HP:BTHBP — Chapter 77 - 78: Reputation by Association
The two of them appeared in Diagon Alley, separated from the chaos by only a single alleyway.
The moment Lucas steadied, a spell came flying.
Protego.
Lucas reacted instantly.
The spell had come from an official standing further down the alley, Rust Vaughan of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement.
Old memories came rushing in all at once.
The name Eddie Cartwright had been burning hot this whole time. The moment Lucas laid eyes on Rust, it slowly went cold.
Rust Vaughan was also a Gryffindor graduate. A former dormitory roommate of Eddie Cartwright.
Back then, both of them had been dead set on becoming Aurors.
The difference was that Rust's Potions grade hadn't made the cut. Rust had ended up settling, with some regret, for another position through the Ministry's general recruitment.
One subject. One score. Two completely different roads.
Right up until Eddie Cartwright's death, Cartwright had never known whether the dormitory brother from those years had played any part in the frame-up.
On the day of the Wizengamot trial, everyone had been worked into a fervor, whispering on the upper tiers, or hurling curses out loud.
Cloaked in the garb of justice, good and evil had blurred beyond recognition.
The memory of those chains weighed heavily.
Cartwright had walked in shackles down a long corridor, with Rust waiting at the far end.
Seeing the old classmate, Cartwright felt hope kindle. Stumbling into a run, grabbing hold of Rust's robes, shouting that it was wrong, that Cartwright was innocent.
Rust had looked at Cartwright with a deeply conflicted expression. Standing on the side of light to make a final pronouncement: "The Wizengamot does not convict wrongly. If you made a mistake, accept it and reform yourself."
"But I really am innocent — someone set me up! Don't you believe me? I'll take Veritaserum! Appeal for me, please, for the sake of everything we were — Rust!" Cartwright shook in waves from the Dementors nearby.
The wand had long since been confiscated. Only Rust's squirrel-form Patronus was keeping Cartwright's mind clear.
The trial itself had been no better, words coming out jumbled and incoherent, the Chief Warlock's gavel pounding like it meant to split open a skull.
"Cartwright, you trained as an Auror. Veritaserum is completely useless on you." Rust pried Cartwright's fingers from the robes, one by one.
They looked at each other. That expression, grief, disappointment, absolute certainty, became the final straw.
Since no one believed it.
Since two Aurors had genuinely died under Cartwright's command.
Since the Wizengamot had ruled Cartwright guilty.
The Dementors kept feeding, steadily draining away every happy memory.
As Cartwright let go, the Dementors descended from above, closing in, taking whatever happiness remained.
Now, Rust and Lucas stood roughly 50 meters apart in Diagon Alley, and there was no backup in sight.
No one had anticipated from the start that this operation would kick up such a commotion. The storm over Knockturn Alley and the valuables spilling out of the auction had thrown everything into chaos. The Department of Magical Law Enforcement had urgently dispatched Aurors to reinforce, pouring every available resource into the center of the disorder. Rust had also been heading for Knockturn Alley to assist at the perimeter, until Eddie Cartwright suddenly appeared.
"Cartwright." Rust's brow furrowed with open distaste. "I thought you would have learned your lesson from those months in Azkaban. And yet here you are, getting in even deeper, keeping company with a dark wizard."
Lucas glanced at Snape standing nearby, dressed head to toe in black. Every inch the dark wizard look, admittedly.
Lucas fired back: "Someone who failed Potions shouldn't be telling anyone else what to do."
"How long are the two of you planning to keep this up?"
Snape watched from a short distance away, frowning.
Gryffindor friendship was beyond him. And besides, this Cartwright was no longer the same person as before. What was the point of any of this?
Rust glanced at the impatient dark wizard standing to one side. Taking on two at once, the odds weren't good. After the initial hot-blooded impulse, Rust thought better of it and held off.
"I told you back then," Rust called out to Cartwright, "if you were innocent, you should have produced evidence! And now you turn up in Diagon Alley, right after that enormous disturbance in Knockturn Alley. I have reason to suspect your involvement. Come back with me for questioning!"
"Petrificus Totalus."
Lucas moved first. The spell hit Rust clean, Rust had not expected Cartwright to attack without warning.
A rigid, standing figure joined the cobblestones of Diagon Alley.
Lucas ran a hand through the hair. Rust's high-volume hollering had been giving Lucas a headache.
Two wizards in their thirties, yelling "innocent" and "guilty" at each other, what was this, reminiscing about lost youth?
Rust could only watch Cartwright's retreating back. Cartwright walked toward that robed, indistinct figure in all black.
They went side by side down Diagon Alley, moving further and further away.
"Attacking a Ministry of Magic official. Not afraid of standing trial again?"
