HP:BTHBP — Chapter 61 - 62: Investigation Progress
After the funeral, Lucas and Snape returned to the castle while Newt headed to Hagrid's hut.
The dark grey cloak kept out the wind and snow well enough, but it dragged a long tail through the snow behind him. Lucas had barely taken a few steps before the robes caught at his feet.
Lucas pulled out a wand and cast a Transfiguration charm on the trailing hem. The shrunken garment fit considerably better — though it made Lucas look even smaller than before.
Snape had already set off toward the castle at a brisk pace. After covering some distance he glanced back, only to find Lucas still fussing with the cloak, nowhere near caught up.
Snape waited. His patience was beginning to fray by the time Lucas finally reached his side.
"Keep up." Snape slowed his pace marginally.
It didn't help much. The snow dragged at Lucas's steps. Lucas pressed on with head down, the Bowtruckle on one shoulder cheering along, its vivid green a sharp splash of color against all that white.
"Is there still community service today, Professor?" Lucas broke the silence when the castle was finally in sight.
Snape was in the middle of applying a drying charm to his robes. He raised an eyebrow. "Of course. The purpose of community service is to punish disobedient students — or did you think cancellations happen every day?"
Lucas looked at him, then hesitated. "You look very tired. You barely rested yesterday."
"That is not a reason to cancel your community service."
So much had happened in two days, Lucius, 'Eddie' in Knockturn Alley, the fire in the Forbidden Forest, the dead Acromantula. It was only when Lucas brought it up that Snape even remembered why he had cancelled community service the day before.
He straightened his robes and pushed open the castle door. "Get inside."
Lucas went through ahead of him, tidied up the cloak, and drew two vials from a pocket.
Earlier, while Newt had Snape's attention diverted, Lucas had collected the Acromantula's venom. "Professor, these are for you."
Snape gave a cold snort. "I haven't sunk so low as to compete with a student for specimens." He had been about to leave, but stopped. "Do you know where to go to handle something like this?"
Lucas hesitated, uncertain whether to nod or shake his head.
The vials were lifted from Lucas's hand. "Community service tonight, on time." Snape gave no indication of where the vials were going. The black cloak swept around the end of the corridor and vanished.
Lunch break. The library.
As Snape passed Madam Pince's desk, he gave a brief nod. Half a term into teaching, wherever Snape walked, the whispering stopped.
The more curious students sneaked glances back to see which shelf Snape was heading toward.
Alice, who had patched things up with Lucas after the holiday, tapped Lucas with the tip of her quill.
Lucas was working through a large reference volume, coursework for History of Magic. Having fallen asleep in class was no reason to do a careless job on the assignment.
The moment Snape disappeared among the rows of shelves, the low hum of conversation swelled back to fill the room.
"Did you see Professor Snape? He just walked past." Alice pointed in the direction he'd gone, a small frown on her face. "That's the archive section, isn't it? He actually didn't go to the Restricted Section?"
Lucas found the sentence needed in a passage about a goblin rebellion. The line went down quickly and Lucas said without looking up, "Maybe the Professor needs to look something up."
Alice suddenly thought of something. "Did you ever find the book you were looking for in the archive section?"
She meant the enrollment record for Lucas's mother. Hogwarts kept records of every student's enrollment and graduation dates, and following those yearbooks, one could find the graduation photographs.
The year Lucas was searching for had been listed as on loan the entire time.
Even after Christmas Lucas had kept watching that shelf, but, "No one has returned it yet."
"Could it have just gone missing? What would you do then? Have you asked Madam Pince?" Alice asked, her voice full of concern.
Lucas's writing hand stilled for just a moment. "I'd rather not ask anyone," came the answer, a trace of discomfort in the voice. A small expression of embarrassment showed, as though looking for a mother's records on the school shelves was something that made Lucas uneasy.
Alice caught that immediately.
She fell quiet, a little guilty, and to change the subject murmured half to herself, "What on earth is Professor Snape doing over there?"
Severus Snape was using his free period to conduct an investigation.
He came to a stop beside the shelves organized chronologically by year.
Like anyone else, he instinctively glanced toward the year most relevant to himself, 1978, not so long ago at all.
The gilt lettering on that volume's spine still gleamed. Hardly anyone would go looking through a year that had only just passed.
Snape didn't pull that one out. His gaze moved forward along the timeline.
Wizards lived long lives, and Eddie Cartwright showed no signs of aging. Snape pulled out all the volumes from 1950 through 1975.
Eddie Cartwright had claimed to have graduated from Gryffindor. Snape moved through the books quickly. Graduation photographs were always in the last few pages, and Snape turned to the back,
1960
1961
...
1968
He nearly missed it. Face after ignorant face, grinning and jostling each other, his temper was already rising. He had turned past that page when something snagged at the edge of his attention, a flicker of recognition from somewhere in the middle of the group.
Snape turned back.
There. Eddie Cartwright, a young Gryffindor standing in the center of the group photograph, smiling school staff arranged in front of the students. A joyful smile on that face, both shoulders draped over by classmates on either side, the whole crowd mid-argument about what word they'd all call out together for the photograph,
Click —
That moment had been fixed on the school's archive shelves ever since.
Snape prodded the two Gryffindors flanking Eddie Cartwright. The figures shied away to either side, leaving Eddie Cartwright to look left, then right.
