Chapter 108 - Three Changes of Allegiance
On one side, Praeris was hastily writing a letter. On the other, Hermione rolled up her sleeves, ready to throw herself into something big.
She was recruiting students for Harry. Anyone interested in learning Defense Against the Dark Arts was to meet at the Hog's Head.
Harry thought it would be nearly impossible, but he couldn't bring himself to crush Hermione's enthusiasm.
Probably, Harry thought dejectedly, the only names on the parchment would end up being the three of them and Prince's fake alias.
"At least we've truly united," Hermione said, giving Harry a nudge of encouragement. "We even brought a Slytherin on board. What can't we do after that?"
The unity the Sorting Hat had warned about, they'd already exceeded the quota.
"What is this!" Harry jabbed a finger at the top of the parchment, staring. "How exactly are we supposed to explain this signature to Ron?"
Praeris Prince. The top Slytherin student, who, beyond her love of keeping her identity under wraps, had a particular gift for inventing pseudonyms of every bizarre and outlandish variety.
The sheer absurdity of this one could only be matched by a certain Harry Weasley Granger.
"Why do you need to explain it?" Hermione rolled up the parchment and stated, flat and certain, "She's my pen pal."
"We can't keep this from Ron." Harry's brow furrowed. "Out of the three of us, only the two of us know the truth. How is Ron supposed to feel about that?"
Harry knew exactly what it felt like to be kept in the dark. He'd had enough of it.
Putting himself in Ron's place, he didn't want Ron going through the same thing.
"Wrong. It's not the two of us keeping it from Ron." Hermione pointed to herself and said with crisp precision, "It's me, keeping it from both of you. The person involved just happened to let you in through the back door."
Harry took the opening to ask the question he'd been sitting on. "Hermione, why didn't you have to swear an oath?"
"Not an oath — an Unbreakable Vow." Hermione enunciated each word with great care, correcting him. "Clearly, my mouth is considerably more secure than Hogwarts' door locks. Relax. When the time is right, I'll tell Ron."
She waved at Ron, who was waiting somewhere near the Hog's Head.
"Come on, let's go!"
And with that, Hermione jogged off toward the pub.
What surprised Harry was how many people actually showed up. Far more than he'd expected.
He even spotted a familiar face in the crowd, Cedric Diggory.
Cedric had kept the promise he'd made at the start of term. He believed Harry.
When Zacharias challenged Harry, Cedric stood up abruptly. "I can tell you."
"I can tell you, Zacharias." Cedric repeated it. "My father, Amos Diggory, died at the hands of Death Eaters three days ago. Simply because I nearly witnessed the return of You-Know-Who."
Harry's eyes went wide. His breath came in short.
Mr. Diggory was dead?!
The room erupted into murmurs, students leaning toward each other, voices overlapping.
"Cedric, I respect you. Everyone in Hufflepuff respects you!" Zacharias pressed him, voice sharp and aggressive. "But when it comes down to it, you didn't actually see You-Know-Who return, did you?"
"The Ministry's investigation concluded that your father died from a sudden fall while out hiking." Zacharias said this to Cedric, who had lost his father three days ago. "That account simply isn't reliable."
Cho Chang was on her feet immediately, taking Cedric's hand in both of hers, trying to give him something to hold onto.
"Smith." Her voice was gentle and steady. "Do you honestly believe Cedric would lie about his own father? Do you honestly believe Cedric can't recognize the traces of Dark magic? Do you honestly believe Mr. Diggory had some reason to wander into a forest alone in the middle of the night?"
Zacharias opened his mouth again. "We need the truth. We can't replace objective facts with emotional speculation —"
"That's enough, Zacharias!" Hermione's voice cut clean across the room. "You might make an excellent investigative journalist someday. But that is not the topic we're here to discuss today."
Hermione quelled the whole thing swiftly and without ceremony, steering the conversation back to learning Defense Against the Dark Arts.
Susan Bones was the first to bring up Harry's Patronus. After that, others chimed in, one after another, going through Harry's accomplishments over the years.
Cedric went further and brought up what had happened in the maze himself, making a point of describing how Harry had fired off spell after spell to blast the giant spiders away.
By the end, everyone in the room had signed their name on the parchment. They would meet again.
