HP:BTHBP — Chapter 69 - 70: Dressed in a Lion's Skin, Part One
Snape tamped down his irritation and asked Lucas: "Are you going to tell me you were sleepwalking?"
He had heard every conceivable excuse in a semester of night patrols. He didn't mind collecting one more.
"I was not sleepwalking!" Lucas defended himself at speed. "I just heard a noise—"
"A noise that compelled you to climb out of bed and transform into a dove?"
"...My roommate still hadn't come back, so I wanted to check." Lucas pushed on quickly. "I'm still wearing my slippers. I had no intention of going far."
Snape looked him up and down. He understood Lucas's game now.
Slytherins never forgot a grudge. From what Snape knew, Lucas's roommate had made Lucas cheer at Quidditch matches, clean the dormitory, and copy Lucas's homework.
Snape gave a cold laugh. He knew all this because Lucas had been regularly tattling on the roommate to the Head of Slytherin.
Catching the roommate out after curfew, with a professor conveniently nearby, of course Lucas wanted to pile on.
But this was still a first-year. With Greengrass's backing and a barely passable excuse, already baring fangs?
"I recall warning you not to leave the dormitory." Snape cut him off. Under other circumstances he might have taken the time to dissect Lucas's motives, using them to deflate Lucas's self-satisfaction and foolishness. Not tonight.
"I—"
"Five points from Slytherin." Snape's voice went cold. "For ignoring a professor's warning. Lucas Graham, I expect to see those five points earned back doubled before next Friday. Am I understood?"
Lucas hung his head. Snape couldn't make out the expression, but he could see the firm nod.
"Good. Now — do you have any idea where your roommate might have gone tonight?"
Lucas shook his head.
Eric Morrison, standing beside Lucas, raised a hand with enthusiasm. "I think I might know, Professor, he's at..."
Eleven-thirty.
Snape caught a group of first-year Slytherins at the Astronomy Tower competing with first-year Gryffindors for so-called "house glory." He docked twenty points from Gryffindor and handed Argus Filch a new candidate for community service.
"In you go."
Snape personally escorted the shivering students back to the dormitory. Lucas poked a head out from behind the bed curtains, took one look, and immediately vanished back inside.
Snape swept the dormitory once, then cast a Nox and extinguished the lights.
Eleven-forty.
No time to change. Snape hastily fastened the everyday teaching robes, threw on his cloak, and left the school through a secret passage.
Midnight.
Just past midnight.
Snape's Portkey lost its glow and reverted to an ordinary glass bead.
He knew he was late. In all likelihood Cartwright had already entered the auction.
One chance in ten that Cartwright was still waiting, and if so, he would finally be able to determine what that wizard actually wanted.
Snape walked into an underground bar in Knockturn Alley, ordered a drink, and sat at the counter.
Lucas arrived late. Knockturn Alley was saturated with anti-tracking charms, and Lucas had been forced to go shop by shop.
At this hour, the bar was sparsely populated, most patrons tucked away in booths.
Lucas passed by outside and peered in through the grimy windowpanes.
Snape sat in his black robes beneath the dim yellow light, a peculiar quality about him, waiting and thinking at once, frowning as his fingers drummed the table.
Lucas walked in under the name Eddie Cartwright.
A light pat on the back of Snape's chair, tone easy. "Did you stand me up just to come drink, Severus? I thought you'd take our appointment a little more seriously."
"You didn't make it into the auction either." Snape stated it plainly.
Lucas exhaled under Eddie's name. There was nothing to be done about that.
After Snape hauled the roommate back, Lucas had stayed ten minutes listening to the adventure story, something about Gryffindors trembling in a pitch-dark corridor, hesitant and skittish, though the roommate said not one word about being too afraid to push to the front.
Lucas couldn't see what effect proving "Gryffindors aren't that brave" was supposed to have. Perhaps it would let the roommate become the first "courageous Slytherin"?
The minds of minors were difficult to read. Fortunately, there was always a Sleeping Charm.
Lucas had been late too.
But as long as Snape hadn't entered the auction, Snape would never know.
Lucas stopped dwelling on it. A glance at the time, then an extended hand toward Snape. "Since you're still here, let's go."
