HP:BTHBP — Chapter 131 - 132: A Fine Tale
As time passed, the dream began to reveal its absurd nature.
Snape and Eddie started appearing at random locations throughout the castle, their link ensuring they always materialized in the same spot —
The wind-swept Astronomy Tower. The Slytherin common room. The school library.
The last time, they appeared in Snape's dormitory. Slytherin had always maintained the fine tradition of double rooms, and the two of them sat side by side on a single bed.
Finding himself in the dormitory, the first thing Snape did was cast Stupefy on the person turning over behind the bed curtains next door.
Lucas raised an eyebrow but offered no comment.
The full moon was drawing close. Lucas bypassed the Marauder's Map's password and read through this work of alchemical craft.
The map had quite a few of the school's secret passages marked on it.
Snape examined it carefully at once. From the look on his face, Lucas could tell he had memorized several of the passages.
They began discussing escape routes.
"The best-case scenario would be..." Eddie tapped a finger on the map. The labeled dots were dragging across the parchment in near-streaks, time moving far too fast inside the dream.
"Just tell me the worst possibility!" Snape cut in, the corner of his mouth curling into a sardonic smirk. "Your luck makes me afraid to hope for anything good."
The Potions master's resentment ran deep.
Eddie pointed at the map plainly. "If the threat comes from inside the castle, we head upward and use broomsticks to move fast. If the threat comes from outside the castle..."
As the discussion went on, Eddie shifted from sitting sideways on the edge of the bed to sitting cross-legged at the foot of it.
Eddie selectively told Snape about a few small caves not marked on the map. Then another cold, desolate gust swept through the underground dormitory's windowless walls.
The four walls vanished.
On the open grounds outside the castle, a Slytherin single bed stood in the grass, completely out of place.
The sky was thick with stars — perfect weather for an Astronomy lesson. A full moon hung low, its gentle light washing softly over everything below.
Eddie waved his wand to drive off the mosquitoes buzzing in close.
Watching Snape sit there in silence, lips pressed shut, Eddie jumped down from the bed.
Eddie had just been about to ask which direction they should head when two distant figures caught his eye, slowly drawing closer.
Eddie rapidly transformed the bed into a rock and cast a Disillusionment Charm on himself. When Eddie turned back, there was no one beside him, though the link between him and Snape told him their relative positions. Snape had cast a Disillusionment Charm as well.
Several wizards were moving toward the Whomping Willow.
Snape's voice reached Eddie from nearby. "There's a secret passage beneath the Whomping Willow. It leads to the Shrieking Shack."
This was nothing new to Lucas. The Savior had told this story before.
The haunted shack had been built to conceal Lupin's secret. The headmaster, out of generosity, had given the werewolf a chance to study, and Lupin had gone on to become the best Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher the Savior ever had. A good story, by any measure.
"Press the knot on the Whomping Willow and you can enter the passage." There was something slightly unreal in Snape's voice. Snape had asked Eddie before: since the events were already known in advance, was it truly necessary to walk willingly toward that fate?
But Eddie had explained: this was a curse, and it had not been made to grant wishes.
The curse's mechanism was to force a person to confront suffering directly. If the first encounter were avoided, the curse would treat those events as weaknesses, and what followed would be a very long cycle of repetition...
The grass bent and parted beneath two invisible figures as they silently trailed the distant wizards.
The Whomping Willow in the darkness looked like a monster baring its fangs and claws.
Eddie picked up a stone from the ground and hurled it. It struck the knot dead-on.
A passage opened before them.
Eddie moved to enter first. Snape seized him by the shoulder.
"Whose memory do you think this is?" Under the Disillusionment Charm, Eddie couldn't see Snape's expression.
But the hand on his shoulder released its grip. Snape stepped into the passage ahead of him and added, over his shoulder: "Don't come in. You'll block the way."
That meant the werewolf was waiting at the far end of the passage. In the story as it had truly happened.
Eddie waited quietly at the mouth of the tunnel.
A sense of unreality settled over him.
