Chapter 243 - Collective Punishment — Face to Face
Astoria broke into a silly grin. "Anyone at all — thank you, whole world!"
Praeris patted her on the shoulder, smile gentle. After Millicent left, she understood Astoria's constant worry better than before.
Unlike Astoria, whose gloom had lifted, the new school rules had made Hogwarts heavier and more oppressive than ever.
"I wasn't wrong!"
Praeris stopped walking. She cast an inquisitive look at the group arguing up ahead. Daphne Greengrass and Pansy Parkinson stopped alongside her.
The girl holding court in the corridor was a Ravenclaw. Praeris remembered her: Lisa Dupin.
Lisa shouted, furious. "Why should we have to share the blame for what Patil did! She and her sister do whatever they want — did they ever think about us? All of us are going to suffer because of what they did!"
"That's exactly what the school rules are designed to do!" Ginny Weasley was angrier than Dupin, hands planted on her hips as she shot back. "Get this straight, it's Snape and the Carrows handing out punishments, not Padma! Today you sell out your classmates out of fear. Sooner or later, your turn will come too!"
Lisa turned her head away irritably. "Don't talk nonsense, Weasley! I'm not like you lot, I would never break the school rules!"
"Is that so?" Ginny Weasley folded her arms, pressing in. "Not today — but what about tomorrow? Not tomorrow — what about the day after? The rules keep piling on, keep changing. Are you really so sure you'll never step on a landmine one day?"
Lisa stiffened. Her expression started to sour.
Ginny Weasley swept a hand out with a flourish and declared at full volume, "Fine! Then let everyone report each other! Let everyone pluck out their own eyes and stick them onto someone else! If we can't trust the people around us anymore, we might as well stop sleeping too! Who knows whether there's a pair of eyes watching you in the dark while you dream?"
"Say whatever you want!" Lisa said, eyes reddening. "This is a Ravenclaw matter, what does it have to do with a Gryffindor like you? Whatever anyone thinks of me, my intentions were good. I did it all for Ravenclaw. Think of me however you like. I have no regrets!"
With that, she covered her face and ran off crying.
The Ravenclaws left behind exchanged glances. Some silently averted their eyes and said nothing. Others hesitated a moment, then went after her.
Lisa ran straight past the staircase where Praeris and the others were standing, which gave Ginny Weasley's group a clear view of the Slytherins watching from a distance.
"And here I thought, some people were just a solid block," Pansy Parkinson said, her tone pointed. "Doesn't look so solid now, does it?"
Daphne Greengrass covered her mouth with perfect timing, trading a knowing smile with Pansy Parkinson. Praeris pulled out her pocket watch and glanced at it. "Let's go. We'll be late."
She turned and stepped onto the staircase first. Pansy Parkinson and Daphne Greengrass followed at once. Pansy Parkinson made a point of pulling a face at Ginny Weasley's group before running off, giggling.
Pansy Parkinson pattered after Praeris, grinning. "These people, and they have the nerve to talk about us Slytherins! They bully Lovegood themselves, give her nicknames. And now look, they've put on a lovely show of their own people reporting their own!"
"My mother said Myrtle the ghost was around even back in her day," Daphne Greengrass said, twirling a strand of hair. "Apparently Myrtle was a Ravenclaw. She ran into a bathroom after being bullied and died there."
"Was Olive Hornby a Ravenclaw too?" Praeris asked.
"What?"
"The girl who mocked Myrtle."
Daphne Greengrass shrugged. "Who knows? All I know is, the girl who bullied Myrtle was the one who found her body. Hilarious, isn't it? Even we Slytherins have friends, did Myrtle really not have a single one who came looking for her? Had to be her enemy who collected the corpse."
Praeris thought back. Myrtle had once said she had no friends. At the time, Praeris had assumed she meant her friends had all graduated and left Hogwarts. She hadn't realized it was the literal truth.
Was Ravenclaw a bad house, then?
Praeris didn't think so.
