March 10, 2025

Monster Hunter Keeps Making Itself Worse, and I Love That | Design Delve

Comments (4)

e
ergotpoisoning 路 March 14, 2025

Radical series change that didn't work out - the new Civ changes are a pretty relevant example! Trying to improve a game thematically *and* in terms of gameplay isn't a zero sum prospect; improving one doesn't necessarily have to come at the expense of worsening the other. Firaxis made the decision to improve gameplay at the expense of massively worsening the thematic feel of Civ, and imo this idea needed a lot more time in the oven. From interviews it seems like the dev/publisher response is largely "We needed to do this to improve the loop!". This to me implies that they thought the tradeoff was inevitable, which I don't think is true.

T
The Critic of Innocence 路 March 10, 2025

Ah, Monster Hunter, a series that does its own thing and gives no care. (Also, the best weapon is the Great Sword, because hitting monsters with raw iron is amazing).

L
Lil' Cass (CJ) 路 March 10, 2025

Hmm... quite thought-provoking and very interesting choice of words, I love it!馃挅

S
Sven F. 路 March 10, 2025

Did not play. Looks like a grinder. No opinion. GDC so cool. So much tech and p.management stuff.