Chapter 231 - The Influence of Dark Arts
Dark Arts is a relatively complex concept.
In the narrow sense, it primarily covers curses and certain spells so cruel they cause permanent injury.
The former mainly refers to the Unforgivable Curses and Blood Curses.
The latter, though not technically Unforgivable, are still considered Dark Arts by nature. Fiendfyre falls here, it can consume everything, and it is almost impossible to control once it starts.
Sectumsempra, invented by Professor Snape, also belongs to this category. The spell leaves permanent wounds. But it has been used so rarely that it carries almost no public notoriety, and most wizards wouldn't recognize it as Dark Arts at all.
In the broader sense, Dark Arts also includes other offensive spells, categorized as jinxes and hexes.
Jinxes are classified as illegal. They are more evil than hexes, and their nature is closer to Dark Arts in the narrow definition. Examples include the Hurling Hex mentioned by Gilderoy Lockhart, the Entrail-Expelling Curse invented by Urquhart Rackharrow, and the Skull-Swelling Hex that causes the victim's head to swell grotesquely, among others.
The original intent behind a jinx isn't necessarily malicious. Rackharrow was actually a Healer. He invented the Entrail-Expelling Curse as a tool to facilitate treatment.
Then there are lethal spells permitted in dueling, weaker than jinxes in effect, called hexes. The Blasting Curse, the Gouging Spell, and the Impediment Jinx all belong here.
It's worth distinguishing: the Sandstorm Spell Praeris uses is meant to confuse an opponent's vision. The Gouging Spell is something else entirely. It can destroy objects and leave an opponent severely injured.
This creates certain thorny questions in wizarding law. For instance: which is the graver offense, using the Cruciatus Curse on a wizard without killing them, or recklessly using the Blasting Curse on a wizard and killing them? The former is a hard line in wizarding law. The latter involves an actual human life, snuffed out.
On the surface, the latter seems worse. But in wizarding legal practice, the sentences handed down for the two don't differ much.
The reason is this: a wizard's power is deeply tied to their emotions and soul. Even a weakened Unforgivable Curse is profoundly evil and agonizing. Using one corrodes the caster's soul, destabilizes their mind, and opens them to the pull of latent darkness, their shadow self stirred to the surface.
So before Voldemort's regime rose to power, any wizard caught using an Unforgivable Curse on another person, even short of murder, faced immediate charges and a cell in Azkaban.
Praeris took no pleasure in tormenting others. But to truly understand the Cruciatus Curse, to get a real grip on it rather than a theoretical one, she chose an efficient and dangerous method.
She deliberately amplified and cultivated her own negative emotions. She simulated the broken, warped psychology of Death Eaters like Amycus, and immersed herself in enough malice that the Cruciatus Curse responded like an extension of her own hand.
The results were stark.
Before, Praeris had understood Dark Arts only in theory. But theory without practice is a castle built on nothing. Now, after an immersive experience in the emotional landscape of a Dark wizard, she could cast the Cruciatus Curse with ease.
The side effects were just as stark. Her emotions swung harder. Her hunger to grow stronger sharpened. Her interest in Dark Arts intensified.
Corruption that happens passively is one thing. This was different. She had done this herself, overconfidence, a door thrown wide open, an invitation to malice. She had given negative emotions the soil to take root. Resisting this particular corrosion was harder precisely because she had no one to blame but herself.
Praeris's family and teachers had taught her the power of love. Because of that, the dark parts of her past had been quietly set aside, intentionally or not. Foolish provocations and petty prejudices rolled off her easily, there were simply too many idiots in the world.
And none of it mattered to her anymore.
Take advanced potion research. If someone went down the wrong path and questioned her conclusions, she was happy to debate it. They could learn together.
But if someone wanted to discuss why Muggles couldn't brew potions? Praeris would just look at them with calm eyes and think: where do you even begin? Potion-making requires wand-assisted operations. That's foundational. If someone didn't know that, they either hadn't sat through a single Potions class, or they were a Muggle who had no idea what magic even was. There was nothing to argue.
