HP:BTHBP — Chapter 193 - 194: Reading Him Exactly Right
Lucas's eyes were red. He started taking the frame apart. "I drew it too badly — I'm sorry, Professor. I shouldn't have gotten it into my head to do something like this."
Snape wanted to say something. He stopped himself.
There were only the two of them in the house, yet he felt as though quite a few pairs of reproachful eyes were watching him.
The words of apology wouldn't come.
He still had doubts about Lucas's reaction. It had been a week, there was no way Lucas hadn't noticed his displeasure.
Lucas moved fast, pulling the sketch free from the frame. His first impulse was to crumple it, but he remembered what the drawing depicted and folded it in half twice instead.
"I'm sorry, Professor. I thought since a week had passed and you hadn't said anything, that meant you'd accepted it." Lucas tucked the sketch away.
The frame sat empty. Nothing inside but a white backing board, clean and blank.
Snape felt an unexpected twinge of guilt.
Lucas hardly had any leisure activities to speak of. He had just, apparently, snuffed out one of the few things that made him happy.
"No —" Snape called out to the young wizard who was about to leave. His throat felt a little dry. "Put it back."
Lucas, still with his back to Snape, went still. He didn't turn around. He only asked, with a slight nasal edge to his voice: "What?"
"I said put it back." The Potions Master's tone was even. When Lucas turned around, Snape wore an expression of pure disdain. "What is there to cry about? I was saying your Felix Felicis progress is too slow — your technique has too many problems, term is nearly upon us, and you still have the energy to clean house. What are you even going on about? Put the sketch back and go set up the cauldron."
The words came more smoothly the longer he spoke. He looked away from Lucas's brightening eyes.
The sketch went back into the frame. The crease was repaired with a touch of magic.
Lucas, visibly delighted, was then hauled by the Professor over to the cauldron to drill the procedural steps.
The tail end of the holiday closed on that small incident.
When mentor and apprentice left Spinner's End with their luggage, the sketch sat in its place on the display shelf above the fireplace, its looping motion playing on quietly. The surrounding ornaments had all been shifted a little farther away, as if to mark its special status, and to wait for the next holiday, when someone would gently pick it up again and wipe away the dust.
Now let us return to Lucas's perspective and look back at this.
The holiday was nearly over, and Lucas felt the time had passed quickly.
He had sometimes become too absorbed in Snape's study. Any book pulled from those shelves at random would bear Snape's annotations.
Some of those notes sparked new directions in his thinking. More often, they were simply cutting remarks written for the pleasure of it.
For instance, Snape had circled a table-of-contents entry for a cure-all potion for hiccups and written in the margin: Drink more hot water!
In his copy of A Theory of Controlled Variables for Advanced Amortentia, next to the condition requiring the brewer to "imbue the potion with genuine feeling," he had sketched a small heart being pierced by Cupid's arrow, with the caption: Suspected delusion of a brewer who has ingested their own potion.
In a paper titled Budget Alternatives to Memory-Enhancement Draught, at the very end, he had appended a furious note: A waste of time. Troll bogwash would make the drinker remember that day just as permanently.
Not every book in the study was dense or advanced. Snape had been collecting volumes since fifth year, and some of the introductory texts had never been replaced. In those, you could find annotations heavy with deeply felt grievances.
Lucas read those books to learn. The marginal notes had a way of leading him somewhere else entirely.
The day he drew the sketch, Snape had, in a rare turn, washed and blow-dried his hair. Lucas had just finished an extraction exercise and the cauldron contents were cooling; he himself was working on the final essay for History of Magic.
The Goblin Wars. Thoroughly dull.
The parchment in front of him was blank. He was resting his chin in his hand, staring upward, when he noticed Snape leaning close to the cauldron to analyze the potion's composition. A strand of hair fell forward. Something stirred in Lucas's chest. He caught the pose and dashed off a one-minute sketch.
But the extraction had run into problems that day, and Snape relit the flame and began stirring the cauldron again. Lucas found himself with considerably more time to refine the image.
By the time he realized what he was doing, there was already a highly finished drawing on his parchment.
This kind of sketch was commonly used as preparation material for full portraits. He had woven magic into the drawing without thinking, which was how Snape ended up with a turning motion.
Lucas had half a mind to get rid of this "accident." He swapped his quill for his wand, then set it back down.
Snape was calling him over to look at the procedural steps.
And so the drawing stayed.
Lucas kept the sketch inside his notebook. He began to feel restless, going about his tasks, he would find his thoughts drifting back to it. Then came the routine cleaning, and he thought the empty frame looked just right. Swapping the sketch in had felt natural. Inevitable, even.
But Snape had been furious.
The mentor was above all else. Lucas was certainly not going to talk back. From the moment it happened, he had been ready to apologize and take the drawing down.
