Chapter 244 - Praeris's Help — Words Unspoken
Watching a work of art get damaged is like watching a plump, rosy apple with a worm bite taken out of it. A shame, plain and simple.
Professor Snape's maneuver was an art of strategy, precise and exquisitely clever. With a single, casually issued rule, he had the students at each other's throats, sowing discord among them.
From the Order of the Phoenix's side, Professor Snape was dismantling student resistance, effectively protecting them. From the Death Eaters' side, Snape was dividing the students, suppressing rebellion, and maintaining control.
It was just a pity that no matter how brilliantly an individual performed, they could still be dragged down by teammates with brains the size of peas.
As someone on the Order of the Phoenix's side, faced with the Carrows' stupidity, Praeris found herself momentarily unsure whether to be pleased or not.
Even Ginny Weasley was rendered speechless. "I must be mad — I actually think I should thank Amycus Carrow."
After the incident where Alecto and Crabbe had pounded on her toilet stall door, Praeris had retrieved the other Two-Way Mirror from Professor Snape and given it to Ginny Weasley as a line of communication between herself and Dumbledore's Army.
Ginny Weasley had gladly accepted the mirror, and to this day still believed its previous user had been Hermione.
Praeris gave a bitter laugh. "You really should thank Amycus Carrow. Otherwise, if things had proceeded at Professor Snape's pace, Lisa Dupin would never have regretted making that report, and an irreconcilable rift would have formed within your ranks."
"Not 'your' — 'our.'" Neville keenly corrected Praeris, then clenched his fist. "This move was too ruthless. Aside from the fake Galleons and the Room of Requirement, I think we need to adopt even more covert methods."
To earn someone's trust, you had to offer yours first. Neville saw no reason to hide things from Praeris; being open was its own way of showing Dumbledore's Army's good faith.
The fake Galleons, Praeris had known about those since shortly after Dumbledore's Army first formed. And given Praeris's abilities, if she had ever truly intended to report them, Dumbledore's Army could never have stayed hidden no matter how hard they tried.
Neville couldn't help feeling grateful that Praeris was not their enemy. Otherwise, Dumbledore's Army would probably have been finished long ago.
Praeris didn't deny "too ruthless," but said flatly, "The professor was also doing it for your own good. Your resistance would only invite even more vicious punishments from the Carrows. That's unnecessary loss."
"But if even we don't resist, the other students will be even less likely to think about resisting!" Ginny Weasley wasn't having it. "I understand what you mean. You think that not resisting protects more people, preserves the greatest effective strength, that it's the highest-yield approach."
"But Praeris." Ginny Weasley's voice sharpened with conviction. "In this process of silent endurance, the courage we lose may not be something we can ever get back. When the truly fierce battle finally comes, will we still have the courage to fight, to resist, to fight for a chance at victory?"
Praeris and Snape's view was the most Slytherin way of thinking, the most astute, the most attuned to the moment, the most efficient in terms of outcome.
Under their approach, Hogwarts students would stay alive. They wouldn't have to suffer too much, and there would be no pointless sacrifices. That was undoubtedly the best result.
Yes. Very good. Did Dumbledore's Army, Ginny Weasley and Neville at the head of it, really not know that groveling under Death Eater rule meant far less suffering? They weren't masochists who insisted on courting misery.
"You already know the answer in your own heart, Praeris!" Ginny Weasley's gaze was steady. "The Death Eaters are in power. Snape is riding high. So why are you still helping us in secret?"
"Because Professor Brown and Ms. Purnell are still out there somewhere, aren't they?" Ginny Weasley thought of Harry, Ron, and Hermione, whereabouts unknown, and her eyes gradually reddened. "Praeris, Neville's answer and mine are the same as yours."
Praeris was caught squarely between two sides, and it was deeply uncomfortable. Everyone was making the decision that was right for their own cause, and every one of those decisions was in conflict with the others.
"Alright, alright, spare me the speeches!" Praeris said, pressing a hand to her head. "Harry never learned Dumbledore's style, but somehow you've picked up four or five parts of it from who-knows-where, and you just keep throwing it at me, one set after another!"