Most foolish provocations got exactly that response from her.
That kind of restraint and tolerance, though, under a flood of indulgence, it tips easily into its opposite. Like the strictly-raised daughters of noblemen in Muggle operas, the ones most likely to be lured into running away.
Astoria arrived. She came with her homework, ready to face judgment.
The classroom was empty. Praeris tossed an apple lightly into the air and caught it. Then, in one fluid motion, she hurled it.
Astoria's eyes hadn't left Praeris's hands. She raised her wand immediately, aimed just ahead of the apple's path: "Diffindo!"
The spell fired. The apple sailed into position. It burst apart with a sharp BANG.
"Not bad." Praeris looked down, unhurried. "Continue."
She reached over and tapped the fruit bowl beside her. "Pear."
"Accio pear!" Astoria called out instantly.
The single pear in the bowl shot toward her at speed. She caught it in a scramble, barely managing to hang on.
"Good. I'm going to attack you now." Praeris said it without moving.
"Protego!" Astoria reacted before the attack even came.
A moment later, a wild chestnut smacked into her Shield Charm and fell to the floor.
"Right now, that's a wild chestnut." Praeris's tone was quiet, almost lazy. "Lia — what if it had been the Killing Curse?"
The Shield Charm covers a wide range of attacks. Most physical and magical damage, it handles. But it has limits. Overly powerful spells break through it. The Killing Curse is one of them.
The instant Astoria's Shield Charm had appeared, Praeris's first thought had been to throw a Killing Curse at it. Astoria's defense would shatter. And Astoria would be dead.
Praeris knocked the side of her own head and silently cursed herself. What are you thinking? This is Astoria. The little sister they had all watched grow up.
"Tell me," Praeris said, her voice firm. "What should you have done?"
Astoria stared at the tips of her shoes. "Found cover."
"So why didn't you?"
Astoria looked up at her with trusting eyes. "Because you would never use the Killing Curse on me."
"And you know for certain I haven't thought about it?" Praeris jabbed a finger toward her, frustration bleeding through. "Potter trained Longbottom. When I used the Cruciatus Curse on Longbottom, he couldn't even react in time."
"Once you're in combat, the other person is your enemy. They could kill you. It doesn't matter whether they look like they're about to cast the Killing Curse. Before combat starts, you find cover. You don't stand out in the open. During a fight, you work to adjust your position constantly, stay close to cover, make sure you can get behind it at any moment."
She paused.
"Are you listening?"
"I'm listening!" Astoria said, a little wheedling. "But this is practice. I'll do better next time."
"Next time." Praeris shook her head. "Lia, life doesn't have that many next times. This time is what counts. If you train yourself to think there's always a next time — if every mistake gets filed under 'I'll fix it later' — then when you face a real enemy, do you think they'll be kind enough to give you another chance?"
Praeris turned it over in her own mind. If the real enemy were her, and Dumbledore weren't there to intervene, this conversation wouldn't be happening. Astoria's life would already be over.
"Praeris, I — I'm sorry," Astoria said quietly.
Praeris rarely criticized Astoria. With her, it was almost always praise and patient explanation, rarely anything stern. The way Winnie had always believed in Praeris, Praeris had always believed Lia could do well.
Now she clicked her tongue, a small, sharp sound of irritation, and shook her head. "Don't apologize to me. Lia, it's your life. You just have to be true to yourself."
"Come on. Let's keep going."
They drilled several other practical offensive and defensive spells after that. Astoria performed well, she attacked and kept her options open at the same time. Her only real flaw was that she looked tense the entire time, wound tight in a way that showed.
When they finished, Astoria hopped up onto the table across from Praeris, propped her hands on either side, and looked over at her.
Praeris grabbed an apple and tossed it to her. "Still nervous? The exam's over."
"No, it's not that." Astoria caught it, shook her head slightly. Then, quietly: "I feel like you're a little different."
She turned the apple over in her hands, conjured a thin stream of water, rinsed it off, and took a bite.
