💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 29, 2026

HP:BTHBP — Chapter 19 - 20: The Innocent Bear the Consequences

Lucas stood behind the older students. The Slytherin and Gryffindor students had separated into their own clusters, robes bearing the marks of a magical scuffle, and quite a few of the Great Hall's dishes had ended up on the floor.

He watched the two sides refuse to budge. In the narrow corridor they shoved and jostled for position, and every small flare-up died the instant Professor McGonagall turned around with a sharp look.

They filed into Professor McGonagall's office in a stumbling, grudging procession.

The sequence of events was actually quite simple.

During the first two periods of Potions that morning, Gryffindor students had thrown frogs into the other house's cauldrons and injured several people. Once the Headmaster stepped in, both sides had smothered their anger — grudgingly. Word was that Snape's expression during that class had been so thunderous that even the most oblivious student could reasonably work out that causing further trouble would earn a curse. He was already rumored to be a Dark wizard, after all.

The real trouble started with the first wave of students to reach the Great Hall for lunch.

Ryan Shafiq, devoted follower of the philosophy of success, lived by one personal creed: I need not be the one who succeeds, but no success shall happen without me. Acting on this, Ryan took the Golden Snitch firework gotten from Lucas and went to show it off to the older students.

The so-called Slytherin Quidditch support plan had its origins in the players' long-running grievance that Gryffindor had monopolized the commentator's box, used it to ramble nonsense during matches, and leveraged a loud voice to slip in cheers for their own house at every opportunity.

So some of the older students, on a whim after a match, had declared: this year, we are going to show Gryffindor exactly what Slytherin solidarity looks like.

The task passed down from the upper years to the lower-year ringleaders, then to Lucas's dormitory mate, and finally landed on Lucas.

Now, with credit sitting on the table, Ryan Shafiq had gone to collect a share.

None of them had anticipated that at noon that day, in full view of the entire Great Hall, the firework would simply go off.

The paper box sitting on the table gave a single shudder. Then a beam of gold light studded with glitter shot straight upward, blazing all the way to the enchanted ceiling where the weather magic lived. It was midday and no holiday, so the House-elves had already taken down the suspended candles, and the weather charm had settled on an overcast sky. Into that grey, the brilliant gold erupted. Glitter scattered like fine rain. The firework did not vanish immediately — instead it assembled itself into a richly saturated, glittering Golden Snitch, beat its wings a few times in the air, and then the great mass of gold dust dissolved, leaving only a fist-sized shape traced in fine shimmer. It circled once and disappeared with a comet's trailing tail.

Every student with a free period during third and fourth lessons saw the whole thing.

This was the Slytherin Quidditch campaign's secret weapon. They had planned the spectacle from the start — not fully trusting their chances on the pitch, they had intended to dominate in atmosphere instead.

A handful of Gryffindors booed loudly. The back-and-forth dragged in the morning's Potions incident for good measure, and then no one quite knew who was the first to break and reach for a wand. The brawl was underway.

Professor McGonagall heard out every participant's account and issued point deductions and punishments for each act of foolishness in turn.

At the end, the gaze came to rest on Lucas, who had been standing there throughout as an accompanying penalty. "Mr. Graham, do you know why you were called here?"

Lucas felt every pair of eyes in the room settle on him. He didn't look at Professor McGonagall. He fixed his gaze on a crack in the floorboards and offered a sincere accounting: "I should not have given the match prop to my classmates ahead of time. Professor Snape said it was only to be brought out during the match."

Everyone in that room understood the unspoken part perfectly well. If the older students had simply decided they wanted it early, a first-year could not have truly refused them.

Professor McGonagall let out a quiet sigh and swept a gaze around the room. In the period just after the Dark Lord's fall, the tensions between houses had grown sharper than in ordinary years. Lucas was clearly the relatively innocent party, but that didn't mean there could be no punishment at all. "In that case, Mr. Graham, I will leave your punishment to your Head of House to decide." The older students were dismissed; only Lucas was kept behind.

Once the others had gone, a House-elf was sent for a small plate of refreshments and a pot of hot tea.

