HP:BTHBP — Chapter 107 - 108: Gold-Medal Mediator
The old Headmaster waited patiently for Lucas to continue.
Lucas, under the scrutiny of several adults, said: "Everything he sent is written right there on his face."
"Headmaster Dumbledore, do you see that? This is his attitude!" The Potions supplier was infuriated by those words.
"I didn't grow up in the wizarding world, so talk of 'evil Slytherin' doesn't mean much to me. But have you actually seen what your child sent?"
Lucas reached into his bag and pulled out a sheet of paper tucked inside a notebook. It appeared to be a page from the Daily Prophet.
The newspaper was dated from last year. It had been crumpled into a ball and then smoothed back out.
"Would you like to take a look?" Lucas glanced toward Headmaster Dumbledore.
The sheet of newspaper drifted lazily through the air and settled into Dumbledore's hands. The Headmaster unfolded it and read, his expression showing no obvious change.
But Snape noticed that the child, who had seemed emboldened moments ago by having someone in his corner, was beginning to look anxious and frightened.
A tongue of flame suddenly ignited, lighting up the dim cellar office.
The newspaper in Dumbledore's hands quickly became several scorched scraps, trailing small sparks as they drifted downward, burning to ash entirely before they ever reached the floor.
The Headmaster looked around at everyone. "All right, it was just a prank. No need to be so tense."
That summary managed to leave everyone dissatisfied.
The parent who had come to complain felt the Headmaster was covering for a student.
Snape suspected Dumbledore had just destroyed a key piece of evidence. Thinking back now, whatever had driven Lucas to go after the child so relentlessly probably wasn't just a dung bomb.
Lucas himself still wore that same expression, outwardly compliant, inwardly ungovernable.
He and Dumbledore had arrived at some kind of unspoken understanding.
"But—"
"The two children look to be about the same age." The old Headmaster said with a cheerful smile, smoothing things over. "They're still at an age full of energy and mischief, it's only natural they don't always stop to think things through."
They were in fact two years apart, but the supplier's child was sturdier, while Lucas had yet to catch up to his peers in height, slight and thin, looking as though he could be knocked over in an instant.
But that was entirely misleading. Wizards didn't settle things with fists, and the moment magic entered the equation, the outcome was obvious.
The parent who had come to complain, however, knew nothing of Lucas's magical abilities.
He was momentarily lost for words, then shifted his attention back to the newspaper. "What was in that newspaper you burned? Is this child really Lucas Graham? Are you certain there isn't a second wizard at this school with that name? What if someone is impersonating him?"
"Someone actually dares to suspect Headmaster Dumbledore — the greatest wizard of this century — of covering for a student, and the one doing the suspecting is a Gryffindor, no less." Snape crossed his arms and gave a cold laugh.
The parent opened his mouth, looked at Snape who was busy fanning the flames, and latched onto another issue entirely: "How can you allow a first-year student to do procurement work?"
Snape had just drawn breath to reply when Lucas got there first: "I come from the Muggle world. My family situation isn't great. Professor Snape noticed my aptitude for figures and offered me a job."
"Coming from the Muggle world, doesn't that only prove you're unsuitable for Potions procurement?" The shopkeeper sneered. "And as I recall, the school has a bursary. Everyone else seems to manage perfectly well, why can't you?"
"I set aside half my bursary for my Muggle father," Lucas answered immediately. "I'm certainly capable of doing this job, because my Potions marks are outstanding, "
Dumbledore cut off the shopkeeper's line of questioning. "That's enough, please don't press into another person's painful history. Lucas Graham is a remarkably capable student, and that is plain for every teacher and student at this school to see."
The Headmaster turned to look at the child who had not spoken this entire time. The corner of his mouth still had a trace of Licorice Wand candy on it.
Dumbledore crouched down and gently guided the child: "I think you know what you did was wrong, don't you? Are you willing to apologize to Lucas?"
The child glanced back at his parent. He looked a little lost, unsure what the right thing to do was.
The Headmaster looked toward Lucas.
Lucas said nothing.
Lucas had once seen the Headmaster disperse a thundercloud over the Forbidden Forest.
And yet this wizard of such extraordinary power was mediating a preschool-age child's prank during dinnertime.
Hogwarts truly was a remarkable place.
"I think the newspaper we just dealt with was deeply out of line. A person's face is an important part of who they are, wouldn't you say?" Dumbledore spoke with deliberate meaning. He reached out and passed his hand gently through the air in front of the child's face. The ink clinging to the child's skin gathered into two drops, hovered in the Headmaster's palm for a moment, and then vanished.