"It was just a Petrificus Totalus. Hard to believe someone couldn't even dodge that." Lucas shook the head, then moved to dry Snape's robes, only to find that the Potions Master was already perfectly dry.
It hadn't even occurred to Lucas to handle that in passing.
Lucas sighed and dried out the clothes instead.
"Where are you headed?" Snape gave Cartwright a suspicious look. They had walked far enough that Rust could barely see them now.
"Don't look back. Keep going a little further." Cartwright kept the voice low. "Rust was Eddie Cartwright's dormitory roommate. They were very close, once. Rust is standing back there right now just waiting for us to look back. So let Rust watch us walk away in style."
Snape did not understand this particular variety of Gryffindor friendship.
But Snape was perfectly happy to watch a piece of it shatter. "Could that person be connected to the Tooth Fairy Powder? Any involvement in framing Cartwright?"
"Not confirmed yet." Lucas answered, only half-present. "Everything is too chaotic right now. Everyone looks like a suspect."
"Were you a Hogwarts student?" Snape asked abruptly. "I mean the version of you that calls himself an Alchemical Master?"
Cartwright was quiet for a moment. "Which house do you think I was in?"
Snape's first instinct was Slytherin. Then Gryffindor seemed just as likely, Cartwright's magic at the very end had been extraordinary, that wand pointed at the sky leaving a deep impression. And yet Cartwright didn't resemble the kind of Slytherin Snape was used to seeing.
Ravenclaw was also a possibility.
Snape had no intention of guessing wrong. Silence did the pressing instead.
Lucas waited. When it became clear Snape truly wasn't going to guess, Lucas thought it over and said: "I was in Hufflepuff!"
Snape stopped walking.
They looked at each other. The concealment charm masked every expression on Snape's face, but the way Snape stood there was an accusation all on its own: how could you possibly be a Hufflepuff.
This dark wizard hadn't said a single honest word.
A glimmer of amusement showed in Lucas's eyes. Lucas started counting off on the fingers.
"Our house has many admirable qualities. Look, first, integrity. Even in death, I could not stand by and let injustice happen. I crawled up out of the valley of death to raise the cry for justice!"
"Loyalty, in the face of danger, I even rescued you and my former senior Scamander!"
"Honesty — I answer every question you put to me!"
"Hard work and patience, that little Thunderbird clearly met you first, and yet it has been pecking away at my fingers this entire time, and I haven't even defended myself!"
➤ Next: Their Own Thoughts
Chapter 78 - Their Own Thoughts
Snape's wand was itching for action.
"Eddie Cartwright!" he called out, voice laced with threat.
"My name isn't an exclamation mark, you don't have to shout it like one. Oh, look, you've called the little bird out!" Lucas's eyes were bright with amusement.
Lucas looked perfectly serious, but had quietly moved a hand to just outside a pocket, making it easy for the little Thunderbird to crawl out and hop onto the palm.
Snape didn't look at the chirping Thunderbird.
He turned sharply, swung his cloak, and picked up the pace.
"Hah!" Lucas had wanted to crack a few more jokes, but the Thunderbird in hand had other ideas.
After its chirping attempts to summon Snape went nowhere, it flapped its bare, downy little wings, pushed off from Lucas's palm, and glided, landing squarely on Snape's robes.
A small, flesh-colored creature clung with great difficulty to the black fabric.
Snape went completely still, as though hit by a Body-Bind Curse.
Lucas couldn't hold it in and laughed out loud. This time it was confirmed: Severus Snape was helpless against small fluffy creatures.
Lucas quickened his steps to catch up, talking as he walked. "Let this loyal Hufflepuff come rescue you."
"Eddie Cartwright!" Snape's voice came through gritted teeth.
"Ah! There you are!" A voice cut across their exchange.
Newt appeared abruptly before both of them, riding the Zouwu. Newt looked a mess, coat dripping, leather case rattling and snapping from inside.
Dawn had not yet broken.
In the dim light, Newt made out the mysterious wizard still standing tall and aloof, while the bare-faced wizard who'd called himself Cartwright was pulling a small, featherless bird off the mysterious wizard's robes.
Newt's attention snapped over at once. "That's the missing Thunderbird chick!"
Newt looked at the two wizards with wariness, especially the one in black, suddenly no longer certain whether they were friend or foe.
"Here." Snape snatched the little Thunderbird from Lucas's hand and tossed it toward Newt.
The Zouwu flinched slightly at the moving object, its gaze following the chick through the air.
Newt reached for it on instinct, but hadn't anticipated that the Thunderbird chick had already learned to glide. Or that it could glide back the way it came.
However it had been thrown, the little bundle looped smoothly back and landed on Snape's arm.
Snape went rigid again. Even in black robes, he cut no intimidating figure at this moment.
