💦 CREATE AND FUCK YOUR OWN AI CUMSLUT 🔥 TRY NOW ♥
Create AI Cumsluts 💦
September 15, 2026

Chapter 234 - Sobering Clarity — Face to Face

Sirius Black once told Harry that by his first year, Snape already knew more Dark Arts than most seventh-years.

Snape had no idea what drivel his nemesis was spreading behind his back. But even if he had, he wouldn't have denied it. The reason was laughably absurd: in his mind, the Dark Arts had once been one of the symbols of happiness.

In Severus's childhood, Tobias and Eileen were always fighting. Always. Over everything, as though there was nothing in the world that couldn't be turned into a quarrel.

At first, young Severus would be frightened. He would cry. Then he grew used to it, grew numb, until his tears ran dry and never came again.

But when the conversation turned to the magical world, there was still a light in Eileen's eyes.

Sometimes, while Eileen stood at the kitchen stove making pea soup, she would tell Severus about brewing potions in her school days. She would let him stir the pot himself, as though they really were standing over a cauldron. Severus thought it was a bit like the Muggle girls playing house he had seen, childish, a game, but Eileen's rare calm and tenderness made the young boy play along without complaint.

Eileen taught Severus magic too, even before he had a wand of his own. She told him: "Sev, you're a wizard. Magic is wondrous. Magic is normal. It doesn't need to be suppressed."

The contradiction was that Tobias despised magic, and despised wizards even more. Eileen hoped Severus would never suppress his power, never come to hate it, never be forced into becoming an Obscurial, and in the same breath, she demanded he never mention magic in front of Tobias.

Severus didn't understand her. She had power. Real power. She could have walked away from this long, suffocating, miserable life at any time. Yet she stayed.

But it was Eileen's choice. Every person was their own. Severus would not try to change it. He could never have moved her even if he had tried.

Still, more than once, the young Severus had let himself imagine: if Eileen had never given up magic, never chosen the Muggle life, would he have had the chance at a happy childhood?

The first thing Eileen ever truly taught him was not ordinary magic. Not the Dark Arts. Not potions. It was this: never surrender your power for any person, or any feeling. He carried that lesson like a brand, holding himself to it every day, refusing to become what his mother had become.

And so Severus arrived at Hogwarts with nothing but the knowledge Eileen had given him, burning to acquire greater power, burning to use that power to change his fate. Even when Lily fell out with him over it, he never set aside his research into the Dark Arts. Never set aside his pursuit of strength.

It was the force his mother had left him. It was how he stayed close to Eileen. And it was how he kept himself from becoming the next Eileen.

Eileen Prince was the person Severus loved and the person he hated. The person he wanted to draw near and the person he needed to keep at a distance.

Before Praeris arrived, Snape had been sitting alone with his thoughts for a long time. He had concluded that he was the last person on earth with any right to tell Praeris to be careful with the Dark Arts.

He had always known that a mind like Praeris's would find its way to the Dark Arts eventually. So four years ago, Snape had set the temptation in front of her deliberately, and felt something unknot in his chest when she turned away from it, choosing the harder road instead.

That was when he understood: Praeris carried a past as scarred as his own, but she was not the same as him. Her future could still be bright.

Fate, it seemed, had a sense of humor.

Because here she was, standing on that road after all. Snape stood before the house-elves, looking down with cold eyes at the dying rooster, it shuddered and twitched at intervals, his gaze dark and still.

Through his own black eyes, he saw another pair of black eyes. Similar to his, yet not the same. There was no resentment toward fate in those eyes. And the black-haired girl was speaking words that sounded like ones he had once said himself. She looked, for a moment, like a younger version of him.

Praeris's emotions had settled. She seemed as gentle and composed as always, and asked quietly: "What about you, sir? I don't think you're inhuman. I don't think you're broken. You are just as normal a person as I am — past or present."

"Sir, studying the Dark Arts and using them has not caused you to lose your humanity. The very fact that you are sitting here now proves the mercy inside you."