The gathering broke up. Students rose and filed out in ones and twos. Cedric, Cho, and Cho's friend Mari were the last to leave.
"I —" Harry instinctively got to his feet when he saw the three of them coming toward him. "I'm so sorry."
Cedric stopped. His throat worked, like he was trying to find the right words.
Harry had lost track of Cho Chang entirely. His eyes were fixed on Cedric. He still felt something strange whenever Cho was nearby, but the guilt he felt toward Cedric was close to swallowing everything else.
Harry had never liked Mr. Diggory. He still didn't, if he was honest.
He'd lost to Cedric on the Quidditch pitch because of the Dementors, and Mr. Diggory had milked that moment shamelessly. This past summer, Mr. Diggory had handed his testimony to every media outlet that would take it, all of them trying to prove Harry was unhinged.
But it was also Harry who had insisted Cedric testify before Fudge, which drew the Ministry's attention and pointed every reporter straight at Cedric.
Cedric had left the graveyard early. In the end, the one who brought help was Professor Sinistra. Mr. Diggory could have walked away from all of it.
A quiet, settled grief filled Cedric's eyes.
"Harry." Cedric was silent for a moment. "You don't need to apologize. Every choice was mine. The one who killed my father wasn't you. It was the Death Eaters."
A house full of Death Eaters.
"I am disappointed. Very —" Voldemort's voice was cold and flat. "I taught you patiently. I gave you abilities beyond the ordinary. And still you refuse to come back to my side."
"Wretch!" Mrs. Burst shrieked. "Master! Let me kill her for you! Kill this traitor!"
"Fool." Voldemort's voice cracked like a whip.
"I can smell fear," Voldemort said. "And worry, of course. What I do not smell is guilt."
"You know better than anyone how powerful I am," he continued, softer now. "And you betrayed me anyway."
"Teacher!" Winnie was shaking so hard she could barely hold herself upright. "It is precisely because you are so powerful that I couldn't come back to you. You know how I am. I'm a coward. I can't even bring myself to kill."
"I was terrified!" Winnie crawled toward him on her knees. "Master, I was terrified. They were going to lock us all in Azkaban. So I lied to Dumbledore, I told him I had been forced."
"Is that so?" Voldemort crouched down. He gripped her chin and tilted her face up, looking directly into her gray-blue eyes.
In the memory, Winnie sat hugging her own head, talking to someone who wasn't there. "You don't know how powerful he used to be. But I saw it with my own eyes. Dumbledore can't stop him. Dumbledore is old, he couldn't stop the rise back then, either."
Tears ran down Winnie's face as she looked up at the thing her teacher had become. "I betrayed you. How could I beg your forgiveness? How could I dare come back?"
"Liar!" Mrs. Burst spat furiously. "You came crawling back to the Master for that spineless wretch Purnell!"
Mrs. Burst had been part of the Owl Post Office incident. Purnell's quick compliance had denied her any satisfaction. She still regretted not getting to watch the girl fall apart and scramble for her life.
Winnie clutched at Voldemort's robes. "Teacher! Teacher! Please! I know you despise traitors above all others. But even when I was captured, I never told anyone who the other Death Eaters were. I never told anyone,"
"Winnie." Voldemort's voice dropped low. "Cowardly little Winnie. You beg for my mercy?" A quiet, horrible pleasure moved through his tone. "I will not spare you. I need people who can think. People whose loyalty does not bend. People with enough nerve to help me reclaim what is mine."
"Wormtail and Lola have no brains. You and Wormtail have no nerve, and you have no loyalty." The pleased note in his voice did not waver. "But that's all right. I can guarantee your loyalty. Your dear friend Purnell is here with me as my guest. What happens to her depends entirely on you."
"Your wavering," Voldemort said softly, "becomes the source of her pain. That is my punishment for you."
---
Hogwarts. The Astronomy Tower.
Hermione had brought an armful of yarn. She cast a spell on the whole pile, setting the needles and wool to work on their own.
"I want to knit more clothes for the house-elves," she said.
Praeris was settled in Professor Sinistra's high-backed chair, eyes lowered, one hand propping up her head, legs loosely open.