But Professor Snape had chosen the cold-war approach.
Lucas was a good apprentice who followed his mentor's lead.
Snape didn't ask; Lucas didn't say. When Snape did ask, he could always act surprised, but the mentor had plainly started to grow angry.
For the past week, Lucas had been careful and precise in everything he did. That small instinct to play dumb had, as Snape silently simmered, quietly transformed into something like curiosity. He genuinely wanted to know how long Snape could sustain a sulk entirely on his own.
At the same time, Lucas had been sitting with a question.
Why had he drawn that portrait in the first place?
The act of drawing had been nearly unconscious, a reflex to capture the figure's movement. Lucas put it down to this: he had never made a proper portrait of Snape, and that had always been a quiet, lingering regret.
Even if he was determined to rewrite the fate of the wizarding world, that was no reason he couldn't make a portrait of Snape.
And besides, if such a portrait truly existed, one that showed Snape delivering his sharp daily commentary on the Daily Prophet, or quietly fuming over something, that would be rather entertaining to have around.
A perfectly reasonable explanation.
The motive behind the sketch incident thus became something defensible. Lucas moved on to thinking about how to get Snape back into a good mood.
That part wasn't difficult. And what he said wouldn't be entirely a lie.
In his first student life, there had been a Slytherin who was extraordinarily talented at drawing. That classmate, at twelve years old, could produce figure paintings in clean, vivid oils.
Lucas had been deeply envious. He would steal glances whenever he could, and eventually decided to try on his own in secret. During common room tidying, he collected the paint boxes that student had discarded, the ones stained and muddied from mixed colors, and used whatever pigment remained to copy the style.
At that point, Lucas had no foundation whatsoever. The essays he turned in still had numerous spelling mistakes.
He used discarded essays that professors had marked with a "T." He painted in oils on cheap parchment; the pigments bled and muddied into grey, and what emerged was barely recognizable as human, showing not a trace of talent.
Worse still, Lucas's secret attempts at imitation, and the envy behind them, had been discovered by his dormitory mates.
First year had been hard to get through. Being mocked for drawing and being accused of theft were not even the worst of it.
Lucas found it effortless to reach back into that stretch of his life for the precise key to prick Snape's guilt. He could tell the story with complete and genuine feeling.
And sure enough, he was granted permission. The frame was returned to its place at the center of the mantelpiece.
To redirect his attention, Snape taught him an extra chapter of exclusive technique.
Then, the following morning, as Lucas and Snape were preparing to return to school, Lucas noticed it: the ornaments around the sketch frame on the mantelpiece had all been nudged a little farther to the sides. Someone had cleared a space for the frame.
It was the first thing you saw when you walked into the sitting room.
Lucas held the banister. He stood very still, not quite sure what he was thinking.
➤ Next: The Candy Scam
Chapter 194 - The Candy Scam
On the first day of term, Snape escorted Lucas to King's Cross Station.
Lucas walked quietly with his luggage. His father's pigskin trunk had originally been stored in a pocket enchanted with a Space-Extension Charm, but Snape had decided to travel back to school the ordinary way.
The trunk was taken out to serve as a prop.
Lucas had been a Hogwarts professor himself once. The moment he saw Snape preparing to board the train, he knew exactly what had happened, Snape had failed to dodge the assignment at the staff meeting and been saddled with the duty of looking after new students on the train.
Every new employee had to go through that at least once.
The two wizards, one tall and one small, stepped into the Muggle station. Snape led Lucas through the crowd of parents bidding their children reluctant farewells, and they boarded the train together.
They had arrived early. The compartment in front of them was empty.
Snape waited while Lucas stowed his luggage. The young wizard quite naturally reached back to close the compartment door and moved to sit down across from him.
"Stay standing." Snape occupied an entire row of seats by himself. Students drifted past in the corridor from time to time, searching for places to sit. Every single one performed the same action: peered through the glass, then bolted as if they had seen a ghost.
And then ran off to warn others.
Lucas stood beside Snape, puzzled.
Snape unhurriedly produced a spell book from his pocket, enlarged it, and instructed Lucas: "Don't stay in this compartment. Go find your friends."
Lucas cast a reluctant glance at the seat across from Snape. His own plan for the journey had also been to read. He even had a pre-shrunk book in his pocket.
But Snape's mind was made up.
Lucas walked out with three backward glances. He pulled the door shut behind him. Out in the corridor, several older students were already intercepting younger ones who kept trying to crane their necks toward Snape's compartment.
Two of them were whispering to each other, though not quietly enough. As Lucas passed, he caught one sentence: "Graham got thrown out too — the professor must be in a terrible mood today... whatever you do, don't go over there!"