It was almost too good an example. Snape had once been a Death Eater. He had devoted himself to the Dark Arts. He now bore infamy he had never deserved, carrying it for the sake of other people's lives. Didn't that prove that studying the Dark Arts had not extinguished the humanity at his core?

Debating with Praeris was a genuinely challenging thing. Without a firm foothold, a person could easily be pulled along by her current, starting to feel she might have a point, losing the thread of where they had begun. Unfortunately, Snape was not that kind of person.

"Is that so?" He sneered. He raised his left arm level and yanked the sleeve back without ceremony, baring the sinister mark burned into the flesh beneath. "Look at me. Tell me — do you think I embraced it? Or was I branded by it forever, imprisoned by it?"

Praeris stared at the Dark Mark on his arm for a long moment. This, too, was Dark Arts. In the days when Voldemort was drawing close to resurrection, many Death Eaters had felt it burn, including Winnie and Professor Snape.

Praeris had seen Winnie's wardrobe. It was full of beautiful camisoles and short-sleeved dresses in every style. For decades, Winnie had worn nothing but long sleeves.

One thing was certain: any choice without a real way out was not a good choice. Being a Death Eater offered almost no way out at all.

"Miss, I understand what you're thinking right now better than anyone else in the world. Because the past me is the present you. You believe that by studying the Dark Arts, you are mastering darkness. You see it as a knife. You believe you can wield it freely — am I right?"

"No." Snape lowered his arm and clasped it behind his back. "The Dark Arts will corrode your soul. They will devour the calm and the rationality you are so proud of and make you willingly find excuses for them. Today I am standing here not because my soul was never corroded — but because even corroded as I am, I have no choice but to drag myself forward and go on living. Not because the Dark Arts are 'not so bad.' But because I must spend the rest of my life in penance, repaying every sin they brought."

Praeris's face remained calm. Inside, her thoughts had begun to bubble.

She thought, at entirely the wrong moment: what exactly is your sin? She wanted to ask it. She swallowed it back down instead.

This was the unspoken agreement they had kept for seven years, unchanged. Neither of them touched the other's past until the other chose to speak of it first. Even now, when every detail of that past lay within her reach, she had never once reached for it.

Snape, unaware of where her mind had wandered, continued: "By the time you realize the Dark Arts have been corroding you, half your body is already buried in the soil of sin. By the time you start defending them, telling yourself they're 'not so bad' — you are already standing at the edge of the pit."

His voice was cold. "You think you are calm. Restrained. In control. No. Your soul has been collecting dust for some time now. You think you can walk away untouched, withdraw at any moment you choose? Ask Brown about the tears she shed for Purnell."

Praeris felt the beginnings of a headache. She found herself thinking, distantly, that Winnie had been drawn to greater power too, that was why she had become a Death Eater. And at the end of that road of great power, Voldemort had ordered Bellatrix to force Winnie to witness death. To force her to kill.

"Sir, Winnie was tempted by darkness," Praeris said. "But she never harmed anyone. She never killed anyone. She did restrain herself."

Even for Bella, the one she hated most, Winnie had not truly killed. On the surface, Praeris was speaking about Winnie's restraint. Beneath the surface, she was pointing at herself: she could do the same. She could use the power of darkness for research and salvation, not for harm, not for killing.

"You see —" Praeris looked down at her own hands. "When I faced Neville, I used the Cruciatus Curse. But I believe he felt very little pain."

"Measured by the final outcome, I wasn't hurting him. I was saving him, sparing him from worse suffering and buying time for their group. The Entrail-Expelling Curse is Dark Arts, but Hararo used it to save lives. Do you think he was causing harm?"

"What very reasonable words," Snape said, his voice sharp with contempt, "coming from someone who has not lived through the alternative. So you have only ever thought of using it for good. No other thoughts at all. Is that what you're telling me?"

"When you were tormenting those animals, did you not feel one single moment of pleasure? When you used the Dark Arts, did you not feel something intoxicating about holding another creature's life in your hands? When you ran into trouble, was the Dark Arts not your very first instinct, the blunt, immediate solution?"