"I have noticed that you always eat lunch very late, Lucas." Professor McGonagall nudged the plate forward. It was clearly meant for Lucas.

Lucas sat down and reached for a biscuit. He chewed a few mechanical bites without really tasting it. He listened as Professor McGonagall made the point about eating at regular hours, then was asked whether he had any difficulties with his studies.

He still had his bag with him. He swallowed the last biscuit in a hurry and asked several questions about Transfiguration spells he'd come across in outside reading.

Professor McGonagall answered them, then asked whether the tapestry the older students had mentioned, Lucas's tapestry, was also a product of Transfiguration work.

"It's actually Alchemy," Lucas said. "I grew up in the Muggle world, and when I thought about magic, I always pictured spells and... Alchemy. I found a few books on tapestry-making in the library and made some attempts."

A rough explanation of the underlying principles followed. Alchemy was Lucas's true area of mastery, and the operational logic could be laid out in the plainest terms for someone outside the field, giving the comfortable impression that they could manage it themselves if they tried.

Professor McGonagall clearly felt where Lucas's real passion lived. A scholar can never fully conceal the thing they are genuinely devoted to.

There was a faint smile when looking at Lucas. "I think this is genuinely a very good idea. Though I am not your Head of House, I am going to award Slytherin three points for your effort."

Lucas's face went slightly red. The excitement that had crept in while talking about Alchemy eased back a little.

Professor McGonagall caught the hesitation and asked encouragingly: "Is there something else on your mind?"

Lucas made up his mind. "There's still a week before the Quidditch match. Since Slytherin has prepared something, I think the other houses ought to prepare as well. The players all work very hard." There followed a description of the standard support programs from post-war Quidditch World Cups: giant mascot costumes, balloon airships, various charms that could summon small fairies or turn the spectators in the stands the color of their house, and so forth.

Lucas left Professor McGonagall's office before the midday break ended.

Whether by coincidence or not, having stayed longer than the others cooled the temper of those who had been inclined to pin the blame on Lucas. The several older students who had thought about waylaying him found they had afternoon classes to get to instead.

Lucas stood outside Professor McGonagall's door for half a minute.

Then headed off to afternoon lessons.


➤ Next: Hidden Among the Trees

Chapter 20 - Hidden Among the Trees

When classes ended that day, Lucas was summoned to Snape's office.

The corridor leading to the Potions Master's office had seen no foot traffic since the first week of term. The further you walked in that direction, the fewer students appeared. Lucas stopped before the stone door, and the guardian statue blinked at him, the door swung open.

This was his second visit to the Head of House's office since term began.

He stepped into the dim room. The stone door closed behind him. The Gnome sculpture still sat at the corner of the desk. Lucas walked quietly to the other side.

His professor was frowning over a stack of essays. The desk lamp cast light across Snape's face, giving the skin a waxy quality. Snape looked nothing like the lively students and teachers one saw during the day, yet still remarkably young. Nothing like the sleeping portrait Lucas had glimpsed in the Headmaster's office years later.

Though Lucas had only ever been a passing visitor to that office, in another life. He hadn't spent any more attention on Snape's portrait than on the others hanging there.

Everything before the war had been, to him, words on a page.

"You've been spending quite a lot of time with the Ravenclaw students?" Snape marked a large 'D' on a piece of parchment. Whoever had written that essay was going to have a rough morning.

"Just ordinary classmates," Lucas said, thinking it over with some frustration. "I don't really have any friends."

Snape's expression shifted, something like a cold sneer, and asked abruptly, "Do you find them all particularly stupid?"

Lucas looked at Snape in surprise. In that moment he wasn't the meek, world-weary, desperate or anxious half-blood Lucas. He was simply, purely surprised. "How could I?"

"Students from the other three houses have already begun warm-up activities for Quidditch. Professor McGonagall told me not to be too hard on you. Rubeus Hagrid wants me to pass along thanks for the bird deterrent you made. Pomona Sprout says you are a very thoughtful child..." Snape's low voice fell neither heavy nor light in the dungeon office, yet every word landed precisely on Lucas's heart. Lucas knew this was not a commendation.