Tonight, he was watching a piece of forgotten history. In all of Harry Potter's fireside conversations, there had never been any mention that Snape had once come within reach of being bitten by Lupin.
Less than half a minute later, a terrifying howl erupted from inside the passage. Snape came scrambling backward in fast retreat.
Eddie spotted a wizard moving in from nearby, and then the figure rushed forward and grabbed Snape just as Snape was breaking out of the tunnel.
A head of disheveled hair. Seen up close, this person looked almost identical to the Savior. Like a program running on a fixed track, someone had come rushing from a distance to pull the imperiled Snape free.
Saved by his own worst enemy.
Lucas could well imagine why Snape had no desire to revisit this memory.
Backing out of the tunnel entrance, Snape brandished his wand and sealed the tree hollow. Amid all the frantic spellcasting, Snape did not forget to turn his wand on James Potter, who had come to the rescue.
"Stupefy!"
"Get him up in the tree. Move!" Snape kept it brief.
Eddie was the more skilled of the two at Transfiguration. Potter was rapidly transfigured into a cat, then sent floating up to the highest branch with a Levitation Charm.
The sounds of werewolf claws scraping against branches grew closer. Splinters were already flying out from the tunnel entrance. Snape cast another spell and packed the opening at the base of the Whomping Willow so tightly it looked like an oversized tree burl.
Lucas's spell was finished.
A broomstick answered the summons. Per their earlier escape plan, if the danger came from outside the castle, they moved toward it.
Eddie swung onto the broom. The school's brooms had been carefully repaired beforehand to prevent any serious accidents in flight.
Snape didn't linger over the question of sharing. The broom dipped slightly under the added weight, and with one kick they launched into the sky.
"That werewolf's attack strength was abnormal. Lupin is only an underage werewolf, but the effect was comparable to one that had drunk a Feral Potion." Thanks to Eddie's warning, Snape had gone in with the highest-intensity protective spells from the very first step.
The familiar scene had been pulling at something in him, tugging him back toward a distant memory.
The broomstick passed over the Black Lake.
The sight below killed that impulse instantly.
The surface of the Black Lake, previously calm, was beginning to ripple. In the shallower areas near the banks, something was crawling up out of the water: creatures moving on all fours, emerging from the dark.
➤ Next: Fate's Cruel Trick
Chapter 132 - Fate's Cruel Trick
Snape drew a sharp breath.
Their broomsticks chose that moment to shudder and sink beneath them.
This was no technical failure. Just as Eddie had explained before, when the scene they feared resurfaced, the curse would find every way to force them to face it directly.
"Sorry, we're going to have to land." Eddie's hair was blown to one side by the wind, revealing calm blue eyes.
They were forced down not far from the Black Lake.
Eddie swept a charm across the lakeshore and drew up a line of fire. The creatures crawling ashore all shrank from the light, and for a moment the advance slowed.
But new creatures kept climbing out from beneath the Black Lake.
Beyond the first wave that moved on all fours, a second kind began to appear, creatures with slender limbs, or stiff, jerky movements.
Eddie killed them steadily. The ones knocked down by curses were trampled by the ones behind them.
Bodies pressed against the red fire line. Eddie raised a second barrier.
Snape had no interest in watching from a distance. Snape strode to Eddie's side and fired a Sectumsempra that dropped the nearest creature, the curse landing alongside Eddie's.
Snape stared at Eddie Cartwright in disbelief, close enough now to see clearly what was crawling out of the Black Lake. "Eddie Cartwright!" The full name. The familiar full name.
Eddie murmured incantations and said nothing else.
The strikes were clean and efficient. Mechanical. As though Eddie had slipped into some waking nightmare on autopilot.
The creatures from the Black Lake came without end. Their sizes varied wildly, but they all shared one thing, every dripping, waterlogged body had the same blue eyes. Cartwright's face.
Countless Eddie Cartwrights, each killed in a different dark magic experiment, gathered here by the curse.
