BTOB Killing Voice UNCUT Vocal Analysis (68 minutes)

Just wanted to give a shoutout to their Melody, because I learned these subtitles are fanmade. That's why they have the names of who's singing/talking what

i wish sungjae has more confidence he has such a nice voice

SUBBED FOR THIS FULL VIDEO ❤️

Yay, Double Thursday on June 11, both Kingdom BTOB Back door plus a few more BTOB songs. Thank you Tim. I can not wait😊

we need all the BtoB love! pretty sure Eunkwang, Hyunsik, and Changsub all studied music and vocals in college outside of just the normal Kpop training. I know at least Eunkwang and Changsub did some. Hyunsik is famous for playing tons of instruments and being the main composer for BtoB's music. Also his father was a famous folk rock singer in Korea (in the 80s?) so he grew up around music.

There's a lot to recommend! If you're curious about BTOB's recording site, I recommend this playlist! https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpx2nOqIZpqDluWqy9VwlhoBxbmv3V-Cx&si=XWaVYGizNv2UXxqS There's also a playlist of live videos of their songs from their debut to now for the reactors! 1. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpx2nOqIZpqAKbEyUO0OXoAemYVepkvre&si=lDcUnhXLPiRKCk4r 2. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLpx2nOqIZpqBwsVrq65QpOuk-8IY-hDNL&si=oO7Wm-ndAOTiPs0v It's organized on this channel playlist, so it'll be easy to watch! Thank you for posting the BTOB video :)

I watched BTOB on YouTube and came to Petrion LOL If you don't have any plans for the next program after checking out all the programs, I recommend the 'Universe League' program! It's not a competition between professional idols, but it's a program where amateur boys and three teams of directors form three teams to compete! There are many talented trainees, and most of all, Changsub of 'BTOB' participated as a director and served as a vocal coach to the kids, so I enjoyed it so much! I recommend it!

Usually I don't pay for reaction videos...but for btob you have me 💸

Recommend Melomance’s Killing Voice episode for rly rly good vocals!! Sooooo good!!

I just wanted to add that Hyunsik and Changsub were accepted into Korea's most prestigious vocal masters program. They were 2 of the 3 entrants in their year!

Hi! This is my first time in patreon, just follow stray kids reaction to here and unintentionally watching BTOB Killing voice with you for the first time! I'm literally got hooked! such a wonderful voice. I understand now why they've been called vocal king. Deserve it!

Thank you so much for this reaction!! I came here to your Patreon after watching it on your youtube channel!! Glad to know that we have one more kpop reactor being interested to check out on BTOB yeayy!!! But tbh, I got confused about to how to recommend songs @.@ When I opened the link that you posted, the recommendations were dominated by one specific group, and so I kinda got overwhelmed by it lmao. So can I just post it here...? 😅 If possible, it would be great if you can react to this concert setlist of them. Tbh there're sooo many songs I want to recommend, but I feel like this concert setlist covers a lot of good ones from them. The video quality might not be the best, and Peniel couldn't dance for most part of the songs bcs of injury, but still their vocals at that time were at their peak. And you can get a snippet of their solo songs too. -> BTOB 10TH ANNIVERSARY CONCERT 2022 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZ_3yuHJj6IT5jhZd7eM0kWJIvqZGClOH About Sungjae's voice, I feel like his vocal capacity and "instrument" is actually just as good as the other 3 vocal members. He's very capable at reaching insane high notes, using various vocal techniques, etc. It's just that as the maknae (youngest) of the group, most of the time he just follows instructions on how to sing from his other members or song producers, rather than coming up with his own style of singing. That's why at times, he might appear to be less confident in what he's actually doing. Meanwhile the other 3 members usually already have their own ideas of how to sing the songs before recording and have more sayings about how they want to sound like. That's why it feels like they really know what they're doing and have more depth on their singing. But as you dig more into BTOB, I'm sure you'll see how Sungjae also excels in singing just like the other members 😊

Had to sub just for this, i love btob and i love your reaction

You were asking how “studied” those three were. Eunkwang and Changsub graduated with a degree in Practical Music. Changsub also owns a vocal academy. Hyunsik holds a Master’s degree in Practical Music.

I just found your reaction video of BTOB and join the community immediately! Thank you for take this journey with them i can proudly say that you'll never disappointed. FYI : Changsub and Hyunsik both got accepted to the same university (Vocal major in Practical music, Howon U.) which was the top teir U. in South Korea for practical music and another thing is in that year (2011) admission competition rate is 3000:5, 3 of 5 are girls and ofc Changsub and Hyunsik are only 2 that got accepted in that round. The funny thing is not long after that they get to know each other as trainees in CUBE Changsub try to brag abt it turning that Hyunsik also got in too lol.