Since term began, Severus Snape had had no shortage of things keeping him occupied. Becoming a teacher had not been as easy as he'd imagined from the other side of the desk. The grinding weight of trivial duties ate into his Potions research and his sleep, and he knew the past pressing down on him would not pass. It would only grow heavier.

Lucas Graham, brought into his care from the start, had initially been a reasonably untroubling student. The thing Snape had worried about — Graham being bullied to death — had not come to pass. The boy had found the cracks to survive in, using the same sharp instinct that had let him pick out second-hand supplies before term started. No real friends, but no foolish moves made in pursuit of them, either.

Perhaps, for a moment, Snape had drawn a comparison between Graham's first weeks and his own. By any measure, this half-blood had managed things quite well.

First year, and already scheming against fellow Slytherins, leaving no trace. But some things were not enough, even when they left no trace.

"Don't worry too much. Ryan Shafiq still thinks the fireworks exploded because of a quality defect. The thought that you caused it deliberately won't occur to him." Snape's gaze alone cut off any protest from Graham before it could begin. "I don't need your alibi. Slytherin doesn't concern itself with innocence — only with outcomes. Who benefits, who walks free: that is sufficient."

The incident had happened, yet Graham's house scheme hadn't drawn undue attention. All four houses were putting forward some eye-catching plan before the official match, so Lucas, the one who had devised the whole thing, was like a single tree hidden inside a forest. Most people's attention had shifted to each house's own showcase. Then the Slytherin students helped themselves to a few of Lucas's finished pieces for good measure.

Lucas had successfully redirected the crowd's focus. Even the inter-house tensions had begun to blur, after Lucas mentioned to Professor McGonagall that all four houses still had time to prepare. Lucas had cleverly used a Muggle background to lower the professors' guard, and Snape found it genuinely difficult to describe what he had felt the moment he heard Professor McGonagall praising Graham.

It was so deeply Slytherin. A child this decisive, this young, this fast. Snape had instinctively glanced over at Albus Dumbledore's expression as Dumbledore likewise listened to Professor McGonagall's account.

The Headmaster's eyes were hidden behind those half-moon lenses. Dumbledore appeared not to have followed the thought to its darker conclusion, but Dumbledore would always get there in the end.

So Snape felt angry. Before Lucas had even entered the room, he had already decided on a course of action: the boy would be assigned labor service until the end of term, the same as any older student in his position.

Lucas spoke before Snape could announce the verdict. "But the outcome was good." The deliberate, unhurried pace of the words, each syllable bitten off carefully, cut through the dungeon's oppressive stillness. Lucas pressed on: "If we're only looking at outcomes, the houses are all now busy competing for their showing in the Quidditch match. They can't come to blows for the time being."

Lucas looked at Snape with a complicated expression.

He really had been using different methods to curry favor with teachers in different subjects. After all, once you left school, where else would you find subject experts so willing to pour out everything they knew, so content to cram precious magical knowledge into heads so empty they echoed?

There were only two people at this school toward whom he kept a wait-and-see approach.

Headmaster Albus Dumbledore. For one thing, Lucas had few opportunities to interact with the Headmaster directly. For someone like Dumbledore, Lucas knew how to communicate, not based on anything from The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore, but at least enough to read something of the Headmaster's behavioral logic.

The other was the Head of House standing before him now: Mr. Severus Snape.

Lucas had kept a careful distance from Snape, guarding against being seen through before having any chance to learn Snape's craft. Beyond that, Lucas genuinely didn't know what kind of student Snape liked.

Answering questions obediently every day had earned nothing but formulaic indifference. Snape kept their interactions within the boundary of teacher and ordinary student. It was clear that a student, simply by not being named Harry Potter, was unlikely to leave any deep impression on this particular professor.

"What do you want?" Snape gave a cold laugh, as if mocking Lucas's naive excuse-making. "Have you come to school to promote peaceful coexistence between the houses? Mr. Dove of Peace."

Lucas was stopped cold by the question. In truth, it had been troubling him ever since he arrived in this era.

