Chapter 245 - The Mysterious Disarming Charm
Having received Praeris's promise, Neville tapped the Two-Way Mirror lightly with his wand, wrapped it carefully in a handkerchief, and passed it to Ginny Weasley.
A small mirror in the pocket of a pretty girl like Ginny Weasley was perfectly ordinary. In Neville's pocket, it would raise questions.
After the Christmas holiday, they had lost Luna Lovegood, and the pressure of managing the team had grown heavier. That was part of why the collective punishment system had first come apart from within Ravenclaw.
"Why?" Ginny Weasley tucked the handkerchief-wrapped mirror into her pocket, one eyebrow arched. "Madam Pomfrey would keep it secret for us."
When it came to asking Praeris for help, Ginny Weasley always hesitated. It wasn't that she didn't trust Praeris, that was old history. She simply believed they couldn't make a habit of relying on her.
Praeris's abilities went without saying. But between this invisible Dumbledore's Army founding member and the current DA team, there were still the open questions of faction and security to contend with.
If Praeris's aid to Dumbledore's Army ever came to light, Slytherin would likely cut her loose. The Death Eaters wouldn't let it slide either. And Dumbledore's Army would lose a reliable ally in one stroke. So the sharpest blade had to be saved for the right moment, this particular secret weapon was not to be used unless absolutely necessary.
Besides, Praeris herself had plenty of Slytherin in her. She had taken reading the room and protecting herself to an art form. Five years of back-channel cooperation with Hermione, and not once had she been found out.
Five whole years. Not once.
Ginny Weasley would stake anything on this: no matter which side won, Praeris would not lose. If the Order of the Phoenix prevailed, Praeris held the credit of secretly aiding Dumbledore's Army. If the Order fell, she still had Snape as her Death Eater mentor, Draco Malfoy as her Death Eater boyfriend, and her own considerable value to whoever held power. At moments like this, even Ginny Weasley couldn't help admiring what this particular Slytherin "creature" was capable of.
Kindness and goodwill didn't mean Praeris had no schemes of her own. Faced with a demand that was both unnecessary and risky, she would never agree lightly.
Hearing Ginny Weasley's question, Neville set down his quill. He had never been able to do two things at once. He scratched his head, thought for a moment, then recalled what he'd actually been trying to accomplish.
"Er — it's because the Death Eaters have tightened their watch on the Hospital Wing."
Alecto Carrow had used the Cruciatus Curse on the Patil sisters, forcing them to go to the Hospital Wing for treatment. After hearing both sisters describe their condition, Nurse Balen gave a single sigh, then went about treating Padma and writing up her prescriptions with the ease of long practice.
While her sister was being treated, the commotion outside the Hospital Wing doors caught Parvati's attention. She lifted a corner of the curtain and saw Madam Pomfrey standing with both arms spread wide, blocking Alecto Carrow's path.
"Get out." Madam Pomfrey's voice was low, pressed down tight. "This is a sick ward, not your battlefield. Unless you need treatment, you are not welcome here."
Alecto leveled her wand at Madam Pomfrey and shrieked: "Out of my way, old woman! I need to check whether any students are hiding in here in violation of school rules!"
"I absolutely forbid it." Madam Pomfrey spoke each word deliberately, rage held just beneath the surface. "Your patrols have already created more than enough of a tense atmosphere. I will not allow you to reach your hands into my territory. And I will not allow you to disturb sick children."
Alecto glared at her, eyes bulging like a toad's. Her face twisted with fury. "You old mother hen — keep guarding your chicks, then! I'll report your lack of cooperation to Headmaster Snape!"
"Go right ahead." Madam Pomfrey's back was a wall of resolve. "Hospitals are sacred and neutral. St. Mungo's is. The Hospital Wing is too. Anyone lying in one of my beds has exactly one identity: patient."
Madam Pomfrey's firmness pushed Alecto back. The Death Eaters had never managed to breach her line, so they settled for the next best thing, pacing the corridor just outside.
Every Dumbledore's Army member who came to the Hospital Wing arrived injured, which made slipping past that surveillance nearly impossible. They had been questioned one by one. So far, the excuses had included "didn't see where I was going and fell down the stairs" and "got into a fight over a love rival," but a few more trips and those stories wouldn't hold up.