When Lucas had cast the Transference Charm, he had used roughly a magical output of 6. Assuming Filius Flitwick had placed a magical output of 7 on the ink to begin with, both layers applied to enhance the ink's staining effect, the Headmaster had cancelled out their combined magic without even raising a wand.
Lucas did not quit while he was ahead. He continued addressing the child: "Next time something like this happens, I'll consider sending the dung bomb back to you exactly as it came. But you know you did something wrong, because if you thought what you wrote was fine, you wouldn't have hidden behind a mask to come and complain."
Snape frowned and asked directly, voicing the question the other child's parent was also very keen to have answered: "What exactly was in that newspaper?"
That newspaper was what had driven Lucas to go after the child so relentlessly, refusing to let it go. Even when the Headmaster had spoken up, he hadn't backed down. And Headmaster Dumbledore, after reading it himself, had tacitly condoned everything Lucas had done.
Lucas was preparing to answer.
The child across from him tensed, desperate to cover his mouth.
"I'm sorry!" He finally spoke and apologized.
"Doodling is in a child's nature. When I was young, I too liked to use the sky as my canvas and shape the clouds into whatever I wished. Perhaps next time you feel like drawing, you might try that gentler method instead." Dumbledore pressed a hand down on each child.
Lucas hadn't moved in the first place.
He looked at the child across from him, the one who had been silent as a mute in person but whose letters had been vicious, so this child could actually speak properly when adults were present.
But that magic of Headmaster Dumbledore's... transmitting any magical force all the way up to the sky was no easy feat. Was that the same principle as the Dark Mark, supposedly? No, wait, that wasn't right. Lumos could achieve something like that as well, in a way. What truly mattered was having enough raw power to produce the desired effect.
To ease the tension, Dumbledore once again reached into the drawer and produced the dish of sweets.
Snape's brow twitched. "Those are mine!" The Headmaster had reached for them so naturally that it had only just occurred to Snape, those were a gift a certain Slytherin parent had brought him.
Lucas's attention was caught.
He listened to a string of sweet names recited aloud and fell into a kind of inner struggle. A moment later, he appeared to reach some kind of decision: "What does a Cockroach Cluster taste like?"
"Why not try one and find out, you might just like it?" The Headmaster's eyes lit up as he launched into an enthusiastic sales pitch.
Snape swatted Lucas's reaching hand away, snatched the dish of sweets, and shoved it back into the drawer.
➤ Next: Unit Conversion
Chapter 108 - Unit Conversion
"Since when do children who misbehave get rewarded with sweets? I thought we gave up our dinner hour to come here and solve a problem. Or is handing out candy and exchanging hollow apologies your idea of handling things?"
Lucas felt, once again, that Snape's words were aimed at something specific.
And why would a parent be sending sweets to the Head of House at all?
Snape had already moved on to his disciplinary verdict: "Since the other party is a preschool-aged child, I will confine my penalty to my own House's student. I will revoke all appointments granted to Lucas Graham, and I will personally take over the procurement arrangements."
Lucas went still.
Something was very wrong here.
Shouldn't Professor Snape be playing along with him, working together to drive the other parent away?
Why was he so angry?
Did it have something to do with Headmaster Dumbledore?
Snape had once been a student at this school himself. Life in his House had never been easy for a half-blood, why hadn't Lucas thought of this before?
The Savior's mother was a Muggle-born Gryffindor. Snape was a half-blood Slytherin. How had those two ever managed to become friends?
Those tired, unoriginal school "pranks", had they touched Snape's years here as well?
Lucas had only ever looked at Snape's record: young Death Eater, Potions Master, Head of Slytherin. Those labels had completely buried everything that came before them.
Judging from Snape's reaction, had he been treated unjustly?
What kind of things had happened to him?
"Hold on a moment, Severus. I think giving Lucas an opportunity to grow is quite worthwhile — don't be so quick to withdraw your trust." Dumbledore stepped in before Snape could say something harsher.
The Headmaster offered Lucas a way out: "If I can persuade your Head of House to preserve your procurement responsibilities, would you still choose this gentleman as your supplier?"
Lucas answered without hesitation. "I would not."
That answer caught everyone off guard again.
But Lucas had reasons and numbers to back it up.
"Before I sent my inquiry, I went back and re-examined the quotes this gentleman has submitted over the past five years."