He might not have had a clear answer for himself, but in that moment he found one that could persuade Snape.

"I genuinely feel weary of it." Lucas's expression cooled. "Knowledge is precious. We are born with magic, but we are not born knowing how to use that gift well. I truly value the chance to study here — yet the people around me fritter away their time, drawing their wands over the most ridiculous things. That question I brought you after class, about the harvesting and processing of Jobberknoll feathers..."

Lucas paused.

That had been around the second week of term. He had gone to Snape carrying a question he had found in a Potions journal in the library, hoping to learn something.

Snape had been so cutting and sarcastic that for a moment Lucas had felt himself transported back to his previous life, studying under his Alchemy mentor. He had been made to feel thoroughly humiliated. He must have looked quite wretched at the time.

But after the dressing-down, Snape had not immediately dismissed him. Instead, Snape asked: "What are the twelve uses of Jobberknoll feathers?"

"Photo imaging, magical canvas treatment, scar-removal potions, Draught of Dragon Sleep..." Lucas had recited all twelve by rote.

Snape paused. Then picked up the question again and answered it.

The memory ended. Lucas gathered his thoughts. He even stepped one pace closer to Snape's desk. "I only want to be a good student." He said it with complete sincerity.

Slytherin pursues power, craves dominance.

That was the original answer.

It reminded Snape of himself. When he had first arrived, he had thought the same way. If he hadn't grown so close to Lily... This student called Lucas came from such a similar place. Lucas had chosen a path Snape himself had never walked. Snape didn't think it was the right one, people like them got everything wrong no matter which road they took, yet Lucas was genuinely attempting one possibility, like an earlier version of Snape who had taken a different turning at the beginning.

So alike, and yet entirely different.

Snape found himself thinking of Albus Dumbledore, that wise old wizard who had spent decades in this school witnessing so many such similarities and differences.

The point was how one guided them. Snape recalled Dumbledore smiling after hearing Professor McGonagall's account and saying: "Don't be too hard on him — Professor McGonagall very rarely praises a student."

Dumbledore was always right. Had Dumbledore once again moved ahead of Snape's suspicion and doubt, and seen that all of this was simply a student's weariness and compromise?

Snape felt somewhat unsettled, but his anger had ebbed.

He looked at Graham standing there with a face full of urgency. The artificial quality about Graham had faded somewhat. Snape could still sense it: as Lucas's emotions surged, the quiet magic of the dungeon had begun to stir. This was only a first-year student, one who still had no control over the magic around them.

Then let the labor service be cut short, Snape decided, adjusting the punishment in his mind.

Lucas was still trembling faintly with agitation. In fact, a part of what Lucas had said was genuinely felt, all those cold looks endured over years of study, bloodline and birth, those things that had never been possible to decide and never been possible to escape. Why, after all those years of effort, after finally achieving something, did it all have to start over again?

Yet looking at the man before him, Snape was a different kind of answer. Equally ill-born, equally hardworking and gifted, equally suppressed, and Severus Snape had chosen something entirely different. When Lucas had studied magical history, the question had always lingered. There was a sense of kinship, yet Snape had chosen to repent the road taken and betray the Dark Lord in the hope that Harry Potter would ultimately defeat him.

Why would Snape make that choice?

If it had been himself, what would he have done?

Lucas thought it quite possible he would have followed the Dark Lord steadfastly, gone so far down the wrong road that right and wrong stopped meaning anything at all.

Lucas was good at flattering mentors. But over many years had grown far better at concealing real thoughts.

Tonight, Snape had stripped away part of that mask, but that was also an opportunity. Lucas could move a little further forward. Could be a more vivid, living student.

A child who is always perfectly obedient, after all, can never capture as much attention as one who cries, can they?

---

Achievement unlocked for Student Lucas: The Squeaky Wheel Gets the Grease, unlock progress: ten percent.

Congratulations to Student Lucas on evolving from Ordinary Student to Mildly Troublesome Student.

The mentor-and-student phase will last quite some time yet. Quantitative change is what eventually produces qualitative change.


➤ Next: The Gnome Sculpture