Lucas nodded in agreement. He silently encouraged them to keep spreading the word and establish Snape's compartment as an absolute forbidden zone. His mentor did not appreciate being disturbed.
The corridor grew gradually more crowded. Lucas tried to find a familiar face and came up empty. Just as he was considering using a spell to guide himself, a small, squat figure entered his field of view.
The Potions supplier's kid.
Lucas couldn't remember the name.
The child had become the center of attention among peers. Three other children surrounded him, and at this age kids tend to follow the crowd, more gathered quickly, listening to him recount his adventures at Hogwarts. He was telling the story of how Professor Dumbledore had lifted a curse from him and given him a sweet. The reason he had been cursed in the first place, he claimed, was because he had spoken a truth no one else had dared to say.
Lucas listened for a while. He had nearly forgotten about this young wizard entirely.
Making a fuss over a child who hadn't even started school yet was really quite beneath him.
Besides, what Lucas had thought at the time was: if this child ended up in Slytherin, how exactly would he face the "evil Slytherin" he had so freely spoken of?
Then again, looked at from the other direction, having Slytherin take in such a troublesome character would only drag the house down.
Had Lucas simply not run into this child before the Sorting concluded, he would not have carried the plan through to the end.
Lucas stood quietly at the outer edge of the little crowd and listened.
The young wizard's version had gone through many iterations by now. He finished his tale with evident satisfaction, looked around at the audience, and announced proudly, "I will select a few people to ask me questions."
The right to ask questions had to be competed for. Sweets were the entry fee.
Lucas had seen enough. The wand up his sleeve twitched once. The young wizard gnawing on a lollipop reached up to touch the back of his head — something had just snagged on the carriage door frame, or so it felt — and thought nothing of it, and kept talking.
Lucas skirted around the storytelling gathering and found the lavatory at the end of the train. He stepped inside and locked the door behind him.
The lavatory had not been expanded with any additional space charm. Standing inside was cramped.
By now the train had pulled out of the station. As it rolled along with its steady rhythm, Lucas layered a series of magic-dampening charms onto every surface around him.
He opened the hand that wasn't holding his wand. Resting quietly in his palm was a short, fine strand of hair.
Lucas levitated it with his wand and began to recite a spell in a steady, measured rhythm.
The incantation was long. He chanted for a full 15 minutes. At last, the strand of hair began to smoke. It burned down to ash, but the ash stayed suspended in the air and quickly transformed into a black medium far greater in volume than the original hair.
Lucas drew the black liquid into a vial.
The contactless enchantment was complete.
He began dismantling the charms layered around the room.
At the same time, knocking started at the door. Having the lavatory occupied this long was a matter of extreme urgency, urgent enough that someone might take desperate measures.
Even disturbing the professor.
And so Snape's absolute forbidden zone was breached. Because compared to disturbing a professor and getting an earful on the first day of term, having an accident in one's trousers was clearly the greater catastrophe.
Snape's pleasant journey was ruined.
Seeing that the student who had come to him was from his own house, Snape made his way through the corridor with a dangerously low atmospheric pressure.
Lucas confirmed everything was in order. He flushed, ran the tiny tap for a moment, then opened the door to the increasingly frantic knocking.
Lucas and Snape came face to face.
Snape paused. He looked at Lucas with suspicion. For a brief moment he wondered whether Lucas had such severe social difficulties that he had retreated into hiding in the lavatory.
Before the Potions professor could say a word, the Slytherin student on the verge of crisis had already shot inside, shoved Lucas out, and locked the door behind them.
"Good day, Professor..." Lucas had no idea why Snape was looking at him like that. He could hardly explain to the professor that he had simply been using the lavatory.
Fortunately, Snape was occupied reprimanding everyone in the vicinity, even the business of directing students to lavatories drew a crowd of spectators poking their heads out of compartments to watch.
Lucas moved through the nearly empty corridor, all the students had retreated into their compartments, which made finding someone considerably easier.
It didn't take long before he spotted Marcus Nott in one of the compartments, happily showing off stories from the summer holiday. Lucas stayed and settled in.
The train pulled into the station at dusk. Lucas followed the stream of students from his house forward until they stopped on an open stretch of ground. Many carriages stood arranged across it, but there were no horses to pull them.
Marcus Nott found everything fresh and fascinating. "Do we have to wait for winged horses to come pull the carriages before we can get to the castle? How can winged horses be late too?"
With that, three older students climbed into the first carriage. The Thestral-drawn coach lifted into the air and climbed higher and higher until it vanished against the darkening sky.
The newly-minted second-years gaped.
Marcus was among them, neck craned back, staring up in open amazement. Then, after a long moment, Marcus began scanning the remaining carriages. "Let's hurry and grab one!"
➤ Next: The It Accessory