Lucas produced the ledger and opened it to a specific page. "Using African acacia thorns as an example: our ledger records weight in pounds, while materials suppliers generally follow the conventions of the country of origin — in this case, kilograms."
"The shop price he quoted in 1979 was three Galleons, six Sickles, and five Knuts per kilogram. Converted to imperial units, one pound should come to one Galleon, eight Sickles, and twenty-seven Knuts."
"For a batch order of fifty pounds, the correct total would be seventy-six Galleons, four Sickles, and sixteen Knuts."
"Yet the price he charged was eighty-four Galleons, seven Sickles, and fifteen Knuts. When I worked through the conversion, he had not converted to pounds at all — he had simply calculated in jin. The discrepancy that produced was seven Galleons, thirteen Sickles, and nineteen Knuts."
"Perhaps it was a genuine calculation error from unfamiliarity with the conversion. But the same kind of pricing error appears repeatedly across his quotes for imported materials. For some of them I can work out why the figure is wrong. For others I cannot. But in nearly every case, the school has overpaid."
Lucas looked around at the adults in the room. "From that perspective, if I am to remain responsible for this, I would propose reducing his share of the supply. That said, for domestically sourced materials, his prices are quite fair, that portion is still worth keeping."
He waited for any one of them to step forward, take the ledger, and check the numbers themselves.
He had always been sensitive to figures. Even when Snape first handed him the ledger, he had already worked out several obvious discrepancies in his head.
Horace Slughorn had been taking kickbacks, and the ledger's unit conventions were a mess on top of that, you could only trust the headings. Snape's calculations were sound, and there was no sign in the accounts that he had taken anything extra, but there were times when prices stayed the same and Snape had simply copied Slughorn's figures wholesale without working through them.
If their own teacher could not be bothered to recalculate, the least you could ask was that the supplier they hired could do basic arithmetic.
The adults in the room said nothing.
The Headmaster, the greatest white wizard of this century, finally reached over and took the ledger from Lucas.
Dumbledore found the entry Lucas had cited, drew his wand, and began checking the figures against the empty air.
Lucas quietly moved to Snape's side and tugged at the hem of his robes. Snape was still watching Dumbledore work his way through the school accounts with Arithmancy. He had been perfectly prepared to ignore Lucas, but Lucas tugged again. And again.
Irritated, Snape looked down and fixed him with a glare.
The little elf had heavy dark circles under his eyes. He must have been up consecutive nights again, piecing all of this together from those ledgers.
"Are you still not going to tell me what that newspaper actually said?" Snape said, his voice cold with contempt. "So you and Headmaster Dumbledore have a little secret. Something your lowly Potions professor isn't permitted to know. Do you really think I can't work it out?"
A newspaper held nothing but text and photographs, moving magical photographs.
Lucas had grown up in the Muggle world. What kind of photograph could make him that angry just from looking at it?
And then there was his chosen method of retaliation. Out of every petty jinx he could have used, he had specifically gone after the boy's face with magic.
The answer was straightforward enough.
Snape had made the front page of the Daily Prophet once, back when Dumbledore had vouched for him and secured his pardon. The Ministry of Magic had staked out a position near Hogsmeade Village and caught him passing through. He had been in poor shape that day, pushing past those persistent wizards in a hurry, but the steam flashbulbs had still caught him in that low, wrecked moment.
That had ended up on the front page.
There had been a wave of Howlers around that time.
Even now, wizards still sent him Howlers every month.
So the little wizard had scribbled all over his magical photograph, and Lucas, unable to hold his temper, had hauled the whole affair before the Headmaster?
Or perhaps it was simpler than that. Perhaps Lucas had only wanted to be rid of a supplier who could not do arithmetic.
One look at the child was enough to tell you that no one at home had ever said a kind word about Slytherin.
But Lucas was not the sort of wizard who cared about House pride.
So, had it been for Snape's sake?
The Potions professor watched without expression as Lucas tried to placate him, tugging at his robes, still playing innocent in front of Dumbledore.
And then there was Dumbledore's theory about the broken cup. Perhaps he ought to believe it. Perhaps Lucas really had set all of this in motion to protect him.
Snape looked back at Dumbledore, who was still running the calculations in mid-air. A wizard of that caliber even worked numbers differently from everyone else.
Dumbledore conjured an astrolabe. Under his spell, the figures from the ledger lifted off the page and drifted into it, spinning rapidly, until at last a result emerged.
The discrepancy was indeed more than seven Galleons.
➤ Next: The Sorting Choice
