Which concept is most interesting?
I recently got into the One Piece tcg with some friends, and got the bug to write a few chapters of One Piece fanfiction. These were a few ideas I thought up. Nothing ground breaking, just general adventure with the goal of ACTUALLY finding the One Piece. I was thinking of it being a crossover with Soul Calibur, including the characters from that franchise, and having the One Piece be the Soul Edge. Not saying I'll write any of these, but if I did, I wanted to see what's most popular.
Comments (20)
Honestly I don't really care for any of these options.
/shrug, I just picked something that I could imagine something happening with. I didn't expect anything from the pokemon/naruto fic either, didn't think you could make those work together (not in a world fusion at least). BOY was I wrong! He usually has his own take on it, and in my experience it tends to work. I think we're just too used to authors that needs a perfectly dreamed up premise to do anything. We forget that there are some that can make what looks like a dubious premise work.
Soul Calibur?? I've never heard of this I don't know what this is.
Old fighting game franchise. It pretty much gets 1-2 new games per console. Slightly older than Tekken. It's main difference is that it uses weapons, and builds in some games. The PS3 version was VERY popular, also featured special character options with Vader and Yoda. The license for that must have cost a pretty penny. But worth it, for the perhaps best iteration in the franchise. Still have the game and console laying around somewhere. Beating the tower is NOT easy. You face ever tougher bots, and you get less and less chance to recover hp between fights. Life steal will get you pretty far, but eventually you pretty much have to make sure they don't get a single hit in. At which point you hit challenge mode in Dark Souls levels of difficulty.
Instead of a mech system, he could eat the Mech Mech fruit that lets him create custom suits of armor like Iron Man
Or what if the Force was Haki?
Starwars is super interesting, should check those out
Ive already seen enel done enough. So my vote goes for the Law SI, Kuina and Ace SIs. I'm not interested in a Luffy SI in the least bit, as its oversaturated I feel. Doflamingo would ALSO be interesting, didn't even notice it earlier. As would the Giant since I've never seen someone do a Giant SI before. So definitely an idea. And Big Dick Energy as its title makes it sound like its A HELLA OF A LOT OF FUN. So i'm all in on that too!
I've actually never seen a fic get far with him. So I wouldn't say I have... They start, and then they drop off in like 3-30 chapters. Never finishing. So I'd still like one where it's actually wrapped up. But I too prefer something else this time. However ,if the MC actually got to choose themselves, they should ABSOLUTELY pick Enel amongst these options. His fruit is just that broken. ACE is a rare option though. I'm fine with seeing where that goes.
Honestly, I would prefer an OC with a unique power/Devil Fruit instead of just an SI into an already established character. I'm a sucker for crossover powers so maybe something like a Green Lantern Fruit(modified so MC can't just fuck off to space and search for the final island from there). I'd vote for the Mecha if it was more Cyborg focused. I'mma be honest, I just flat out don't like Mecha's but that's a personal preference.
I agree that it should be a new unique fruit. But I don't care for a crossover where it doesn't serve a clear purpose in the story.
Ace
At this point I want to read about mihawk and Emiya from fate, the sass and care of the two to other people they care about would be funny.
I like the idea of Ace ( SI) he truly lives up to being Son of pirate king and has different Devil Fruit
Also Mecha System scratches that Gurren Lagann itch. Create a Drill that shall Slay the Celestial Dragons!
I chose fishman, because I have never seen a fishman SI
If you choose a fish that would have additional powers it could be pretty interesting.
Luffy seems fun especially if you go full Loony Tunes with it.
I voted for 3 of them i am very indecisive, they all seem so interesting
Same lol