If Snape hadn't heard from the house-elves that Praeris had been requesting test subjects from them for some time now, he might have believed his student was still as rational as she had always been.

DONG!

It was as though a bell rang somewhere inside Praeris's skull. She found, to her own shock, that everything Professor Snape had said was correct.

Yes, learning and using the Dark Arts required feeding on negative emotion. But when had the Dark Arts become her first choice? How long had she been drowning in those negative emotions without even noticing?

The Neville incident, fine, but was Dark Arts power truly the only path to growing stronger? She had other methods. She had always had other methods.

Facing Astoria, why had she even entertained the idea of using the Dark Arts on a little sister she had watched grow up? She could imagine Lia facing that kind of danger from somewhere outside. But the danger coming from herself? Even if the sun rose in the west, that should have been impossible.

Facing Crabbe, when she thought about putting him in his place, why had the Skull-Swelling Curse flickered through her mind? The impulse to make his fat head match his fat body?

"The greater the power, the greater the need for restraint."

She remembered who had said that. Dumbledore.

After dealing with the Death Eaters who had tailed them, after visiting the Carter family, after wandering through Hogsmeade together, Dumbledore had doubled back around and spoken with her about why he had stopped her from killing the Death Eaters.

He had said, gently: "Child, killing a person takes only a moment. The crack it leaves on your soul is nearly impossible to mend in a lifetime."

"I know that," Praeris had replied, without any resentment at being corrected, her voice level. "I think the same thing about Draco."

If she didn't want Draco's soul fractured by killing, she couldn't treat it as nothing herself either.

The same spell, cast by different hands, landed differently. The same spell, landing on different people, worked differently too.

Against Praeris, whose will was strong, the Dark Arts had found another way in: waiting until she lowered her guard willingly, then flowing through the opening, eroding her from within in gradual, almost imperceptible increments, like rain working its way into stone. And still, the people who cared about her had noticed. Each in their own way, they had been trying to warn her.

Or perhaps the very abnormality was its own form of resistance, a sign that her soul was still fighting back. Another expression of a will that refused to break.

"The power you feel is bait," Snape said, and there was something almost raw beneath the frustration in his voice. "It's the nectar a pitcher plant uses to pull insects into the trap. It makes you feel like you are growing stronger, that you can do everything you want. That sensation means it is actually dismantling your true strength, your will, your judgment, your moral foundations."

In the past, how could Praeris have failed to recall a sentence spoken just a few months ago? A few months was nothing. In her mind, something a stranger had said years before sat as vivid as something that had happened a moment ago. The fact that she had forgotten at all, that was the proof.

Snape knew Praeris well. He caught the shift in her quickly. His voice dropped. "Praeris, I don't enjoy saying things like this. But I have gradually come to believe them."

"True strength comes from mastery, not from being mastered. The most powerful magic in the world is rooted in love, in protection, in an unbreakable will, not in destruction and corruption. Gaining that kind of strength asks nothing of your soul, though the path to it is full of trials and unimaginably hard."

He raised his hand. A stag coalesced in the air from a gathering of silver-white light, solid and steady, as though it were made of something more substantial than magic. It looked exactly like Snape's will made visible.

"Miss." His sharp eyes fixed on her. "Your turn."

Praeris frowned and spoke: "Expecto Patronum."

Nothing.

The Patronus she used to cast without a wand, without even speaking, gone.

She pulled her wand. Gathered herself. Tried again.

"Expecto Patronum."

The tip of her wand breathed out thin, faint wisps of white smoke. Not even a match for Astoria, who was barely a beginner.

Snape sneered and watched in cold silence. He didn't intervene. He simply let it unfold, while his stag Patronus paced nearby, hooves shifting against the ground.

Praeris closed her eyes. She reached for Occlumency, sorting through the tangle of her emotions, sealing off what didn't belong, pressing her will against the current of every dark feeling inside her until they began, one by one, to still.


➤ Next: Ginny’s Plea for Help