In her eyes, Professor Flitwick, Winnie Brown, Baron, and Myrtle were all perfectly friendly. Cho Chang and Luna Lovegood, whom she didn't know well, seemed decent too. And yet, among those same people, Winnie Brown had been a Death Eater, and Myrtle was more than a little unhinged.
Beyond that, there were those who had made mistakes, and the fractures between Ravenclaws that Pansy Parkinson and Daphne Greengrass had mentioned.
Human nature is complicated. You can't sort people into good and bad and then announce which house is which.
After class, Praeris found her moment and went straight to Myrtle's bathroom to deliver the Veela soap liquid.
Myrtle drifted back and forth through the bathroom, giggling, repeating herself in loops. "Praeris, no one, no one has ever given me a gift like this. Oh, no! Actually, no one has ever given me a gift. At all!"
Praeris felt obliged to tell her, "Myrtle, I'm sorry. It doesn't work on ghosts."
Myrtle clasped both hands to her chest and murmured to herself, "If only Baron would share it with me..." Then, snapping out of it: "What a silly thing to say! I'm dead, how could something meant for the living work on me?"
"Oh, right, I'd forgotten I was already dead, I'd..." Myrtle crashed abruptly into grief and burst into loud sobs. "Why, why did no one give me a gift when I was alive! Now I'm dead, I'm already dead, and only now do I get a gift, I don't even know what romance feels like!"
"Myrtle!" Praeris moved to comfort her. "The past doesn't matter anymore. What matters is now. Now you have a gift. I think you deserve it, that's why I'm giving it to you."
Myrtle's emotions swung up and down, back and forth, like a Bludger, impossible to track. "Really?" she said, brightening. "You think I deserve it? You think it belongs with me?"
"Yes."
"Quick, quick, Praeris, blow some bubbles!" Myrtle said, seized by a sudden inspiration. "I want to be the first to share this soap liquid with you!"
"But Baron —"
"That doesn't matter!" Myrtle said, practically vibrating. "Blow them, blow them!"
Praeris felt the situation drifting somewhere strange. Under Myrtle's expectant gaze, she slowly unscrewed the cap, drew it out, and blew bubbles into the air.
Aberforth might always fob off the Death Eaters, but he never fobbed off Praeris. Every bubble from the soap liquid was a beautiful rose-pink. Utterly girlish. Utterly romantic.
Myrtle flew through them like a delighted child. "Praeris, I think you were wrong! My soul can feel the romance, I love your gift!"
Praeris stopped hearing her.
She stared at the bubbles and found that the run-down bathroom around her had become the clock tower. The mirror had become a glass window, and through it, snow was falling.
In the stillness of winter, she heard only the wind, the turning of the clock tower's mechanical parts, and the long, clean lines of a violin.
Praeris let out a quiet laugh and blinked herself free. Her willpower was strong enough that the soap liquid barely touched her.
The whole thing lasted a second or two. Myrtle hadn't noticed a thing. She was still floating around in a giddy haze.
Myrtle directed Praeris to set the bottle beside her favorite tap. "I'm going to find Nick and show him my gift!"
"Don't say it was from me," Praeris said quickly.
Myrtle agreed at once and flew straight through the wall, almost certainly off to track down every ghost in the school and show off.
The Patil sisters had been reported. Both of them and Gryffindor were punished. Ravenclaw got a "pardon" thanks to Lisa's tip.
At the midday table, the Gryffindors were sitting on their anger, doing their best not to glare at Lisa over on the Ravenclaw side. It looked like Neville Longbottom and Ginny Weasley had given them the talk.
They weren't looking, but the whispers still ran. The moment Praeris walked into the Great Hall, she caught a Gryffindor saying as they passed, "If you ask me, if everyone just ignores the rule, then the rule means nothing. Stay together, and everything goes back to the way it was."
It wouldn't, though. Even with no one reporting, one person caught by accident would bring the whole group down. That was exactly why Lisa had done what she'd done.
The cracks inside Ravenclaw were already there. The rift between Ravenclaw and Gryffindor was already there too.