The two people on the other side of the mirror went quiet.
Praeris froze. She had actually forgotten that, in everyone's eyes, Dumbledore was already a dead man, and a victim of violent death at that.
"Ahem." She covered the slip with a light, casual tone. "Where were we, more covert methods, right?"
"Right." Neville didn't linger in the feeling. He was the first to answer. "Our original approach was to communicate through the fake Galleons and gather in the Room of Requirement. But now..."
"Ginny Weasley is right. Dupin shouldn't have shifted the blame onto us. By the same token, we won't hold a grudge against Dupin either. But we can't be as lax as we were before. We need to be more vigilant — not just against the Carrows and Slytherin — you excluded — but against other students outside of Dumbledore's Army too."
The Patil sisters had fallen into the trap precisely because Dupin was neither a blood purist nor a Dark Arts fanatic, and certainly not like Crabbe, who used reporting as a way to curry favor. The members of Dumbledore's Army were furious at what Dupin had done and scorned any association with her, yet they couldn't bring themselves to treat her as an outright enemy, after all, Dupin's starting point had genuinely been for Ravenclaw's good.
But honestly, good starting point or not, could Dupin just not start at all?
"Fine. I'll help you. Whatever you do in private is your business. As long as you don't get caught, it saves Professor Snape the trouble of disciplining you." Praeris casually pinned a reason to herself. "So here's the question: what's the most plentiful thing in Hogwarts, and what moves around the most freely?"
Ginny Weasley and Neville looked at each other. Their eyes lit up. They answered at the same moment: "Portraits / Ghosts!"
"Exactly." Praeris smiled with easy confidence. "Portraits that are on good terms with each other pay visits all the time. If the portraits are willing to help you, they can serve as your lookouts and messengers. And ghosts? They have feelings too. As Gryffindors, you might be able to get Nearly Headless Nick on your side."
Among the ghosts, Praeris had a friend like Myrtle, that tearful girl had stood guard and kept watch for Praeris more times than she could count. If Myrtle could do it, other ghosts were worth trying.
"And Peeves!" Ginny Weasley rubbed her hands together, itching to get started. "He'd definitely love to hurl dungbombs at those two damned Death Eaters! How did we not think of this?"
The plan was too good. Both of them hurriedly wrote "Portraits" and "Ghosts" on a piece of parchment, ready to go greet every single one the moment the conversation ended.
Neville added offhandedly, "When Hermione was teaching me everything she knew, I used to think about this a lot, how on earth do minds like yours grow the way they do?"
Ginny Weasley didn't let the remark land. "How else could the two of them have grown? Born from their mothers, raised on food, it's not like they were conjured by magic..."
Praeris didn't like the topic of mothers. She cut Ginny Weasley off and moved on. "If you want specifics, I also have information on the Carrows' patrol patterns."
Ginny Weasley and Neville immediately dropped the other subject and listened closely.
Unlike the lucid cruelty Amycus Carrow displayed in class, he was in fact a drunkard, six to eight pints a day, without fail.
3 days a week, Amycus patrolled the ground floor and the underground structures of the castle alone, because that was when he made the trip to the kitchens to collect his liquor.
"On the surface, it looks like patrolling the ground floor and underground." Praeris's gaze was steady and composed, everything seemingly within her grasp. "In reality, for the half hour before curfew, he's down on the basement level enjoying his drink. During that window, as long as you don't make too much noise, the ground floor is practically safe."
Praeris gave a cold, disdainful laugh. "On top of that, he's a lazy slob. On days he doesn't fetch liquor, he likes to make the rounds of spots where you're easier to catch, like the entrance to Gryffindor Tower..."
Ginny Weasley covered her face, clearly recalling something unpleasant.
"This lazy slob dozes off after lunch and gets drowsy at the first light of dawn. During those times, it's mainly Alecto Carrow handling patrols and catching students breaking curfew."
Ginny Weasley couldn't help asking, "Have you ever roamed the corridors at night?"
"Once." Praeris answered without hesitation. "Third year."
Ginny Weasley hesitated, then asked anyway. "So how do you know who's patrolling at night?"