With Praeris, it was different. She was a Potions prodigy. Slughorn had put her in charge of brewing the Hospital Wing's treatment supplies. She had the materials and a standing reason to produce large quantities of potions, and she was occasionally sent to deliver finished batches in person. Every condition for supplying Dumbledore's Army was already in place.
Ginny Weasley stared at him, the pieces clicking together all at once. "You said one sentence and she just understood?"
Neville hadn't offered a single word of explanation. Praeris had untangled the whole situation on her own and agreed without a moment's hesitation.
"I'd guess it's because she's always delivering potions to the Hospital Wing," Neville said, almost to himself. "So she'd know when things there had changed?"
Ginny Weasley shook her head slowly. "Praeris is terrifying."
Before long, Praeris's first Defense Against the Dark Arts class after Christmas arrived, as punctual as a werewolf on the fifteenth night of the full moon.
Amycus's eyes flickered with excitement. Like a hungry wolf that had just caught the scent of blood, his gaze moved across the students in the classroom, slow and greedy. The new school rules had clearly put a dent in his enjoyment of tormenting students. The petty thrill of catching rule-breakers on patrol was nowhere near enough to satisfy him. He needed to feed on fear and pain to fill whatever darkness had eaten through his chest.
"All of you — just like Professor me — had a relaxing and pleasant Christmas holiday, didn't you?" Amycus let out a short burst of laughter. In the silent classroom, it landed like a stone.
"What? Not happy?" His expression dropped instantly. He lurched into the crowd without warning, grabbed the student standing nearest to the front by the collar, and bellowed in his face: "Boy. You're not happy? You don't want to be in my class?!"
Neville, caught by the collar, stiffened his neck and looked down at Amycus from above. "You guessed right."
"Why aren't you happy!" Amycus's spittle hit Neville in the face. "Smile! Smile for me!"
Neville wiped his face. Cold snort. "Can't."
Then, for good measure, he spat directly back at Amycus. "Ptui."
Amycus went red. His nostrils flared. Fury surged up fast and he raised his wand straight at Neville's face. "Cruci—"
BANG!
In an instant, Amycus's wand flew from his hand, spun several times in the air, and clattered to the floor behind them and to the right.
The classroom went dead silent. Like every vocal cord in the room had been cut.
Amycus turned his head slowly and looked at the wand on the floor. Then, at the same crawling speed, he turned back around.
Neville stumbled free, clutched his chest, steadied himself after a few staggering steps, and laughed. Cold and sharp. Funny how that worked out.
Amycus ignored him. His eyes moved across the room, scanning each face in turn.
Surprise on some. Confusion on others. Relief. Poorly concealed glee. A few looking sideways in bewilderment, not sure what had just happened. Praeris was in the confused camp. Her brow was faintly creased, lips parted slightly, her dominant left hand hooked through Pansy Parkinson's arm, the two of them practically fused at the elbow. Praeris's body tilted toward Parkinson, while Parkinson craned her neck toward Praeris, eyes darting around the room, murmuring something low and quick.
Amycus had a clear enough picture of the students' Dark Arts levels. Other magic was less certain. But Praeris was a different matter. That girl was formidable in everything, and Amycus found it difficult to fully set aside his suspicion.
"Who did it." His voice came out flat and low, each word carrying its own weight of threat. "No one answers, everyone gets punished."
Crabbe shouted immediately: "Professor, it had to be a Gryffindor! They're the only ones who'd defend Longbottom!"
"Not necessarily!" Ernie's voice rang out from the crowd. "Anyone with a shred of justice in them would be glad to do it!"
Ernie had once misjudged Harry, but since fifth year he had openly declared his support for Dumbledore and Harry both. He wasn't afraid of punishment. He was only afraid of failing the conscience he'd worked to rebuild.
Neville forced himself not to look toward the crowd. He kept his eyes locked on Amycus, glaring with steady, focused hatred, afraid that a single glance the wrong way might give something away.
"Fine, fine!" Amycus clapped his hands together, hard. "Then the two of you can be punished together!"
He retrieved his wand with a grim face, plunged into the crowd, hauled Ernie out with one hand and Neville with the other, and dragged them both out of the classroom.
The door had barely swung shut before the room erupted.
Half a year in, and this was already the second time something had gone wrong in the seventh-year Defense Against the Dark Arts class. Students were worried about Neville and Ernie. They were also intensely curious about who could possibly be skilled enough to knock the wand out of a seasoned Death Eater's hand.