Waited months for this, thank you! Melody isn't a big fandom in the English sphere compared to others, so I hope you'll enjoy more BTOB (and Forestella) because YOU like them

I sub just to see this and I loved it ❤️

The way I came running to make an account after seeing the video go up on youtube 😂

BTOB stand for born to beat and they stay true to that. Every beat need a melody why BTOB fandom is melody. They are definitely a vocal driven group. Ever since BTOB came to be, Sungjae was always in the background in vocal terms. He has definitely improved so much and that why BTOB doesn’t use term of main vocal. To get more feel of Sungjae power, I would check out his cover of beautiful things, his songs be somebody and lie. For BTOB songs it depend of your taste and feel, dance song( beep beep, insane,thriller, I be your man), R&B( broken heart, open, when I was your man), pop( only one for me), ballad( beautiful pain, missing you, way back home, the song, father) , rock( higher). The vocal line also has songs stand by me and when it rains(highly recommended for power vocal)

Aaaaah finally! What a beautiful thing, BTOB, I agree with you about those three, I believe Eunkwang is widely considerered the best in the group, but they are just monsters... (By the way rapper on the left Minhyuk is an insane singer, just that they have already so many singers and he's an insane rapper as well so he takes that role).

Had to sub just for this!! Btob are so great I hope you continue to get more into them, there are so many older groups whose vocals blow me away but sadly don’t get as much love and attention as the newer groups so thank you for checking them out! Some other killing voices I think you’d love: tvxq, nct127 (both from sm), infinite, highlight

I wonder if you would enjoy Apink's Killing voice? Apink and BTOB trained under Cube entertainment, Apink debuting in 2011, BTOB in 2012. Apink's songs in their early career are on the cuter side but they did evolve to a more mature sound later. Apink are great singers and did live harmonies in their KV. They aren't as riffy as BTOB but solid singers. Especially Eunji is considered one of the best vocalists in kpop, she was originally trying to become a vocal coach. Bomi and Namjoo are also great singers, Chorong and Hayoung hold their own and have great texture to their voices. I requested Apink's Killing voice in one of the past monthly request posts but it may have been buried in the avalanche of requests lol.

I'm so happy to see your reaction to BTOB’s Killing Voice! Welcome to the fandom—congratulations on falling for their charm. What makes BTOB stand out from other idols is their ability to create such rich, beautiful music through their vocal harmonies. Most of their songs are written and composed by Hyunsik and Minhyuk, which is why Hyunsik is affectionately called "the father of BTOB's music." I’ve put together some song recommendations where you can truly appreciate their incredible harmonies. I’m really looking forward to your reaction! 💙 https://youtu.be/_TanXRzIpx8?si=TnzpwCjO_R2Eweei https://youtu.be/33GODknx04I?si=xYArCOQzYPn-zUrG https://youtu.be/O4qyesUUI5c?si=QcsE24HtsnN326hj https://youtu.be/TBmb6Zt8R9s?si=whmeY5zIqeAavq45

BTOB stands for Born to Beat. So they name their fans Melody because you need both Beat and Melody to make a song.. Isn't it cute?? Hehe. Their title songs are usually more ballady but their B-sides covers a lot of different genres. I can't wait for you to react more to them as a group and as individuals. 💙🩵💙

had to rejoin the $10 tier specifically for this video. i was losing hope i'd see this anytime soon so it totally caught me by surprise to see this up. hahahha. That was fun watching you get blown away.

Finally! 💜 Love that you love them 🙈

and what I will say about Sungjae's singing voice......let's just say God is fair lol. With his visuals and acting ability (he's been in a TON of kdramas), giving him eunkwang/hyunsik/changsub level singing would be grossly unfair to the human race

OK....lol.....just gonna correct you bc you said his name so many times. i've noticed when you read korean names and there's a "u", your default is the 'oooo' sound (so you kept saying 'hyooooonsik'). In romanization of korean words, if you see a 'u' its actually the 'uh' sound more often (so you're saying it correctly in the second syllable of changsub's name). So Hyunsik is actually pronounced more like "hyuhn shik". the sh sound is another pronunciation rule (kinda like "i before e except...." in english so no way you'd deduce that)

Love how you slowly lost your mind throughout this video 😂 I know BTOB through Kingdom but haven't seen much of them otherwise. I'm not a ballad lover so I wouldn't listen to their music on a regular basis, but this was a great watch. They're all amazing singers!

and yeah.....Hyunsik is korean music royalty. His dad is Im Jiehoon who is a LEGENDARY korean folk singer so that music gene runs deep in that family. Here is him and his dad performing one of his dad's songs

a fun little tidbit from this killing voice....when it was released the directors/sound engineers of Killing Voice released an apology statement to Melody bc at times if you watch again the sound mixing gets a little weird and compressed. it's bc the staff at Killing Voice didnt realize how LOUD these boys could sing and there was all this sound bleeding and pickup between all the mics (side note since you asked.....those are the Austrian Audio Austrian Audio OC818 condenser mics)

In all honesty.....learning the korean alphabet will take you not EVEN a single day. It is the most efficient, economic alphabet in the world (lots of history as to why). The language itself is a different story.......BUT......just learning the alphabet will IMMENSELY help you with names

now you know why people have been begging you to react to this for a LONG TIME