Lucas held back the laugh this time.
Lucas realized that Severus Snape was still a wizard in his twenties.
Lucas walked over and coaxed the Thunderbird off Snape again, then explained to Newt: "This little one got its first look at our... mysterious man-in-black. I'm afraid some kind of magical imprinting bond has formed between them."
Newt took the chick Lucas handed over. The little creature made a determined effort to lean back toward the dark-clad wizard.
"My friend here is not in a position to raise a bird. It works out perfectly to return it to its mother." Lucas fished another piece of white bread from a pocket and coaxed the Thunderbird to peck at it.
"But how do you...", know that the mother Thunderbird is with me?
Lucas raised one finger to his lips. Then explained: "This Thunderbird caused such severe damage at the Ministry of Magic, the Ministry will certainly find a way to sentence it to death. It's a good thing for it to go with you."
"But—"
Newt's words were cut off by Snape. "Do I look like a bird's mother? Take it away. Otherwise tomorrow I'll use it as experimental material."
Who on earth would believe a threat like that?
Lucas had just been about to smooth things over when he turned and caught the grave look on Newt's face, a hesitant expression that hadn't been there before.
"But—"
"You can go ahead and take both Thunderbirds without worry. Although this chick did first lay eyes on the 'mysterious man-in-black'", Lucas was quite pleased with the nickname, "as long as it continues to follow its mother, the imprinting won't last very long."
Watching two wizards arrange everything so neatly between themselves, Newt shook his head. "But I have no way of taking either Thunderbird."
That single sentence stopped both wizards mid-preparation to Apparate.
The reason Snape and Cartwright had been walking through Diagon Alley on foot was primarily to draw Newt out into the open.
Lucas knew there was no way Snape could leave with the Thunderbird chick.
At the very end of the earlier storm, standing at the eye of the magical tempest, both Lucas and Snape had briefly gained a clear field of vision. Unlike the Aurors and Dark wizards still fumbling blind, they had seen Newt Scamander riding the Zouwu, using the leather case to shelter the Thunderbird that had fallen from the sky.
Newt had finally stopped them.
Newt let out a breath and explained: "I've been on the British Ministry of Magic's surveillance list all along. Every magical creature I carry is subject to strict inspection, especially after a storm like that. There is no way I can hide this Thunderbird."
"Have you tried asking the all-powerful Professor Dumbledore for help?" Lucas offered.
It was the first time Snape had ever heard anyone call Dumbledore "all-powerful." The title carried no particular reverence. What Hufflepuff would call the old headmaster that?
Snape felt a flash of shame at having entertained, even for a moment, the idea that Cartwright was a Hufflepuff.
Lucas was completely unaware of this. The phrase was borrowed from some of the later assessments in the Daily Prophet. The storm magic from just now had left Lucas feeling a rush unlike anything before.
This kind of power, achieved without a single spoken incantation, could not be replicated in the short term. But a higher threshold had been glimpsed, and that mattered. Every great wizard had inevitably passed through trials and ordeals, large and small.
Lucas had burned through the better part of magical reserves, and was buzzing with it.
Newt was not fond of Cartwright's choice of words either. "The headmaster has hidden a Thunderbird once before," Newt said, shaking his head. "I think that avenue is closed too."
Both Snape and Lucas heard that Newt was still building toward something.
Snape spoke first. Without naming Cartwright as an Alchemy Master, Snape simply said: "Sheltering two magical creatures, I imagine Mr. Cartwright would be willing to oblige."
"Weren't you saying you wanted me to bear witness, Mr. Cartwright?" Snape's tone was light. There was reason enough to establish a connection with Cartwright, and this Thunderbird was a useful test of exactly what sort of wizard Cartwright was.
Cartwright had called himself an Alchemy Master. Had claimed to have returned to the world of the living after death.
Albus Dumbledore, the greatest wizard of this century, had made it explicitly clear to Snape: one day the Dark Lord would return.
The Dark Lord had vanished. He likely no longer possessed a physical body. In what form would he return? Could Eddie Cartwright, a wizard who had already strayed from the rightful path, become an instrument for that return? Might the method of resurrection apply equally to the Dark Lord?
Snape had to confirm these matters with far greater care.
Lucas had also anticipated that Snape would say something like this. After all, if Dumbledore sheltered the Thunderbird, the chick would immediately expose Snape's identity.
The war had just ended, and the savior was still very young. Lucas guessed that at this stage Snape would not be reporting to Dumbledore the matter of someone having possessed Eddie Cartwright. Snape would need to consolidate the intelligence first, verify it beyond doubt, and only then inform Dumbledore, that had always been the value Snape offered.
That window of time was enough.
"But—" This time it was Lucas who was cut off.
➤ Next: Not Worth Very Much
