Mage Steel 2 Thoughts
So that was the end of Book 2. Would love thoughts, dissections, things that could be improved or made better.
Give me some ideas for the Chapterhouse Name and what your thought are to Kon's first full rune will be. I already have an idea but if one of you are better I will steal it.
Book 3 Starts tomorrow and we're going to keep that 5x a week release schedule.
Book 4 Will be dropping to 3x a week though and I'll be taking a week off between 3 and 4. I have other responsibilities that I've been neglecting to push Mage Steel through its early days.
Comments (14)
Not sure if you have decided on the Rune. But a Fire rune to purify his steel body would be nice
Chapterhouse 'Crucible'
I don’t disagree with a lot of what Daniel wrote. I will say keep the pacing and chapter length to how you need to put out work without burning yourself out it is a web serial and those tend to have shorter chapters for authors who put out chapters as often as you do. Upon publishing and editing some should probably be combined. I think the biggest miss in the first two books were some opportunities for exposition. One example being when Turja is introduced. We got she looks like a demon and her race lives longer. Then later we see her drinking blood and are like ok weird why? how come? Here are some questions I still have that I would like expounded upon either in the first two books or soon. What kinds of non traditional cultivation is out there and other forms of power? Do the lupines use some sort of bestial cultivation why do they rarely hit C-grade if not? What are the known major racial players in the galaxy? These other power armor users that don’t have earths rune tech in them, what’s the purpose of that armor? Are they perhaps part cyborg people, do they not cultivate? Are there advanced tech only using non cultivation races that are also at the top due to their advanced tech that’s possibly AI or utilizes rift energy? (Outside of our rune gimmick I just don’t believe there’s a way humans popped into the galaxy and reversed engineered all the way to the top of technology unless there’s some logical science Cap that no one has broken through or the major cultivation powers keep destroying super tech societies). If a fleet of ships can compete with even A-grades why do so many of these civilizations seem so far behind earth in making ships? I get cultivators are bad in space, but Diurs explanation of the Ulmna confederacy’s fleet size seems odd. What is the resource or reason keeping them from building more and powerful ships? Just turn some barren planets and asteroids into ships otherwise. I feel like fleet building would be a priority for any civilization even a cultivator one if it can compete with at least b-grades.
That was a very good last chapter to book two! Bravo! First my condensed thoughts on books one and two. Book one was a frantic race for survival with a small cast. The short chapters, brutal conditions, and trama bonding were shown very well. The descriptions and sparse world building along with the character development worked very well. The short chapters worked very well to convey urgency. The first book lacked in depth world building but that made sense in the circumstances that the cast found themselves in Book two: book two was characterized by two younger adults being caught up in games of factions more powerful and far older than them. The two MC’s were doing their best to keep their heads above water while trying to learn and grow fast enough to survive the games of other factions. Book two did well but really needed to have more in depth world building and more in depth character development. Conclusion: Book three needs to drastically slow down the breakneck pace of the plot and world build along with building unique characters. The short chapters worked very well for conveying the frantic pace of survival in the first two books but now that Kon and Duir are not scrambling to survive you (the author) need to spend time building a world with self contained logic, factions, and make us care about the characters. The audience needs to see the thoughts, dreams, success and failures of the cast, we need to both emphasize and to not have Mary Su’s. Yes we have multiple special snowflakes in this cast but we need to see that there are other big fish also. The different factions need to be shown and given valid reasons for their actions, no chaotic evil or for the luz, there need to be good reasons for choices that make sense even if it sacrifices a few good people. Take your time and pace the chapter releases but make them longer and much more in depth and detailed. Build a living breathing world, all actions have consequences. Take your time to explore the various cast members pasts, thoughts, motivations, and dreams. Have a few smaller battles through book three but the focus should not be on combat but the new house/sect setting down roots and building a stable foundation for the future. Explore the species and their unique relationships with each other, how the aliens are truly alien but how some are comparable with humans and some are not purely by the virtue of their existence. Don’t feel like every chapter must be a complete scene, a scene can be multiple chapters long. Just do not fall in love with cliffhangers, one or two is ok after that they get annoying. I would recommend story boarding out a rough plot, add more details than you think is needed but remember that you can change things when the patron group points out inconsistent parts. Hope this helps!
House Odyssey, something unique to the old legends of earth that only those in the know may recognize the meaning of. I also like that it feels relevant with the current falling of humanity to the temptations of power and greed when far from home among a few other connections I'm sure could be made while also being about a hero's homecoming (love you benny boy, tho it's not a perfect 1:1 cuz benny actually grew as a person I assume). (in making sure I remembered enough about the odyssey to even say these things I have been suckered into reading it, curses) a link for anyone bored or interested https://classics.mit.edu/Homer/odyssey.html
Still think seekers in the dark is a neat name. This book had a few rough spots, mainly the character interactions that seemed a little 2d. But it set a great foundation to build off IMO. Overall I think it turned out really good, will be fun to see how Kon stacks up to Alice in the next book after he caps his current rune web.
And what about “The Order of The First Seal” basically explains the Rune mage path since it was the first path humanity had before they lost the way to earth.
What about The Aegis of Terra
I would love to see some kind of name that explains their "secret" goal. Exodus? Phoenix? Slipstream? Preferably some name that is a signal flag to "those in the know", but not 100% completely obvious for the rest of the oblivious humans and other alien species.
Hudolions...it's Welsh for Enchantress or Sorcerers
Tellus
What have we read besides Draconis and Lion? I’m trying to think of an animal that’s not a dumb turtle that travels but always returns home. Other than that hmmm Return(ers), Origin, Maji.
those are Orders not Chapters. Chapterhouses are much smaller and specialize in specific things while Orders are more large scale support strucctures
MEGA ( Make Earth Great Again) joking here. Something like knights of the forgotten path would work. Or road since they will be seeking the way back