Snape had ordered the drink but not touched a drop. He warily pulled the glass back toward his own side, even the glass needed to keep its distance from Cartwright.
Snape was waiting for an explanation from Eddie Cartwright.
Lucas scratched at his hair, a touch of exasperation creeping in. "I won't make an issue of you investigating me. So are we fine?"
Of course they were not fine. There were far too many problems.
Snape had deliberately chosen a bar for this. Without the cover of that dangerous wizarding house, this was a far better place to settle accounts with Cartwright.
Snape chose the most pressing question. "Why did you insist on bringing me to the auction?"
"Because you're a witness." From Snape's tone, Lucas judged this conversation would take a while. A wave brought the bartender over, and Lucas ordered a drink.
"A witness to what, for a former Death Eater? Who would believe any of it?" Snape mocked, Cartwright still wasn't telling the truth.
"You are Dumbledore's man." The name Eddie burned at the wrist. Lucas was silent for a moment before continuing. "Someone needs to bear witness... that Eddie Cartwright did not betray his companions."
Snape noticed the movement. He wasn't convinced. "If that were truly the case, what you need isn't an auction, you need me to introduce you to the Headmaster. If the Headmaster is even willing to believe you."
Lucas was quiet.
Snape took that for Cartwright thinking through how to be convincing.
Snape gave no time to react. "A friend of mine found the records for that Knockturn Alley house at the Ministry of Magic. This looks very much like another dereliction of duty on your part. Explain to me how a house that is actually the family property of other pure-blood wizards came to look as though it belonged to someone called Eddie Cartwright, a wizard who betrayed fellow Aurors and was sentenced to Azkaban."
He pressed further. "The most plausible explanation I can think of is that you spotted that house while you were still an Auror and simply seized it for yourself. You don't look nearly as destitute as the average wizard fresh out of Azkaban. What exactly do you have to offer that would make Headmaster Dumbledore believe a word you say?"
➤ Next: Wearing the Lion's Skin (Part Two)
Chapter 70 - Wearing the Lion's Skin (Part Two)
"I said, I only need a witness." Lucas spoke unhurriedly. He had long anticipated Snape turning on him. "You now believe I'm Eddie Cartwright — that I seized a Dark wizard's house, that I graduated from Gryffindor, that my dream was to become an Auror, and that I got two of my companions killed. Is that right?"
Lucas threw out a contradiction. "You accuse me of being a traitor, yet you're also puzzled — why would Lucius Malfoy be hunted by both a werewolf and an Auror simply for investigating my name?"
Snape cut him off. "The werewolf and the Auror are only your word. You could easily have hired people to stage that entire scene."
Cartwright seemed stumped. Lucas was not. The answer had been ready for a long time. "If pinning me as the killer would put an end to all of this, perhaps that isn't so bad."
Lucas moved to roll up his sleeve.
The bartender, in the middle of setting down a glass of Firewhisky, paused for just a fraction of a second. Baring the tattoo on one's arm had become a rather sensitive gesture in Knockturn Alley lately.
"Sir," the bartender said politely, "perhaps you would prefer a private room for your conversation."
When Lucas's hand touched his own arm, Snape's mind raced through possibilities. He quickly considered whether he had ever encountered this former Auror among the Dark Lord's ranks.
"Then — a private room?" Lucas waited for Snape's reply.
They changed locations. The bartender, looking slightly anxious, sent along an extra plate of fish and chips.
Once the bartender withdrew, Lucas rolled up his sleeve again. Along his wrist ran a series of red, blurred lines, faint and indistinct.
Snape frowned and leaned in to study them. From the magical resonance, this was a vow-type enchantment. He waited for Cartwright to explain further.
"I imagine you know the Unbreakable Vow. This is a variant of it." Lucas patiently traced a triangular section of the markings on his wrist. "This is the rune for exchange. There is a name on each side of it. Eddie Cartwright is already dead, and I am here to find the truth for him."
It took Snape a full two seconds to grasp what Cartwright was implying. He concluded that this Auror had perhaps finally broken his own brain.