Pansy's eyes were bright. She was looking toward the Gryffindor side, but her voice was aimed at Praeris. "So — who do you think did it? Can you work it out?"
"It's complicated." Praeris was quiet for a moment. "I don't think any student in this room could draw their wand faster than my eyes can follow. But I genuinely didn't see anyone reach for a wand."
Daphne hissed through her teeth. "Wandless magic?"
"Wandless magic. A Disarming Charm." Draco Malfoy kept his head down, turning something over in his fingers. "Hitting a seasoned Death Eater, no less." He looked up just enough to be sardonic. "What, you think it's the Dark Lord?"
Praeris glanced over at Draco Malfoy. The corner of her mouth moved. Barely. Just enough to count.
Slytherin and Ravenclaw watched from a distance. The Gryffindors and Hufflepuffs had no such luxury.
Slytherin was simply curious. Ravenclaw was gratified and curious in equal measure. Gryffindor and Hufflepuff were running the full spectrum.
Humiliating Amycus had felt good, no question about that. But Neville and Ernie had just been hauled out of the room, and no one knew what was waiting for them.
"What do you think," Parvati asked, voice tight with worry. "Why did whoever it was knock away Carrow's wand? What was the point?"
"Maybe it wasn't a person!" Lavender said, her eyes wide. "Maybe it was Dumbledore's ghost, protecting Neville!"
Lavender's tendency toward mystical explanation had apparently spread from Divination into Defense Against the Dark Arts.
"I mean, does it matter either way?" Parvati said. "It's still the Cruciatus Curse waiting for them, and now Ernie's been dragged into it too..."
"No." Seamus cut her off. "It does matter."
Everyone around him looked over. The attention seemed to make him nervous for a second.
He pushed through it. "Did you see Amycus Carrow's face? Neville had goaded him. He was completely enraged. If nobody had intervened, there's a real chance he wouldn't have stopped casting the Cruciatus Curse on his own."
Everyone knew what too much of the Cruciatus Curse did to a person. Madness. Convulsions. Death.
"That's not good enough." Seamus's voice climbed. "We don't even know if Amycus has calmed down by now. If he hasn't, I'm going to find Professor McGonagall."
He was out the door before anyone could say a word. This time, no one tried to stop him.
Seamus hadn't come back yet when Amycus Carrow walked back in. The general consensus, unspoken, was that he'd handed Neville and Ernie off to his sister.
Amycus gripped his wand tight and ordered the students to pair up again, casting the Cruciatus Curse on each other.
Most of them couldn't manage it properly, the results were dismal to watch. The Dumbledore's Army members had been through willpower training, which gave them just enough resistance to handle curses at this level. At least they wouldn't be in screaming agony.
Amycus's expression never lifted. He looked like someone who'd just been told his sister had dropped dead. He moved through the crowd, and eventually came across Praeris, doing absolutely nothing.
"Prince." His suspicious gaze landed on her. "Why aren't you practicing?"
Praeris looked more self-righteous than anyone else in the room. "Professor, our class has an odd number. And my partner was taken away by you."
Odd number meant that after 2 people left, it was still odd.
And Ernie's previous partner, assuming they had any sense at all, was not going to volunteer to face off against Praeris, the girl who had once knocked Neville unconscious. The "future Dark witch," as some had taken to calling her.
So with no Neville to pair against, Praeris was left standing alone.
Amycus obviously couldn't stand watching her spectate. But as long as Snape held the headmaster's office and remained in the Dark Lord's favor, Amycus could not afford to touch his prized student.
With no good options available, Amycus swallowed his fury and fetched a lizard. He dropped it in front of Praeris and told her to practice on that instead.
Which is how Praeris, strange witch that she was, ended up treating Dark magic like an ordinary area of academic inquiry. She actually initiated a discussion with Amycus about the theoretical development of the Cruciatus Curse.
Amycus had no interest whatsoever in hearing her research. The topic: whether controlling the intensity of the Cruciatus Curse could extend the duration a subject could endure it before breaking, a feasibility study in making suffering last.
He announced that he needed to check on the other students' progress, and left this peculiar woman to test on her own whether a slow, measured approach to casting could keep the lizard going longer.
➤ Next: A Little Knock