"You might already understand," Praeris said, calm and unhurried, "that for them, there's a difference between one piece of clothing and another."
"Yes. But at the very least, they should know that someone is trying." Hermione's eyes were very bright. "Blueprints get drawn by people who think they're above everyone else. I won't draw one for myself. If I can't fully liberate the house-elves, then I should at least do what I'm actually able to do. Shouldn't I?"
"I do admire your enthusiasm." Praeris's tone stayed even. "Though I doubt the house-elves will appreciate it much. Something that earns you nothing shouldn't be taking up your time."
Hermione smiled. "But you've done plenty of things that earn you nothing."
Praeris sighed. In moments like this, she always felt faintly like Professor Snape, grumbling the whole time while trudging through a pile of thankless work.
She pushed the thought away. "Recently, have you had any letters from the safe house?"
"We don't always do things just to gain something." Hermione looked slightly puzzled at the shift. "Probably not? The last contact came from their side, too. Has something happened?"
"Winnie may be in trouble." Praeris closed her eyes. "I haven't received a single letter from home in weeks."
"Surely not, maybe things are just difficult right now," Hermione said, uncertain. "We haven't had any letters from Sirius either."
"There's a difference between letters that never come and letters that suddenly stop." Praeris's voice went flat and cold. "Amos Diggory is dead. The Death Eaters have already started moving."
Hermione nodded slowly, the weight of it settling on her. "Cedric told us. But Dumbledore has forbidden Miss Brown from leaving, and he has Sirius watching her. Under those conditions, what could possibly happen to her?"
"But Madam Pree goes out." Praeris drew a slow breath. "If I were You-Know-Who, I would have someone follow Madam Pree and sweep up Dumbledore's supporters in one go."
"But the Secret-Keeper for the safe house is Dumbledore himself. There is nowhere in the world safer than that place." Hermione pushed back immediately. "Even if it were standing right in front of them, they wouldn't see it."
Praeris nodded. "Then there are only two options: kill Madam Pree, or capture her. You-Know-Who hates Dumbledore and needs to build his authority. But Mr. Diggory just died, and the Ministry is already on edge. They've covered it up, but everyone who matters knows the truth."
"So that leaves capturing her and using her to draw Winnie in." Praeris's eyes were sharp. Her voice was cold. "On one side: it costs Dumbledore people and shakes the supporters Winnie brought to him. On the other: it works with the Ministry's posture, breaks the opposition's spirit, and builds You-Know-Who's reputation. Everything gained at once."
Hermione stared at her. "Then, then Professor Brown, doesn't that mean —"
Three changes of allegiance.
If Professor Brown truly turned back to Voldemort, what would that mean for her and Praeris? Could she still trust Praeris at all?
In a war, trust was the thing you needed most. It was also the hardest thing to give.
"Dumbledore's reputation wasn't built on nothing." Praeris's voice steadied. "He's far cleverer than I am. He would have foreseen this. He'll have something in place."
"What sort of something? A rescue?" Hermione asked, urgent.
Praeris shook her head. "I don't know. I can't think of it."
There are limits to what any person can figure out, and Praeris was not omniscient. The plans Dumbledore laid were beyond her reach.
Not because she wasn't clever enough. That wasn't it.
She could trace Voldemort's thinking well enough, most of the time. His politics had no sentiment in them. He calculated benefits, and he calculated winning, bigger and better, always. But Dumbledore's politics were warm. They moved with the human heart, not against it.
As she had said before: she was a Slytherin.
And Dumbledore, in every way that counted, was a Gryffindor.
That was the nature of a Gryffindor. No matter how thorough the plan looked on the surface, no matter how solid, there was always some element of risk woven into it, some factor that couldn't be controlled, some faith placed in things that weren't strictly rational.
And on top of all that, Dumbledore was someone the Sword of Gryffindor had recognized. If that meant anything, it meant he was the most thoroughgoing Gryffindor this school had ever produced.
Things had reached a standstill. Hogwarts protected them, to a point, and to that same point, it trapped them.
People outside couldn't easily get in. Praeris had no way of learning what was happening beyond the walls.
Hermione promised: the moment she heard anything from the safe house, she would come to Praeris first.
➤ Next: Scoring — The Conversation