Before Snape could say anything mocking, Lucas asked, "You went to Garrick Ollivander to have your wand examined, did he not tell you the person who adjusted it was an alchemical master? Since I am indeed Eddie Cartwright, and a former Auror's records at the Ministry of Magic are thorough, it would be impossible for me to also be an expert in alchemy." Lucas fastened his cuff. He settled back comfortably and watched Snape sink into a new round of thought.
After a long moment, Snape asked carefully: "What exactly are you?"
He had, in fact, read similar descriptions in books on the Dark Arts. Whatever a wizard summoned at the cost of his own life tended to be extremely dangerous.
"A shadow from a former time." Lucas was quiet for a moment. He thought of the eleven years on Platform Nine and Three-Quarters and let out a sigh. "I consider myself an alchemical master whose talents went unrecognized."
Snape's mouth twitched. He wanted to point out that "unrecognized talents" and "alchemical master" had no business appearing in the same sentence, but what he actually asked was: "What were the terms of the ritual?"
"I must prove Eddie Cartwright's innocence, and after that," Lucas ate a chip and smiled. "After that, I will be Eddie Cartwright."
That left Snape feeling cold.
If this method was legitimate, it was deeply sinister magic. Dangerous. He pressed for the specifics. "Were you alive or dead when you entered the ritual?"
"Dead." Lucas was happy to flesh out the story. "I told you my talents went unrecognized, I was trapped inside that house. You drew blood in the alley, and the house awakened. I opened it to save you. Eddie Cartwright, who had been following you, entered the house and triggered the ritual."
Snape worked through the chain of events.
The entire story was absurd. The logic, however, held. There had been two separate groups fighting him in the alley: Eddie Cartwright had been investigating the Tooth Fairy, while the werewolf had been sent by the auction house to intercept and kill him. The reason this person in front of him had been shadowing him so persistently was most likely because he was genuinely the witness the ritual required.
A moment ago, Snape had been trying to prove Eddie Cartwright was a corrupt Auror. Now he needed to prove this person was not Eddie Cartwright at all.
"What kind of person were you before? What alchemical works did you produce?"
Lucas answered only the second question. "I studied alchemical rituals and magical architecture, and I crafted certain instruments. I am already Eddie Cartwright now. As for who I was before, I think we should preserve a sense of mystery."
Mystery be damned.
Snape's expression did not change.
Everything he had asked Lucius to investigate had become this wizard's advantage. Cartwright, for now, but everything about this wizard remained a complete enigma.
"What is there left for us to do?" Snape asked, with no great willingness. "You want me to accompany you while you 'prove your innocence.' What exactly do I get out of it?"
Lucas smiled under the name Eddie Cartwright and answered without hesitation. "I can build you a perfect laboratory. An exclusive commission from an alchemical master."
Snape laughed coldly. "We've already missed the auction."
Lucas shook his head. He stood and extended a hand toward Snape once more. "I don't think we have. Let me prove it."
Snape had no particular desire for physical contact, but Lucas tossed two gold Galleons onto the table and grabbed his wrist himself.
The next instant, Snape felt a hook jerk somewhere behind his navel. His feet left the ground. Everything blurred.
"Steady, we've arrived." When they landed, Lucas caught Snape as he pitched forward, steadied him on his feet, and was promptly shoved off.
The light around them was bright, the scene entirely changed.
A wizard stood with wand raised, visibly tense. Long platinum hair gleamed in the light.
"Lucius?"
"Severus? Name the last book you borrowed from me." Lucius's wand did not move.
Snape gave the answer. "A History of the Dark Arts."
He was deeply displeased at the question and turned it back immediately. "What was the book I borrowed before that one?"
Lucius was stumped.
He scrambled to offer a different shared secret instead. Snape had already nodded. "If you can't remember," he said, with complete certainty, "then you're definitely Malfoy."
Lucas listened to the whole exchange from the side and offered a slow, sardonic round of applause. "Do you go through this interrogation every time you see each other?"
Snape's reply was cool. "Ordinarily, no, except when I appear somewhere I shouldn't, in the company of someone whose identity is unknown."
He placed deliberate weight on several phrases in that sentence. The note of accusation was unmistakable, plain enough that even Lucius found himself wondering exactly what the two of them had exchanged while he wasn't watching.
➤ Next: Auction, Part One
