Which of These Anime Interest You the Most?

Can anyone tell me why they don’t have a reaction to Solo Leveling or Star Wars: Skeleton Crew?

To the creators of Clannad, I'd love to hear your thoughts on Kanon (2006)—it's another legendary anime from Studio KEY....

Ahhh I missed the poll by just a few days! RIP Anyways I did want to retroactively speak my support for a few shows. NieR:Automata Ver1.1a is definitely a really good one, not just as a good watch but as a good discussion piece. It leans very philosophical so I think yall would have a good time discussing it. Plus, it's based on a game and I know sometimes yall stream games so maybe after watching the show, you could jump in to trying the game? Or game before or concurrent with the show, whatever you desire. Secrets of the Silent Witch was one of my favorite Summer 2025 shows alongside Gachiakuta. Its kind of a feel good anime for me, very cute but not boring. Very much an adorable and intriguing fantasy show. And Wind Breaker. Oh, Wind Breaker. The first season was my favorite show of Spring 2024. It's second season permanently launched it into my top 5 anime EVER (and that's alongside big names like FMAB). The action? Amazing. The character development? Chefs kiss. It's one of those shows I fell so deeply in love with that as soon as I ran out of episodes to watch, I picked up the manga (the only other shows I've ever done this with are the Gachiakuta manga and the 86 light novels). Highly HIGHLY recommend to check out at least at some point. Still waiting on that season 3 announcement.

Taking this opportunity to ask you guys in case you know, have Caleb and Jacob ever watched Shirobako and Bakuman before? I've always thought about wanting to see them react to it / listen to their discussions, which is unlikely since both shows are quite old and not as well known... so I do wonder if they've ever talked about having seen both series bcs it's not on their MAL either.

Mentioning Iruma on every poll until it wins 5

THEY WILL LOVE JOURNAL WITH WITCH THE DISCUSSIONS WILL BE AWESOME

undead unluck got more votes than sakamoto last time and still left out :(

How about a write-in for Apocalypse Hotel?

Isekai ojisan is getting sleept on

Lord of mystery but watch it in eng dub

Isekai Ojisan and Handyman Saito

Undead Unluck needs to be on this poll.

i would loveeee to see windbreaker

come on journal with witch=Ikoku nikki. Have you two seen afterschool insomniacs?

silent witch is so good

I'm voting for Lord of Mysteries despite the anime being rushed because if anyone can understand and piece together the story despite the flaws, it's these guys

Lord of Mysteries is great

For the Discord, I must mention Welcome to Demon School Iruma-kun.

Where's Overlord when you need it.

Was Makeine ever on a poll? Didn't get much attention if so? Love that show, but maybe it's not really a match with this channel's audience....

Glad to see Secrets of the Silent Witch on here even though I don't imagine it will get that much love. I picked up the light novels for that series after enjoying the anime, they were a great read.

I feel like a lot of people slept on NieR:Automata Ver1.1a. I really liked the game and the anime series and would like to see more reactors like you guys actually give it a chance. Main reasons it got less coverage: (1) it's based on a game and may people would argue to play the game instead. This show is very faithful to the game while taking a few Yoko Taro (creator) directed liberties. It would be interesting either way to see your reaction if you played the game, or not, or if only one of you played it. (2) Horrible delays/release schedule which were a cascade effect of 86 production issues (yup, same team worked on this that worked on 86). That ended up squashing any reactors from continuing on when it got delayed for an indeterminate amount of time. It is fully release now, so that should be a non-issue. Side Note: Yoko Taro is writing the script for the new Neon Genesis Evangelion anime series, so if you want to get a sneak peak at how he me might treat Evangelion , here is your chance!

Why do we put current seasonals on polls like this? Recency Bias is a real thing which is clearly visible here again because #1 (Fate) and #2 (Journal with Witch) are current seasonals... Don't get me wrong, they're both good... But yeah.

I guess this means Insomniacs After School is out :(

Omg I've been wanting you guys to react to Windbreaker for awhile! 🤞🏻

Journal with Witch is probably one of the more slept on shows this season simply because it's slice-of-life drama, but with amazing grounded storytelling. When it came out, I was told that Secrets of the Silent Witch was essentially Bocchi the Witch, and that sold me the entire series. More heart, less action, but still very well told.

I'd vote Lord of Mysteries if the anime wasn't a speed run. Luckily, I see a lot of good anime on this list.

Sakamoto or windbreaker

Akiba Maid War. Anime original single cour show, that tells funny and epic story in its entirety

Fateeee. And might be controversial but putting my vote on Sakamoto Days. The bros would love it

BUCKLE UP, Y'ALL! IT'S A BIG ONE!

Lord of the Mysteries is peak fiction, and the anime is full of insane visuals

Come ooooon Fate.

No UU? 😭 fuck