Praeris couldn't help but feel a flicker of admiration. Professor Snape had played a masterful move. In Wizard's Chess, this was a perfect pin.
A pin: one side attacks an opponent's piece, but behind that piece sits one of far greater value. The attacked piece cannot move. It loses its freedom.
In the past, whatever the DA did, they bore the consequences themselves. Their mistakes had nothing to do with anyone else.
Under the collective punishment system, Professor Snape still only targeted the DA directly, but now the DA couldn't afford to ignore every ordinary student around them. One rash move and innocent people would suffer alongside them. They were caught in a moral trap. They couldn't act freely.
While pinning the DA, he had also forced the ordinary students into a choice: sacrifice themselves, do nothing, yet be punished alongside the DA, or sacrifice others, trade a report for the collective's temporary safety. The wedge drove itself.
For a moment, Praeris felt she was still far too green. She hadn't absorbed even a fraction of Professor Snape's skill.
A sharp move. But Ginny Weasley's counter was sharp too. She had shifted the frame from student-against-student to student-against-the-administration, pointing out that the root cause was the school rules themselves, not the DA. Then she had painted a picture of a future where no one slept soundly, where everyone feared for themselves, a warning to the wavering.
A strong counter. But not a clean solution. The open clash between Ravenclaw and Gryffindor, and the fracture inside Ravenclaw itself, said as much.
Lisa couldn't eat. She sat at the table crying, wiping her eyes. "How is this my fault? If Patil hadn't broken the rules first, would any of this have happened? She knew and she did it anyway, she didn't think about what it would cost anyone else!"
After this, Lisa could never admit she was wrong. The only way to justify herself was to prove that the Patil sisters were the ones who hadn't cared about the bigger picture.
Lisa's friends crowded around her. "It's fine, it's fine." "What's done is done, don't dwell on it." "You were doing it for everyone." "Don't be upset, this isn't your fault."
Padma Patil walked back from the office, stopped in front of the table, and stared at Lisa with barely contained fury, her shoulders rising and falling with every breath. "I really misjudged you. My sister and I were sitting in that office taking the punishment, and we told them over and over that it was entirely our own idea, that no one else had anything to do with it, not Ravenclaw, not Gryffindor. And you, you actually..."
She couldn't finish.
At the staff table, 3 seats in the center sat empty: Snape's, and the Carrow siblings'. Professor McGonagall had one hand pressed to her forehead, silent. Professor Flitwick let out a long, heavy sigh.
The Ravenclaws didn't know what to say. Lisa had done it for the collective. As members of that collective, as people who had benefited, they couldn't really turn on her. But Padma Patil wasn't someone who'd thrown the collective aside either, she and her sister had taken the fall for both houses.
"I'm afraid your plan failed," Padma Patil said, tears threatening. "Alecto Carrow said your report proves there are already unhealthy ideas spreading through Ravenclaw. So Ravenclaw gets punished too."
The color drained from Lisa's face. She had never imagined that the choice she'd made for the collective, the "rational" choice, would count for nothing. She had become a traitor. She had gained nothing from it. She hadn't even protected Ravenclaw.
"To no avail," Praeris said quietly.
Pansy Parkinson clicked her tongue and shook her head. "Now this I love. A few more shows like this and my life wouldn't be so boring."
A few more. Praeris shook her head inwardly. Professor Snape probably couldn't survive that.
To fracture the resistance, Professor Snape had rolled out the school rules specifically, punished only Gryffindor specifically, all to cultivate hatred. Open conspiracy, taken to its absolute limit.
Then Amycus, good teammate that he was, had dismantled the whole thing with one move: he added punishment for Ravenclaw.
Just like that, the benefit of reporting, protecting your own house, became its own punishment.
If reporting doesn't protect the house, who in their right mind would report anyone? Students might stop rule-breaking when they saw it, but they'd never report it again. The collective punishment system was still standing. It just no longer had teeth.
Who had recruited these Death Eaters, honestly?
Oh, right. Voldemort.
➤ Next: Praeris's Help — Words Unspoken