"Can you not control your own mind!" Snape was shaken by the parade of failed dark magic experiments stretching before him, each more grotesque than the last. The root of it was Cartwright's complete lack of restraint.
"Sorry, I can't control images that have already taken root in the mindscape." Eddie, afraid Snape might misunderstand, added between casts: "They're just shadows the curse left behind. From before."
After that first Sectumsempra, Snape switched to Stunning Spells to conserve magical energy.
Snape silently counted the curses as he cast them. If each one represented a Cartwright who had died once, how had Eddie appeared before him looking so utterly unfazed?
Lucas, at Snape's side, let out a quiet sigh.
Too long spent on a mentor's experimental table. If not for tonight at the Black Lake, Lucas would never have seen that many ways to die laid out all at once.
This cannot go on. The magical energy was nearly gone.
In the real world, the lingering effects of the Tooth Fairy Powder and the injury to the ribs were both pulling Lucas under.
Snape's condition was not much better. They fought while falling back, and the fire line dividing the battle drew closer and closer.
"Tell me, Severus — in your memory, how did the werewolf situation get resolved?" Eddie asked suddenly.
It wasn't hard to piece together. Snape had never revealed that Remus Lupin was a werewolf, not even by graduation, which meant someone had come to silence Snape. The likely candidates were few, senior figures connected to the Marauders.
Whoever it had been, they needed to draw on those same forces now.
"Dumbledore." Snape answered flatly.
Diffindo on the creature lunging forward. Sectumsempra for the one behind it.
Eddie processed what had been said and drew a sharp breath.
"Does that surprise you? I didn't realize you were still one of the headmaster's devoted followers." Snape's expression twisted into a sneer.
As if to confirm the words, a column of flame erupted from behind them both.
A devastating fire spell ignited the creatures along the lakeshore, magical energy rolling over them before they plunged beneath the surface, fierce red still burning across the water, refusing to die. The creatures turned to ash beneath it in an instant. The source was brought under control quickly. The light blazed bright enough that anyone in the distance might have mistaken it for a bonfire. The flickering firelight turned Eddie's blue eyes a burning orange.
Magic burned everything foul away.
Snape and Eddie collapsed against the trees at the Black Lake's edge, exhausted. The crisis was over.
But they had not yet woken from the dream.
Eddie watched Dumbledore — the one who had swept the evil away — walk toward them. The dream's own logic caused the headmaster to skip past any questions about what had just occurred. The priority was clear: Snape had witnessed the werewolf.
"Everyone deserves a second chance..."
"James saved you at that critical moment..."
"I hope you will keep this secret."
A silencing order.
A silencing order from the greatest wizard of the century.
As the headmaster's blurred features finished speaking, the wind rose. They finally began to leave the dream.
Lucas gazed at Snape. Now it was completely clear, the reason Snape had carried this wound into fifth year.
Three times in a single night.
A werewolf out of control. The rescue by a sworn enemy. And then the headmaster's command to silence.
"This was wrong." Eddie said suddenly, speaking to the blurred face of the headmaster. Not about that specific event. About fate itself.
History had given Lucas the answer: the Marauders scattered after graduation. Pettigrew betrayed them. Remus Lupin fell into destitution. Sirius Black was imprisoned. James Potter died at Lord Voldemort's hand. And the Slytherin that Headmaster Dumbledore had sacrificed that night became the blade driven straight into Lord Voldemort's weakness.
"It shouldn't have been allowed..." Eddie murmured, but there was no time to say more to a phantom in a dream.
The dream began to collapse.
The last words Eddie heard from Dumbledore were: "You promised..."
Lucas woke in complete darkness.
Face-down on the carpet. The sharp pain of the real world snapped everything into focus at once.
The name Eddie Cartwright fell silent all at once, like a power cut.
In the darkened house, only first-year Lucas Graham and Snape remained in the hall.
Lucas said nothing. Drawing on what little magical energy was left, Lucas rendered the Potions Master unconscious, just as the first time.
➤ Next: Changing the Lightbulb
