumbledore actually struck?
After the feast ended, everyone drifted back toward the dormitories half-asleep.
The houses split off at the corridors. The Slytherin column converged and wound its way down toward the dungeons.
Lucas and Marcus were walking near the rear when a burst of fierce crying and shouting erupted from the very back of the line.
Every student snapped to attention and turned around as one.
Lucas saw that a fight had broken out among the first-years. The apprentice from the Potions supply shop and another student who had just been sorted were locked in a furious brawl. Both wands had been knocked loose in the scuffle. Now they were pulling hair and clawing at each other's faces, neither gaining the upper hand.
The prefect came charging back from the front of the line like a gust of wind, muttering as he passed: "Good heavens — and it's only the first day!"
The two young witches and wizards were pulled apart. Robes dishevelled, noses bleeding.
"Both of you, with me to the professor's office!" The prefect seized them both with a spell, delivered a sharp scolding, and marched them off down the corridor.
They weren't far from Snape's office to begin with.
Under normal circumstances, Snape didn't make an appearance on the first day of term. It was the older students who handled things, a briefing back in the common room, the usual useful information passed down to the younger years.
Marcus caught the hem of Lucas's robes, then let go as Lucas turned: "Where are you going? The dormitory isn't that way."
Lucas answered with complete ease. "I still have my work duty."
Work duty on the first day of term?
Marcus thought about it for a moment, then his brow smoothed out. Lucas was simply curious about those two students and was using that as an excuse to go and see what had happened.
By the time Lucas reached the office door, Snape had already finished reprimanding the pair.
The familiar Benjamin came striding out with a thoroughly defiant air, yanking open the door to Snape's office and shouting: "The Sorting Hat must have made a mistake!"
Then the left foot caught on a flagstone, and Benjamin doubled over in pain.
Snape had just reached the doorway at that moment. Snape was visibly displeased to see Lucas standing there.
Lucas rubbed his nose and stepped up beside Snape, keeping his voice low. "Professor, it's the first day of term and the owls from the suppliers have all piled up in your office. I'm here to sort through the deliveries."
A perfectly reasonable excuse. It earned Lucas a front-row seat to the spectacle.
Snape let out a cold snort. "I suspect it isn't only the Potions materials that have arrived. The supplier will be along any moment now."
Lucas said nothing. Both of them knew the real reason for being there, but passing comment would have been overstepping.
Lucas slipped past the edge of Snape's robes and got to work pulling on gloves, perfectly composed.
Professor Dumbledore and the familiar supplier arrived at Benjamin Hank's side.
"What have you done to my son?" Old Hank wrenched out a wand in fury.
Snape's expression was haughty. There was no move toward drawing a wand.
"Papa!" Benjamin Hank rushed behind the supplier and stretched out a finger, pointing at everyone in front: "They bullied me!"
Snape raised an eyebrow. "Allow me to summarise the situation. Your son was just placed into my house by the Sorting Hat."
A look toward Dumbledore. "I have not laid a single finger on the boy, and yet Hank has violently assaulted a classmate. I believe this warrants serious disciplinary action. Headmaster, my recommendation is expulsion."
Lucas was unpacking parcels and checking the quantities of materials inside.
Headmaster Dumbledore's voice carried across the room: "It hasn't come to that, Severus. Sometimes the Sorting Hat's decision can take people by surprise, but in time, people come to find that everything was arranged for the best."
Monkshood, vanilla root, lemongrass...
Lucas felt that most choices were not the best arrangement at all. The most famous sorting controversy was the eldest son of the Black family being placed into Gryffindor.
Harry Potter's godfather. The Sorting Hat had made its choice.
But what if it had placed Black into Slytherin. What if Black had never left school, and the two brothers had ended up in the same house.
Sirius Black and Regulus Black.
The two of them had once been the subject of one of the Saviour's tea gatherings. Harry Potter spoke about them, to illustrate the Black family's regrets, to show that heroes could come from any house, to pay tribute to a godfather.
But if Sirius Black had entered Slytherin and been killed during the height of Lord Voldemort's power, it might have triggered a defection of the Black family. That, in turn, could have changed the course of the wizarding world entirely.
The Sorting Hat's decisions were easy enough to tamper with. Amplify certain emotions, and a misreading would follow. Young witches and wizards could choose their own houses freely. The dominant houses grew more dominant still, breeding prejudice, deepening resentment.
Gillyweed, wormwood extract, bezoar...
The argument at the office doorway had grown fierce. The student's parent was insisting that the Sorting Hat's decision had been flawed.
"There has never been a precedent in this school for changing houses," Professor Dumbledore declared. "You should trust in the Sorting Hat's decision."
➤ Next: Extra 1.1 — Please Answer 2025