Those blue eyes were unmistakably identical to the ones Snape had seen in Knockturn Alley.
Snape had assumed Eddie Cartwright appeared neither particularly young nor particularly old, but seeing this wizard at the moment of graduation, it felt like a completely different person.
1968. Snape ran the numbers. That would make Eddie Cartwright thirty-one years old now.
The two of them had been in different houses, and by the time Snape enrolled, Eddie had already been gone from the school for years.
Snape turned to the earlier pages and found the transcript.
Defence Against the Dark Arts, Potions, Transfiguration, Herbology, and Charms, all Outstanding. History of Magic and Astronomy, Exceeds Expectations.
Snape copied out the relevant two pages and left the library.
➤ Next: A Winter Coat
Chapter 62 - A Winter Coat
Lucas had no classes for the last two periods of the afternoon. He slept for a few hours in the Room of Requirement.
The fire in the Forbidden Forest the previous night had made one thing clear: the staff would be checking whether any students had snuck out after hours. Lucas had hurried back to the dormitory to sign in, waited for the prefect to leave, then slipped out again to retrieve Argos.
Argos's torn body had left behind no blood, no flesh. The ritual construct had shattered and dissolved into black mist, which made the retrieval considerably easier.
The mist coiled around Lucas's hand. He gathered it into a glass vial.
The risk had been worth it.
Lucas could sense that Argos was transforming. He steadily channeled magical energy into the construct and waited to see what Argos would become.
At 7 o'clock sharp, Lucas arrived at the dungeon.
Medusa, standing guard at the entrance, stepped aside to let him through.
He walked into Snape's office with his school bag. No one was at the desk.
Lucas set his bag down and checked the supply room. Nothing inside except a stack of clean cauldrons.
He looked at the two remaining closed doors, thought for a moment, then pulled a draft notebook from his bag and Transfigured it into a small folding stool.
When Snape came out of the inner room, Lucas was reading, leaning against the wooden leg of the office desk, murmuring quietly to himself.
He noticed the professor enter and looked up. He Transfigured the stool back without fumbling, stood up straight, and waited.
Snape rubbed the back of his stiff neck.
Even after a short nap, he was still exhausted. He looked at Lucas standing there attentively and said, "Where is the cloak Mr. Scamander gave you?"
Lucas's clothes were slightly thicker than before, but the cloak from earlier in the day was gone.
"Mr. Scamander left the school this afternoon — he came to find the Bowtruckle. I returned the cloak to him." Lucas corrected himself carefully, switching from "Newt" to "Mr. Scamander," matching Snape's habit.
Snape hadn't expected him to adjust that fast. A reluctant laugh escaped him.
He settled into his chair. The pile of student essays on his desk greeted him, and his mood soured immediately.
"You wander around the castle dressed like that, and when outside guests come through, they'll think Slytherin makes a fashion of wearing a single robe in winter?"
Snape understood that wizards from modest backgrounds sometimes dressed poorly in the cold. But Lucas learned fast, even running a small side business at school, there was no reason to look this threadbare.
"I simply haven't gotten around to it, Professor." Lucas said, flat.
The truth was that last night's events had run too close together. He'd been putting out fires and hadn't had time to think about much else.
"Then take care of yourself." Snape fixed him with a brief look and snapped his fingers. A house-elf appeared.
He instructed it to bring a chair, then to deliver supper to the dungeon.
"Professor, the labor service —" Lucas hadn't finished the sentence. He watched Snape open a drawer, take out a coin pouch, and drop several handfuls of gold Galleons onto the desk.
"The agreed price for the Acromantula venom." Snape looked at him, Lucas was clearly not quite himself today, and asked with undisguised contempt: "Did you not read the part in the textbook where it says this material is quite valuable?"
Lucas stared at the gleaming Galleons.
After a long moment, he said nothing. He took out his own coin pouch and pocketed the coins.
Once the money was secured, he caught the look in Snape's eyes. A warning. One that clearly forbade anything sentimental.
He thought about the last incident, the one involving the word "decent." A small mischievous impulse stirred.
Lucas cleared his throat. Under Snape's watchful gaze, he said: "I hadn't expected you to find a buyer so quickly."
Snape relaxed slightly. He assumed the matter was settled and was about to assign Lucas his labor service,
"With this money," Lucas said, unhurried, "I think I'll be able to buy a winter coat that's truly my own." He put a distinct emphasis on "truly my own."
Snape had already picked up his quill. He stopped. A drop of ink fell onto the parchment beneath it, and he used the moment to give that particular essay a large, deliberate "D."
He looked up. "Mr. Lucas Graham," he said, in a measured tone, "your labor service today was originally going to be sorting the newly arrived Potions ingredients. But your forgetful Potions professor has just recalled that there are five unwashed cauldrons in the Potions classroom..."
CRACK. The house-elf arrived with Snape's supper and the requested chair.
Under Snape's direction, the house-elf placed the chair on the opposite side of his desk, then received one more instruction: "Go fetch the five unwashed cauldrons from the Potions classroom and bring them here."
The house-elf vanished.
Lucas watched his Potions professor lean back in the lamplight, a slow, wicked smile spreading across his face. Snape announced, with undisguised satisfaction:
"Your assignment has been changed. To celebrate your having a winter coat that is truly your own — go wash your cauldrons."
➤ Next: Ministry of Magic Investigation