"Different how?" Praeris said, sounding bored. "Did you and Draco coordinate? He said something similar."
Though what Draco had said was: not like something you would do.
"I can't explain it." Astoria lowered her voice. "Maybe it's just my imagination. But... Praeris, you said you used the Cruciatus Curse on Longbottom. What did that feel like?"
As a Slytherin, Astoria wasn't ignorant of Dark Arts.
But Mr. Greengrass was a textbook example of a father who existed solely for domestic comfort and did nothing of substance. His paternal duties rose from the dead occasionally, flickered for a moment, and then settled back into peaceful slumber.
Mrs. Greengrass, for her part, was a mother who plainly preferred her younger daughter.
With Daphne, the first child, Mrs. Greengrass had been a complete novice. Learning to drive on a motorcycle, basically. The whole thing was a crash site.
By the time Astoria came along, Mrs. Greengrass had gathered some experience. The process of raising a child started to feel manageable. And little Lia was sickly from birth, never cried, never fussed, sweet and quiet and obedient, the kind of child who needed extra attention. Otherwise she might just slip away without a sound.
So in a tidy virtuous cycle, Mrs. Greengrass grew closer to Astoria. More attentive, more attached.
Then Astoria found Grace, and everything inverted. Lia became the difficult one. Daphne became the easy, well-behaved one. But Mrs. Greengrass still worried more about Lia, because now she had a mission: getting her younger daughter back to normal.
In pursuit of that mission, she had once paid an enormous sum for a bottle of unlicensed, unlabeled potion. The vendor claimed it could cure any rebellious streak in a pure-blood child. He asked for 500 Galleons, the same market price as Felix Felicis, for reference.
He hadn't even finished his sales pitch when Mrs. Greengrass had already talked herself into it. Quality costs money. A potion this effective would be suspicious if it were cheap.
She bought it.
The result was Astoria in a bed at St. Mungo's.
As parents, this unreliable pair had only ever provided ambient influence. Background environment. Not a single lesson in Dark Arts, or even hexes, had passed between them and their daughters.
Praeris blinked. "A sense of control, I suppose," she said, in the tone of someone discussing the weather.
"A sense of control?" Astoria didn't follow.
"The feeling of holding someone's life or death in your hands." Praeris said it calmly.
Something shifted in Astoria's expression. A kind of helplessness moved through her that she couldn't quite hide.
She hesitated for a moment. Then: "I thought you'd rather protect the people who matter to you. Like how I want to get stronger, because I want to be able to protect Kiki."
That was the argument Praeris had originally used to convince Astoria to train.
"What's the difference?" Praeris didn't see it. "If I have the power to decide who lives and who dies, then who can touch the people I care about?"
She had powerful memory. Sharp analytical ability. Strong magic. A vast reservoir of spells. Talent in potions and Divination. How had she never seen it before? Why had she always been making compromises, for family, for the people she loved? Why not just remove the obstacles?
Astoria's eyes went wide. An expression of sudden understanding crossed her face.
That's true, isn't it.
"Praeris, Praeris!" Astoria looked at her, eyes bright with anticipation. "Professor Carrow hasn't walked us through the practical on the Cruciatus Curse yet. Can you teach me?"
"You're just a kid, what are you learning —" Praeris stopped mid-sentence.
Wait.
Something was wrong.
Had it just become reflex? Her instinct had been to stop Lia, this "kid," from learning the Cruciatus Curse.
"Ahem." Praeris smoothed over the awkward pause. "Lia, you're not old enough yet. Get the spells I've already taught you down solid first."
Astoria tilted her head. "But Professor Carrow teaches us this way in class too..."
"Do you trust me?" Praeris said simply.
"Yes." No hesitation at all.
Praeris reached over and touched the top of Astoria's head. "Let's skip this one for now. Alright?"
For a moment, Astoria felt like Praeris had become herself again, the version she knew. But Praeris was always Praeris. The same person, the same face. How much could anyone really change in an hour?
She chose to trust her, the same way she always did.
"Alright!"
➤ Next: The Indictment — Words Unspoken