Before curfew and over lunch were one thing. But at four or five in the morning, Praeris could still know who was on patrol. Ginny Weasley simply couldn't work it out.
"You eat breakfast in the Great Hall, don't you?" Praeris said, the corner of her mouth twitching upward.
Ginny Weasley blinked. "Of course. So does almost everyone at Hogwarts."
"What a coincidence, the Carrows eat breakfast in the Great Hall too." Praeris's tone held not a trace of surprise. She said slowly, "Have you ever watched the two of them at breakfast? Really watched? And consider this: Alecto Carrow's Muggle Studies class, not a single session is scheduled in the morning. Her brother, on the other hand, is the exact opposite."
Praeris would never volunteer explanations for these things. To her, they were far too obvious, just as no wizard would stop to explain what a wizard was unless someone specifically asked.
She went on to lay out Alecto's movement patterns.
Alecto was more focused on ideology. She liked to linger near the Muggle Studies classroom and wherever school rules or Dark Lord propaganda slogans were posted, admiring the effect of her own work. She also made regular trips to the library to see whether students were reading banned books, increasingly, that meant anything Muggle-related. The Owlery was another stop: she would intercept and inspect students' letters and parcels.
Beyond that, Muggle Studies had become a compulsory course for the entire school, which gave Alecto access to the younger students for indoctrination.
She frequently "summoned" students who were solitary or introverted, framing it as concern, and hinted to the younger ones that they could earn her approval through reporting.
To address this, Praeris had specifically asked Astoria to keep a closer eye on Slytherin students who fit that description.
As a result, the students currently serving as Alecto's informants came disproportionately from the other three houses. In Slytherin, there were only those who had sought the role out of ambition, none who had been won over by soft words.
Praeris gave a brief rundown of both Carrows' habits and patrol routes, then appended a disclaimer. "For reference only. No guarantee they won't change their plans."
"This is more than enough." Neville said, and meant it. "Without you, we would certainly have paid a much higher price."
Without Praeris's help, they would have stumbled into every one of these traps and spent far more time piecing together the two Death Eaters' patterns on their own.
He finally understood why Hermione held Praeris in such high regard.
"I did promise someone I'd help you, after all." Praeris lowered her head, running her fingers over the gemstone bracelet Millicent had given her, and let out a quiet laugh. "As long as you don't curse me as a cunning and treacherous Slytherin snake, I should be content, shouldn't I? Though I'm actually rather fond of that description."
Ginny Weasley and Neville both assumed Praeris was talking about Hermione. She wasn't. The person she had made that promise to was Dumbledore.
Hearing Praeris's words, both people on the other side of the mirror looked a little awkward, especially Ginny Weasley, who couldn't help thinking back to those days when she had made Praeris a target.
"Those were all misunderstandings." Ginny Weasley said reflexively, then, with a rare flash of genuine sheepishness, rushed out the rest at a slightly too-fast clip. "I'm very sorry, it was all my fault. My apologizing doesn't mean I expect you to forgive me, I just think I ought to apologize for the way I acted."
"Oh?" Praeris's smile turned mischievous. "In that case, I won't accept it."
"Huh?" Ginny Weasley stared. Then she saw the smile, and ground her teeth. "You're awful."
"Passable." Praeris said modestly.
Ginny Weasley had drifted into personal territory with Praeris. Only Neville still had his head in the actual work. He flipped through his parchment notebook. "Praeris, can we order potions from you?"
"What?" Praeris asked, puzzled. "What do you need potions from me for?"
Neville answered plainly. "Treating injuries."
Praeris let out a quiet, understanding "Oh," and agreed without hesitation. "I see. It's not impossible, but quantities will be limited, and you'll need to act with more caution and restraint."
"Understood what?" Ginny Weasley looked at Neville, baffled. "I still don't get it. Can't you just go to the Hospital Wing?"
"I'm afraid that won't always work." Praeris reached out and took hold of the Two-Way Mirror. "But I've explained enough. Let your companion tell you the rest."
➤ Next: The Mysterious Disarming Charm
